TSTP Solution File: LCL686+1.005 by PyRes---1.3
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : PyRes---1.3
% Problem : LCL686+1.005 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% Computer : n015.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Sun Jul 17 13:56:50 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 1.62s 1.89s
% Output : Refutation 1.62s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.07/0.12 % Problem : LCL686+1.005 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% 0.07/0.13 % Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n015.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.34 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Mon Jul 4 10:51:16 EDT 2022
% 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 1.62/1.89 # Version: 1.3
% 1.62/1.89 # SZS status Theorem
% 1.62/1.89 # SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 1.62/1.89 fof(reflexivity,axiom,(![X]:r1(X,X)),input).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c83,axiom,(![X38]:r1(X38,X38)),inference(variable_rename,status(thm),[reflexivity])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c84,axiom,r1(X39,X39),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c83])).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(main,conjecture,(~(?[X]:(~((![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(~p15(Y)))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~p1(X))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((((![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|$false)))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p14(Y)&(~p13(Y)))|((~p14(Y))&p13(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p13(X)&(~p12(X)))|((~p13(X))&p12(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p12(Y)&(~p11(Y)))|((~p12(Y))&p11(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p11(X)&(~p10(X)))|((~p11(X))&p10(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p10(Y)&(~p9(Y)))|((~p10(Y))&p9(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p9(X)&(~p8(X)))|((~p9(X))&p8(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p8(Y)&(~p7(Y)))|((~p8(Y))&p7(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p7(X)&(~p6(X)))|((~p7(X))&p6(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p6(Y)&(~p5(Y)))|((~p6(Y))&p5(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p5(X)&(~p4(X)))|((~p5(X))&p4(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p4(Y)&(~p3(Y)))|((~p4(Y))&p3(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p3(X)&(~p2(X)))|((~p3(X))&p2(X)))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p2(Y)&(~p1(Y)))|((~p2(Y))&p1(Y))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p15(Y))))|(![Y]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((~r1(X,Y))|((~p13(Y))&(~p14(Y))))|(p14(Y)&p13(Y)))|((~p12(Y))&(~p13(Y))))|(p13(Y)&p12(Y)))|((~p11(Y))&(~p12(Y))))|(p12(Y)&p11(Y)))|((~p10(Y))&(~p11(Y))))|(p11(Y)&p10(Y)))|((~p9(Y))&(~p10(Y))))|(p10(Y)&p9(Y)))|((~p8(Y))&(~p9(Y))))|(p9(Y)&p8(Y)))|((~p7(Y))&(~p8(Y))))|(p8(Y)&p7(Y)))|((~p6(Y))&(~p7(Y))))|(p7(Y)&p6(Y)))|((~p5(Y))&(~p6(Y))))|(p6(Y)&p5(Y)))|((~p4(Y))&(~p5(Y))))|(p5(Y)&p4(Y)))|((~p3(Y))&(~p4(Y))))|(p4(Y)&p3(Y)))|((~p2(Y))&(~p3(Y))))|(p3(Y)&p2(Y)))|((~p1(Y))&(~p2(Y))))|(p2(Y)&p1(Y))))))))))))))),input).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c0,negated_conjecture,(~(~(?