TSTP Solution File: LCL668+1.001 by PyRes---1.3
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : PyRes---1.3
% Problem : LCL668+1.001 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% Computer : n021.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Sun Jul 17 13:56:23 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 78.29s 78.62s
% Output : Refutation 78.29s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.07/0.09 % Problem : LCL668+1.001 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% 0.07/0.09 % Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% 0.08/0.29 % Computer : n021.cluster.edu
% 0.08/0.29 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.08/0.29 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.08/0.29 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.08/0.29 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.08/0.29 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.08/0.29 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.08/0.29 % DateTime : Sun Jul 3 07:26:15 EDT 2022
% 0.08/0.29 % CPUTime :
% 78.29/78.62 # Version: 1.3
% 78.29/78.62 # SZS status Theorem
% 78.29/78.62 # SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 78.29/78.62 fof(reflexivity,axiom,(![X]:r1(X,X)),input).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(c41,axiom,(![X50]:r1(X50,X50)),inference(variable_rename,status(thm),[reflexivity])).
% 78.29/78.62 cnf(c42,axiom,r1(X51,X51),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c41])).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(main,conjecture,(~(?[X]:(~((((![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|((((((~p12(X))&(~p10(X)))&(~p8(X)))&(~p6(X)))&(~p4(X)))&(~p2(X)))))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p7(Y))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(((~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p5(X))&(~p1(X)))|(p1(X)&p5(X)))))))))))))))))))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|p6(X))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p4(X))&(~p5(X)))|(p5(X)&p4(X)))))))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p5(Y))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(((~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p3(X))&(~p4(X)))|(p4(X)&p3(X)))))))))))))))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|p4(X))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p2(X))&(~p3(X)))|(p3(X)&p2(X)))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p3(Y))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p1(X))&(~p2(X)))|(p2(X)&p1(X))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(((((p6(X)&p5(X))&p4(X))&p3(X))&p2(X))&p1(X)))))))))))))))))),input).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(c0,negated_conjecture,(~(~(?[X]:(~((((![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|((((((~p12(X))&(~p10(X)))&(~p8(X)))&(~p6(X)))&(~p4(X)))&(~p2(X)))))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p7(Y))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(((~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p5(X))&(~p1(X)))|(p1(X)&p5(X)))))))))))))))))))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|p6(X))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p4(X))&(~p5(X)))|(p5(X)&p4(X)))))))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p5(Y))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(((~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p3(X))&(~p4(X)))|(p4(X)&p3(X)))))))))))))))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|p4(X))))|(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p2(X))&(~p3(X)))|(p3(X)&p2(X)))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|p3(Y))))|(~(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(~(~(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(~(((~p1(X))&(~p2(X)))|(p2(X)&p1(X))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(![Y]:((~r1(X,Y))|(![X]:((~r1(Y,X))|(((((p6(X)&p5(X))&p4(X))&p3(X))&p2(X))&p1(X))))))))))))))))))),inference(assume_negation,status(cth),[main])).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(c1,negated_conjecture,(~(~(?[X]:(~((((![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(((((~p12(X)&~p10(X))&~p8(X))&~p6(X))&~p4(X))&~p2(X))))))))))))))|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|p7(Y))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~(((~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((~p5(X)&~p1(X))|(p1(X)&p5(X)))))))))))))))))))|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|p6(X))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~(((~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((~p4(X)&~p5(X))|(p5(X)&p4(X)))))))))))))))))|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|p5(Y))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~(((~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((~p3(X)&~p4(X))|(p4(X)&p3(X)))))))))))))))|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|p4(X))))|(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~(((~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((~p2(X)&~p3(X))|(p3(X)&p2(X)))))))))))))|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|p3(Y))))|(~(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(~(~(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(~((~p1(X)&~p2(X))|(p2(X)&p1(X))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(((((p6(X)&p5(X))&p4(X))&p3(X))&p2(X))&p1(X))))))))))))))))))),inference(fof_simplification,status(thm),[c0])).