TSTP Solution File: MGT034-2 by Bliksem---1.12
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Bliksem---1.12
% Problem : MGT034-2 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : bliksem %s
% Computer : n029.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 0s
% DateTime : Sun Jul 17 21:57:46 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 24.27s 24.62s
% Output : Refutation 24.27s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.00/0.11 % Problem : MGT034-2 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.00/0.12 % Command : bliksem %s
% 0.13/0.33 % Computer : n029.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.33 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.33 % DateTime : Thu Jun 9 08:51:21 EDT 2022
% 0.13/0.33 % CPUTime :
% 2.35/2.77 *** allocated 10000 integers for termspace/termends
% 2.35/2.77 *** allocated 10000 integers for clauses
% 2.35/2.77 *** allocated 10000 integers for justifications
% 2.35/2.77 Bliksem 1.12
% 2.35/2.77
% 2.35/2.77
% 2.35/2.77 Automatic Strategy Selection
% 2.35/2.77
% 2.35/2.77 Clauses:
% 2.35/2.77 [
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( Y, Z, X, T ) ), ~( greater(
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( Z, T ), 'growth_rate'( Y, T ) ) ), 'selection_favors'( Z,
% 2.35/2.77 Y, T ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( decreases( difference(
% 2.35/2.77 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, 'critical_point'( X ) )
% 2.35/2.77 ), subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X,
% 2.35/2.77 'critical_point'( X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, appear(
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 2.35/2.77 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), decreases( difference(
% 2.35/2.77 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 2.35/2.77 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ), ~(
% 2.35/2.77 'greater_or_equal'( Z, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 2.35/2.77 Y, Z ) ), ~( decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ),
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ) ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 2.35/2.77 , Z ) ), zero ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), greater( 'growth_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'first_movers', X ) ) ), greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), greater(
% 2.35/2.77 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 2.35/2.77 , X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), greater( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 2.35/2.77 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero )
% 2.35/2.77 ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 2.35/2.77 'in_environment'( X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), ~(
% 2.35/2.77 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), 'in_environment'( X, T ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), 'in_environment'( X, 'start_time'( X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( appear( 'first_movers', X )
% 2.35/2.77 , 'start_time'( X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, 'critical_point'( X ) )
% 2.35/2.77 ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~(
% 2.35/2.77 greater( 'critical_point'( X ), Y ) ), 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~( greater(
% 2.35/2.77 'cardinality_at_time'( 'first_movers', Y ), zero ) ), ~( greater(
% 2.35/2.77 'cardinality_at_time'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), zero ) ),
% 2.35/2.77 subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), subpopulations( 'efficient_producers',
% 2.35/2.77 'first_movers', X, Y ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 2.35/2.77 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ), greater( X, Y ), =( X, Y ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( greater( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( =( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ],
% 2.35/2.77 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Y ) ) ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 greater( Z, Y ) ), greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ) ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, T ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ]
% 24.27/24.62 ,
% 24.27/24.62 [ environment( sk1 ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ 'in_environment'( sk1, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ 'greater_or_equal'( sk2, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), sk2 ) ],
% 24.27/24.62 [ ~( 'selection_favors'( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) )
% 24.27/24.62 ]
% 24.27/24.62 ] .