[X]:(~((![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(~p15(Y)))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~p1(X))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((((![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:(((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:(((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|$false)))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p14(Y)&(~p13(Y)))|((~p14(Y))&p13(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p13(X)&(~p12(X)))|((~p13(X))&p12(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p12(Y)&(~p11(Y)))|((~p12(Y))&p11(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p11(X)&(~p10(X)))|((~p11(X))&p10(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p10(Y)&(~p9(Y)))|((~p10(Y))&p9(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p9(X)&(~p8(X)))|((~p9(X))&p8(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p8(Y)&(~p7(Y)))|((~p8(Y))&p7(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p7(X)&(~p6(X)))|((~p7(X))&p6(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p6(Y)&(~p5(Y)))|((~p6(Y))&p5(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p5(X)&(~p4(X)))|((~p5(X))&p4(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p4(Y)&(~p3(Y)))|((~p4(Y))&p3(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~((p3(X)&(~p2(X)))|((~p3(X))&p2(X)))))))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~((p2(Y)&(~p1(Y)))|((~p2(Y))&p1(Y))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p15(Y))))|(![Y]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((~r1(X,Y))|((~p13(Y))&(~p14(Y))))|(p14(Y)&p13(Y)))|((~p12(Y))&(~p13(Y))))|(p13(Y)&p12(Y)))|((~p11(Y))&(~p12(Y))))|(p12(Y)&p11(Y)))|((~p10(Y))&(~p11(Y))))|(p11(Y)&p10(Y)))|((~p9(Y))&(~p10(Y))))|(p10(Y)&p9(Y)))|((~p8(Y))&(~p9(Y))))|(p9(Y)&p8(Y)))|((~p7(Y))&(~p8(Y))))|(p8(Y)&p7(Y)))|((~p6(Y))&(~p7(Y))))|(p7(Y)&p6(Y)))|((~p5(Y))&(~p6(Y))))|(p6(Y)&p5(Y)))|((~p4(Y))&(~p5(Y))))|(p5(Y)&p4(Y)))|((~p3(Y))&(~p4(Y))))|(p4(Y)&p3(Y)))|((~p2(Y))&(~p3(Y))))|(p3(Y)&p2(Y)))|((~p1(Y))&(~p2(Y))))|(p2(Y)&p1(Y)))))))))))))))),inference(assume_negation,status(cth),[main])).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c1,negated_conjecture,(~(~(?[X]:(~((![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|~p15(Y))|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|~p1(X)))))|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((((![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:~r1(X,Y)))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p14(Y)&~p13(Y))|(~p14(Y)&p13(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((p13(X)&~p12(X))|(~p13(X)&p12(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p12(Y)&~p11(Y))|(~p12(Y)&p11(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((p11(X)&~p10(X))|(~p11(X)&p10(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p10(Y)&~p9(Y))|(~p10(Y)&p9(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((p9(X)&~p8(X))|(~p9(X)&p8(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p8(Y)&~p7(Y))|(~p8(Y)&p7(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((p7(X)&~p6(X))|(~p7(X)&p6(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p6(Y)&~p5(Y))|(~p6(Y)&p5(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((p5(X)&~p4(X))|(~p5(X)&p4(X))))))))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p4(Y)&~p3(Y))|(~p4(Y)&p3(Y))))))))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((p3(X)&~p2(X))|(~p3(X)&p2(X)))))))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~((p2(Y)&~p1(Y))|(~p2(Y)&p1(Y))))))))|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|p15(Y))))|(![Y]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((~r1(X,Y)|(~p13(Y)&~p14(Y)))|(p14(Y)&p13(Y)))|(~p12(Y)&~p13(Y)))|(p13(Y)&p12(Y)))|(~p11(Y)&~p12(Y)))|(p12(Y)&p11(Y)))|(~p10(Y)&~p11(Y)))|(p11(Y)&p10(Y)))|(~p9(Y)&~p10(Y)))|(p10(Y)&p9(Y)))|(~p8(Y)&~p9(Y)))|(p9(Y)&p8(Y)))|(~p7(Y)&~p8(Y)))|(p8(Y)&p7(Y)))|(~p6(Y)&~p7(Y)))|(p7(Y)&p6(Y)))|(~p5(Y)&~p6(Y)))|(p6(Y)&p5(Y)))|(~p4(Y)&~p5(Y)))|(p5(Y)&p4(Y)))|(~p3(Y)&~p4(Y)))|(p4(Y)&p3(Y)))|(~p2(Y)&~p3(Y)))|(p3(Y)&p2(Y)))|(~p1(Y)&~p2(Y)))|(p2(Y)&p1(Y)))))))))))))))),inference(fof_simplification,status(thm),[c0])).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c2,negated_conjecture,(?[X]:((?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&p15(Y))&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&p1(X)))))&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((((?