TSTP Solution File: SYN621-1 by cvc5---1.0.5
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : cvc5---1.0.5
% Problem : SYN621-1 : TPTP v8.2.0. Released v2.5.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : do_cvc5 %s %d
% Computer : n010.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Wed May 29 18:26:09 EDT 2024
% Result : Unsatisfiable 0.43s 0.63s
% Output : Proof 0.44s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.10/0.16 % Problem : SYN621-1 : TPTP v8.2.0. Released v2.5.0.
% 0.17/0.18 % Command : do_cvc5 %s %d
% 0.19/0.40 % Computer : n010.cluster.edu
% 0.19/0.40 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.19/0.40 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.19/0.40 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.19/0.40 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.19/0.40 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.19/0.40 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.19/0.40 % DateTime : Tue May 28 13:51:09 EDT 2024
% 0.19/0.40 % CPUTime :
% 0.43/0.59 %----Proving TF0_NAR, FOF, or CNF
% 0.43/0.60 --- Run --decision=internal --simplification=none --no-inst-no-entail --no-cbqi --full-saturate-quant at 10...
% 0.43/0.63 % SZS status Unsatisfiable for /export/starexec/sandbox/tmp/tmp.kvr35R2kV9/cvc5---1.0.5_19650.smt2
% 0.43/0.63 % SZS output start Proof for /export/starexec/sandbox/tmp/tmp.kvr35R2kV9/cvc5---1.0.5_19650.smt2
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a0 (forall ((X0 $$unsorted)) (tptp.p10 X0 X0)))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a1 (forall ((X78 $$unsorted)) (tptp.p8 X78 X78)))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a2 (forall ((X71 $$unsorted)) (tptp.p7 X71 X71)))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a3 (forall ((X38 $$unsorted)) (tptp.p4 X38 X38)))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a4 (forall ((X12 $$unsorted)) (tptp.p2 X12 X12)))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a5 (forall ((X7 $$unsorted)) (tptp.p13 X7 X7)))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a6 (not (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a7 (forall ((X10 $$unsorted) (X11 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p13 (tptp.f14 X10) (tptp.f14 X11)) (not (tptp.p7 X10 X11)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a8 (forall ((X59 $$unsorted) (X60 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f5 X59) (tptp.f5 X60)) (not (tptp.p4 X59 X60)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a9 (forall ((X45 $$unsorted) (X46 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f16 X45) (tptp.f16 X46)) (not (tptp.p2 X45 X46)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a10 (forall ((X24 $$unsorted) (X25 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 (tptp.f3 X24) (tptp.f3 X25)) (not (tptp.p2 X24 X25)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a11 (forall ((X22 $$unsorted) (X23 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 (tptp.f18 X22) (tptp.f18 X23)) (not (tptp.p2 X22 X23)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a12 (forall ((X20 $$unsorted) (X21 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 (tptp.f17 X20) (tptp.f17 X21)) (not (tptp.p2 X20 X21)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a13 (forall ((X1 $$unsorted) (X2 $$unsorted) (X0 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p10 X1 X2) (not (tptp.p10 X0 X1)) (not (tptp.p10 X0 X2)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a14 (forall ((X79 $$unsorted) (X80 $$unsorted) (X78 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p8 X79 X80) (not (tptp.p8 X78 X79)) (not (tptp.p8 X78 X80)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a15 (forall ((X72 $$unsorted) (X73 $$unsorted) (X71 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p7 X72 X73) (not (tptp.p7 X71 X72)) (not (tptp.p7 X71 X73)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a16 (forall ((X39 $$unsorted) (X40 $$unsorted) (X38 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 X39 X40) (not (tptp.p4 X38 X39)) (not (tptp.p4 X38 X40)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a17 (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a18 (forall ((X13 $$unsorted) (X14 $$unsorted) (X12 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X13 X14) (not (tptp.p2 X12 X13)) (not (tptp.p2 X12 X14)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a19 (forall ((X8 $$unsorted) (X9 $$unsorted) (X7 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p13 X8 X9) (not (tptp.p13 X7 X8)) (not (tptp.p13 X7 X9)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a20 (forall ((X26 $$unsorted) (X27 $$unsorted) (X28 $$unsorted) (X29 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X26 X27) (not (tptp.p4 X28 X26)) (not (tptp.p4 X29 X27)) (not (tptp.p21 X28 X29)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a21 (forall ((X34 $$unsorted) (X35 $$unsorted) (X37 $$unsorted) (X36 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p22 X34 X35) (not (tptp.p22 X37 X36)) (not (tptp.p4 X37 X34)) (not (tptp.p13 X36 X35)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a22 (forall ((X74 $$unsorted) (X75 $$unsorted) (X76 $$unsorted) (X77 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p7 (tptp.f11 X74 X75) (tptp.f11 X76 X77)) (not (tptp.p10 X75 X77)) (not (tptp.p2 X74 X76)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a23 (forall ((X3 $$unsorted) (X4 $$unsorted) (X5 $$unsorted) (X6 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p10 (tptp.f12 X3 X4) (tptp.f12 X5 X6)) (not (tptp.p2 X3 X5)) (not (tptp.p2 X4 X6)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a24 (forall ((X41 $$unsorted) (X42 $$unsorted) (X43 $$unsorted) (X44 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f15 X41 X42) (tptp.f15 X43 X44)) (not (tptp.p4 X41 X43)) (not (tptp.p4 X42 X44)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a25 (forall ((X47 $$unsorted) (X48 $$unsorted) (X49 $$unsorted) (X50 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f19 X47 X48) (tptp.f19 X49 X50)) (not (tptp.p4 X48 X50)) (not (tptp.p7 X47 X49)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a26 (forall ((X61 $$unsorted) (X62 $$unsorted) (X63 $$unsorted) (X64 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f6 X61 X62) (tptp.f6 X63 X64)) (not (tptp.p4 X61 X63)) (not (tptp.p4 X62 X64)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a27 (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a28 (forall ((X65 $$unsorted) (X66 $$unsorted) (X67 $$unsorted) (X68 $$unsorted) (X69 $$unsorted) (X70 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f9 X65 X66 X67) (tptp.f9 X68 X69 X70)) (not (tptp.p7 X65 X68)) (not (tptp.p8 X66 X69)) (not (tptp.p4 X67 X70)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a29 (forall ((X51 $$unsorted) (X52 $$unsorted) (X53 $$unsorted) (X54 $$unsorted) (X55 $$unsorted) (X56 $$unsorted) (X57 $$unsorted) (X58 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p4 (tptp.f20 X51 X52 X53 X54) (tptp.f20 X55 X56 X57 X58)) (not (tptp.p2 X53 X57)) (not (tptp.p4 X54 X58)) (not (tptp.p2 X51 X55)) (not (tptp.p2 X52 X56)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a30 (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a31 (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a32 (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X19 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 X19))) (not (tptp.p22 X19 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18))))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (assume a33 (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t1 (cl (=> (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31))))) :rule implies_neg1)
% 0.44/0.64 (anchor :step t2)
% 0.44/0.64 (assume t2.a0 (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t2.t1 (cl (or (not (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))) :rule forall_inst :args ((:= X30 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27)))) (:= X31 (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (:= X32 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t2.t2 (cl (not (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule or :premises (t2.t1))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t2.t3 (cl (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t2.t2 t2.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t2 (cl (not (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule subproof :discharge (t2.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t3 (cl (=> (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t1 t2))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t4 (cl (=> (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))) :rule implies_neg2)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t5 (cl (=> (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (=> (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t3 t4))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t6 (cl (=> (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31)))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))) :rule contraction :premises (t5))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t7 (cl (not (forall ((X30 $$unsorted) (X31 $$unsorted) (X32 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 X30 X31) (not (tptp.p21 X30 X32)) (not (tptp.p21 X32 X31))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule implies :premises (t6))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t8 (cl (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule or_pos)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t9 (cl (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))) :rule reordering :premises (t8))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t10 (cl (not (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))) :rule or_pos)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t11 (cl (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule reordering :premises (t10))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t12 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule implies_neg1)
% 0.44/0.64 (anchor :step t13)
% 0.44/0.64 (assume t13.a0 (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t13.t1 (cl (or (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule forall_inst :args ((:= X15 tptp.c23) (:= X16 tptp.c27) (:= X17 tptp.c25) (:= X18 tptp.c26)))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t13.t2 (cl (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule or :premises (t13.t1))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t13.t3 (cl (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t13.t2 t13.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t13 (cl (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule subproof :discharge (t13.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t14 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t12 t13))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t15 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (not (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule implies_neg2)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t16 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t14 t15))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t17 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) :rule contraction :premises (t16))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t18 (cl (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 X16 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)) X16) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule implies :premises (t17))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t19 (cl (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t18 a33))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t20 (cl (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t11 a6 t19))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t21 (cl (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule or_pos)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t22 (cl (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))) (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) :rule reordering :premises (t21))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t23 (cl (not (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))) :rule or_pos)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t24 (cl (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))) (not (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule reordering :premises (t23))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t25 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18))))))) :rule implies_neg1)