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 percentage equality = 0.044444, percentage horn = 0.900000
% 24.27/24.62 This is a problem with some equality
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Options Used:
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 useres = 1
% 24.27/24.62 useparamod = 1
% 24.27/24.62 useeqrefl = 1
% 24.27/24.62 useeqfact = 1
% 24.27/24.62 usefactor = 1
% 24.27/24.62 usesimpsplitting = 0
% 24.27/24.62 usesimpdemod = 5
% 24.27/24.62 usesimpres = 3
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 resimpinuse = 1000
% 24.27/24.62 resimpclauses = 20000
% 24.27/24.62 substype = eqrewr
% 24.27/24.62 backwardsubs = 1
% 24.27/24.62 selectoldest = 5
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 litorderings [0] = split
% 24.27/24.62 litorderings [1] = extend the termordering, first sorting on arguments
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 termordering = kbo
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 litapriori = 0
% 24.27/24.62 termapriori = 1
% 24.27/24.62 litaposteriori = 0
% 24.27/24.62 termaposteriori = 0
% 24.27/24.62 demodaposteriori = 0
% 24.27/24.62 ordereqreflfact = 0
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 litselect = negord
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 maxweight = 15
% 24.27/24.62 maxdepth = 30000
% 24.27/24.62 maxlength = 115
% 24.27/24.62 maxnrvars = 195
% 24.27/24.62 excuselevel = 1
% 24.27/24.62 increasemaxweight = 1
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 maxselected = 10000000
% 24.27/24.62 maxnrclauses = 10000000
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 showgenerated = 0
% 24.27/24.62 showkept = 0
% 24.27/24.62 showselected = 0
% 24.27/24.62 showdeleted = 0
% 24.27/24.62 showresimp = 1
% 24.27/24.62 showstatus = 2000
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 prologoutput = 1
% 24.27/24.62 nrgoals = 5000000
% 24.27/24.62 totalproof = 1
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Symbols occurring in the translation:
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 {} [0, 0] (w:1, o:2, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 . [1, 2] (w:1, o:27, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 ! [4, 1] (w:0, o:18, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 = [13, 2] (w:1, o:0, a:0, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 ==> [14, 2] (w:1, o:0, a:0, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 environment [40, 1] (w:1, o:25, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 subpopulations [44, 4] (w:1, o:62, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate' [45, 2] (w:1, o:53, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 greater [46, 2] (w:1, o:54, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'selection_favors' [47, 3] (w:1, o:61, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers' [48, 0] (w:1, o:16, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers' [49, 0] (w:1, o:15, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'disbanding_rate' [50, 2] (w:1, o:56, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 difference [51, 2] (w:1, o:57, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 decreases [52, 1] (w:1, o:24, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point' [53, 1] (w:1, o:23, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment' [54, 2] (w:1, o:58, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 appear [55, 2] (w:1, o:59, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'founding_rate' [56, 2] (w:1, o:52, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 zero [57, 0] (w:1, o:17, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal' [58, 2] (w:1, o:60, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'start_time' [59, 1] (w:1, o:26, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 'cardinality_at_time' [60, 2] (w:1, o:55, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 sk1 [61, 0] (w:1, o:5, a:1, s:1, b:0),
% 24.27/24.62 sk2 [62, 0] (w:1, o:6, a:1, s:1, b:0).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Starting Search:
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Resimplifying inuse:
% 24.27/24.62 Done
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Intermediate Status:
% 24.27/24.62 Generated: 255974
% 24.27/24.62 Kept: 2007
% 24.27/24.62 Inuse: 925
% 24.27/24.62 Deleted: 106
% 24.27/24.62 Deletedinuse: 4
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Resimplifying inuse:
% 24.27/24.62 Done
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Resimplifying inuse:
% 24.27/24.62 Done
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Intermediate Status:
% 24.27/24.62 Generated: 1185868
% 24.27/24.62 Kept: 4013
% 24.27/24.62 Inuse: 2167
% 24.27/24.62 Deleted: 311
% 24.27/24.62 Deletedinuse: 55
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Resimplifying inuse:
% 24.27/24.62 Done
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 Bliksems!, er is een bewijs:
% 24.27/24.62 % SZS status Unsatisfiable
% 24.27/24.62 % SZS output start Refutation
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 0, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( Y, Z, X, T ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 greater( 'growth_rate'( Z, T ), 'growth_rate'( Y, T ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'selection_favors'( Z, Y, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( decreases( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 2, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 4, [ ~( decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'( 'first_movers', X )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), decreases(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 5, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 Y, Z ) ), ~( decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ) ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Z ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 6, [ ~( greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X
% 24.27/24.62 ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 8, [ ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 10, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), 'in_environment'( X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 13, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater( 'critical_point'( X ), Y ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 15, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), subpopulations( 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 16, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 17, [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ), greater( X, Y ), =( X, Y ) ]