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:((r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:((r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:((r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:((r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:((r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:((r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:((r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:r1(X,Y)))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p14(Y)|p13(Y))&(p14(Y)|~p13(Y))))))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((~p13(X)|p12(X))&(p13(X)|~p12(X))))))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p12(Y)|p11(Y))&(p12(Y)|~p11(Y))))))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((~p11(X)|p10(X))&(p11(X)|~p10(X))))))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p10(Y)|p9(Y))&(p10(Y)|~p9(Y))))))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((~p9(X)|p8(X))&(p9(X)|~p8(X))))))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p8(Y)|p7(Y))&(p8(Y)|~p7(Y))))))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((~p7(X)|p6(X))&(p7(X)|~p6(X))))))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p6(Y)|p5(Y))&(p6(Y)|~p5(Y))))))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((~p5(X)|p4(X))&(p5(X)|~p4(X))))))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p4(Y)|p3(Y))&(p4(Y)|~p3(Y))))))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((~p3(X)|p2(X))&(p3(X)|~p2(X)))))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|((~p2(Y)|p1(Y))&(p2(Y)|~p1(Y))))))&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&~p15(Y))))&(?[Y]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((r1(X,Y)&(p13(Y)|p14(Y)))&(~p14(Y)|~p13(Y)))&(p12(Y)|p13(Y)))&(~p13(Y)|~p12(Y)))&(p11(Y)|p12(Y)))&(~p12(Y)|~p11(Y)))&(p10(Y)|p11(Y)))&(~p11(Y)|~p10(Y)))&(p9(Y)|p10(Y)))&(~p10(Y)|~p9(Y)))&(p8(Y)|p9(Y)))&(~p9(Y)|~p8(Y)))&(p7(Y)|p8(Y)))&(~p8(Y)|~p7(Y)))&(p6(Y)|p7(Y)))&(~p7(Y)|~p6(Y)))&(p5(Y)|p6(Y)))&(~p6(Y)|~p5(Y)))&(p4(Y)|p5(Y)))&(~p5(Y)|~p4(Y)))&(p3(Y)|p4(Y)))&(~p4(Y)|~p3(Y)))&(p2(Y)|p3(Y)))&(~p3(Y)|~p2(Y)))&(p1(Y)|p2(Y)))&(~p2(Y)|~p1(Y))))))))))),inference(fof_nnf,status(thm),[c1])).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c3,negated_conjecture,(?[X2]:((?[X3]:((r1(X2,X3)&p15(X3))&(?[X4]:(r1(X3,X4)&p1(X4)))))&(?[X5]:(r1(X2,X5)&(![X6]:(~r1(X5,X6)|((((?[X7]:((r1(X6,X7)&(?[X8]:((r1(X7,X8)&(?[X9]:((r1(X8,X9)&(?[X10]:((r1(X9,X10)&(?[X11]:((r1(X10,X11)&(?[X12]:((r1(X11,X12)&(?[X13]:((r1(X12,X13)&(?[X14]:((r1(X13,X14)&(?[X15]:((r1(X14,X15)&(?[X16]:((r1(X15,X16)&(?[X17]:((r1(X16,X17)&(?[X18]:((r1(X17,X18)&(?[X19]:r1(X18,X19)))&(![X20]:(~r1(X18,X20)|((~p14(X20)|p13(X20))&(p14(X20)|~p13(X20))))))))&(![X21]:(~r1(X17,X21)|((~p13(X21)|p12(X21))&(p13(X21)|~p12(X21))))))))&(![X22]:(~r1(X16,X22)|((~p12(X22)|p11(X22))&(p12(X22)|~p11(X22))))))))&(![X23]:(~r1(X15,X23)|((~p11(X23)|p10(X23))&(p11(X23)|~p10(X23))))))))&(![X24]:(~r1(X14,X24)|((~p10(X24)|p9(X24))&(p10(X24)|~p9(X24))))))))&(![X25]:(~r1(X13,X25)|((~p9(X25)|p8(X25))&(p9(X25)|~p8(X25))))))))&(![X26]:(~r1(X12,X26)|((~p8(X26)|p7(X26))&(p8(X26)|~p7(X26))))))))&(![X27]:(~r1(X11,X27)|((~p7(X27)|p6(X27))&(p7(X27)|~p6(X27))))))))&(![X28]:(~r1(X10,X28)|((~p6(X28)|p5(X28))&(p6(X28)|~p5(X28))))))))&(![X29]:(~r1(X9,X29)|((~p5(X29)|p4(X29))&(p5(X29)|~p4(X29))))))))&(![X30]:(~r1(X8,X30)|((~p4(X30)|p3(X30))&(p4(X30)|~p3(X30))))))))&(![X31]:(~r1(X7,X31)|((~p3(X31)|p2(X31))&(p3(X31)|~p2(X31)))))))&(![X32]:(~r1(X6,X32)|((~p2(X32)|p1(X32))&(p2(X32)|~p1(X32))))))&(?[X33]:(r1(X6,X33)&~p15(X33))))&(?[X34]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((r1(X6,X34)&(p13(X34)|p14(X34)))&(~p14(X34)|~p13(X34)))&(p12(X34)|p13(X34)))&(~p13(X34)|~p12(X34)))&(p11(X34)|p12(X34)))&(~p12(X34)|~p11(X34)))&(p10(X34)|p11(X34)))&(~p11(X34)|~p10(X34)))&(p9(X34)|p10(X34)))&(~p10(X34)|~p9(X34)))&(p8(X34)|p9(X34)))&(~p9(X34)|~p8(X34)))&(p7(X34)|p8(X34)))&(~p8(X34)|~p7(X34)))&(p6(X34)|p7(X34)))&(~p7(X34)|~p6(X34)))&(p5(X34)|p6(X34)))&(~p6(X34)|~p5(X34)))&(p4(X34)|p5(X34)))&(~p5(X34)|~p4(X34)))&(p3(X34)|p4(X34)))&(~p4(X34)|~p3(X34)))&(p2(X34)|p3(X34)))&(~p3(X34)|~p2(X34)))&(p1(X34)|p2(X34)))&(~p2(X34)|~p1(X34))))))))))),inference(variable_rename,status(thm),[c2])).