TSTP Solution File: MED005+1 by SPASS---3.9
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : SPASS---3.9
% Problem : MED005+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v3.2.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp
% Command : run_spass %d %s
% Computer : n017.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Sun Jul 17 21:55:52 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 86.49s 86.67s
% Output : Refutation 88.93s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.06/0.12 % Problem : MED005+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v3.2.0.
% 0.06/0.13 % Command : run_spass %d %s
% 0.12/0.34 % Computer : n017.cluster.edu
% 0.12/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.12/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.12/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.12/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.12/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.12/0.34 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.12/0.34 % DateTime : Tue Jul 5 00:51:13 EDT 2022
% 0.12/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 86.49/86.67
% 86.49/86.67 SPASS V 3.9
% 86.49/86.67 SPASS beiseite: Proof found.
% 86.49/86.67 % SZS status Theorem
% 86.49/86.67 Problem: /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 86.49/86.67 SPASS derived 39632 clauses, backtracked 13984 clauses, performed 109 splits and kept 32346 clauses.
% 86.49/86.67 SPASS allocated 130945 KBytes.
% 86.49/86.67 SPASS spent 0:1:26.28 on the problem.
% 86.49/86.67 0:00:00.04 for the input.
% 86.49/86.67 0:00:00.06 for the FLOTTER CNF translation.
% 86.49/86.67 0:00:00.33 for inferences.
% 86.49/86.67 0:00:00.80 for the backtracking.
% 86.49/86.67 0:1:24.59 for the reduction.
% 86.49/86.67
% 86.49/86.67
% 86.49/86.67 Here is a proof with depth 9, length 223 :
% 86.49/86.67 % SZS output start Refutation
% 86.49/86.67 1[0:Inp] || -> s0(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 2[0:Inp] || gt(u,u)* -> .
% 86.49/86.67 15[0:Inp] || gt(u,skf38(u))*r -> .
% 86.49/86.67 16[0:Inp] SkP8(u) || -> bcapacitysn(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 18[0:Inp] SkP9(u) || -> bcapacitysn(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 19[0:Inp] SkP10(u) || -> bcapacityne(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 26[0:Inp] || gt(u,skf41(u))*r -> .
% 86.49/86.67 27[0:Inp] || gt(u,skf42(u))*r -> .
% 86.49/86.67 28[0:Inp] || gt(u,skf43(u))*r -> .
% 86.49/86.67 33[0:Inp] bcapacityex(u) bcapacityne(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 35[0:Inp] bcapacitysn(u) bcapacityex(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 38[0:Inp] conditionnormo(u) conditionhyper(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 46[0:Inp] s1(u) s0(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 47[0:Inp] s2(u) s0(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 48[0:Inp] s3(u) s0(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 52[0:Inp] || conditionnormo(skf38(u))* -> SkP7(u).
% 86.49/86.67 54[0:Inp] SkP11(u) bcapacityex(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 55[0:Inp] || bsecretioni(skf41(u))* -> SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 57[0:Inp] || -> releaselg(u) uptakelg(u)* gt(v,u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 61[0:Inp] SkP8(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 62[0:Inp] SkP10(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 64[0:Inp] SkP11(u) || -> drugsu(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 65[0:Inp] || -> drugbg(u)* releaselg(skf42(v))* gt(v,u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 66[0:Inp] uptakelg(u) releaselg(u) || -> gt(v,u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 67[0:Inp] SkP8(u) || gt(u,v)*+ -> conditionhyper(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 68[0:Inp] SkP9(u) releaselg(v) || -> gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 69[0:Inp] SkP9(u) || gt(u,v)*+ -> conditionhyper(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 70[0:Inp] SkP10(u) || gt(u,v)*+ -> conditionhyper(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 71[0:Inp] drugbg(u) || -> s3(u)* s2(u) s1(u).
% 86.49/86.67 72[0:Inp] drugsu(u) || -> s3(u)* s2(u) s1(u).
% 86.49/86.67 76[0:Inp] s1(u) || -> gt(u,skf23(u))*r gt(n0,u).
% 86.49/86.67 77[0:Inp] s1(u) || conditionhyper(skf23(v))*+ -> gt(n0,u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 80[0:Inp] || gt(u,v)* gt(v,w)* -> gt(u,w)*.
