TSTP Solution File: NLP252-1 by ConnectPP---0.3.0
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : ConnectPP---0.3.0
% Problem : NLP252-1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : connect++ --verbosity 0 --no-colour --tptp-proof --schedule default %s
% Computer : n009.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Mon Mar 25 14:22:48 EDT 2024
% Result : Unsatisfiable 82.95s 83.20s
% Output : Proof 82.95s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.08/0.13 % Problem : NLP252-1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.08/0.13 % Command : connect++ --verbosity 0 --no-colour --tptp-proof --schedule default %s
% 0.14/0.34 % Computer : n009.cluster.edu
% 0.14/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.14/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.14/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.14/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.14/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.14/0.34 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.14/0.34 % DateTime : Wed Mar 20 16:43:44 EDT 2024
% 0.14/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 82.95/83.20 % SZS status Unsatisfiable for theBenchmark
% 82.95/83.20 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark
% 82.95/83.20
% 82.95/83.20 % Problem matrix:
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-0, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 = __eqx_0) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-1, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqx_1) | ( __eqx_1 = __eqx_0) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-2, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqx_1) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqx_2) | ( __eqx_0 = __eqx_2) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-3, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( skf2(__eqx_0) = skf2(__eqy_0)) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-4, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( skf4(__eqx_0) = skf4(__eqy_0)) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-5, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~smoke(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | smoke(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-6, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~event(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | event(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-7, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~eventuality(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | eventuality(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-8, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~thing(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | thing(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-9, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~singleton(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | singleton(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-10, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~specific(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | specific(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-11, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~nonexistent(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | nonexistent(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-12, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~unisex(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | unisex(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-13, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~proposition(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | proposition(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-14, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~relation(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | relation(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-15, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~abstraction(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | abstraction(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-16, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~nonhuman(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | nonhuman(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-17, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~general(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | general(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-18, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~state(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | state(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-19, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~man(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | man(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-20, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~human_person(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | human_person(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-21, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~organism(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | organism(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-22, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~entity(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | entity(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-23, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~existent(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | existent(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-24, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~impartial(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | impartial(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-25, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~living(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | living(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-26, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~human(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | human(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-27, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~animate(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | animate(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-28, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~male(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | male(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-29, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~forename(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | forename(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-30, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~relname(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | relname(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-31, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~vincent_forename(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | vincent_forename(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-32, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~jules_forename(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | jules_forename(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-33, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ( __eqx_2 != __eqy_2) | ( __eqx_3 != __eqy_3) | ~be(__eqx_0, __eqx_1, __eqx_2, __eqx_3) | be(__eqy_0, __eqy_1, __eqy_2, __eqy_3) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-34, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~accessible_world(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | accessible_world(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-35, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~present(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | present(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-36, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ~think_believe_consider(__eqx_0, __eqx_1) | think_believe_consider(__eqy_0, __eqy_1) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-37, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ( __eqx_2 != __eqy_2) | ~agent(__eqx_0, __eqx_1, __eqx_2) | agent(__eqy_0, __eqy_1, __eqy_2) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-38, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ( __eqx_2 != __eqy_2) | ~theme(__eqx_0, __eqx_1, __eqx_2) | theme(__eqy_0, __eqy_1, __eqy_2) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-39, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ( __eqx_1 != __eqy_1) | ( __eqx_2 != __eqy_2) | ~of(__eqx_0, __eqx_1, __eqx_2) | of(__eqy_0, __eqy_1, __eqy_2) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-40, plain, ( ( __eqx_0 != __eqy_0) | ~actual_world(__eqx_0) | actual_world(__eqy_0) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-41, plain, ( ~smoke(U, V) | event(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-42, plain, ( ~event(U, V) | eventuality(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-43, plain, ( ~eventuality(U, V) | thing(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-44, plain, ( ~thing(U, V) | singleton(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-45, plain, ( ~eventuality(U, V) | specific(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-46, plain, ( ~eventuality(U, V) | nonexistent(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-47, plain, ( ~eventuality(U, V) | unisex(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-48, plain, ( ~proposition(U, V) | relation(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-49, plain, ( ~relation(U, V) | abstraction(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-50, plain, ( ~abstraction(U, V) | thing(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-51, plain, ( ~abstraction(U, V) | nonhuman(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-52, plain, ( ~abstraction(U, V) | general(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-53, plain, ( ~abstraction(U, V) | unisex(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-54, plain, ( ~state(U, V) | eventuality(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-55, plain, ( ~state(U, V) | event(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-56, plain, ( ~man(U, V) | human_person(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-57, plain, ( ~human_person(U, V) | organism(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-58, plain, ( ~organism(U, V) | entity(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-59, plain, ( ~entity(U, V) | thing(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-60, plain, ( ~entity(U, V) | specific(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-61, plain, ( ~entity(U, V) | existent(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-62, plain, ( ~organism(U, V) | impartial(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-63, plain, ( ~organism(U, V) | living(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-64, plain, ( ~human_person(U, V) | human(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-65, plain, ( ~human_person(U, V) | animate(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-66, plain, ( ~man(U, V) | male(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-67, plain, ( ~forename(U, V) | relname(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-68, plain, ( ~relname(U, V) | relation(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-69, plain, ( ~vincent_forename(U, V) | forename(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-70, plain, ( ~jules_forename(U, V) | forename(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-71, plain, ( ~male(U, V) | ~unisex(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-72, plain, ( ~general(U, V) | ~specific(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-73, plain, ( ~human(U, V) | ~nonhuman(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-74, plain, ( ~nonexistent(U, V) | ~existent(U, V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-75, plain, ( ~be(U, V, W, X) | ( W = X) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-76, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~smoke(U, W) | smoke(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-77, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~event(U, W) | event(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-78, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~eventuality(U, W) | eventuality(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-79, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~thing(U, W) | thing(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-80, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~singleton(U, W) | singleton(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-81, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~specific(U, W) | specific(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-82, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~nonexistent(U, W) | nonexistent(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-83, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~unisex(U, W) | unisex(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-84, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~present(U, W) | present(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-85, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~think_believe_consider(U, W) | think_believe_consider(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-86, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~proposition(U, W) | proposition(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-87, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~relation(U, W) | relation(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-88, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~abstraction(U, W) | abstraction(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-89, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~nonhuman(U, W) | nonhuman(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-90, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~general(U, W) | general(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-91, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~state(U, W) | state(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-92, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~man(U, W) | man(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-93, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~human_person(U, W) | human_person(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-94, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~organism(U, W) | organism(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-95, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~entity(U, W) | entity(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-96, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~existent(U, W) | existent(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-97, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~impartial(U, W) | impartial(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-98, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~living(U, W) | living(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-99, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~human(U, W) | human(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-100, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~animate(U, W) | animate(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-101, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~male(U, W) | male(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-102, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~forename(U, W) | forename(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-103, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~relname(U, W) | relname(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-104, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~vincent_forename(U, W) | vincent_forename(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-105, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~jules_forename(U, W) | jules_forename(V, W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-106, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~agent(U, W, X) | agent(V, W, X) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-107, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~theme(U, W, X) | theme(V, W, X) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-108, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~of(U, W, X) | of(V, W, X) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-109, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~be(U, W, X, Y) | be(V, W, X, Y) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-110, plain, ( ~forename(U, V) | ~of(U, W, X) | ~forename(U, W) | ~of(U, V, X) | ~entity(U, X) | ( W = V) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-111, plain, ( ~proposition(U, V) | ~proposition(U, W) | ~theme(U, X, V) | ~think_believe_consider(U, X) | ~think_believe_consider(U, Y) | ~theme(U, Y, W) | ~agent(U, Y, Z) | ~agent(U, X, Z) | ( V = W) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-112, plain, ( actual_world(skc8) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-113, plain, ( man(skc8, skc15) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-114, plain, ( forename(skc8, skc14) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-115, plain, ( vincent_forename(skc8, skc14) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-116, plain, ( event(skc8, skc13) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-117, plain, ( present(skc8, skc13) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-118, plain, ( think_believe_consider(skc8, skc13) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-119, plain, ( jules_forename(skc8, skc11) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-120, plain, ( forename(skc8, skc11) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-121, plain, ( man(skc8, skc10) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-122, plain, ( state(skc8, skc9) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-123, plain, ( accessible_world(skc8, skc12) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-124, plain, ( proposition(skc8, skc12) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-125, plain, ( of(skc8, skc14, skc15) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-126, plain, ( agent(skc8, skc13, skc15) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-127, plain, ( theme(skc8, skc13, skc12) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-128, plain, ( of(skc8, skc11, skc10) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-129, plain, ( be(skc8, skc9, skc10, skc10) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-130, plain, ( ~man(skc12, U) | smoke(skc12, skf2(V)) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-131, plain, ( ~man(skc12, U) | present(skc12, skf2(V)) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-132, plain, ( ~man(skc12, U) | event(skc12, skf2(V)) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-133, plain, ( ~man(skc12, U) | agent(skc12, skf2(U), U) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-134, plain, ( ~accessible_world(U, V) | ~proposition(U, V) | ~theme(U, W, V) | ~event(U, W) | ~present(U, W) | ~think_believe_consider(U, W) | ~forename(U, X) | ~vincent_forename(U, X) | ~of(U, X, Y) | ~man(U, Y) | ~agent(U, W, Y) | ~state(U, Z) | ~smoke(X1, X2) | ~present(X1, X2) | ~agent(X1, X2, X3) | ~event(X1, X2) | ~be(U, Z, X3, X3) | ~man(U, X3) | ~of(U, X4, X3) | ~jules_forename(U, X4) | ~forename(U, X4) | ~proposition(U, X1) | ~accessible_world(U, X1) | ~think_believe_consider(U, X5) | ~present(U, X5) | ~event(U, X5) | ~theme(U, X5, X1) | ~vincent_forename(U, X6) | ~forename(U, X6) | ~agent(U, X5, X7) | ~man(U, X7) | ~of(U, X6, X7) | ~actual_world(U) | man(V, skf4(V)) )).
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(matrix-135, plain, ( ~smoke(U, V) | ~present(U, V) | ~agent(U, V, skf4(U)) | ~event(U, V) | ~accessible_world(W, U) | ~proposition(W, U) | ~theme(W, X, U) | ~event(W, X) | ~present(W, X) | ~think_believe_consider(W, X) | ~forename(W, Y) | ~vincent_forename(W, Y) | ~of(W, Y, Z) | ~man(W, Z) | ~agent(W, X, Z) | ~state(W, X1) | ~smoke(X2, X3) | ~present(X2, X3) | ~agent(X2, X3, X4) | ~event(X2, X3) | ~be(W, X1, X4, X4) | ~man(W, X4) | ~of(W, X5, X4) | ~jules_forename(W, X5) | ~forename(W, X5) | ~proposition(W, X2) | ~accessible_world(W, X2) | ~think_believe_consider(W, X6) | ~present(W, X6) | ~event(W, X6) | ~theme(W, X6, X2) | ~vincent_forename(W, X7) | ~forename(W, X7) | ~agent(W, X6, X8) | ~man(W, X8) | ~of(W, X7, X8) | ~actual_world(W) )).
