TSTP Solution File: NLP258+1 by leanCoP---2.2
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : leanCoP---2.2
% Problem : NLP258+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : leancop_casc.sh %s %d
% Computer : n012.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Mon Jul 18 03:00:22 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 47.86s 46.82s
% Output : Proof 47.86s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.06/0.12 % Problem : NLP258+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.06/0.12 % Command : leancop_casc.sh %s %d
% 0.13/0.33 % Computer : n012.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.33 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.33 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.13/0.33 % DateTime : Thu Jun 30 22:38:18 EDT 2022
% 0.13/0.33 % CPUTime :
% 47.86/46.82 % SZS status Theorem for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 47.86/46.82 % SZS output start Proof for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 47.86/46.83
% 47.86/46.83 %-----------------------------------------------------
% 47.86/46.83 fof(co1, conjecture, ~ (? [_174133] : (actual_world(_174133) & ? [_174148, _174151, _174154, _174157, _174160, _174163, _174166] : (of(_174133, _174151, _174148) & man(_174133, _174148) & vincent_forename(_174133, _174151) & forename(_174133, _174151) & proposition(_174133, _174157) & agent(_174133, _174154, _174148) & theme(_174133, _174154, _174157) & event(_174133, _174154) & present(_174133, _174154) & think_believe_consider(_174133, _174154) & accessible_world(_174133, _174157) & ! [_174293] : (man(_174157, _174293) => ? [_174311] : (event(_174157, _174311) & agent(_174157, _174311, _174293) & present(_174157, _174311) & smoke(_174157, _174311))) & of(_174133, _174160, _174163) & man(_174133, _174163) & jules_forename(_174133, _174160) & forename(_174133, _174160) & man(_174133, _174163) & state(_174133, _174166) & be(_174133, _174166, _174163, _174163))) & ~ ? [_174443] : (actual_world(_174443) & ? [_174458, _174461, _174148, _174151, _174154, _174157, _174160, _174163, _174166, _174478, _174481] : (of(_174443, _174458, _174163) & jules_forename(_174443, _174458) & forename(_174443, _174458) & of(_174443, _174461, _174148) & vincent_forename(_174443, _174461) & forename(_174443, _174461) & of(_174443, _174151, _174148) & man(_174443, _174148) & vincent_forename(_174443, _174151) & forename(_174443, _174151) & proposition(_174443, _174157) & agent(_174443, _174154, _174148) & theme(_174443, _174154, _174157) & event(_174443, _174154) & present(_174443, _174154) & think_believe_consider(_174443, _174154) & accessible_world(_174443, _174157) & ! [_174293] : (man(_174157, _174293) => ? [_174311] : (event(_174157, _174311) & agent(_174157, _174311, _174293) & present(_174157, _174311) & smoke(_174157, _174311))) & of(_174443, _174160, _174163) & man(_174443, _174163) & jules_forename(_174443, _174160) & forename(_174443, _174160) & man(_174443, _174163) & state(_174443, _174166) & be(_174443, _174166, _174163, _174163) & proposition(_174443, _174481) & agent(_174443, _174478, _174148) & theme(_174443, _174478, _174481) & event(_174443, _174478) & present(_174443, _174478) & think_believe_consider(_174443, _174478) & accessible_world(_174443, _174481) & ? [_174896] : (event(_174481, _174896) & agent(_174481, _174896, _174163) & present(_174481, _174896) & smoke(_174481, _174896))))), file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 fof(ax49, axiom, ! [_176933, _176936, _176939] : (accessible_world(_176936, _176939) & man(_176936, _176933) => man(_176939, _176933)), file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', ax49)).