% 86.49/86.67 82[0:Inp] SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP9(u) SkP8(u) bcapacityex(u).
% 86.49/86.67 83[0:Inp] s0(u) || -> conditionnormo(v)* s1(skf43(u))* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 87[0:Inp] SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP9(u) SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 91[0:Inp] SkP7(u) || gt(u,v)* -> conditionhyper(v)* SkP8(u) SkP9(u) SkP10(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 92[0:Inp] s0(u) || gt(skf43(u),v)*+ -> conditionnormo(w)* conditionhyper(v)* gt(u,w)*.
% 86.49/86.67 103[0:MRR:91.3,91.4,91.5,67.0,69.0,70.0] SkP7(u) || gt(u,v)*+ -> conditionhyper(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 104[0:Res:1.0,92.0] || gt(skf43(n0),u)*+ -> conditionnormo(v)* conditionhyper(u)* gt(n0,v).
% 86.49/86.67 105[0:Res:1.0,83.0] || -> conditionnormo(u)* s1(skf43(n0))* gt(n0,u).
% 86.49/86.67 106[0:Res:1.0,46.0] s1(n0) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 107[0:Res:1.0,47.0] s2(n0) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 256[1:Spt:77.0,77.2] s1(u) || -> gt(n0,u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 259[2:Spt:105.0,105.2] || -> conditionnormo(u)* gt(n0,u).
% 86.49/86.67 267[2:Res:259.0,52.0] || -> gt(n0,skf38(u))*r SkP7(u).
% 86.49/86.67 278[0:EmS:48.0,48.1,72.1,1.0] drugsu(n0) || -> s2(n0)* s1(n0).
% 86.49/86.67 281[0:MRR:278.1,278.2,107.0,106.0] drugsu(n0) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 284[0:EmS:48.0,48.1,71.1,1.0] drugbg(n0) || -> s2(n0)* s1(n0).
% 86.49/86.67 287[0:MRR:284.1,284.2,107.0,106.0] drugbg(n0) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 293[1:Res:256.1,28.0] s1(skf43(n0)) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 330[2:Res:267.0,15.0] || -> SkP7(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 332[2:NCh:80.2,80.1,267.0,2.0] || gt(skf38(u),n0)*l -> SkP7(u).
% 86.49/86.67 380[2:Res:57.2,332.0] || -> releaselg(n0) uptakelg(n0) SkP7(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 382[0:SoR:281.0,64.1] SkP11(u) || -> gt(u,n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 421[3:Spt:380.2] || -> SkP7(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 422[3:MRR:82.0,421.0] || -> SkP10(u)* SkP9(u) SkP8(u) bcapacityex(u).
% 86.49/86.67 423[3:MRR:103.0,421.0] || gt(u,v)*+ -> conditionhyper(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 425[3:MRR:87.0,421.0] || -> SkP10(u)* SkP9(u) SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 439[0:Res:382.1,2.0] SkP11(n0) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 540[0:Res:62.1,55.0] SkP10(u) || -> gt(u,skf41(v))* SkP11(v).
% 86.49/86.67 544[3:Res:62.2,423.0] SkP10(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 582[3:EmS:544.0,422.0] || -> bsecretioni(u)* conditionhyper(u) bcapacityex(v) SkP8(v) SkP9(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 583[4:Spt:582.0,582.1] || -> bsecretioni(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 86.49/86.67 584[4:Res:583.0,55.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf41(u))* SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 587[4:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,584.0] || -> gt(n0,skf41(u))*r SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 589[0:Res:61.1,55.0] SkP8(u) || -> gt(u,skf41(v))* SkP11(v).
% 86.49/86.67 593[3:Res:61.2,423.0] SkP8(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 638[4:Res:587.0,26.0] || -> SkP11(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 651[4:MRR:638.0,439.0] || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 652[4:Spt:651.0,582.2,582.3,582.4] || -> bcapacityex(u) SkP8(u) SkP9(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 655[0:SoR:287.0,65.0] || -> gt(u,n0) releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 86.49/86.67 657[3:Res:65.2,423.0] || -> drugbg(u)* releaselg(skf42(v))* conditionhyper(u).
% 86.49/86.67 677[0:NCh:80.2,80.1,65.2,2.0] || gt(u,v)*+ -> drugbg(u)* releaselg(skf42(v))*.
