TSTP Solution File: NLP225-1 by FDP---0.9.16

View Problem - Process Solution

%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File     : FDP---0.9.16
% Problem  : NLP225-1 : TPTP v5.0.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm  : add_equality
% Format   : protein
% Command  : fdp-casc %s %d

% Computer : art02.cs.miami.edu
% Model    : i686 i686
% CPU      : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
% Memory   : 2018MB
% OS       : Linux 2.6.26.8-57.fc8
% CPULimit : 300s
% DateTime : Sun Jan  9 22:59:22 EST 2011

% Result   : Satisfiable 10.45s
% Output   : Assurance 10.45s
% Verified : 
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax   : Number of formulae    : 0

% Comments : 
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----NO SOLUTION OUTPUT BY SYSTEM
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 		o===================================o
% 		|      EQuality TRAnsFOrmation      |
% 		| bthomas@informatik.uni-koblenz.de |
% 		o===================================o
% 		          $Revision: 1.14 $
% reading /tmp/NLP225-1+eq_rstfp.tme
% result written to : /tmp/NLP225-1+eq_rstfp-eqt.tme
% FDPLL - A First-Order Davis-Putnam Theorem Prover
% Version 0.9.16 (26/06/2002)
% Proving /tmp/NLP225-1+eq_rstfp-eqt ...
% Done.
% Input File...............: /tmp/NLP225-1+eq_rstfp-eqt.tme
% System...................: Linux art02.cs.miami.edu 2.6.26.8-57.fc8 #1 SMP Thu Dec 18 19:19:45 EST 2008 i686 i686 i386 GNU/Linux
% Automatic mode...........: on
% Time limit...............: 300 seconds
% Current restart interval.: 157 seconds
% Restart with =-axioms....: 225 seconds
% Initial interpretation...: [+(_216387)]
% Clause set type..........: Horn, with equality
% Equality transformation..: on
% Non-constant functions...: yes
% Term depth settings......: 3/2 (Init/Increment)
% unit_extend..............: on
% splitting type...........: exact
% Final tree statistics:
% Tree for clause set......: with equality transformation applied
% # Restarts...............: 0
% Term depth limit.........: 5
% # Splits.................: 0
% # Commits................: 0
% # Unit extension steps...: 539
% # Unit back subsumptions.: 0
% # Branches closed........: 0
% # Level cuts.............: 0
% Time.....................: 10.01 seconds.
% Result...................: SATISFIABLE with model:
%   -(tpos(skc15, skf1(V_2447_216461)))
%   -(tpos(skc13, skf1(V_2447_216471)))
%   -(tpos(skc11, skf1(V_2447_216481)))
%   -(skc13(skf1(V_2447_216490)))
%   -(skc15(skf1(V_2447_216499)))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc8, skf1(V_2447_216509)))
%   -(jules_forename(skc8, skf1(V_2447_216519)))
%   -(be(U_2501_216529, V_2502_216530, skf1(V_2447_216533), skc13))
%   -(be(U_2479_216543, V_2480_216544, skc13, skf1(V_2447_216547)))
%   -(be(U_2501_216557, V_2502_216558, skf1(V_2447_216561), skc15))
%   -(be(U_2479_216571, V_2480_216572, skc15, skf1(V_2447_216575)))
%   -(skc11(skf1(V_2447_216584)))
%   -(forename(skc8, skf1(V_2447_216594)))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc11, skf1(V_2447_216604)))
%   -(jules_forename(skc11, skf1(V_2447_216614)))
%   -(be(U_2501_216624, V_2502_216625, skf1(V_2447_216628), skc11))
%   -(be(U_2479_216638, V_2480_216639, skc11, skf1(V_2447_216642)))
%   -(tpos(skf1(V_2447_216652), skc13))
%   -(be(U_2501_216662, V_2502_216663, skc12, skc13))
%   -(be(U_2479_216673, V_2480_216674, skc13, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2501_216684, V_2502_216685, skc9, skc13))
%   -(be(U_2479_216695, V_2480_216696, skc13, skc9))
