TSTP Solution File: RNG026-7 by Fiesta---2
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Fiesta---2
% Problem : RNG026-7 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v1.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : dedam
% Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% Computer : n019.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Mon Jul 18 20:27:49 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 153.65s 154.21s
% Output : CNFRefutation 153.75s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.07/0.12 % Problem : RNG026-7 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v1.0.0.
% 0.07/0.13 % Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n019.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.34 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Mon May 30 07:09:55 EDT 2022
% 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 153.65/154.21 Theorem Proved.
% 153.65/154.21 % SZS status Unsatisfiable
% 153.65/154.21 % SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 153.65/154.21 [3=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X12),additive_inverse(multiply(X11,X12))) = multiply(add(X10,additive_inverse(X11)),X12)].
% 153.65/154.21 [4=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X12))) = multiply(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [5=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 multiply(X10,additive_inverse(X11)) = additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [7=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 multiply(additive_inverse(X10),X11) = additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [10=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X11,X10),additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11))) = commutator(X10,X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [11=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 associator(X10,X11,X12) = add(multiply(multiply(X10,X11),X12),additive_inverse(multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [14=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(add(X10,X11),X12) = add(X10,add(X11,X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [15=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,X11) = add(X11,X10)].
% 153.65/154.21 [16=demod(11),[15],
% 153.65/154.21 associator(X10,X11,X12) = add(additive_inverse(multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(multiply(X10,X11),X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [17=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X12),multiply(X11,X12)) = multiply(add(X10,X11),X12)].
% 153.65/154.21 [18=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),multiply(X10,X12)) = multiply(X10,add(X11,X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [19=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(additive_inverse(X10)) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [20=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(X10)) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [22=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 multiply(additive_identity,X10) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [23=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_identity) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [24=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(additive_identity,X10) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [25=axiom,[],
% 153.65/154.21 thtop(X10,X10) = thmfalse].
% 153.65/154.21 [26=axiom,[16,16,14,16,16,14,16,14,14,14,14,14],
% 153.65/154.21 thtop(add(additive_inverse(multiply(multiply(a,b),multiply(c,d))),add(multiply(multiply(multiply(a,b),c),d),add(additive_inverse(multiply(a,multiply(b,multiply(c,d)))),add(multiply(multiply(a,b),multiply(c,d)),additive_inverse(add(additive_inverse(multiply(a,multiply(multiply(b,c),d))),add(multiply(multiply(a,multiply(b,c)),d),add(multiply(a,add(additive_inverse(multiply(b,multiply(c,d))),multiply(multiply(b,c),d))),multiply(add(additive_inverse(multiply(a,multiply(b,c))),multiply(multiply(a,b),c)),d))))))))),additive_identity) = thmtrue].
% 153.65/154.21 [36=param(14,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,X12)) = add(X12,add(X10,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [37=param(14,15),[14],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,X12)) = add(X11,add(X10,X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [38=param(14,20),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X10,X11)))) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [39=param(14,20),[24],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X11,add(additive_inverse(X11),X10)) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [42=param(39,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(X10))) = X11].
% 153.65/154.21 [50=param(42,14),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,add(X12,additive_inverse(X10)))) = add(X11,X12)].
% 153.65/154.21 [54=param(10,5),[7,19],
% 153.65/154.21 add(additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11)),multiply(X11,X10)) = commutator(additive_inverse(X11),X10)].
% 153.65/154.21 [55=param(10,5),[7,19,54],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(additive_inverse(X10),X11) = commutator(X10,additive_inverse(X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [56=demod(54),[55],
% 153.65/154.21 add(additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11)),multiply(X11,X10)) = commutator(X11,additive_inverse(X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [57=param(10,15),[56],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(X10,X11) = commutator(X11,additive_inverse(X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [60=param(42,10),[15],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),multiply(X10,X11)) = multiply(X11,X10)].