% 86.49/86.67 697[5:Spt:657.0,657.2] || -> drugbg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 86.49/86.67 698[5:SoR:287.0,697.0] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 701[5:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,698.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 703[5:MRR:701.0,2.0] || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 704[5:Spt:703.0,657.1] || -> releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 86.49/86.67 706[0:Res:66.2,2.0] uptakelg(u) releaselg(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 790[0:Res:68.2,27.0] SkP9(u) releaselg(skf42(u)) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 850[5:SSi:790.1,704.0] SkP9(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 851[5:MRR:652.2,850.0] || -> bcapacityex(u) SkP8(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 853[5:MRR:425.1,850.0] || -> SkP10(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 854[5:EmS:593.0,851.1] || -> bsecretioni(u)* conditionhyper(u) bcapacityex(v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 855[6:Spt:854.0,854.1] || -> bsecretioni(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 86.49/86.67 856[6:Res:855.0,55.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf41(u))* SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 859[6:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,856.0] || -> gt(n0,skf41(u))*r SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 869[6:Res:859.0,26.0] || -> SkP11(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 882[6:MRR:869.0,439.0] || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 883[6:Spt:882.0,854.2] || -> bcapacityex(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 884[6:MRR:33.0,883.0] bcapacityne(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 886[6:MRR:35.1,883.0] bcapacitysn(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 889[6:MRR:19.1,884.0] SkP10(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 893[6:MRR:16.1,886.0] SkP8(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 895[6:MRR:853.0,889.0] || -> SkP8(u)* uptakelg(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 897[6:MRR:895.0,893.0] || -> uptakelg(u)* gt(v,u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 939[6:EmS:706.0,706.1,897.0,704.0] || -> gt(u,skf42(v))*.
% 86.49/86.67 974[6:UnC:939.0,27.0] || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 977[3:Spt:974.0,380.0,380.1] || -> releaselg(n0) uptakelg(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 979[4:Spt:977.0] || -> releaselg(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1176[0:SoR:790.1,655.1] SkP9(u) || -> gt(u,n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1461[0:Res:65.2,103.1] SkP7(u) || -> drugbg(v)* releaselg(skf42(u))* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 1469[0:Res:61.2,103.1] SkP8(u) SkP7(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 1520[0:Res:65.2,70.1] SkP10(u) || -> drugbg(v)* releaselg(skf42(u))* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 1524[0:Res:382.1,70.1] SkP11(u) SkP10(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1529[0:Res:62.2,70.1] SkP10(u) SkP10(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 1557[0:Obv:1529.0] SkP10(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 1559[0:EmS:1557.0,82.1] SkP7(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v) bcapacityex(u) SkP8(u) SkP9(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1560[0:MRR:1559.4,1469.0] SkP7(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v) bcapacityex(u) SkP9(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1567[0:Res:1176.1,69.1] SkP9(u) SkP9(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1601[0:Obv:1567.0] SkP9(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1610[0:Res:65.2,67.1] SkP8(u) || -> drugbg(v)* releaselg(skf42(u))* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 1614[0:Res:382.1,67.1] SkP11(u) SkP8(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1722[5:Spt:1461.1,1461.3] || -> drugbg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 86.49/86.67 1723[5:SoR:287.0,1722.0] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1813[5:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,1723.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1815[5:MRR:1813.0,2.0] || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 1817[5:Spt:1815.0,1461.0,1461.2] SkP7(u) || -> releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 86.49/86.67 1821[5:SoR:790.1,1817.1] SkP9(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 1823[5:MRR:87.2,1821.0] SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* gt(u,v)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1825[5:MRR:1560.4,1821.0] SkP7(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v) bcapacityex(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 1911[6:Spt:1825.1,1825.2] || -> bsecretioni(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 86.49/86.67 1914[6:Res:1911.0,55.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf41(u))* SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 1925[6:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,1914.0] || -> gt(n0,skf41(u))*r SkP11(u).
% 86.49/86.67 2111[5:Res:1823.4,103.1] SkP7(u) SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 2175[5:Obv:2111.0] SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 86.49/86.67 3097[6:Res:1925.0,26.0] || -> SkP11(n0)*.
% 86.49/86.67 3127[6:MRR:3097.0,439.0] || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 3130[6:Spt:3127.0,1825.0,1825.3] SkP7(u) || -> bcapacityex(u)*.
