TSTP Solution File: MGT001+1 by leanCoP---2.2
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : leanCoP---2.2
% Problem : MGT001+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : leancop_casc.sh %s %d
% Computer : n025.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Sun Jul 17 22:16:42 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 3.54s 4.49s
% Output : Proof 3.54s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.03/0.11 % Problem : MGT001+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.0.0.
% 0.03/0.12 % Command : leancop_casc.sh %s %d
% 0.12/0.33 % Computer : n025.cluster.edu
% 0.12/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.12/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.12/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.12/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.12/0.33 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.12/0.33 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.12/0.33 % DateTime : Thu Jun 9 09:20:50 EDT 2022
% 0.12/0.33 % CPUTime :
% 3.54/4.49 % SZS status Theorem for /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 3.54/4.50 % SZS output start Proof for /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 3.54/4.51
% 3.54/4.51 %-----------------------------------------------------
% 3.54/4.51 fof(t1_FOL, conjecture, ! [_43807, _43810, _43813, _43816, _43819, _43822, _43825, _43828] : (organization(_43807, _43813) & organization(_43810, _43816) & reorganization_free(_43807, _43813, _43813) & reorganization_free(_43810, _43816, _43816) & inertia(_43807, _43819, _43813) & inertia(_43810, _43822, _43816) & survival_chance(_43807, _43825, _43813) & survival_chance(_43810, _43828, _43816) & greater(_43822, _43819) => greater(_43828, _43825)), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 fof(mp1, axiom, ! [_44384, _44387] : (organization(_44384, _44387) => ? [_44405] : reliability(_44384, _44405, _44387)), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', mp1)).
% 3.54/4.51 fof(mp2, axiom, ! [_44567, _44570] : (organization(_44567, _44570) => ? [_44588] : accountability(_44567, _44588, _44570)), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', mp2)).
% 3.54/4.51 fof(mp3, axiom, ! [_44750, _44753] : (organization(_44750, _44753) => ? [_44771] : reproducibility(_44750, _44771, _44753)), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', mp3)).
% 3.54/4.51 fof(a1_FOL, hypothesis, ! [_44933, _44936, _44939, _44942, _44945, _44948, _44951, _44954, _44957, _44960] : (organization(_44933, _44957) & organization(_44936, _44960) & reliability(_44933, _44939, _44957) & reliability(_44936, _44942, _44960) & accountability(_44933, _44945, _44957) & accountability(_44936, _44948, _44960) & survival_chance(_44933, _44951, _44957) & survival_chance(_44936, _44954, _44960) & greater(_44942, _44939) & greater(_44948, _44945) => greater(_44954, _44951)), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', a1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 fof(a3_FOL, hypothesis, ! [_45462, _45465, _45468, _45471, _45474, _45477, _45480, _45483] : (organization(_45462, _45468) & organization(_45465, _45471) & reorganization_free(_45462, _45468, _45468) & reorganization_free(_45465, _45471, _45471) & reproducibility(_45462, _45474, _45468) & reproducibility(_45465, _45477, _45471) & inertia(_45462, _45480, _45468) & inertia(_45465, _45483, _45471) => (greater(_45477, _45474) <=> greater(_45483, _45480))), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', a3_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 fof(a2_FOL, hypothesis, ! [_45940, _45943, _45946, _45949, _45952, _45955, _45958, _45961, _45964, _45967] : (organization(_45940, _45946) & organization(_45943, _45949) & reliability(_45940, _45952, _45946) & reliability(_45943, _45955, _45949) & accountability(_45940, _45958, _45946) & accountability(_45943, _45961, _45949) & reproducibility(_45940, _45964, _45946) & reproducibility(_45943, _45967, _45949) => (greater(_45967, _45964) <=> greater(_45955, _45952) & greater(_45961, _45958))), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', a2_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(1, plain, [-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(2, plain, [-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(3, plain, [-(reorganization_free(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 6 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(4, plain, [-(reorganization_free(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(5, plain, [-(inertia(4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(6, plain, [-(inertia(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(7, plain, [-(survival_chance(4 ^ [], 10 ^ [], 6 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(8, plain, [-(survival_chance(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [], 7 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(9, plain, [-(greater(9 ^ [], 8 ^ []))], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(10, plain, [greater(11 ^ [], 10 ^ [])], clausify(t1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(11, plain, [organization(_6256, _6307), -(reliability(_6256, 1 ^ [_6307, _6256], _6307))], clausify(mp1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(12, plain, [organization(_6669, _6720), -(accountability(_6669, 2 ^ [_6720, _6669], _6720))], clausify(mp2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(13, plain, [organization(_7082, _7133), -(reproducibility(_7082, 3 ^ [_7133, _7082], _7133))], clausify(mp3)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(14, plain, [-(greater(_8489, _8350)), organization(_7495, _8627), organization(_7640, _8764), reliability(_7495, _7784, _8627), reliability(_7640, _7927, _8764), accountability(_7495, _8069, _8627), accountability(_7640, _8210, _8764), survival_chance(_7495, _8350, _8627), survival_chance(_7640, _8489, _8764), greater(_7927, _7784), greater(_8210, _8069)], clausify(a1_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(15, plain, [greater(_13543, _13420), -(greater(_13296, _13171)), organization(_12661, _12918), organization(_12790, _13045), reorganization_free(_12661, _12918, _12918), reorganization_free(_12790, _13045, _13045), reproducibility(_12661, _13171, _12918), reproducibility(_12790, _13296, _13045), inertia(_12661, _13420, _12918), inertia(_12790, _13543, _13045)], clausify(a3_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(16, plain, [-(greater(_10798, _10657)), greater(_11352, _11215), organization(_10083, _10372), organization(_10228, _10515), reliability(_10083, _10657, _10372), reliability(_10228, _10798, _10515), accountability(_10083, _10938, _10372), accountability(_10228, _11077, _10515), reproducibility(_10083, _11215, _10372), reproducibility(_10228, _11352, _10515)], clausify(a2_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf(17, plain, [-(greater(_11077, _10938)), greater(_11352, _11215), organization(_10083, _10372), organization(_10228, _10515), reliability(_10083, _10657, _10372), reliability(_10228, _10798, _10515), accountability(_10083, _10938, _10372), accountability(_10228, _11077, _10515), reproducibility(_10083, _11215, _10372), reproducibility(_10228, _11352, _10515)], clausify(a2_FOL)).