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c5,negated_conjecture,(![X6]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X24]:(![X25]:(![X26]:(![X27]:(![X28]:(![X29]:(![X30]:(![X31]:(![X32]:(((r1(skolem0001,skolem0002)&p15(skolem0002))&(r1(skolem0002,skolem0003)&p1(skolem0003)))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0004)&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(((((r1(X6,skolem0005(X6))&((r1(skolem0005(X6),skolem0006(X6))&((r1(skolem0006(X6),skolem0007(X6))&((r1(skolem0007(X6),skolem0008(X6))&((r1(skolem0008(X6),skolem0009(X6))&((r1(skolem0009(X6),skolem0010(X6))&((r1(skolem0010(X6),skolem0011(X6))&((r1(skolem0011(X6),skolem0012(X6))&((r1(skolem0012(X6),skolem0013(X6))&((r1(skolem0013(X6),skolem0014(X6))&((r1(skolem0014(X6),skolem0015(X6))&((r1(skolem0015(X6),skolem0016(X6))&r1(skolem0016(X6),skolem0017(X6)))&(~r1(skolem0016(X6),X20)|((~p14(X20)|p13(X20))&(p14(X20)|~p13(X20))))))&(~r1(skolem0015(X6),X21)|((~p13(X21)|p12(X21))&(p13(X21)|~p12(X21))))))&(~r1(skolem0014(X6),X22)|((~p12(X22)|p11(X22))&(p12(X22)|~p11(X22))))))&(~r1(skolem0013(X6),X23)|((~p11(X23)|p10(X23))&(p11(X23)|~p10(X23))))))&(~r1(skolem0012(X6),X24)|((~p10(X24)|p9(X24))&(p10(X24)|~p9(X24))))))&(~r1(skolem0011(X6),X25)|((~p9(X25)|p8(X25))&(p9(X25)|~p8(X25))))))&(~r1(skolem0010(X6),X26)|((~p8(X26)|p7(X26))&(p8(X26)|~p7(X26))))))&(~r1(skolem0009(X6),X27)|((~p7(X27)|p6(X27))&(p7(X27)|~p6(X27))))))&(~r1(skolem0008(X6),X28)|((~p6(X28)|p5(X28))&(p6(X28)|~p5(X28))))))&(~r1(skolem0007(X6),X29)|((~p5(X29)|p4(X29))&(p5(X29)|~p4(X29))))))&(~r1(skolem0006(X6),X30)|((~p4(X30)|p3(X30))&(p4(X30)|~p3(X30))))))&(~r1(skolem0005(X6),X31)|((~p3(X31)|p2(X31))&(p3(X31)|~p2(X31)))))&(~r1(X6,X32)|((~p2(X32)|p1(X32))&(p2(X32)|~p1(X32)))))&(r1(X6,skolem0018(X6))&~p15(skolem0018(X6))))&((((((((((((((((((((((((((r1(X6,skolem0019(X6))&(p13(skolem0019(X6))|p14(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p14(skolem0019(X6))|~p13(skolem0019(X6))))&(p12(skolem0019(X6))|p13(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p13(skolem0019(X6))|~p12(skolem0019(X6))))&(p11(skolem0019(X6))|p12(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p12(skolem0019(X6))|~p11(skolem0019(X6))))&(p10(skolem0019(X6))|p11(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p11(skolem0019(X6))|~p10(skolem0019(X6))))&(p9(skolem0019(X6))|p10(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p10(skolem0019(X6))|~p9(skolem0019(X6))))&(p8(skolem0019(X6))|p9(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p9(skolem0019(X6))|~p8(skolem0019(X6))))&(p7(skolem0019(X6))|p8(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p8(skolem0019(X6))|~p7(skolem0019(X6))))&(p6(skolem0019(X6))|p7(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p7(skolem0019(X6))|~p6(skolem0019(X6))))&(p5(skolem0019(X6))|p6(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p6(skolem0019(X6))|~p5(skolem0019(X6))))&(p4(skolem0019(X6))|p5(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p5(skolem0019(X6))|~p4(skolem0019(X6))))&(p3(skolem0019(X6))|p4(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p4(skolem0019(X6))|~p3(skolem0019(X6))))&(p2(skolem0019(X6))|p3(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p3(skolem0019(X6))|~p2(skolem0019(X6))))&(p1(skolem0019(X6))|p2(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p2(skolem0019(X6))|~p1(skolem0019(X6)))))))))))))))))))))),inference(shift_quantors,status(thm),[fof(c4,negated_conjecture,(((r1(skolem0001,skolem0002)&p15(skolem0002))&(r1(skolem0002,skolem0003)&p1(skolem0003)))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0004)&(![X6]:(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(((((r1(X6,skolem0005(X6))&((r1(skolem