% 47.86/46.83
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(1, plain, [-(12 ^ [_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476]), event(_106610, _124211), agent(_106610, _124211, 11 ^ [_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476]), present(_106610, _124211), smoke(_106610, _124211)], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(2, plain, [-(12 ^ [_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476]), -(man(_106610, 11 ^ [_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476]))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(3, plain, [-(10 ^ [_123729]), -(smoke(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [_123729]))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(4, plain, [-(10 ^ [_123729]), -(present(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [_123729]))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(5, plain, [-(10 ^ [_123729]), -(agent(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [_123729], _123729))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(6, plain, [-(10 ^ [_123729]), -(event(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [_123729]))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(7, plain, [-(actual_world(1 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(8, plain, [-(of(1 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(9, plain, [-(man(1 ^ [], 2 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(10, plain, [-(vincent_forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(11, plain, [-(forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(12, plain, [-(proposition(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(13, plain, [-(agent(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 2 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(14, plain, [-(theme(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 5 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(15, plain, [-(event(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(16, plain, [-(present(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(17, plain, [-(think_believe_consider(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(18, plain, [-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(19, plain, [-(of(1 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(20, plain, [-(man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(21, plain, [-(jules_forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(22, plain, [-(forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(23, plain, [-(state(1 ^ [], 8 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(24, plain, [-(be(1 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(25, plain, [man(5 ^ [], _123729), 10 ^ [_123729]], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(26, plain, [actual_world(_104476), of(_104476, _104870, _107299), jules_forename(_104476, _104870), forename(_104476, _104870), of(_104476, _105220, _105569), vincent_forename(_104476, _105220), forename(_104476, _105220), of(_104476, _105917, _105569), man(_104476, _105569), vincent_forename(_104476, _105917), forename(_104476, _105917), proposition(_104476, _106610), agent(_104476, _106264, _105569), theme(_104476, _106264, _106610), event(_104476, _106264), present(_104476, _106264), think_believe_consider(_104476, _106264), accessible_world(_104476, _106610), 12 ^ [_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476], of(_104476, _106955, _107299), jules_forename(_104476, _106955), forename(_104476, _106955), man(_104476, _107299), state(_104476, _107642), be(_104476, _107642, _107299, _107299), proposition(_104476, _108325), agent(_104476, _107984, _105569), theme(_104476, _107984, _108325), event(_104476, _107984), present(_104476, _107984), think_believe_consider(_104476, _107984), accessible_world(_104476, _108325), event(_108325, _111521), agent(_108325, _111521, _107299), present(_108325, _111521), smoke(_108325, _111521)], clausify(co1)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf(27, plain, [-(man(_86423, _86312)), accessible_world(_86368, _86423), man(_86368, _86312)], clausify(ax49)).
% 47.86/46.83
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1',plain,[-(man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],start(20)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1',plain,[man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []), actual_world(1 ^ []), of(1 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 7 ^ []), jules_forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []), forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []), of(1 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ []), vincent_forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []), forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []), of(1 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ []), man(1 ^ [], 2 ^ []), vincent_forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []), forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []), proposition(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), agent(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 2 ^ []), theme(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 5 ^ []), event(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []), present(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []), think_believe_consider(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []), accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), 12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []], of(1 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 7 ^ []), jules_forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []), forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []), state(1 ^ [], 8 ^ []), be(1 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []), proposition(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), agent(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 2 ^ []), theme(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 5 ^ []), event(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []), present(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []), think_believe_consider(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []), accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), event(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []]), agent(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []], 7 ^ []), present(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []]), smoke(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []])],extension(26,bind([[_106610, _106264, _105917, _105220, _104870, _106955, _107642, _105569, _107984, _104476, _107299, _108325, _111521], [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 1 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.1',plain,[-(actual_world(1 ^ []))],extension(7)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.2',plain,[-(of(1 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(19)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.3',plain,[-(jules_forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(21)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.4',plain,[-(forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(22)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.5',plain,[-(of(1 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ []))],extension(8)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.6',plain,[-(vincent_forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []))],extension(10)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.7',plain,[-(forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []))],extension(11)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.8',plain,[-(of(1 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ []))],extension(8)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.9',plain,[-(man(1 ^ [], 2 ^ []))],extension(9)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.10',plain,[-(vincent_forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []))],extension(10)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.11',plain,[-(forename(1 ^ [], 3 ^ []))],extension(11)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.12',plain,[-(proposition(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(12)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.13',plain,[-(agent(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 2 ^ []))],extension(13)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.14',plain,[-(theme(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(14)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.15',plain,[-(event(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))],extension(15)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.16',plain,[-(present(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))],extension(16)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.17',plain,[-(think_believe_consider(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))],extension(17)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.18',plain,[-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(18)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19',plain,[-(12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]), event(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]), agent(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]), present(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]), smoke(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])],extension(1,bind([[_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476, _106610, _124211], [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.1',plain,[-(event(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])), -(10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])],extension(6,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.1.1',plain,[10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]], man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.1.