% 153.65/154.21 [62=param(14,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),X12) = add(commutator(X11,X10),add(multiply(X11,X10),X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [65=param(60,57),[5,7],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(multiply(X11,X10))) = additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [70=param(38,15),[14,15],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X11,X10)))) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [82=param(39,70),[23],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(X10)))) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [85=param(39,82),[],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(additive_inverse(X10),additive_inverse(X11))) = add(X10,X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [89=param(85,19),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(additive_inverse(X10),X11) = additive_inverse(add(X10,additive_inverse(X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [92=demod(56),[89,10],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(X10,additive_inverse(X11)) = additive_inverse(commutator(X10,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [93=demod(55),[92],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(additive_inverse(X10),X11) = additive_inverse(commutator(X10,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [94=demod(57),[92],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(X10,X11) = additive_inverse(commutator(X11,X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [98=param(89,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,additive_inverse(X11))) = add(X11,additive_inverse(X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [100=param(42,89),[19],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,X10))) = additive_inverse(X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [102=param(36,14),[14],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,add(X12,X13))) = add(X11,add(X12,add(X13,X10)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [103=param(14,36),[14,14,14],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,add(X12,X13))) = add(X11,add(X12,add(X10,X13)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [105=param(36,60),[36],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,multiply(X11,X12)) = add(commutator(X12,X11),add(multiply(X12,X11),X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [107=param(36,89),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)))) = add(X12,add(X10,additive_inverse(X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [109=param(36,89),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(X12))) = additive_inverse(add(X12,additive_inverse(add(X10,X11))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [111=param(20,94),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),commutator(X11,X10)) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [112=param(89,94),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),X12) = additive_inverse(add(commutator(X11,X10),additive_inverse(X12)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [114=param(93,94),[],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(commutator(X10,X11),X12) = additive_inverse(commutator(commutator(X11,X10),X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [118=param(100,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X10,X11))) = additive_inverse(X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [120=param(37,15),[14],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,X12)) = add(X10,add(X12,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [121=param(37,36),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,X12)) = add(X12,add(X11,X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [123=param(37,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,multiply(X11,X12)) = add(commutator(X12,X11),add(X10,multiply(X12,X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [125=param(37,100),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X12,add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,X12)))) = add(X10,additive_inverse(X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [126=param(118,36),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X10,X12)))) = additive_inverse(add(X12,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [127=param(118,37),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X10,X12)))) = additive_inverse(add(X11,X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [128=demod(126),[127],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,X11)) = additive_inverse(add(X11,X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [129=param(37,118),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X12,add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X12,X11)))) = add(X10,additive_inverse(X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [130=param(14,111),[24],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X11,X12),add(commutator(X12,X11),X10)) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [131=param(36,111),[23],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X11,X12),add(X10,commutator(X12,X11))) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [134=param(128,14),[],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,add(X11,X12))) = additive_inverse(add(X12,add(X10,X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [136=param(89,128),[89,14,14],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)))) = additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X10,additive_inverse(X12))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [143=param(98,98),[14,89,19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)))) = add(X12,additive_inverse(add(X11,X10)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [145=param(14,131),[14],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X12,X13),add(X10,add(commutator(X13,X12),X11))) = add(X10,X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [146=param(37,131),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X12,X13),add(X10,add(X11,commutator(X13,X12)))) = add(X10,X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [149=param(50,130),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),X12) = add(X12,additive_inverse(commutator(X11,X10)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [155=param(121,89),[89],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)))) = add(X12,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(X10))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [161=param(120,18),[18],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,multiply(X11,add(X12,X13))) = add(X10,multiply(X11,add(X13,X12)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [164=param(120,89),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)))) = add(X10,add(X12,additive_inverse(X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [167=param(128,120),[14],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,add(X11,X12))) = additive_inverse(add(X12,add(X11,X10)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [190=param(62,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),add(X12,multiply(X10,X11))) = add(multiply(X11,X10),X12)].
% 153.65/154.21 [191=param(62,37),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),X12) = add(multiply(X11,X10),add(commutator(X11,X10),X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [192=param(149,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(commutator(X11,X12))) = add(X10,commutator(X12,X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [195=param(192,15),[89],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,commutator(X11,X12)) = additive_inverse(add(commutator(X12,X11),additive_inverse(X10)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [198=param(94,114),[19],
% 153.65/154.21 commutator(commutator(X10,X11),X12) = commutator(X12,commutator(X11,X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [200=param(20,114),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(commutator(X10,X11),X12),commutator(commutator(X11,X10),X12)) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [206=param(111,198),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,commutator(X11,X12)),commutator(X10,commutator(X12,X11))) = additive_identity].