% 0.44/0.64 (anchor :step t26)
% 0.44/0.64 (assume t26.a0 (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t26.t1 (cl (or (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule forall_inst :args ((:= X15 tptp.c23) (:= X17 tptp.c25) (:= X18 tptp.c26) (:= X16 tptp.c27)))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t26.t2 (cl (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule or :premises (t26.t1))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t26.t3 (cl (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule resolution :premises (t26.t2 t26.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t26 (cl (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule subproof :discharge (t26.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t27 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule resolution :premises (t25 t26))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t28 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) (not (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule implies_neg2)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t29 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t27 t28))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t30 (cl (=> (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18)))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule contraction :premises (t29))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t31 (cl (not (forall ((X15 $$unsorted) (X17 $$unsorted) (X18 $$unsorted) (X16 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p2 X15 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 X17 X15 X18 X16) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 X17 (tptp.f12 X15 X18))))))) (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule implies :premises (t30))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t32 (cl (or (tptp.p2 tptp.c23 (tptp.f3 tptp.c24)) (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))) :rule resolution :premises (t31 a27))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t33 (cl (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))) :rule resolution :premises (t24 a6 t32))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t34 (cl (=> (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) :rule implies_neg1)
% 0.44/0.64 (anchor :step t35)
% 0.44/0.64 (assume t35.a0 (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t35.t1 (cl (or (not (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) :rule forall_inst :args ((:= X33 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t35.t2 (cl (not (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule or :premises (t35.t1))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t35.t3 (cl (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t35.t2 t35.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t35 (cl (not (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule subproof :discharge (t35.a0))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t36 (cl (=> (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t34 t35))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t37 (cl (=> (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) :rule implies_neg2)
% 0.44/0.64 (step t38 (cl (=> (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (=> (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t36 t37))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t39 (cl (=> (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) :rule contraction :premises (t38))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t40 (cl (not (forall ((X33 $$unsorted)) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 X33))) (not (tptp.p22 X33 (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)))))))) (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule implies :premises (t39))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t41 (cl (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27)))) (not (tptp.p22 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27) (tptp.f14 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t40 a30))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t42 (cl (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) :rule resolution :premises (t22 t33 t41))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t43 (cl (not (or (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f9 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c28 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))))) (not (tptp.p21 (tptp.f5 (tptp.f6 tptp.c27 (tptp.f20 tptp.c25 tptp.c23 tptp.c26 tptp.c27))) (tptp.f15 (tptp.f19 (tptp.f11 tptp.c25 (tptp.f12 tptp.c23 tptp.c26)) tptp.c27) (tptp.f16 (tptp.f3 (tptp.f17 (tptp.f18 tptp.c24)))))))))) :rule resolution :premises (t9 a31 t20 t42))
% 0.44/0.64 (step t44 (cl) :rule resolution :premises (t7 t43 a17))
% 0.44/0.64
% 0.44/0.64 % SZS output end Proof for /export/starexec/sandbox/tmp/tmp.kvr35R2kV9/cvc5---1.0.5_19650.smt2
% 0.44/0.65 % cvc5---1.0.5 exiting
% 0.44/0.65 % cvc5---1.0.5 exiting
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------