%   -(tpos(skf1(V_2447_216706), skc15))
%   -(be(U_2501_216716, V_2502_216717, skc12, skc15))
%   -(be(U_2479_216727, V_2480_216728, skc15, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2501_216738, V_2502_216739, skc9, skc15))
%   -(be(U_2479_216749, V_2480_216750, skc15, skc9))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc11, skc9))
%   -(jules_forename(skc11, skc9))
%   -(tpos(skc15, skc9))
%   -(tpos(skc13, skc9))
%   -(tpos(skc14, skf1(V_2447_216788)))
%   -(tpos(skc10, skf1(V_2447_216798)))
%   -(human_person(skc8, skf1(V_2447_216808)))
%   -(proposition(skc8, skf1(V_2447_216818)))
%   -(relname(skc8, skf1(V_2447_216828)))
%   -(forename(skc11, skf1(V_2447_216838)))
%   -(tpos(skf1(V_2447_216848), skc11))
%   -(be(U_2501_216858, V_2502_216859, skc9, skc11))
%   -(be(U_2479_216869, V_2480_216870, skc11, skc9))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc11, skc12))
%   -(jules_forename(skc11, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2501_216894, V_2502_216895, skc11, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2479_216905, V_2480_216906, skc12, skc11))
%   -(tpos(skc15, skc12))
%   -(tpos(skc13, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2501_216930, V_2502_216931, skc10, skc13))
%   -(be(U_2479_216941, V_2480_216942, skc13, skc10))
%   -(skf1(V_2447_216950, skc13))
%   -(smoke(skc11, skc13))
%   -(tpos(skc12, skc13))
%   -(tpos(skc9, skc13))
%   -(be(U_2501_216981, V_2502_216982, skc13, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2479_216992, V_2480_216993, skc14, skc13))
%   -(be(U_2501_217003, V_2502_217004, skc14, skc15))
%   -(be(U_2479_217014, V_2480_217015, skc15, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2501_217025, V_2502_217026, skc10, skc15))
%   -(be(U_2479_217036, V_2480_217037, skc15, skc10))
%   -(skf1(V_2447_217045, skc15))
%   -(smoke(skc11, skc15))
%   -(tpos(skc12, skc15))
%   -(tpos(skc9, skc15))
%   -(forename(skc11, skc9))
%   -(tpos(skc11, skc9))
%   -(skc13(skc9))
%   -(skc15(skc9))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc8, skc9))
%   -(jules_forename(skc8, skc9))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc11, skc10))
%   -(jules_forename(skc11, skc10))
%   -(be(U_2501_217130, V_2502_217131, skf1(V_2447_217134), skc10))
%   -(be(U_2479_217144, V_2480_217145, skc10, skf1(V_2447_217148)))
%   -(tpos(skc15, skc10))
%   -(tpos(skc13, skc10))
%   -(skc10(skf1(V_2447_217171)))
%   -(skc14(skf1(V_2447_217180)))
%   -(organism(skc8, skf1(V_2447_217190)))
%   -(human_person(skc11, skf1(V_2447_217200)))
%   -(relation(skc8, skf1(V_2447_217210)))
%   -(proposition(skc11, skf1(V_2447_217220)))
%   -(relname(skc11, skf1(V_2447_217230)))
%   -(be(U_2501_217240, V_2502_217241, skc10, skc11))
%   -(be(U_2479_217251, V_2480_217252, skc11, skc10))
%   -(skf1(V_2447_217260, skc11))
%   -(smoke(skc11, skc11))
%   -(tpos(skc12, skc11))
%   -(tpos(skc9, skc11))
%   -(forename(skc11, skc12))
%   -(tpos(skc11, skc12))
%   -(skc13(skc12))
%   -(skc15(skc12))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc8, skc12))
%   -(jules_forename(skc8, skc12))
%   -(tpos(skc14, skc13))
%   -(tpos(skc10, skc13))
%   -(organism(skc11, skc13))
%   -(event(skc11, skc13))
%   -(state(skc11, skc13))
%   -(skc12(skc13))
%   -(smoke(skc8, skc13))
%   -(skc9(skc13))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc11, skc14))
%   -(jules_forename(skc11, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2501_217399, V_2502_217400, skf1(V_2447_217403), skc14))