% 153.65/154.21 [214=param(14,206),[24],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X11,commutator(X12,X13)),add(commutator(X11,commutator(X13,X12)),X10)) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [217=param(36,200),[23],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(commutator(X11,X12),X13),add(X10,commutator(commutator(X12,X11),X13))) = X10].
% 153.65/154.21 [219=param(167,107),[89,19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(X12))))) = add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X10,X12)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [311=param(145,206),[23],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(commutator(X10,X11),X12),X13) = add(X13,commutator(X12,commutator(X11,X10)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [322=param(161,15),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,multiply(X11,add(X12,X13))) = add(multiply(X11,add(X13,X12)),X10)].
% 153.65/154.21 [334=param(146,217),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,commutator(X11,X12)),X13) = add(commutator(commutator(X12,X11),X10),X13)].
% 153.65/154.21 [347=param(14,17),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(add(X10,X11),X12),X13) = add(multiply(X10,X12),add(multiply(X11,X12),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [352=param(14,18),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,add(X11,X12)),X13) = add(multiply(X10,X11),add(multiply(X10,X12),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [353=demod(322),[352],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,multiply(X11,add(X12,X13))) = add(multiply(X11,X13),add(multiply(X11,X12),X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [427=param(129,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),add(X12,additive_inverse(multiply(X11,X10)))) = add(X12,additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [437=param(62,17),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X11,X10),multiply(X12,X11)) = add(commutator(X10,X11),multiply(add(X10,X12),X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [448=param(127,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(add(X12,multiply(X11,X10)))) = additive_inverse(add(X12,multiply(X10,X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [492=param(37,192),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,commutator(X12,X13))) = add(X11,add(X10,additive_inverse(commutator(X13,X12))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [506=demod(191),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),X12) = add(multiply(X11,X10),add(commutator(X11,X10),X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [631=param(112,192),[19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(commutator(X10,X11),commutator(X12,X13))) = add(commutator(X11,X10),commutator(X13,X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1282=param(506,118),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(add(multiply(X11,X10),X12)))) = additive_inverse(X12)].
% 153.65/154.21 [1537=param(1282,164),[19],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),add(commutator(X10,X11),add(X12,additive_inverse(multiply(X11,X10))))) = X12].
% 153.65/154.21 [1652=param(62,3),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X11,X10),additive_inverse(multiply(X12,X11))) = add(commutator(X10,X11),multiply(add(X10,additive_inverse(X12)),X11))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1653=param(62,4),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X11,X10),additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X12))) = add(commutator(X10,X11),multiply(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(X12))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1708=param(129,129),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X12,additive_inverse(X13))))) = add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X12,additive_inverse(add(X10,X13)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1717=param(127,127),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X12,X13))))) = additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X12,add(X10,X13)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1718=param(127,129),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X12,additive_inverse(X13))))) = additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X12,additive_inverse(add(X10,X13)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1721=param(125,18),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,X11),add(X12,additive_inverse(multiply(X10,add(X13,X11))))) = add(X12,additive_inverse(multiply(X10,X13)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1786=param(103,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,multiply(X12,X13))) = add(X11,add(commutator(X13,X12),add(X10,multiply(X13,X12))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [1887=demod(50),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,add(X12,additive_inverse(X10)))) = add(X11,X12)].
% 153.65/154.21 [1922=param(109,149),[89,19],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,commutator(X12,X13)))) = additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X10,commutator(X13,X12)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [2203=param(134,143),[89,14,19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X12,additive_inverse(X13)))))) = add(X12,add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X10,X13))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [2395=param(134,155),[89,14,89,19,19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X12,additive_inverse(X13)))))) = add(X12,additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X10,X13))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [2711=param(214,145),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,commutator(X11,X12)),add(X13,X14)) = add(X13,add(commutator(commutator(X12,X11),X10),X14))].
% 153.65/154.21 [2712=param(145,214),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(commutator(X10,X11),X12),add(X13,X14)) = add(X13,add(commutator(X12,commutator(X11,X10)),X14))].