% 24.27/24.62 )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 18, [ ~( greater( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 19, [ ~( =( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 20, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 21, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 22, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 greater( Z, Y ) ), greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 23, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 24, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 25, [ environment( sk1 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 26, [ 'in_environment'( sk1, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 27, [ 'greater_or_equal'( sk2, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 )
% 24.27/24.62 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 28, [ greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 29, [ ~( 'selection_favors'( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , sk2 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 31, [ 'greater_or_equal'( X, X ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 32, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( greater( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', 'critical_point'( X ) ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', 'critical_point'( X ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 35, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', 'first_movers', X, sk2 ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2 ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 37, [ 'greater_or_equal'( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 38, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ), ~( decreases( difference( 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', X )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'disbanding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 42, [ subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 115, [ greater( X, sk2 ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( 'critical_point'(
% 24.27/24.62 sk1 ), X ) ), greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), X ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 138, [ ~( 'in_environment'( sk1, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1
% 24.27/24.62 ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1,
% 24.27/24.62 appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 187, [ ~( 'in_environment'( sk1, X ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), ~( greater( X, sk2 ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2 ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2 ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 312, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, T ), ~( =( T, Y ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 321, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, Z ), ~( =( Z, Y ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 338, [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1
% 24.27/24.62 ) ) ), ~( greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), X ) ), 'in_environment'( sk1
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 374, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1, X ) ), subpopulations( 'efficient_producers', 'first_movers', sk1, X
% 24.27/24.62 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 406, [ 'in_environment'( sk1, X ), ~( =( X, 'critical_point'( sk1 )
% 24.27/24.62 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 420, [ 'greater_or_equal'( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 430, [ greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ), =( appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ),
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 440, [ ~( =( appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ), 'critical_point'(
% 24.27/24.62 sk1 ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1,
% 24.27/24.62 appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 459, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1, X ) ), greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), 'greater_or_equal'(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 481, [ ~( =( X, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 492, [ ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ), 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 494, [ ~( greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 519, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 ~( greater( 'critical_point'( X ), Y ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 586, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Y, sk2 ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 603, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1, X ) ), decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 24.27/24.62 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 682, [ ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2 ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ) ), ~( subpopulations(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1, sk2 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 700, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1, X ) ), decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1164, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1, sk2 ) ), ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2
% 24.27/24.62 ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ), zero ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1229, [ 'in_environment'( sk1, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 )
% 24.27/24.62 ), =( appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ), 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ]
% 24.27/24.62 )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1277, [ subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1
% 24.27/24.62 , appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1863, [ ~( =( X, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( sk1 ), X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1946, [ ~( =( X, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ), greater( X, sk2 ) ]
% 24.27/24.62 )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 2924, [ 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3232, [ ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1, X ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, sk2 ) ), subpopulations(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1, sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3300, [ subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', sk1
% 24.27/24.62 , sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3303, [ ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2
% 24.27/24.62 ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ), zero ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3309, [ decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', sk2 )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3476, [ ~( 'in_environment'( sk1, X ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), ~( greater( X, sk2 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 4598, [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero )
% 24.27/24.62 ), ~( =( X, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 4612, [] )
% 24.27/24.62 .
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 % SZS output end Refutation
% 24.27/24.62 found a proof!