0005(X6),skolem0006(X6))&((r1(skolem0006(X6),skolem0007(X6))&((r1(skolem0007(X6),skolem0008(X6))&((r1(skolem0008(X6),skolem0009(X6))&((r1(skolem0009(X6),skolem0010(X6))&((r1(skolem0010(X6),skolem0011(X6))&((r1(skolem0011(X6),skolem0012(X6))&((r1(skolem0012(X6),skolem0013(X6))&((r1(skolem0013(X6),skolem0014(X6))&((r1(skolem0014(X6),skolem0015(X6))&((r1(skolem0015(X6),skolem0016(X6))&r1(skolem0016(X6),skolem0017(X6)))&(![X20]:(~r1(skolem0016(X6),X20)|((~p14(X20)|p13(X20))&(p14(X20)|~p13(X20)))))))&(![X21]:(~r1(skolem0015(X6),X21)|((~p13(X21)|p12(X21))&(p13(X21)|~p12(X21)))))))&(![X22]:(~r1(skolem0014(X6),X22)|((~p12(X22)|p11(X22))&(p12(X22)|~p11(X22)))))))&(![X23]:(~r1(skolem0013(X6),X23)|((~p11(X23)|p10(X23))&(p11(X23)|~p10(X23)))))))&(![X24]:(~r1(skolem0012(X6),X24)|((~p10(X24)|p9(X24))&(p10(X24)|~p9(X24)))))))&(![X25]:(~r1(skolem0011(X6),X25)|((~p9(X25)|p8(X25))&(p9(X25)|~p8(X25)))))))&(![X26]:(~r1(skolem0010(X6),X26)|((~p8(X26)|p7(X26))&(p8(X26)|~p7(X26)))))))&(![X27]:(~r1(skolem0009(X6),X27)|((~p7(X27)|p6(X27))&(p7(X27)|~p6(X27)))))))&(![X28]:(~r1(skolem0008(X6),X28)|((~p6(X28)|p5(X28))&(p6(X28)|~p5(X28)))))))&(![X29]:(~r1(skolem0007(X6),X29)|((~p5(X29)|p4(X29))&(p5(X29)|~p4(X29)))))))&(![X30]:(~r1(skolem0006(X6),X30)|((~p4(X30)|p3(X30))&(p4(X30)|~p3(X30)))))))&(![X31]:(~r1(skolem0005(X6),X31)|((~p3(X31)|p2(X31))&(p3(X31)|~p2(X31))))))&(![X32]:(~r1(X6,X32)|((~p2(X32)|p1(X32))&(p2(X32)|~p1(X32))))))&(r1(X6,skolem0018(X6))&~p15(skolem0018(X6))))&((((((((((((((((((((((((((r1(X6,skolem0019(X6))&(p13(skolem0019(X6))|p14(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p14(skolem0019(X6))|~p13(skolem0019(X6))))&(p12(skolem0019(X6))|p13(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p13(skolem0019(X6))|~p12(skolem0019(X6))))&(p11(skolem0019(X6))|p12(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p12(skolem0019(X6))|~p11(skolem0019(X6))))&(p10(skolem0019(X6))|p11(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p11(skolem0019(X6))|~p10(skolem0019(X6))))&(p9(skolem0019(X6))|p10(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p10(skolem0019(X6))|~p9(skolem0019(X6))))&(p8(skolem0019(X6))|p9(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p9(skolem0019(X6))|~p8(skolem0019(X6))))&(p7(skolem0019(X6))|p8(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p8(skolem0019(X6))|~p7(skolem0019(X6))))&(p6(skolem0019(X6))|p7(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p7(skolem0019(X6))|~p6(skolem0019(X6))))&(p5(skolem0019(X6))|p6(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p6(skolem0019(X6))|~p5(skolem0019(X6))))&(p4(skolem0019(X6))|p5(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p5(skolem0019(X6))|~p4(skolem0019(X6))))&(p3(skolem0019(X6))|p4(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p4(skolem0019(X6))|~p3(skolem0019(X6))))&(p2(skolem0019(X6))|p3(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p3(skolem0019(X6))|~p2(skolem0019(X6))))&(p1(skolem0019(X6))|p2(skolem0019(X6))))&(~p2(skolem0019(X6))|~p1(skolem0019(X6))))))))),inference(skolemize,status(esa),[c3])).])).
% 1.62/1.89 fof(c6,negated_conjecture,(![X6]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X24]:(![X25]:(![X26]:(![X27]:(![X28]:(![X29]:(![X30]:(![X31]:(![X32]:(((r1(skolem0001,skolem0002)&p15(skolem0002))&(r1(skolem0002,skolem0003)&p1(skolem0003)))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0004)&((((((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(X6,skolem0005(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0005(X6),skolem0006(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0006(X6),skolem0007(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0007(X6),skolem0008(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0008(X6),skolem0009(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0009(X6),skolem0010(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0010(X6),skolem0011(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