% 86.49/86.67 3136[6:EmS:33.0,33.1,3130.1,19.1] SkP7(u) SkP10(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 3137[6:EmS:35.0,35.1,16.1,3130.1] SkP8(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 86.49/86.67 3141[6:MRR:2175.1,3136.1] SkP7(u) || -> SkP8(u)* uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 3254[6:MRR:3141.1,3137.0] SkP7(u) || -> uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 3451[6:EmS:3254.0,330.0] || -> uptakelg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 3456[6:EmS:706.0,706.1,3451.0,979.0] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 3469[6:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,3456.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 3471[6:MRR:3469.0,2.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 3474[4:Spt:3471.0,977.0,979.0] || releaselg(n0)* -> .
% 88.93/89.09 3475[4:Spt:3471.0,977.1] || -> uptakelg(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 3897[0:Res:87.5,103.1] SkP7(u) SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP9(u) SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 3964[0:Obv:3897.0] SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP9(u) SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 3981[5:Spt:1610.1,1610.3] || -> drugbg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 3982[5:SoR:287.0,3981.0] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4295[5:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,3982.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4297[5:MRR:4295.0,2.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 4300[5:Spt:4297.0,1610.0,1610.2] SkP8(u) || -> releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 88.93/89.09 4492[6:Spt:1520.1,1520.3] || -> drugbg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 4493[6:SoR:287.0,4492.0] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4505[6:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,4493.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4507[6:MRR:4505.0,2.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 4510[6:Spt:4507.0,1520.0,1520.2] SkP10(u) || -> releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 88.93/89.09 4713[7:Spt:1461.1,1461.3] || -> drugbg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 4714[7:SoR:287.0,4713.0] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4725[7:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,4714.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4727[7:MRR:4725.0,2.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 4729[7:Spt:4727.0,1461.0,1461.2] SkP7(u) || -> releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 88.93/89.09 4735[7:SoR:790.1,4729.1] SkP9(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 4739[7:MRR:1560.4,4735.0] SkP7(u) || -> bsecretioni(v)* conditionhyper(v) bcapacityex(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 4743[7:MRR:3964.2,4735.0] SkP7(u) || -> SkP10(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 4918[8:Spt:4739.1,4739.2] || -> bsecretioni(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 4921[8:Res:4918.0,55.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf41(u))* SkP11(u).
% 88.93/89.09 5032[8:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,4921.0] || -> gt(n0,skf41(u))*r SkP11(u).
% 88.93/89.09 5386[8:Res:5032.0,26.0] || -> SkP11(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 5417[8:MRR:5386.0,439.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 5419[8:Spt:5417.0,4739.0,4739.3] SkP7(u) || -> bcapacityex(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 5420[8:EmS:33.0,33.1,5419.1,19.1] SkP7(u) SkP10(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 5421[8:EmS:35.0,35.1,16.1,5419.1] SkP8(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 5433[8:MRR:4743.1,5420.1] SkP7(u) || -> SkP8(u)* uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 5539[8:MRR:5433.1,5421.0] SkP7(u) || -> uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 5802[8:EmS:5539.0,330.0] || -> uptakelg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 7818[0:Res:589.1,26.0] SkP8(u) || -> SkP11(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 7904[0:MRR:1614.0,7818.1] SkP8(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 7927[0:Res:540.1,26.0] SkP10(u) || -> SkP11(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 8015[0:MRR:1524.0,7927.1] SkP10(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 9242[0:Res:65.2,677.0] || -> drugbg(u) releaselg(skf42(v))* drugbg(v) releaselg(skf42(u))*.
% 88.93/89.09 9350[0:Con:9242.0] || -> releaselg(skf42(u))* drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 9381[8:EmS:706.0,706.1,5802.0,9350.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf42(u))* drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 9401[8:EmS:38.0,38.1,259.0,9381.0] || -> gt(n0,skf42(u))*r drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 15282[8:Res:9401.0,27.0] || -> drugbg(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 15376[8:MRR:15282.0,287.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 15378[2:Spt:15376.0,105.1] || -> s1(skf43(n0))*.
% 88.93/89.09 15379[2:MRR:15378.0,293.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 15412[1:Spt:15379.0,77.1] || conditionhyper(skf23(u))* -> .
% 88.93/89.09 15424[2:Spt:104.1,104.3] || -> conditionnormo(u)* gt(n0,u).