%   -(be(U_2479_217413, V_2480_217414, skc14, skf1(V_2447_217417)))
%   -(be(U_2501_217427, V_2502_217428, skc11, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2479_217438, V_2480_217439, skc14, skc11))
%   -(tpos(skc15, skc14))
%   -(tpos(skc13, skc14))
%   -(tpos(skc14, skc15))
%   -(tpos(skc10, skc15))
%   -(organism(skc11, skc15))
%   -(event(skc11, skc15))
%   -(state(skc11, skc15))
%   -(skc12(skc15))
%   -(smoke(skc8, skc15))
%   -(skc9(skc15))
%   -(human_person(skc11, skc9))
%   -(proposition(skc11, skc9))
%   -(relname(skc11, skc9))
%   -(skc11(skc9))
%   -(forename(skc8, skc9))
%   -(forename(skc11, skc10))
%   -(tpos(skf1(V_2447_217558), skc10))
%   -(tpos(skc11, skc10))
%   -(skc13(skc10))
%   -(skc15(skc10))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc8, skc10))
%   -(jules_forename(skc8, skc10))
%   -(be(U_2501_217601, V_2502_217602, skc9, skc10))
%   -(be(U_2479_217612, V_2480_217613, skc10, skc9))
%   -(man(skc8, skf1(V_2447_217623)))
%   -(entity(skc8, skf1(V_2447_217633)))
%   -(organism(skc11, skf1(V_2447_217643)))
%   -(abstraction(skc8, skf1(V_2447_217653)))
%   -(relation(skc11, skf1(V_2447_217663)))
%   -(tpos(skc14, skc11))
%   -(tpos(skc10, skc11))
%   -(organism(skc11, skc11))
%   -(event(skc11, skc11))
%   -(state(skc11, skc11))
%   -(skc12(skc11))
%   -(smoke(skc8, skc11))
%   -(skc9(skc11))
%   -(be(U_2501_217727, V_2502_217728, skc10, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2479_217738, V_2480_217739, skc12, skc10))
%   -(human_person(skc11, skc12))
%   -(proposition(skc11, skc12))
%   -(relname(skc11, skc12))
%   -(skc11(skc12))
%   -(forename(skc8, skc12))
%   -(man(skc11, skc13))
%   -(skc10(skc13))
%   -(skc14(skc13))
%   -(entity(skc11, skc13))
%   -(eventuality(skc11, skc13))
%   -(organism(skc8, skc13))
%   -(event(skc8, skc13))
%   -(state(skc8, skc13))
%   -(human_person(skc11, skc13))
%   -(forename(skc11, skc14))
%   -(tpos(skf1(V_2447_217851), skc14))
%   -(tpos(skc11, skc14))
%   -(skc13(skc14))
%   -(skc15(skc14))
%   -(vincent_forename(skc8, skc14))
%   -(jules_forename(skc8, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2501_217894, V_2502_217895, skc12, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2479_217905, V_2480_217906, skc14, skc12))
%   -(be(U_2501_217916, V_2502_217917, skc9, skc14))
%   -(be(U_2479_217927, V_2480_217928, skc14, skc9))
%   +(jules_forename(skc11, skc13))
%   +(vincent_forename(skc11, skc15))
%   -(man(skc11, skc15))
%   -(skc10(skc15))
%   -(skc14(skc15))
%   -(entity(skc11, skc15))
%   -(eventuality(skc11, skc15))
%   -(organism(skc8, skc15))
%   -(event(skc8, skc15))
%   -(state(skc8, skc15))
%   -(human_person(skc11, skc15))
%   -(tpos(skc14, skc9))
%   -(tpos(skc10, skc9))
%   -(organism(skc11, skc9))
%   -(human_person(skc8, skc9))
%   -(relation(skc11, skc9))
%   -(proposition(skc8, skc9))
%   -(relname(skc8, skc9))
%   -(proposition(skc11, skc10))
%   -(relname(skc11, skc10))
%   -(skf1(V_2447_218074, skc10))
%   -(smoke(skc11, skc10))
%   -(skc11(skc10))
%   -(forename(skc8, skc10))
%   -(tpos(skc12, skc10))
%   -(tpos(skc9, skc10))
%   -(nonexistent(skc11, skc10))
%   -(general(skc11, skc10))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc10))
%   -(male(skc8, skf1(V_2447_218139)))
%   -(man(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218149)))
%   -(existent(skc8, skf1(V_2447_218159)))
%   -(entity(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218169)))
%   -(general(skc8, skf1(V_2447_218179)))
%   -(abstraction(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218189)))
