TSTP Solution File: NLP091-1 by Refute---2015
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Refute---2015
% Problem : NLP091-1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s
% Computer : n017.star.cs.uiowa.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 2.40GHz
% Memory : 16091.75MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% DateTime : Thu Apr 14 01:28:01 EDT 2016
% Result : Timeout 300.02s
% Output : None
% Verified :
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax : Number of formulae : 0
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----No solution output by system
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.00/0.03 % Problem : NLP091-1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.00/0.04 % Command : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s
% 0.03/0.23 % Computer : n017.star.cs.uiowa.edu
% 0.03/0.23 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.03/0.23 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 @ 2.40GHz
% 0.03/0.23 % Memory : 16091.75MB
% 0.03/0.23 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64
% 0.03/0.23 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.03/0.23 % DateTime : Tue Apr 5 12:40:54 CDT 2016
% 0.03/0.23 % CPUTime :
% 6.30/5.84 > val it = (): unit
% 6.60/6.19 Trying to find a model that refutes: True
% 8.31/7.87 Unfolded term: [| !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((~ bnd_revenge U V | ~ bnd_of U W V) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_event U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_present U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_nonreflexive U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_scream U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_agent U W X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_shot U (bnd_skf10 U Y)) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_group U X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_six U X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_male U X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_cannon U Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_ssSkP0 Z X1 X U) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_of U Z X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_man U X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_male U X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_patient U W X2) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_cry U X2) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_actual_world U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((~ bnd_revenge U V | ~ bnd_of U W V) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_event U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_present U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_nonreflexive U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_scream U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_agent U W X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_group U X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_six U X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_male U X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_cannon U Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_ssSkP0 Y Z X U) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_of U Y Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_man U Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_male U Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_patient U W X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_cry U X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_actual_world U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_member U (bnd_skf10 U X) X;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((~ bnd_from_loc U V W | ~ bnd_fire U V) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_nonreflexive U V) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_present U V) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_patient U V (bnd_skf13 W X Y U)) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_agent U V X) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_from_loc U (bnd_skf11 U V X Z) X;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_patient U (bnd_skf11 U V Z X1) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_agent U (bnd_skf11 U V X Y) Y;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_fire U (bnd_skf11 U Z X1 X2);
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_nonreflexive U (bnd_skf11 U Z X1 X2);
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_present U (bnd_skf11 U Z X1 X2);
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_ssSkP0 X Y W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_event U (bnd_skf11 U Z X1 X2);
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X. bnd_ssSkP0 U V W X | bnd_member X (bnd_skf13 U V W X) W;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U. ~ bnd_member bnd_skc4 U bnd_skc5 | bnd_shot bnd_skc4 U;
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_ssSkP0 bnd_skc6 bnd_skc7 bnd_skc5 bnd_skc4;
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_of bnd_skc4 bnd_skc6 bnd_skc7; bnd_group bnd_skc4 bnd_skc5;
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six bnd_skc4 bnd_skc5; bnd_cannon bnd_skc4 bnd_skc6;
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_man bnd_skc4 bnd_skc7; bnd_male bnd_skc4 bnd_skc7;
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_actual_world bnd_skc4;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_skf26 U V W X Y Z X1 X2 = W |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 U X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 V X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 W X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X5 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X6 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X7 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six X3 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = V) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 X6 = X7;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_skf26 U V W X Y Z X1 X2 = X |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 U X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 V X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 W X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X5 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X6 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six X3 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = V) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X6;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_skf26 U V W X Y Z X1 X2 = Y |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 U X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 V X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 W X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 Y X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X5 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six X3 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = V) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 Y = X5;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_skf26 U V W X Y Z X1 X2 = Z |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 U X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 V X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 W X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 Y X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 Z X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six X3 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = V) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = W) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 W = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 Y = Z;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_member U X W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member U Y W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member U Z W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member U X1 W) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member U X2 W) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six U W) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_member U (bnd_skf26 V X Y Z X1 X2 W U) W) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X2) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = X2) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 X = Y) |
% 8.31/7.87 Y = X2) |
% 8.31/7.87 Y = X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 Y = Z) |
% 8.31/7.87 Z = X2) |
% 8.31/7.87 Z = X1) |
% 8.31/7.87 X1 = X2;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8 X9.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_skf26 U V W X Y Z X1 X2 = U |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 U X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X5 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X6 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X7 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X8 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X9 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six X3 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X9) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X9) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 X6 = X9) |
% 8.31/7.87 X6 = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 X6 = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 X7 = X9) |
% 8.31/7.87 X7 = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 X8 = X9;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8.