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])), -(12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(2,bind([[_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476], [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.1.1.1.1',plain,[12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]],reduction('1.1')).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.2',plain,[-(agent(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])), -(10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])],extension(5,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.2.1',plain,[10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]], man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.2.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])), -(12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(2,bind([[_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476], [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.2.1.1.1',plain,[12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]],reduction('1.1')).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.3',plain,[-(present(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])), -(10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])],extension(4,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.3.1',plain,[10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]], man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.3.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])), -(12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(2,bind([[_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476], [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.3.1.1.1',plain,[12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]],reduction('1.1')).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.4',plain,[-(smoke(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])), -(10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]])],extension(3,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.4.1',plain,[10 ^ [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]], man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.4.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])), -(12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []])],extension(2,bind([[_108325, _107984, _107642, _107299, _106955, _106610, _106264, _105917, _105569, _105220, _104870, _104476], [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.19.4.1.1.1',plain,[12 ^ [5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 2 ^ [], 3 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 1 ^ []]],reduction('1.1')).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.20',plain,[-(of(1 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(19)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.21',plain,[-(jules_forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(21)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.22',plain,[-(forename(1 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(22)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.23',plain,[-(state(1 ^ [], 8 ^ []))],extension(23)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.24',plain,[-(be(1 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(24)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.25',plain,[-(proposition(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(12)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.26',plain,[-(agent(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 2 ^ []))],extension(13)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.27',plain,[-(theme(1 ^ [], 4 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(14)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.28',plain,[-(event(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))],extension(15)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.29',plain,[-(present(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))],extension(16)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.30',plain,[-(think_believe_consider(1 ^ [], 4 ^ []))],extension(17)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.31',plain,[-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(18)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.32',plain,[-(event(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []])), -(10 ^ [7 ^ []])],extension(6,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.32.1',plain,[10 ^ [7 ^ []], man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.32.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])), accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(27,bind([[_86423, _86368, _86312], [5 ^ [], 1 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.32.1.1.1',plain,[-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(18)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.32.1.1.2',plain,[-(man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(20)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.33',plain,[-(agent(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), -(10 ^ [7 ^ []])],extension(5,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.33.1',plain,[10 ^ [7 ^ []], man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.33.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])), accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(27,bind([[_86423, _86368, _86312], [5 ^ [], 1 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.33.1.1.1',plain,[-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(18)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.33.1.1.2',plain,[-(man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(20)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.34',plain,[-(present(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []])), -(10 ^ [7 ^ []])],extension(4,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.34.1',plain,[10 ^ [7 ^ []], man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.34.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])), accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(27,bind([[_86423, _86368, _86312], [5 ^ [], 1 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.34.1.1.1',plain,[-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(18)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.34.1.1.2',plain,[-(man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(20)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.35',plain,[-(smoke(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [7 ^ []])), -(10 ^ [7 ^ []])],extension(3,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.35.1',plain,[10 ^ [7 ^ []], man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(25,bind([[_123729], [7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.35.1.1',plain,[-(man(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])), accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []), man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(27,bind([[_86423, _86368, _86312], [5 ^ [], 1 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.35.1.1.1',plain,[-(accessible_world(1 ^ [], 5 ^ []))],extension(18)).
% 47.86/46.83 cnf('1.1.35.1.1.2',plain,[-(man(1 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(20)).
% 47.86/46.83 %-----------------------------------------------------
% 47.86/46.83
% 47.86/46.83 % SZS output end Proof for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------