TSTP Solution File: NLP080-1 by Gandalf---c-2.6
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Gandalf---c-2.6
% Problem : NLP080-1 : TPTP v3.4.2. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : add_equality:r
% Format : otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
% Command : gandalf-wrapper -time %d %s
% Computer : art07.cs.miami.edu
% Model : i686 unknown
% CPU : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
% Memory : 1000MB
% OS : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
% CPULimit : 600s
% Result : Unsatisfiable 50.0s
% Output : Assurance 50.0s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax : Number of formulae : 0
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----NO SOLUTION OUTPUT BY SYSTEM
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
%
% Gandalf c-2.6 r1 starting to prove: /home/graph/tptp/TSTP/PreparedTPTP/otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)---add_equality:r/NLP/NLP080-1+noeq.in
% Using automatic strategy selection.
% Time limit in seconds: 600
%
% prove-all-passes started
%
% detected problem class: nne
% detected subclass: medium
%
% strategies selected:
% (hyper 27 #f 2 39)
% (binary-unit 10 #f 2 39)
% (binary-double 16 #f 2 39)
% (binary 54 #t 2 39)
% (binary-order 27 #f 2 39)
% (binary-posweight-order 125 #f)
% (binary-order-sos 54 #t)
% (binary-unit-uniteq 27 #f)
% (binary-weightorder 54 #f)
% (binary-order 54 #f)
% (hyper-order 43 #f)
% (binary 109 #t)
%
%
% SOS clause
% -revenge(X,Y) | -of(X,Z,Y) | -event(X,Z) | -present(X,Z) | -nonreflexive(X,Z) | -scream(X,Z) | -agent(X,Z,U) | -shot(X,skf6(X,V)) | -group(X,U) | -six(X,U) | -male(X,U) | -cannon(X,W) | -ss^sk^p0(W,X1,U,X) | -of(X,W,X1) | -man(X,X1) | -male(X,X1) | -patient(X,Z,X2) | -cry(X,X2) | -actual_world(X) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% was split for some strategies as:
% -revenge(X,Y) | -of(X,Z,Y) | -event(X,Z) | -present(X,Z) | -nonreflexive(X,Z) | -scream(X,Z) | -agent(X,Z,U) | -shot(X,skf6(X,V)) | -group(X,U) | -six(X,U) | -male(X,U) | -cannon(X,W) | -ss^sk^p0(W,X1,U,X) | -of(X,W,X1) | -man(X,X1) | -male(X,X1) | -patient(X,Z,X2) | -cry(X,X2) | -actual_world(X).
% -ss^sk^c0(0).
%
% ********* EMPTY CLAUSE DERIVED *********
%
%
% timer checkpoints: c(51,40,1,106,0,1,108297,5,902,108298,1,902,108298,50,902,108298,40,902,108353,0,902,108516,50,903,108571,0,903,108734,50,904,108789,0,904,108952,50,906,109007,0,906,109170,50,907,109225,0,907,109388,50,908,109443,0,908,109606,50,910,109661,0,910,109824,50,911,109879,0,911,110042,50,913,110097,0,913,110260,50,915,110315,0,915,110478,50,916,110533,0,916,110696,50,918,110751,0,918,110914,50,920,110969,0,920,111132,50,921,111187,0,922,111350,50,923,111405,0,923,111568,50,925,111623,0,925,111786,50,927,111841,0,928,112004,50,930,112059,0,930,112222,50,932,112277,0,932,112440,50,934,112495,0,934,112658,50,936,112658,40,936,112713,0,937,114751,3,1195,115088,4,1313,115863,5,1438,115863,1,1438,115863,50,1438,115863,40,1438,115918,0,1438,122019,3,3133,122019,4,3133,122909,1,3239,122909,50,3239,122909,40,3239,122964,0,3239,123567,5,4140,123567,1,4141,123567,50,4141,123567,40,4141,123622,0,4141)
%
%
% START OF PROOF
% 123568 [] -ss^sk^c0(0) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 123569 [] ss^sk^c0(0) | member(X,skf12(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,V,X1) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 123570 [] ss^sk^c0(0) | -shot(X,skf12(X,Y)) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,V,X) | -patient(X,W,X1) | -agent(X,W,V) | -of(X,W,X2) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,X1) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,V) | -six(X,V) | -group(X,V) | -scream(X,W) | -nonreflexive(X,W) | -present(X,W) | -event(X,W) | -revenge(X,X2) | -actual_world(X).