%   -(man(skc11, skc11))
%   -(skc10(skc11))
%   -(skc14(skc11))
%   -(entity(skc11, skc11))
%   -(eventuality(skc11, skc11))
%   -(organism(skc8, skc11))
%   -(event(skc8, skc11))
%   -(state(skc8, skc11))
%   -(human_person(skc11, skc11))
%   -(tpos(skc14, skc12))
%   -(tpos(skc10, skc12))
%   -(organism(skc11, skc12))
%   -(human_person(skc8, skc12))
%   -(relation(skc11, skc12))
%   -(proposition(skc8, skc12))
%   -(relname(skc8, skc12))
%   -(male(skc11, skc13))
%   -(man(skc8, skc13))
%   -(specific(skc11, skc13))
%   -(entity(skc8, skc13))
%   -(eventuality(skc8, skc13))
%   -(human(skc11, skc13))
%   -(human_person(skc8, skc13))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc13))
%   -(proposition(skc11, skc14))
%   -(relname(skc11, skc14))
%   -(skf1(V_2447_218377, skc14))
%   -(smoke(skc11, skc14))
%   -(skc11(skc14))
%   -(forename(skc8, skc14))
%   -(tpos(skc12, skc14))
%   -(tpos(skc9, skc14))
%   +(jules_forename(skc8, skc13))
%   +(vincent_forename(skc8, skc15))
%   -(nonexistent(skc11, skc14))
%   -(general(skc11, skc14))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc14))
%   -(male(skc11, skc15))
%   -(man(skc8, skc15))
%   -(specific(skc11, skc15))
%   -(entity(skc8, skc15))
%   -(eventuality(skc8, skc15))
%   -(human(skc11, skc15))
%   -(human_person(skc8, skc15))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc15))
%   -(man(skc11, skc9))
%   -(skc10(skc9))
%   -(skc14(skc9))
%   -(entity(skc11, skc9))
%   -(organism(skc8, skc9))
%   -(abstraction(skc11, skc9))
%   -(relation(skc8, skc9))
%   -(relation(skc11, skc10))
%   -(event(skc11, skc10))
%   -(state(skc11, skc10))
%   -(proposition(skc8, skc10))
%   -(relname(skc8, skc10))
%   -(skc12(skc10))
%   -(smoke(skc8, skc10))
%   -(skc9(skc10))
%   +(existent(skc11, skc10))
%   -(nonexistent(skc8, skc10))
%   +(specific(skc11, skc10))
%   -(general(skc8, skc10))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc10))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc10))
%   -(male(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218655)))
%   -(existent(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218665)))
%   -(general(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218675)))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skf1(V_2447_218685)))
%   -(male(skc11, skc11))
%   -(man(skc8, skc11))
%   -(specific(skc11, skc11))
%   -(entity(skc8, skc11))
%   -(eventuality(skc8, skc11))
%   -(human(skc11, skc11))
%   -(human_person(skc8, skc11))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc11))
%   -(man(skc11, skc12))
%   -(skc10(skc12))
%   -(skc14(skc12))
%   -(entity(skc11, skc12))
%   -(organism(skc8, skc12))
%   -(abstraction(skc11, skc12))
%   -(relation(skc8, skc12))
%   +(unisex(skc11, skc13))
%   -(male(skc8, skc13))
%   +(general(skc11, skc13))
%   -(specific(skc8, skc13))
%   +(nonhuman(skc11, skc13))
%   -(human(skc8, skc13))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc13))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc13))
%   -(relation(skc11, skc14))
%   -(event(skc11, skc14))
%   -(state(skc11, skc14))
%   -(proposition(skc8, skc14))
%   -(relname(skc8, skc14))
%   -(skc12(skc14))
%   -(smoke(skc8, skc14))
%   -(skc9(skc14))
%   +(skc15(skc13))
%   +(skc13(skc15))
%   +(existent(skc11, skc14))
%   -(nonexistent(skc8, skc14))
%   +(specific(skc11, skc14))
%   -(general(skc8, skc14))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc14))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc14))