% 153.65/154.21 [9986=param(1721,65),[1652,100,7],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(add(X12,X10),X11),additive_inverse(multiply(X11,X12))) = add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(multiply(X12,X11)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [9999=param(1537,9986),[1887],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),commutator(X12,X11)) = commutator(add(X10,X12),X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [10000=param(14,9999),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(add(X10,X11),X12),X13) = add(commutator(X10,X12),add(commutator(X11,X12),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [10235=param(9999,93),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(commutator(X12,X11))) = commutator(add(X10,additive_inverse(X12)),X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [10237=param(9999,94),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(commutator(X11,X12))) = commutator(add(X10,X12),X11)].
% 153.65/154.21 [10314=param(631,9999),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X12,X10),commutator(X12,X11)) = additive_inverse(commutator(add(X10,X11),X12))].
% 153.65/154.21 [10367=param(10314,92),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),additive_inverse(commutator(X10,X12))) = additive_inverse(commutator(add(X11,additive_inverse(X12)),X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [10463=param(1887,10237),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,X11),add(X12,commutator(add(X13,X11),X10))) = add(X12,commutator(X13,X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [10797=param(146,10463),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,add(X11,X12)),add(X13,commutator(X11,X10))) = add(commutator(X10,X12),X13)].
% 153.65/154.21 [10813=param(146,10797),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,add(X11,X12)),X13) = add(commutator(X10,X11),add(commutator(X10,X12),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12117=param(103,65),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(multiply(X12,X13)))) = add(X11,add(commutator(X12,X13),add(X10,additive_inverse(multiply(X13,X12)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12185=param(107,107),[14,89],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X12,additive_inverse(X13))))) = add(X13,additive_inverse(add(X11,additive_inverse(add(X10,additive_inverse(X12))))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12234=param(103,112),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,additive_inverse(add(commutator(X11,X12),additive_inverse(add(X13,X14))))) = add(commutator(X12,X11),add(X13,add(X10,X14)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12235=param(103,112),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,additive_inverse(add(commutator(X12,X13),additive_inverse(X14))))) = add(X11,add(commutator(X13,X12),add(X10,X14)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12365=param(10813,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(X10,multiply(X11,X12)),X13) = add(commutator(X10,commutator(X12,X11)),add(commutator(X10,multiply(X12,X11)),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12382=param(134,102),[14,14],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(X10,add(X11,add(X12,add(X13,X14))))) = additive_inverse(add(X11,add(X12,add(X13,add(X10,X14)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12466=param(10000,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(commutator(multiply(X10,X11),X12),X13) = add(commutator(commutator(X11,X10),X12),add(commutator(multiply(X11,X10),X12),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12770=param(37,437),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(commutator(X11,X12),multiply(add(X11,X13),X12))) = add(multiply(X12,X11),add(X10,multiply(X13,X12)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12777=param(352,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12)),X13) = add(multiply(X10,commutator(X12,X11)),add(multiply(X10,multiply(X12,X11)),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [12796=param(347,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(multiply(multiply(X10,X11),X12),X13) = add(multiply(commutator(X11,X10),X12),add(multiply(multiply(X11,X10),X12),X13))].
% 153.65/154.21 [15054=param(353,60),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,multiply(X11,multiply(X12,X13))) = add(multiply(X11,multiply(X13,X12)),add(multiply(X11,commutator(X13,X12)),X10))].
% 153.65/154.21 [16148=param(103,62),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,add(multiply(X12,X13),X14))) = add(commutator(X13,X12),add(multiply(X13,X12),add(X10,add(X11,X14))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [16149=param(103,62),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(commutator(X11,X12),add(multiply(X11,X12),add(X13,X14)))) = add(multiply(X12,X11),add(X13,add(X10,X14)))].
% 153.65/154.21 [16155=param(103,102),[],
% 153.65/154.21 add(X10,add(X11,add(X12,add(X13,add(X14,X15))))) = add(X11,add(X15,add(X10,add(X12,add(X13,X14)))))].
% 153.65/154.21 [21245=param(352,195),[5,89,352,5,89,19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(multiply(X10,commutator(X11,X12)),additive_inverse(add(multiply(X10,X13),X14)))) = add(multiply(X10,X13),add(multiply(X10,commutator(X12,X11)),X14))].