% 123580 [] -ss^sk^c0(0) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 123581 [] ss^sk^c0(0) | -member(skc39,X,skc42) | shot(skc39,X).
% 123582 [] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123583 [] ss^sk^p0(skc43,skc44,skc42,skc39) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123584 [] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123585 [] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123586 [] agent(skc14,skc15,skc17) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123587 [] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123588 [] patient(skc39,skc40,skc41) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123589 [] of(skc39,skc43,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123590 [] agent(skc39,skc40,skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123591 [] of(skc39,skc40,skc45) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123592 [] revenge(skc14,skc16) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123593 [] male(skc14,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123594 [] man(skc14,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123595 [] cannon(skc14,skc18) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123596 [] male(skc14,skc17) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123597 [] six(skc14,skc17) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123598 [] group(skc14,skc17) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123599 [] scream(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123600 [] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123601 [] present(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123602 [] event(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123603 [] cry(skc14,skc20) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123604 [] cry(skc39,skc41) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123605 [] male(skc39,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123606 [] man(skc39,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123607 [] cannon(skc39,skc43) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123608 [] male(skc39,skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123609 [] six(skc39,skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123610 [] group(skc39,skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123611 [] scream(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123612 [] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123613 [] present(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123614 [] event(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123615 [] revenge(skc39,skc45) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 123616 [] actual_world(skc14).
% 123617 [] actual_world(skc39).
% 123619 [] -ss^sk^c0(0) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Z) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -male(U,Y) | -male(U,Z) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 123620 [] -shot(X,skf6(X,Y)) | $spltprd1($spltcnst17,X).
% 123621 [] $spltprd1($spltcnst18,X) | -actual_world(X).
% 123622 [] -$spltprd1($spltcnst17,X) | -$spltprd1($spltcnst16,X) | -$spltprd1($spltcnst18,X).
% 123624 [binary:123616,123621.2] $spltprd1($spltcnst18,skc14).
% 123774 [binary:123592.2,123612.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 123775 [binary:123593.2,123612.2] male(skc14,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123776 [binary:123594.2,123612.2] man(skc14,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123777 [binary:123595.2,123612.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123778 [binary:123619,123612.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Z) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -male(U,Z) | -male(U,Y) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 123779 [binary:123596.2,123612.2] male(skc14,skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123780 [binary:123597.2,123612.2] six(skc14,skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123781 [binary:123598.2,123612.2] group(skc14,skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123782 [binary:123599.2,123612.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123783 [binary:123600.2,123612.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | nonreflexive(skc14,skc15).
% 123784 [binary:123601.2,123612.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | present(skc14,skc15).
% 123785 [binary:123602.2,123612.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | event(skc14,skc15).
% 123786 [binary:123603.2,123612.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123787 [binary:123568,123612.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 123791 [binary:123592.2,123613.2] present(skc39,skc40) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 123792 [binary:123593.2,123613.2] male(skc14,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123793 [binary:123594.2,123613.2] man(skc14,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123794 [binary:123595.2,123613.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123795 [binary:123619,123613.2] present(skc39,skc40) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Z) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -male(U,Z) | -male(U,Y) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 123796 [binary:123596.2,123613.2] male(skc14,skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123797 [binary:123597.2,123613.2] six(skc14,skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123798 [binary:123598.2,123613.2] group(skc14,skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123799 [binary:123599.2,123613.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123800 [binary:123600.2,123613.2] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123801 [binary:123601.2,123613.2] present(skc39,skc40) | present(skc14,skc15).
% 123802 [binary:123602.2,123613.2] present(skc39,skc40) | event(skc14,skc15).
% 123803 [binary:123603.2,123613.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123804 [binary:123568,123613.2] present(skc39,skc40) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 123807 [binary:123592.2,123614.2] event(skc39,skc40) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 123808 [binary:123593.2,123614.2] male(skc14,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123809 [binary:123594.2,123614.2] man(skc14,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123810 [binary:123595.2,123614.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123811 [binary:123619,123614.2] event(skc39,skc40) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Z) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -male(U,Z) | -male(U,Y) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 123812 [binary:123596.2,123614.2] male(skc14,skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123813 [binary:123597.2,123614.2] six(skc14,skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123814 [binary:123598.2,123614.2] group(skc14,skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123815 [binary:123599.2,123614.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123816 [binary:123600.2,123614.2] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123817 [binary:123601.2,123614.2] present(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123818 [binary:123602.2,123614.2] event(skc39,skc40) | event(skc14,skc15).