%   +(unisex(skc11, skc15))
%   -(male(skc8, skc15))
%   +(general(skc11, skc15))
%   -(specific(skc8, skc15))
%   +(nonhuman(skc11, skc15))
%   -(human(skc8, skc15))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc15))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc15))
%   +(be(skc11, skc9, skc10, skc10))
%   +(tpos(skc10, skc10))
%   +(be(skc11, skc9, skc10, skc14))
%   +(of(skc11, skc13, skc10))
%   +(agent(skc11, skc12, skc10))
%   +(of(skc11, skc15, skc10))
%   +(be(skc11, skc9, skc14, skc14))
%   +(tpos(skc14, skc14))
%   -(male(skc11, skc9))
%   -(man(skc8, skc9))
%   -(existent(skc11, skc9))
%   -(entity(skc8, skc9))
%   -(general(skc11, skc9))
%   -(abstraction(skc8, skc9))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc9))
%   -(abstraction(skc11, skc10))
%   -(eventuality(skc11, skc10))
%   -(relation(skc8, skc10))
%   -(event(skc8, skc10))
%   -(state(skc8, skc10))
%   -(nonhuman(skc11, skc10))
%   +(living(skc11, skc10))
%   +(impartial(skc11, skc10))
%   +(entity(skc11, skc10))
%   +(existent(skc8, skc10))
%   +(specific(skc8, skc10))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc10))
%   +(unisex(skc11, skf1(V_2447_219216)))
%   +(nonexistent(skc11, skf1(V_2447_219226)))
%   +(specific(skc11, skf1(V_2447_219236)))
%   +(thing(skc11, skf1(V_2447_219246)))
%   +(unisex(skc11, skc11))
%   -(male(skc8, skc11))
%   +(general(skc11, skc11))
%   -(specific(skc8, skc11))
%   +(nonhuman(skc11, skc11))
%   -(human(skc8, skc11))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc11))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc11))
%   -(male(skc11, skc12))
%   -(man(skc8, skc12))
%   -(existent(skc11, skc12))
%   -(entity(skc8, skc12))
%   -(general(skc11, skc12))
%   -(abstraction(skc8, skc12))
%   +(singleton(skc11, skc12))
%   +(abstraction(skc11, skc13))
%   +(unisex(skc8, skc13))
%   +(general(skc8, skc13))
%   +(nonhuman(skc8, skc13))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc13))
%   -(abstraction(skc11, skc14))
%   -(eventuality(skc11, skc14))
%   -(relation(skc8, skc14))
%   -(event(skc8, skc14))
%   -(state(skc8, skc14))
%   -(nonhuman(skc11, skc14))
%   +(living(skc11, skc14))
%   +(impartial(skc11, skc14))
%   +(tpos(skc15, skc15))
%   +(tpos(skc15, skc13))
%   +(tpos(skc13, skc15))
%   +(tpos(skc13, skc13))
%   +(entity(skc11, skc14))
%   +(existent(skc8, skc14))
%   +(specific(skc8, skc14))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc14))
%   +(abstraction(skc11, skc15))
%   +(unisex(skc8, skc15))
%   +(general(skc8, skc15))
%   +(nonhuman(skc8, skc15))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc15))
%   +(be(skc8, skc9, skc10, skc10))
%   +(be(skc8, skc9, skc10, skc14))
%   +(of(skc8, skc13, skc10))
%   +(agent(skc8, skc12, skc10))
%   +(of(skc8, skc15, skc10))
%   +(be(skc8, skc9, skc14, skc14))
%   +(unisex(skc11, skc9))
%   -(male(skc8, skc9))
%   +(nonexistent(skc11, skc9))
%   -(existent(skc8, skc9))
%   +(specific(skc11, skc9))
%   -(general(skc8, skc9))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc9))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc9))
%   -(unisex(skc11, skc10))
%   -(abstraction(skc8, skc10))
%   -(eventuality(skc8, skc10))
%   +(animate(skc11, skc10))
%   +(human(skc11, skc10))
%   -(nonhuman(skc8, skc10))
%   +(organism(skc11, skc10))
%   +(living(skc8, skc10))
%   +(impartial(skc8, skc10))
%   +(entity(skc8, skc10))
%   +(eventuality(skc11, skf1(V_2447_219720)))
%   +(abstraction(skc11, skc11))
%   +(unisex(skc8, skc11))
%   +(general(skc8, skc11))