0011(X6),skolem0012(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0012(X6),skolem0013(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0013(X6),skolem0014(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0014(X6),skolem0015(X6)))&(((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0015(X6),skolem0016(X6)))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(skolem0016(X6),skolem0017(X6))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0016(X6),X20)|(~p14(X20)|p13(X20))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0016(X6),X20)|(p14(X20)|~p13(X20)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0015(X6),X21)|(~p13(X21)|p12(X21))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0015(X6),X21)|(p13(X21)|~p12(X21)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0014(X6),X22)|(~p12(X22)|p11(X22))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0014(X6),X22)|(p12(X22)|~p11(X22)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0013(X6),X23)|(~p11(X23)|p10(X23))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0013(X6),X23)|(p11(X23)|~p10(X23)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0012(X6),X24)|(~p10(X24)|p9(X24))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0012(X6),X24)|(p10(X24)|~p9(X24)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0011(X6),X25)|(~p9(X25)|p8(X25))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0011(X6),X25)|(p9(X25)|~p8(X25)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0010(X6),X26)|(~p8(X26)|p7(X26))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0010(X6),X26)|(p8(X26)|~p7(X26)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0009(X6),X27)|(~p7(X27)|p6(X27))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0009(X6),X27)|(p7(X27)|~p6(X27)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0008(X6),X28)|(~p6(X28)|p5(X28))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0008(X6),X28)|(p6(X28)|~p5(X28)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0007(X6),X29)|(~p5(X29)|p4(X29))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0007(X6),X29)|(p5(X29)|~p4(X29)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0006(X6),X30)|(~p4(X30)|p3(X30))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0006(X6),X30)|(p4(X30)|~p3(X30)))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0005(X6),X31)|(~p3(X31)|p2(X31))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(skolem0005(X6),X31)|(p3(X31)|~p2(X31))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(X6,X32)|(~p2(X32)|p1(X32))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~r1(X6,X32)|(p2(X32)|~p1(X32))))))&((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(X6,skolem0018(X6)))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|~p15(skolem0018(X6)))))&(((((((((((((((((((((((((((~r1(skolem0004,X6)|r1(X6,skolem0019(X6)))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p13(skolem0019(X6))|p14(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p14(skolem0019(X6))|~p13(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p12(skolem0019(X6))|p13(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p13(skolem0019(X6))|~p12(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p11(skolem0019(X6))|p12(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p12(skolem0019(X6))|~p11(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p10(skolem0019(X6))|p11(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p11(skolem0019(X6))|~p10(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p9(skolem0019(X6))|p10(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p10(skolem0019(X6))|~p9(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p8(skolem0019(X6))|p9(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p9(skolem0019(X6))|~p8(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p7(skolem0019(X6))|p8(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p8(skolem0019(X6))|~p7(