% 123819 [binary:123603.2,123614.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123820 [binary:123568,123614.2] event(skc39,skc40) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 123824 [binary:123592.2,123615.2] revenge(skc39,skc45) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 123825 [binary:123593.2,123615.2] male(skc14,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123826 [binary:123594.2,123615.2] man(skc14,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123827 [binary:123595.2,123615.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123828 [binary:123619,123615.2] revenge(skc39,skc45) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Z) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -male(U,Z) | -male(U,Y) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 123829 [binary:123596.2,123615.2] male(skc14,skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123830 [binary:123597.2,123615.2] six(skc14,skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123831 [binary:123598.2,123615.2] group(skc14,skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123832 [binary:123599.2,123615.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123833 [binary:123600.2,123615.2] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123834 [binary:123601.2,123615.2] present(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123835 [binary:123602.2,123615.2] event(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123836 [binary:123603.2,123615.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123837 [binary:123568,123615.2] revenge(skc39,skc45) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 123847 [binary:123612.2,123584.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123848 [binary:123613.2,123584.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123849 [binary:123614.2,123584.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123850 [binary:123615.2,123584.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123860 [binary:123612.2,123585.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123861 [binary:123613.2,123585.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123862 [binary:123614.2,123585.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123863 [binary:123615.2,123585.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123874 [binary:123612.2,123586.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123875 [binary:123613.2,123586.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123876 [binary:123614.2,123586.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123877 [binary:123615.2,123586.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 123888 [binary:123612.2,123587.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 123889 [binary:123613.2,123587.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 123890 [binary:123614.2,123587.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 123891 [binary:123615.2,123587.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 124025 [binary:123612.2,123580] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 124026 [binary:123613.2,123580] present(skc39,skc40) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 124027 [binary:123614.2,123580] event(skc39,skc40) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 124028 [binary:123615.2,123580] revenge(skc39,skc45) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 124054 [binary:123612.2,123582.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 124055 [binary:123613.2,123582.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 124056 [binary:123614.2,123582.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 124057 [binary:123615.2,123582.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 124084 [binary:123569.3,123583,cut:123617,binarycut:123589,binarycut:123606,binarycut:123607,binarycut:123605,binarycut:123608,binarycut:123609,binarycut:123610] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0) | -agent(skc39,X,skc42) | -patient(skc39,X,Y) | -of(skc39,X,Z) | -cry(skc39,Y) | -scream(skc39,X) | -nonreflexive(skc39,X) | -present(skc39,X) | -event(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Z).
% 124522 [binary:123778.2,124054,binarycut:123860,binarycut:123776,binarycut:123777,binarycut:123779,binarycut:123775,binarycut:123780,binarycut:123781] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124524 [binary:123787.3,124054,cut:123616,binarycut:123860,binarycut:123776,binarycut:123777,binarycut:123775,binarycut:123779,binarycut:123780,binarycut:123781] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124534 [binary:123795.2,124055,binarycut:123861,binarycut:123793,binarycut:123794,binarycut:123796,binarycut:123792,binarycut:123797,binarycut:123798] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124536 [binary:123804.3,124055,cut:123616,binarycut:123861,binarycut:123793,binarycut:123794,binarycut:123792,binarycut:123796,binarycut:123797,binarycut:123798] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124546 [binary:123811.2,124056,binarycut:123862,binarycut:123809,binarycut:123810,binarycut:123812,binarycut:123808,binarycut:123813,binarycut:123814] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124548 [binary:123820.3,124056,cut:123616,binarycut:123862,binarycut:123809,binarycut:123810,binarycut:123808,binarycut:123812,binarycut:123813,binarycut:123814] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124558 [binary:123828.2,124057,binarycut:123863,binarycut:123826,binarycut:123827,binarycut:123829,binarycut:123825,binarycut:123830,binarycut:123831] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124560 [binary:123837.3,124057,cut:123616,binarycut:123863,binarycut:123826,binarycut:123827,binarycut:123825,binarycut:123829,binarycut:123830,binarycut:123831] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 124898 [binary:123590,124084.3,binarycut:123611,binarycut:123612,binarycut:123613,binarycut:123614] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0) | -patient(skc39,skc40,X) | -of(skc39,skc40,Y) | -cry(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Y).