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 % ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 initialclauses(
% 24.27/24.62 [ clause( 4614, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( Y, Z, X, T ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( Z, T ), 'growth_rate'( Y, T ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'selection_favors'( Z, Y, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4615, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( decreases( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4616, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4617, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4618, [ ~( decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), decreases(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4619, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 Y, Z ) ), ~( decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ) ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Z ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4620, [ ~( greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4621, [ ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ) ) ), greater( zero, difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4622, [ ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X
% 24.27/24.62 ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4623, [ ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4624, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), 'in_environment'( X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4625, [ ~( environment( X ) ), 'in_environment'( X, 'start_time'(
% 24.27/24.62 X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4626, [ ~( environment( X ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'start_time'( X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4627, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater( 'critical_point'( X ), Y ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4628, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 greater( 'cardinality_at_time'( 'first_movers', Y ), zero ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'cardinality_at_time'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), zero ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4629, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), subpopulations( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'first_movers', X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4630, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4631, [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ), greater( X, Y ), =( X, Y
% 24.27/24.62 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4632, [ ~( greater( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4633, [ ~( =( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4634, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), greater( zero, difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Y ) ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4635, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4636, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 greater( Z, Y ) ), greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4637, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4638, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', Y ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4639, [ environment( sk1 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4640, [ 'in_environment'( sk1, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4641, [ 'greater_or_equal'( sk2, appear( 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.62 sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4642, [ greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4643, [ ~( 'selection_favors'( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 ] ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 0, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( Y, Z, X, T ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 greater( 'growth_rate'( Z, T ), 'growth_rate'( Y, T ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'selection_favors'( Z, Y, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4614, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( Y, Z, X, T ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( Z, T ), 'growth_rate'( Y, T ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 'selection_favors'( Z, Y, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y ), :=( Z, Z ), :=( T, T )] ),
% 24.27/24.62 permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 )] )
% 24.27/24.62 ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 1, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( decreases( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4615, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( decreases( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.62 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 2, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4616, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1,
% 24.27/24.62 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 3, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4617, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1,
% 24.27/24.62 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 4, [ ~( decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'( 'first_movers', X )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), decreases(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4618, [ ~( decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), decreases(
% 24.27/24.62 difference( 'disbanding_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'disbanding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1,
% 24.27/24.62 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 5, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 Y, Z ) ), ~( decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ) ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Z ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4619, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( Z, appear( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.62 Y, Z ) ), ~( decreases( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ) ) ) ), greater( difference(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , Z ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y ), :=( Z, Z )] ),
% 24.27/24.62 permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 ),
% 24.27/24.62 ==>( 4, 4 ), ==>( 5, 5 ), ==>( 6, 6 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 6, [ ~( greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X
% 24.27/24.62 ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ), greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4620, [ ~( greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.62 greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.62 'first_movers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1,
% 24.27/24.62 1 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 8, [ ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ),
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4622, [ ~( greater( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X
% 24.27/24.62 ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ) ), zero ) ), greater(
% 24.27/24.62 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', X ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.62 , X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1,
% 24.27/24.62 1 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 10, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), 'in_environment'( X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4624, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'in_environment'( X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.62 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), 'in_environment'( X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y ), :=( Z, Z ), :=( T, T )] ),
% 24.27/24.62 permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 ),
% 24.27/24.62 ==>( 4, 4 ), ==>( 5, 5 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 13, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater( 'critical_point'( X ), Y ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , clause( 4627, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( 'in_environment'( X,
% 24.27/24.62 'critical_point'( X ) ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ), ~( greater( 'critical_point'( X ), Y ) )