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p6(skolem0019(X6))|p7(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p7(skolem0019(X6))|~p6(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p5(skolem0019(X6))|p6(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p6(skolem0019(X6))|~p5(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p4(skolem0019(X6))|p5(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p5(skolem0019(X6))|~p4(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p3(skolem0019(X6))|p4(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p4(skolem0019(X6))|~p3(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p2(skolem0019(X6))|p3(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p3(skolem0019(X6))|~p2(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(p1(skolem0019(X6))|p2(skolem0019(X6)))))&(~r1(skolem0004,X6)|(~p2(skolem0019(X6))|~p1(skolem0019(X6)))))))))))))))))))))),inference(distribute,status(thm),[c5])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c53,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0004,X44)|r1(X44,skolem0019(X44)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c96,plain,r1(skolem0004,skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c53, c84])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c50,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0004,X142)|~r1(X142,X143)|p2(X143)|~p1(X143),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c768,plain,~r1(skolem0004,X144)|p2(X144)|~p1(X144),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c50, c84])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c840,plain,p2(skolem0019(skolem0004))|~p1(skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c768, c96])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c78,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0004,X180)|p1(skolem0019(X180))|p2(skolem0019(X180)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c1455,plain,p1(skolem0019(skolem0004))|p2(skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c78, c84])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c1635,plain,p2(skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1455, c840])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c79,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0004,X181)|~p2(skolem0019(X181))|~p1(skolem0019(X181)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c49,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0004,X139)|~r1(X139,X140)|~p2(X140)|p1(X140),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c643,plain,~r1(skolem0004,X141)|~p2(X141)|p1(X141),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c49, c84])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c713,plain,~p2(skolem0019(skolem0004))|p1(skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c643, c96])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c1637,plain,p1(skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1455, c713])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c1644,plain,~r1(skolem0004,skolem0004)|~p2(skolem0019(skolem0004)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1637, c79])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c1760,plain,~r1(skolem0004,skolem0004),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1644, c1635])).
% 1.62/1.89 cnf(c1761,plain,$false,inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1760, c84])).
% 1.62/1.89 # SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 1.62/1.89
% 1.62/1.89 # Initial clauses : 75
% 1.62/1.89 # Processed clauses : 359
% 1.62/1.89 # Factors computed : 0
% 1.62/1.89 # Resolvents computed: 1680
% 1.62/1.89 # Tautologies deleted: 1
% 1.62/1.89 # Forward subsumed : 60
% 1.62/1.89 # Backward subsumed : 7
% 1.62/1.89 # -------- CPU Time ---------
% 1.62/1.89 # User time : 1.503 s
% 1.62/1.89 # System time : 0.015 s
% 1.62/1.89 # Total time : 1.518 s
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------