% 125675 [binary:123874,124522.3,binarycut:123782] -nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125698 [binary:123874,124524.3,binarycut:123782] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125719 [binary:123783.2,125675] -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125744 [binary:123875,124534.3,binarycut:123799,binarycut:123800] -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125763 [binary:123875,124536.3,binarycut:123799,binarycut:123800] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125776 [binary:123784.2,125719] -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125793 [binary:123876,124546.3,binarycut:123815,binarycut:123816,binarycut:123817] -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125820 [binary:123876,124548.3,binarycut:123815,binarycut:123816,binarycut:123817] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -event(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125835 [binary:123785.2,125776] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125854 [binary:123877,124558.3,binarycut:123832,binarycut:123833,binarycut:123834,binarycut:123835] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125881 [binary:123877,124560.3,binarycut:123832,binarycut:123833,binarycut:123834,binarycut:123835] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 125901 [binary:123888,125835.3,binarycut:123786] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 125910 [binary:123847,125901.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 125919 [binary:123774.2,125910] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 126098 [binary:123891,125854.3,binarycut:123836] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 126109 [binary:123850,126098.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 126122 [binary:123824.2,126109] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 126194 [binary:123818.2,125793] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 126297 [binary:123890,126194.3,binarycut:123819] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 126307 [binary:123849,126297.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 126319 [binary:123807.2,126307] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 126331 [binary:123588,124898.3,binarycut:123604] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0) | -of(skc39,skc40,X) | -revenge(skc39,X).
% 126334 [binary:123591,126331.3,binarycut:123615] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 126356 [binary:123581.2,126334] shot(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42)) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 126390 [binary:123570.2,126356,cut:123617] ss^sk^c0(0) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,skc39) | -patient(skc39,U,V) | -agent(skc39,U,Z) | -of(skc39,U,W) | -of(skc39,X,Y) | -cry(skc39,V) | -man(skc39,Y) | -cannon(skc39,X) | -male(skc39,Y) | -male(skc39,Z) | -six(skc39,Z) | -group(skc39,Z) | -scream(skc39,U) | -nonreflexive(skc39,U) | -present(skc39,U) | -event(skc39,U) | -revenge(skc39,W).
% 127017 [binary:123801.2,125744] -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 127056 [binary:123802.2,127017] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 127113 [binary:123889,127056.3,binarycut:123803] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 127122 [binary:123848,127113.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 127131 [binary:123791.2,127122] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 128269 [binary:123891,125881.3,binarycut:123836] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 128282 [binary:123850,128269.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 128295 [binary:123824.2,128282.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 128327 [binary:124028.2,128295,binarydemod:123620] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 128438 [binary:123622,128327,cut:123624,binarycut:126122] revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 128594 [binary:123783.2,125698.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 128714 [binary:123801.2,125763.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -event(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 128817 [binary:123818.2,125820.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 128840 [binary:123890,128817.3,binarycut:123819] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 128852 [binary:123849,128840.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 128864 [binary:123807.2,128852.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 128894 [binary:124027.2,128864,binarydemod:123620] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 128996 [binary:123622,128894,cut:123624,binarycut:126319] event(skc39,skc40).
% 129387 [binary:123802.2,128714.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 129408 [binary:123889,129387.3,binarycut:123803] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 129419 [binary:123848,129408.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 129430 [binary:123791.2,129419.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 129458 [binary:124026.2,129430,binarydemod:123620] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 129551 [binary:123622,129458,cut:123624,binarycut:127131] present(skc39,skc40).
% 129717 [binary:123583,126390.2,binarycut:123589,binarycut:123606,binarycut:123607,binarycut:123608,binarycut:123605,binarycut:123609,binarycut:123610] ss^sk^c0(0) | -agent(skc39,X,skc42) | -patient(skc39,X,Y) | -of(skc39,X,Z) | -cry(skc39,Y) | -scream(skc39,X) | -nonreflexive(skc39,X) | -present(skc39,X) | -event(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Z).
% 130601 [binary:123784.2,128594.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -event(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 130611 [binary:123785.2,130601.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 130630 [binary:123888,130611.3,binarycut:123786] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 130640 [binary:123847,130630.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 130650 [binary:123774.2,130640.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 130676 [binary:124025.2,130650,binarydemod:123620] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 130796 [binary:123622,130676,cut:123624,binarycut:125919] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 131163 [binary:123590,129717.2,cut:130796,cut:129551,cut:128996,binarycut:123611] ss^sk^c0(0) | -patient(skc39,skc40,X) | -of(skc39,skc40,Y) | -cry(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Y).