% 24.27/24.62 , 'in_environment'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.62 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.62 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 ), ==>( 4, 4 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62
% 24.27/24.62 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.62 clause( 15, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.62 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), subpopulations( 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4629, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.63 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), subpopulations( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.63 , 'first_movers', X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 16, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4630, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.63 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( Y, appear(
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 17, [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ), greater( X, Y ), =( X, Y ) ]
% 24.27/24.63 )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4631, [ ~( 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ), greater( X, Y ), =( X, Y
% 24.27/24.63 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 18, [ ~( greater( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4632, [ ~( greater( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 19, [ ~( =( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4633, [ ~( =( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 20, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), greater( zero, difference( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.63 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ),
% 24.27/24.63 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4634, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.63 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), greater( zero, difference(
% 24.27/24.63 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.63 , Y ) ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( difference( 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.63 , Y ), 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ), zero ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 21, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.63 ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4635, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) )
% 24.27/24.63 , ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 22, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.63 ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.63 greater( Z, Y ) ), greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.63 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4636, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) )
% 24.27/24.63 , ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.63 greater( Z, Y ) ), greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Z ),
% 24.27/24.63 'growth_rate'( 'first_movers', Z ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y ), :=( Z, Z )] ),
% 24.27/24.63 permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 ),
% 24.27/24.63 ==>( 4, 4 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 23, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.63 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4637, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.63 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, Z ) ), ~( 'greater_or_equal'( T, Y ) ), ~(
% 24.27/24.63 'greater_or_equal'( Z, T ) ), subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, T ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y ), :=( Z, Z ), :=( T, T )] ),
% 24.27/24.63 permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 ), ==>( 3, 3 ),
% 24.27/24.63 ==>( 4, 4 ), ==>( 5, 5 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 24, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', Y ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4638, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations( 'first_movers'
% 24.27/24.63 , 'efficient_producers', X, Y ) ), decreases( difference( 'founding_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', Y ), 'founding_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0
% 24.27/24.63 ), ==>( 1, 1 ), ==>( 2, 2 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 25, [ environment( sk1 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4639, [ environment( sk1 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 26, [ 'in_environment'( sk1, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4640, [ 'in_environment'( sk1, 'critical_point'( sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 27, [ 'greater_or_equal'( sk2, appear( 'efficient_producers', sk1 )
% 24.27/24.63 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4641, [ 'greater_or_equal'( sk2, appear( 'efficient_producers',
% 24.27/24.63 sk1 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 28, [ greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4642, [ greater( 'critical_point'( sk1 ), sk2 ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 29, [ ~( 'selection_favors'( 'first_movers', 'efficient_producers'
% 24.27/24.63 , sk2 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4643, [ ~( 'selection_favors'( 'first_movers',
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', sk2 ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 eqswap(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 4733, [ ~( =( Y, X ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 19, [ ~( =( X, Y ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , 0, substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, Y )] )).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 eqrefl(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 4734, [ 'greater_or_equal'( X, X ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4733, [ ~( =( Y, X ) ), 'greater_or_equal'( X, Y ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , 0, substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X ), :=( Y, X )] )).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 31, [ 'greater_or_equal'( X, X ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4734, [ 'greater_or_equal'( X, X ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 eqswap(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 4735, [ ~( =( 'critical_point'( Y ), X ) ), ~( environment( Y ) ),
% 24.27/24.63 ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 21, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( =( Y, 'critical_point'( X ) ) ),
% 24.27/24.63 ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', Y ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', Y ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , 1, substitution( 0, [ :=( X, Y ), :=( Y, X )] )).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 eqrefl(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 4736, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( greater( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', 'critical_point'( X ) ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', 'critical_point'( X ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4735, [ ~( =( 'critical_point'( Y ), X ) ), ~( environment( Y ) )
% 24.27/24.63 , ~( greater( 'growth_rate'( 'efficient_producers', X ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', X ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , 0, substitution( 0, [ :=( X, 'critical_point'( X ) ), :=( Y, X )] )).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 subsumption(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 32, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( greater( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', 'critical_point'( X ) ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', 'critical_point'( X ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , clause( 4736, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( greater( 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', 'critical_point'( X ) ), 'growth_rate'(
% 24.27/24.63 'first_movers', 'critical_point'( X ) ) ) ) ] )
% 24.27/24.63 , substitution( 0, [ :=( X, X )] ), permutation( 0, [ ==>( 0, 0 ), ==>( 1,
% 24.27/24.63 1 )] ) ).
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63
% 24.27/24.63 resolution(
% 24.27/24.63 clause( 4737, [ ~( environment( X ) ), ~( subpopulations(
% 24.27/24.63 'efficient_producers', 'first_movers', X, sk2 ) ), ~( greater(
% 24.27/24.63 'growth_rate'( 'fCputime limit exceeded (core dumped)
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------