% 82.95/83.20
% 82.95/83.20 % Proof stack:
% 82.95/83.20 cnf(proof-stack, plain,
% 82.95/83.20 proof_stack(
% 82.95/83.20 start(125),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 135, 35, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 130, 1, 3),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 134, 33, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(5),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 112, 0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(6),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 113, 0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(8),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(9),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 114, 0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(10),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 115, 0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(11),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 127, 0, 12),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(12),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 116, 0, 13),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(13),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 117, 0, 14),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(14),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 118, 0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(15),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 124, 0, 17),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(17),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 120, 0, 18),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(18),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 119, 0, 19),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(19),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 128, 0, 20),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(20),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 21),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 129, 0, 22),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(22),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 23),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 24),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 25),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(25),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(24),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(23),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 24),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 25),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(26),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(25),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(24),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 131, 1, 25),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 26),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 27),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(27),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 28),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(28),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(25),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 130, 1, 26),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 27),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 28),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(28),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 29),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(29),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(27),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(26),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 122, 0, 27),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(27),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 28),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(28),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 3),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(4),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(3),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 112, 0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(4),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 113, 0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(5),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(6),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 114, 0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(7),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 115, 0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(8),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 127, 0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(9),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 116, 0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(10),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 117, 0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(11),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 118, 0, 12),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(12),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 13),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(13),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 124, 0, 14),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(14),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 120, 0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(15),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 119, 0, 16),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(16),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 128, 0, 17),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(17),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 18),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(18),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 129, 0, 19),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(19),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 20),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 134, 33, 21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 22),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(22),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 1),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(26),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 127, 0, 29),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(29),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 120, 0, 35),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(35),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 13),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 128, 0, 37),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(37),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 129, 0, 39),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(39),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 40),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 41),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 42),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(42),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 43),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(43),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(41),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(40),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 41),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 42),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 43),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(43),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(42),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(41),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 131, 1, 42),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 43),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 44),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(44),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 45),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(45),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(43),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(42),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 130, 1, 43),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 44),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 45),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(45),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 46),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(46),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(44),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(43),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 122, 0, 44),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(44),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 45),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(45),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(21),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(20),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 22),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 23),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(23),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(22),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 131, 1, 22),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 23),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 24),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(24),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 25),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(25),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(23),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(22),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 130, 1, 23),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 24),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 25),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(25),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(26),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(24),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(23),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 122, 0, 24),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(24),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 25),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(25),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 36),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 134, 33, 37),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 38),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(38),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 1),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 42),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(42),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 127, 0, 45),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(45),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 120, 0, 51),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(51),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 13),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 128, 0, 53),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(53),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 129, 0, 55),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(55),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 56),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 57),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 58),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(58),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 59),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(59),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(57),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(56),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 57),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 58),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 59),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(59),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(58),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(57),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 19),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 20),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 61),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(61),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(37),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(36),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 37),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 134, 33, 38),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 39),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(39),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 1),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 43),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(43),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 127, 0, 46),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(46),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 120, 0, 52),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(52),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 13),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 128, 0, 54),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(54),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 129, 0, 56),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(56),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 57),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 58),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 59),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(59),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 60),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(60),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(58),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(57),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 58),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 59),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 60),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(60),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(59),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(58),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 19),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 20),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 62),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(62),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(38),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(37),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 131, 1, 38),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 134, 33, 39),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 40),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(40),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 1),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 44),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(44),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 127, 0, 47),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(47),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 10),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 120, 0, 53),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(53),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 13),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 128, 0, 55),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(55),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 129, 0, 57),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(57),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 132, 1, 58),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 59),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 60),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(60),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 121, 0, 61),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(61),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(59),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(58),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 133, 1, 59),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 92, 2, 60),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 123, 0, 61),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(61),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 15),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(60),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(59),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 19),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 20),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 21),
% 82.95/83.20 left_branch(0, 126, 0, 63),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(63),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 2),
% 82.95/83.20 reduction(0, 0),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 5),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 4),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 9),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 8),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 7),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 6),
% 82.95/83.20 lemmata(0, 11),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(39),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(38),
% 82.95/83.20 right_branch(2)
% 82.95/83.20 )).
% 82.95/83.20 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------