% 131171 [binary:123588,131163.2,binarycut:123604] ss^sk^c0(0) | -of(skc39,skc40,X) | -revenge(skc39,X).
% 131173 [binary:123591,131171.2,cut:128438] ss^sk^c0(0).
% 131175 [binary:123592.2,131173] revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 131176 [binary:123593.2,131173] male(skc14,skc19).
% 131177 [binary:123594.2,131173] man(skc14,skc19).
% 131178 [binary:123595.2,131173] cannon(skc14,skc18).
% 131179 [binary:123619,131173] -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Z) | -of(U,V,X1) | -of(U,X,Y) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -male(U,Y) | -male(U,Z) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 131180 [binary:123596.2,131173] male(skc14,skc17).
% 131181 [binary:123597.2,131173] six(skc14,skc17).
% 131182 [binary:123598.2,131173] group(skc14,skc17).
% 131183 [binary:123599.2,131173] scream(skc14,skc15).
% 131184 [binary:123600.2,131173] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15).
% 131185 [binary:123601.2,131173] present(skc14,skc15).
% 131186 [binary:123602.2,131173] event(skc14,skc15).
% 131187 [binary:123603.2,131173] cry(skc14,skc20).
% 131188 [binary:123568,131173] member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,Y) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -male(X,U) | -male(X,Y) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 131189 [binary:123584.2,131173] of(skc14,skc15,skc16).
% 131190 [binary:123585.2,131173] of(skc14,skc18,skc19).
% 131191 [binary:123586.2,131173] agent(skc14,skc15,skc17).
% 131192 [binary:123587.2,131173] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20).
% 131193 [binary:123580,131173] -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 131194 [binary:123582.2,131173] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14).
% 131670 [binary:131194,131179,cut:131190,cut:131177,cut:131178,cut:131176,cut:131180,cut:131181,cut:131182] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 131681 [binary:131191,131670.2,cut:131183,cut:131184,cut:131185,cut:131186] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 131683 [binary:131192,131681.2,cut:131187] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 131685 [binary:131189,131683.2,cut:131175] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14).
% 133419 [binary:131194,131188.2,cut:131190,cut:131177,cut:131178,cut:131176,cut:131180,cut:131181,cut:131182,cut:123616] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -agent(skc14,X,skc17) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 133423 [binary:131191,133419.2,cut:131183,cut:131184,cut:131185,cut:131186] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 133425 [binary:131192,133423.2,cut:131187] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 133427 [binary:131189,133425.2,cut:131175] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17).
% 133443 [binary:131193,133427,binarydemod:123620] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14).
% 133459 [binary:123622,133443,cut:131685,cut:123624] contradiction
% END OF PROOF
%
% Proof found by the following strategy:
%
% using binary resolution
% using first neg lit preferred strategy
% not using sos strategy
% using dynamic demodulation
% using ordered paramodulation
% using kb ordering for equality
% preferring bigger arities for lex ordering
% using clause demodulation
% seconds given: 41
%
%
% ***GANDALF_FOUND_A_REFUTATION***
%
% Global statistics over all passes:
%
% given clauses: 6919
% derived clauses: 245150
% kept clauses: 14439
% kept size sum: 724322
% kept mid-nuclei: 106727
% kept new demods: 0
% forw unit-subs: 249
% forw double-subs: 46603
% forw overdouble-subs: 61078
% backward subs: 6456
% fast unit cutoff: 48021
% full unit cutoff: 0
% dbl unit cutoff: 2165
% real runtime : 52.51
% process. runtime: 52.47
% specific non-discr-tree subsumption statistics:
% tried: 6674132
% length fails: 44446
% strength fails: 324090
% predlist fails: 2160461
% aux str. fails: 4757
% by-lit fails: 2125568
% full subs tried: 1765097
% full subs fail: 1697322
%
% ; program args: ("/home/graph/tptp/Systems/Gandalf---c-2.6/gandalf" "-time" "600" "/home/graph/tptp/TSTP/PreparedTPTP/otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)---add_equality:r/NLP/NLP080-1+noeq.in")
%
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------