%   +(nonhuman(skc8, skc11))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc11))
%   +(unisex(skc11, skc12))
%   -(male(skc8, skc12))
%   +(nonexistent(skc11, skc12))
%   -(existent(skc8, skc12))
%   +(specific(skc11, skc12))
%   -(general(skc8, skc12))
%   +(thing(skc11, skc12))
%   +(singleton(skc8, skc12))
%   +(relation(skc11, skc13))
%   +(abstraction(skc8, skc13))
%   -(unisex(skc11, skc14))
%   -(abstraction(skc8, skc14))
%   -(eventuality(skc8, skc14))
%   +(animate(skc11, skc14))
%   +(human(skc11, skc14))
%   -(nonhuman(skc8, skc14))
%   +(organism(skc11, skc14))
%   +(living(skc8, skc14))
%   +(impartial(skc8, skc14))
%   +(entity(skc8, skc14))
%   +(relation(skc11, skc15))
%   +(abstraction(skc8, skc15))
%   +(skc14(skc10))
%   +(skc10(skc14))
%   +(event(skc11, skc9))
%   +(eventuality(skc11, skc9))
%   +(unisex(skc8, skc9))
%   +(nonexistent(skc8, skc9))
%   +(specific(skc8, skc9))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc9))
%   +(agent(skc11, skf1(skc10), skc10))
%   +(male(skc11, skc10))
%   -(unisex(skc8, skc10))
%   +(human_person(skc11, skc10))
%   +(animate(skc8, skc10))
%   +(human(skc8, skc10))
%   +(organism(skc8, skc10))
%   +(agent(skc11, skf1(skc14), skc14))
%   +(event(skc11, skf1(V_2447_220035)))
%   +(present(skc11, skf1(V_2447_220045)))
%   +(smoke(skc11, skf1(V_2447_220055)))
%   +(relation(skc11, skc11))
%   +(abstraction(skc8, skc11))
%   +(eventuality(skc11, skc12))
%   +(unisex(skc8, skc12))
%   +(nonexistent(skc8, skc12))
%   +(specific(skc8, skc12))
%   +(thing(skc8, skc12))
%   +(relname(skc11, skc13))
%   +(relation(skc8, skc13))
%   +(male(skc11, skc14))
%   -(unisex(skc8, skc14))
%   +(human_person(skc11, skc14))
%   +(animate(skc8, skc14))
%   +(human(skc8, skc14))
%   +(organism(skc8, skc14))
%   +(relname(skc11, skc15))
%   +(relation(skc8, skc15))
%   +(be(skc11, skc9, skc14, skc10))
%   +(tpos(skc14, skc10))
%   +(tpos(skc10, skc14))
%   +(state(skc11, skc9))
%   +(event(skc8, skc9))
%   +(eventuality(skc8, skc9))
%   +(man(skc11, skc10))
%   +(male(skc8, skc10))
%   +(human_person(skc8, skc10))
%   +(tpos(skc11, skc11))
%   +(theme(skc11, skc12, skc11))
%   +(agent(skc11, skc12, skc14))
%   +(of(skc11, skc15, skc14))
%   +(of(skc11, skc13, skc14))
%   +(vincent_forename(skc11, skc13))
%   +(proposition(skc11, skc11))
%   +(think_believe_consider(skc11, skc12))
%   +(present(skc11, skc12))
%   +(jules_forename(skc11, skc15))
%   +(forename(skc11, skc15))
%   +(forename(skc11, skc13))
%   +(man(skc11, skc14))
%   +(event(skc11, skc12))
%   +(relation(skc8, skc11))
%   +(eventuality(skc8, skc12))
%   +(relname(skc8, skc13))
%   +(male(skc8, skc14))
%   +(human_person(skc8, skc14))
%   +(relname(skc8, skc15))
%   +(be(skc8, skc9, skc14, skc10))
%   +(state(skc8, skc9))
%   +(man(skc8, skc10))
%   +(theme(skc8, skc12, skc11))
%   +(accessible_world(skc8, skc11))
%   +(proposition(skc8, skc11))
%   +(agent(skc8, skc12, skc14))
%   +(event(skc8, skc12))
%   +(present(skc8, skc12))
%   +(think_believe_consider(skc8, skc12))
%   +(of(skc8, skc13, skc14))
%   +(forename(skc8, skc13))
%   +(vincent_forename(skc8, skc13))
%   +(of(skc8, skc15, skc14))
%   +(man(skc8, skc14))
%   +(forename(skc8, skc15))
%   +(jules_forename(skc8, skc15))
%   +(actual_world(skc8))
%   +(skc9(skc9))
%   +(skc10(skc10))
%   +(skc11(skc11))
%   +(skc12(skc12))
%   +(skc13(skc13))
%   +(skc14(skc14))
%   +(skc15(skc15))
%   +(skc8(skc8))
%   +(skf1(_2418_220570, skf1(_2418_220570)))
%   +(_220576)
% 
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------