% 8.31/7.87 (((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_skf26 U V W X Y Z X1 X2 = V |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 U X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 V X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X5 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X6 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X7 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 ~ bnd_member X3 X8 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 bnd_six X3 X4) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 U = V) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = X5) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 X5 = X6) |
% 8.31/7.87 X6 = X8) |
% 8.31/7.87 X6 = X7) |
% 8.31/7.87 X7 = X8;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.87 ((((((~ bnd_member U V W | ~ bnd_six U W) | V = bnd_skf15 W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = bnd_skf17 W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = bnd_skf19 W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = bnd_skf21 W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = bnd_skf23 W U) |
% 8.31/7.87 V = bnd_skf25 W U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.87 (~ bnd_nonreflexive U V | ~ bnd_patient U V W) | ~ bnd_agent U V W;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf17 U V = bnd_skf15 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf19 U V = bnd_skf17 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf19 U V = bnd_skf15 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf21 U V = bnd_skf19 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf21 U V = bnd_skf17 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf21 U V = bnd_skf15 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf23 U V = bnd_skf21 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf23 U V = bnd_skf19 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf23 U V = bnd_skf17 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf23 U V = bnd_skf15 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf25 U V = bnd_skf23 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf25 U V = bnd_skf21 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf25 U V = bnd_skf19 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf25 U V = bnd_skf17 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_skf25 U V = bnd_skf15 U V | ~ bnd_six V U;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_member U (bnd_skf15 V U) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_member U (bnd_skf17 V U) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_member U (bnd_skf19 V U) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_member U (bnd_skf21 V U) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_member U (bnd_skf23 V U) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_member U (bnd_skf25 V U) V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_nonliving U V | ~ bnd_animate U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_nonexistent U V | ~ bnd_existent U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_living U V | ~ bnd_nonliving U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_multiple U V | ~ bnd_singleton U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_male U V | ~ bnd_unisex U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_man U V | bnd_male U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_human_person U V | bnd_animate U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_human_person U V | bnd_human U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_organism U V | bnd_living U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_organism U V | bnd_impartial U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_organism U V | bnd_entity U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_human_person U V | bnd_organism U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_man U V | bnd_human_person U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_object U V | bnd_unisex U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_object U V | bnd_impartial U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_object U V | bnd_nonliving U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_entity U V | bnd_existent U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_entity U V | bnd_specific U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_entity U V | bnd_thing U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_object U V | bnd_entity U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_artifact U V | bnd_object U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_instrumentality U V | bnd_artifact U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_weaponry U V | bnd_instrumentality U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_weapon U V | bnd_weaponry U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_cannon U V | bnd_weapon U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_fire U V | bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_six U V | bnd_group U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_set U V | bnd_multiple U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_group U V | bnd_set U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_shot U V | bnd_action U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_act U V | bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_action U V | bnd_act U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_revenge U V | bnd_action U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_cry U V | bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_scream U V | bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_unisex U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_nonexistent U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_specific U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_thing U V | bnd_singleton U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_thing U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_event U V | bnd_eventuality U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_sound U V | bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.87 !!U V. ~ bnd_scream U V | bnd_sound U V; !!U V. ~ bnd_member U V V |]
% 8.31/7.87 ==> True
% 8.31/7.87 Adding axioms...
% 8.31/7.88 Typedef.type_definition_def
% 20.82/20.38 ...done.
% 20.92/20.40 Ground types: ?'b, TPTP_Interpret.ind
% 20.92/20.40 Translating term (sizes: 1, 1) ...
% 31.35/30.87 Invoking SAT solver...
% 31.35/30.87 No model exists.
% 31.35/30.87 Translating term (sizes: 2, 1) ...
% 42.45/41.97 Invoking SAT solver...
% 42.45/41.97 No model exists.
% 42.45/41.97 Translating term (sizes: 1, 2) ...
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------