% 3.54/4.51
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1',plain,[greater(11 ^ [], 10 ^ [])],start(10)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1',plain,[-(greater(11 ^ [], 10 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reliability(4 ^ [], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reliability(5 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), accountability(4 ^ [], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), accountability(5 ^ [], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), survival_chance(4 ^ [], 10 ^ [], 6 ^ []), survival_chance(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [], 7 ^ []), greater(1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []]), greater(2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []])],extension(14,bind([[_7495, _8350, _8627, _7640, _8489, _8764, _7927, _7784, _8210, _8069], [4 ^ [], 10 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 11 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []]]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.2',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.3',plain,[-(reliability(4 ^ [], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(11,bind([[_6256, _6307], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.3.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.4',plain,[-(reliability(5 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(11,bind([[_6256, _6307], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.4.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.5',plain,[-(accountability(4 ^ [], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(12,bind([[_6669, _6720], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.5.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.6',plain,[-(accountability(5 ^ [], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(12,bind([[_6669, _6720], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.6.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.7',plain,[-(survival_chance(4 ^ [], 10 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(7)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.8',plain,[-(survival_chance(5 ^ [], 11 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(8)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9',plain,[-(greater(1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []])), greater(3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []]), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reliability(4 ^ [], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reliability(5 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), accountability(4 ^ [], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), accountability(5 ^ [], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])],extension(16,bind([[_10657, _10798, _10938, _11077, _10083, _11215, _10372, _10228, _11352, _10515], [1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1',plain,[-(greater(3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []])), greater(9 ^ [], 8 ^ []), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reorganization_free(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 6 ^ []), reorganization_free(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), inertia(4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ []), inertia(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(15,bind([[_13171, _13296, _12661, _13420, _12918, _12790, _13543, _13045], [3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.1',plain,[-(greater(9 ^ [], 8 ^ []))],extension(9)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.2',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.3',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.4',plain,[-(reorganization_free(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(3)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.5',plain,[-(reorganization_free(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(4)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.6',plain,[-(reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.6.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.7',plain,[-(reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.7.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.8',plain,[-(inertia(4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(5)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.1.9',plain,[-(inertia(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(6)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.2',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.3',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.4',plain,[-(reliability(4 ^ [], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []))],lemmata('1.1')).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.5',plain,[-(reliability(5 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []))],lemmata('1.1')).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.6',plain,[-(accountability(4 ^ [], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(12,bind([[_6669, _6720], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.6.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.7',plain,[-(accountability(5 ^ [], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(12,bind([[_6669, _6720], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.7.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.8',plain,[-(reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.8.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.9',plain,[-(reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.9.9.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10',plain,[-(greater(2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []])), greater(3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []]), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reliability(4 ^ [], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reliability(5 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), accountability(4 ^ [], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), accountability(5 ^ [], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])],extension(17,bind([[_10657, _10798, _10938, _11077, _10083, _11215, _10372, _10228, _11352, _10515], [1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1',plain,[-(greater(3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []])), greater(9 ^ [], 8 ^ []), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reorganization_free(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 6 ^ []), reorganization_free(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []), reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []), reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []), inertia(4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ []), inertia(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(15,bind([[_13171, _13296, _12661, _13420, _12918, _12790, _13543, _13045], [3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.1',plain,[-(greater(9 ^ [], 8 ^ []))],extension(9)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.2',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.3',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.4',plain,[-(reorganization_free(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(3)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.5',plain,[-(reorganization_free(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(4)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.6',plain,[-(reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.6.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.7',plain,[-(reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.7.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.8',plain,[-(inertia(4 ^ [], 8 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(5)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.1.9',plain,[-(inertia(5 ^ [], 9 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(6)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.2',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.3',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.4',plain,[-(reliability(4 ^ [], 1 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(11,bind([[_6256, _6307], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.4.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.5',plain,[-(reliability(5 ^ [], 1 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(11,bind([[_6256, _6307], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.5.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.6',plain,[-(accountability(4 ^ [], 2 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ []))],lemmata('1.1')).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.7',plain,[-(accountability(5 ^ [], 2 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ []))],lemmata('1.1')).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.8',plain,[-(reproducibility(4 ^ [], 3 ^ [6 ^ [], 4 ^ []], 6 ^ [])), organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [4 ^ [], 6 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.8.1',plain,[-(organization(4 ^ [], 6 ^ []))],extension(1)).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.9',plain,[-(reproducibility(5 ^ [], 3 ^ [7 ^ [], 5 ^ []], 7 ^ [])), organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ [])],extension(13,bind([[_7082, _7133], [5 ^ [], 7 ^ []]]))).
% 3.54/4.51 cnf('1.1.10.9.1',plain,[-(organization(5 ^ [], 7 ^ []))],extension(2)).
% 3.54/4.51 %-----------------------------------------------------
% 3.54/4.51
% 3.54/4.51 % SZS output end Proof for /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------