% 88.93/89.09 15435[2:Res:15424.0,52.0] || -> gt(n0,skf38(u))*r SkP7(u).
% 88.93/89.09 15463[0:EmS:8015.0,82.1] SkP7(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0) bcapacityex(u) SkP8(u) SkP9(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 15470[0:MRR:15463.3,15463.4,7904.0,1601.0] SkP7(u) || -> conditionhyper(n0) bcapacityex(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 15478[3:Spt:15470.0,15470.2] SkP7(u) || -> bcapacityex(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 15481[3:EmS:33.0,33.1,15478.1,19.1] SkP7(u) SkP10(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 15482[3:EmS:54.0,54.1,7818.1,15478.1] SkP8(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 15485[3:EmS:35.0,35.1,18.1,15478.1] SkP9(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 15487[3:MRR:3964.1,15481.1] SkP7(u) || -> SkP9(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 15595[3:MRR:15487.1,15487.2,15485.0,15482.0] SkP7(u) || -> uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 20272[2:Res:15435.0,15.0] || -> SkP7(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 20412[3:EmS:15595.0,20272.0] || -> uptakelg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 20422[3:EmS:706.0,706.1,20412.0,9350.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf42(u))* drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 20720[3:EmS:38.0,38.1,15424.0,20422.0] || -> gt(n0,skf42(u))*r drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 24388[3:Res:20720.0,27.0] || -> drugbg(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 24517[3:MRR:24388.0,287.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 24519[3:Spt:24517.0,15470.1] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 24541[3:EmS:38.0,38.1,15424.0,24519.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 24542[3:MRR:24541.0,2.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 24546[2:Spt:24542.0,104.0,104.2] || gt(skf43(n0),u)*+ -> conditionhyper(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 24592[2:Res:76.1,24546.0] s1(skf43(n0)) || -> gt(n0,skf43(n0)) conditionhyper(skf23(skf43(n0)))*.
% 88.93/89.09 24635[2:MRR:24592.1,24592.2,28.0,15412.0] s1(skf43(n0)) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 24636[2:MRR:105.1,24635.0] || -> conditionnormo(u)* gt(n0,u).
% 88.93/89.09 24679[3:Spt:15470.0,15470.2] SkP7(u) || -> bcapacityex(u)*.
% 88.93/89.09 24682[3:EmS:33.0,33.1,24679.1,19.1] SkP7(u) SkP10(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 24683[3:EmS:54.0,54.1,7818.1,24679.1] SkP8(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 24686[3:EmS:35.0,35.1,18.1,24679.1] SkP9(u) SkP7(u) || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 24689[3:MRR:3964.1,24682.1] SkP7(u) || -> SkP9(u)* SkP8(u) uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 24797[3:MRR:24689.1,24689.2,24686.0,24683.0] SkP7(u) || -> uptakelg(v)* conditionhyper(v).
% 88.93/89.09 27359[2:Res:24636.0,52.0] || -> gt(n0,skf38(u))*r SkP7(u).
% 88.93/89.09 30773[2:Res:27359.0,15.0] || -> SkP7(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 30948[3:EmS:24797.0,30773.0] || -> uptakelg(u)* conditionhyper(u).
% 88.93/89.09 30956[3:EmS:706.0,706.1,30948.0,9350.0] || -> conditionhyper(skf42(u))* drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 31393[3:EmS:38.0,38.1,24636.0,30956.0] || -> gt(n0,skf42(u))*r drugbg(u).
% 88.93/89.09 41040[3:Res:31393.0,27.0] || -> drugbg(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 41211[3:MRR:41040.0,287.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 41213[3:Spt:41211.0,15470.1] || -> conditionhyper(n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 41236[3:EmS:38.0,38.1,24636.0,41213.0] || -> gt(n0,n0)*.
% 88.93/89.09 41237[3:MRR:41236.0,2.0] || -> .
% 88.93/89.09 % SZS output end Refutation
% 88.93/89.09 Formulae used in the proof : transs0s1 irreflexivity_gt normo su_completion bg_completion trans_ax1 xorcapacity2 xorcapacity4 xorcondition3 xorstep2 xorstep3 xorstep4 uptake_completion liver_glucose bgcomp sucomp transitivity_gt
% 88.93/89.09
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------