% 153.65/154.21 [21250=param(10813,195),[92,89,10813,92,89,19],
% 153.65/154.21 additive_inverse(add(commutator(X10,commutator(X11,X12)),additive_inverse(add(commutator(X10,X13),X14)))) = add(commutator(X10,X13),add(commutator(X10,commutator(X12,X11)),X14))].
% 153.75/154.23 [26075=param(352,311),[352],
% 153.75/154.23 add(multiply(X10,X11),add(multiply(X10,commutator(X12,commutator(X13,X14))),X15)) = add(multiply(X10,commutator(commutator(X14,X13),X12)),add(multiply(X10,X11),X15))].
% 153.75/154.23 [26884=param(103,334),[],
% 153.75/154.23 add(X10,add(commutator(commutator(X11,X12),X13),add(X14,X15))) = add(commutator(X13,commutator(X12,X11)),add(X14,add(X10,X15)))].
% 153.75/154.23 [28136=param(26,15),[105,12777,12365,-12234,57,92,89,19,19,-2712,57,92,57,19,105,12777,12365,-12234,57,92,89,19,19,-2712,57,92,57,19,352,352,352,352,5,89,14,14,14,14,15,-219,19,62,437,57,92,-12235,57,92,89,19,19,-12235,57,92,89,19,19,1887,-123,-12770,57,92,60,89,118,19,89,118,19,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,1708,89,12777,19,-21245,57,92,5,136,89,19,19,62,26075,57,92,57,19,89,118,19,62,26075,57,92,57,19,89,118,19,62,26075,57,92,57,19,89,118,19,-2395,1718,62,12777,12796,62,12777,62,-16149,57,92,-16149,57,92,62,-16149,57,92,62,-16149,57,92,62,89,118,19,89,118,19,89,118,19,62,-12234,57,92,-2395,89,19,19,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,89,118,19,-12234,57,92,12382,89,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,12365,57,92,89,118,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,12365,57,92,12466,89,12365,57,92,89,19,1708,118,19,-2395,-219,19,-21250,57,92,92,89,19,19,-2395,-219,19,19,-21250,57,92,92,89,19,19,19,-2395,-219,19,19,-21250,57,92,92,89,19,19,-2395,1717,19,-21250,57,92,92,89,19,19,19,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,-2203,-2395,1717,89,127,19,19,-2395,-219,19,-219,19,19,-219,19,19,62,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,-2203,-2395,1717,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,12117,57,92,3,20,22,15,24,62,-492,57,92,89,118,19,62,-12234,57,92,89,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,89,118,19,62,-12234,57,92,89,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,89,118,19,62,-12234,57,92,89,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,89,118,19,19,-2395,-219,19,-219,19,19,-219,19,19,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,-2203,-2395,1717,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,16148,57,92,1887,62,1786,57,92,17,60,89,-219,19,-448,57,92,89,19,12365,57,92,89,19,129,118,19,89,1717,62,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,1717,89,118,19,1717,62,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,-219,19,89,118,19,-219,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,19,-2711,57,92,57,92,93,19,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,-219,19,1708,-219,19,1708,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,-2395,1718,16155,18,60,36,15,-427,57,92,89,12365,57,92,12466,89,12365,57,92,89,19,1717,1718,12117,1653,57,92,65,5,89,19,12365,-2395,12365,57,92,12466,89,12365,57,92,89,19,118,19,129,1717,-427,57,92,89,12365,57,92,89,19,1708,118,19,118,19,1717,1718,12117,1652,57,92,3,20,22,22,15,24,20,-190,57,92,24,89,65,19,1717,1718,18,15054,-21245,57,92,5,89,19,19,19,1708,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,4,127,5,1708,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,4,1922,57,92,10367,1652,57,92,20,22,15,24,57,19,19,-190,57,92,1786,89,118,19,60,5,19,1708,26884,57,92,57,92,93,19,4,65,5,1708,1887,9999,60,1717,10235,1652,57,92,20,22,15,24,93,-12185,20,15,24,-98,10237,60,57,92,19,10367,1652,57,92,20,22,15,24,93,19,20,25],
% 153.75/154.23 thmtrue = thmfalse].
% 153.75/154.23 % SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 153.75/154.23 Space: 515946 KB
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------