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(c2,negated_conjecture,(?[X]:((((?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&(((((p12(X)|p10(X))|p8(X))|p6(X))|p4(X))|p2(X))))))))))))))&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&~p7(Y))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(((![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((p5(X)|p1(X))&(~p1(X)|~p5(X)))))))))))))))))&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&~p6(X))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(((![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((p4(X)|p5(X))&(~p5(X)|~p4(X)))))))))))))))&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&~p5(Y))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(((![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((p3(X)|p4(X))&(~p4(X)|~p3(X)))))))))))))&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&~p4(X))))&(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(((![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((p2(X)|p3(X))&(~p3(X)|~p2(X)))))))))))&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&~p3(Y))))&(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|(![Y]:(~r1(X,Y)|(![X]:(~r1(Y,X)|((p1(X)|p2(X))&(~p2(X)|~p1(X))))))))))))))))))))))))&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&(?[Y]:(r1(X,Y)&(?[X]:(r1(Y,X)&(((((~p6(X)|~p5(X))|~p4(X))|~p3(X))|~p2(X))|~p1(X)))))))))))))))),inference(fof_nnf,status(thm),[c1])).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(c3,negated_conjecture,(?[X2]:((((?[X3]:(r1(X2,X3)&(?[X4]:(r1(X3,X4)&(?[X5]:(r1(X4,X5)&(?[X6]:(r1(X5,X6)&(?[X7]:(r1(X6,X7)&(?[X8]:(r1(X7,X8)&(((((p12(X8)|p10(X8))|p8(X8))|p6(X8))|p4(X8))|p2(X8))))))))))))))&(?[X9]:(r1(X2,X9)&~p7(X9))))&(![X10]:(~r1(X2,X10)|(((![X11]:(~r1(X10,X11)|(![X12]:(~r1(X11,X12)|(![X13]:(~r1(X12,X13)|(![X14]:(~r1(X13,X14)|(![X15]:(~r1(X14,X15)|(![X16]:(~r1(X15,X16)|(![X17]:(~r1(X16,X17)|((p5(X17)|p1(X17))&(~p1(X17)|~p5(X17)))))))))))))))))&(?[X18]:(r1(X10,X18)&~p6(X18))))&(![X19]:(~r1(X10,X19)|(((![X20]:(~r1(X19,X20)|(![X21]:(~r1(X20,X21)|(![X22]:(~r1(X21,X22)|(![X23]:(~r1(X22,X23)|(![X24]:(~r1(X23,X24)|(![X25]:(~r1(X24,X25)|((p4(X25)|p5(X25))&(~p5(X25)|~p4(X25)))))))))))))))&(?[X26]:(r1(X19,X26)&~p5(X26))))&(![X27]:(~r1(X19,X27)|(((![X28]:(~r1(X27,X28)|(![X29]:(~r1(X28,X29)|(![X30]:(~r1(X29,X30)|(![X31]:(~r1(X30,X31)|(![X32]:(~r1(X31,X32)|((p3(X32)|p4(X32))&(~p4(X32)|~p3(X32)))))))))))))&(?[X33]:(r1(X27,X33)&~p4(X33))))&(![X34]:(~r1(X27,X34)|(((![X35]:(~r1(X34,X35)|(![X36]:(~r1(X35,X36)|(![X37]:(~r1(X36,X37)|(![X38]:(~r1(X37,X38)|((p2(X38)|p3(X38))&(~p3(X38)|~p2(X38)))))))))))&(?[X39]:(r1(X34,X39)&~p3(X39))))&(![X40]:(~r1(X34,X40)|(![X41]:(~r1(X40,X41)|(![X42]:(~r1(X41,X42)|(![X43]:(~r1(X42,X43)|((p1(X43)|p2(X43))&(~p2(X43)|~p1(X43))))))))))))))))))))))))&(?[X44]:(r1(X2,X44)&(?[X45]:(r1(X44,X45)&(?[X46]:(r1(X45,X46)&(?[X47]:(r1(X46,X47)&(?[X48]:(r1(X47,X48)&(?[X49]:(r1(X48,X49)&(((((~p6(X49)|~p5(X49))|~p4(X49))|~p3(X49))|~p2(X49))|~p1(X49)))))))))))))))),inference(variable_rename,status(thm),[c2])).
% 78.29/78.62 fof(c5,negated_conjecture,(![X10]:(![X11]:(![X12]:(![X13]:(![X14]:(![X15]:(![X16]:(![X17]:(![X19]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X24]:(![X25]:(![X27]:(![X28]:(![X29]:(![X30]:(![X31]:(![X32]:(![X34]:(![X35]:(![X36]:(![X37]:(![X38]:(![X40]:(![X41]:(![X42]:(![X43]:((((r1(skolem0001,skolem0002)&(r1(skolem0002,skolem0003)&(r1(skolem0003,skolem0004)&(r1(skolem0004,skolem0005)&(r1(skolem0005,skolem0006)&(r1(skolem0006,skolem0007)&(((((p12(skolem0007)|p10(skolem0007))|p8(skolem0007))|p6(skolem0007))|p4(skolem0007))|p2(skolem0007))))))))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0008)&~p7(skolem0008)))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(((~r1(X10,X11)|(~r1(X11,X12)|(~r1(X12,X13)|(~r1(X13,X14)|(~r1(X14,X15)|(~r1(X15,X16)|(~r1(X16,X17)|((p5(X17)|p1(X17))&(~p1(X17)|~p5(X17))))))))))&(r1(X10,skolem0009(X10))&~p6(skolem0009(X10))))&(~r1(X10,X19)|(((~r1(X19,X20)|(~r1(X20,X21)|(~r1(X21,X22)|(~r1(X22,X23)|(~r1(X23,X24)|(~r1(X24,X25)|((p4(X25)|p5(X25))&(~p5(X25)|~p4(X25)))))))))&(r1(X19,skolem0010(X10,X19))&~p5(skolem0010(X10,X19))))&(~r1(X19,X27)|(((~r1(X27,X28)|(~r1(X28,X29)|(~r1(X29,X30)|(~r1(X30,X31)|(~r1(X31,X32)|((p3(X32)|p4(X32))&(~p4(X32)|~p3(X32))))))))&(r1(X27,skolem0011(X10,X19,X27))&~p4(skolem0011(X10,X19,X27))))&(~r1(X27,X34)|(((~r1(X34,X35)|(~r1(X35,X36)|(~r1(X36,X37)|(~r1(X37,X38)|((p2(X38)|p3(X38))&(~p3(X38)|~p2(X38)))))))&(r1(X34,skolem0012(X10,X19,X27,X34))&~p3(skolem0012(X10,X19,X27,X34))))&(~r1(X34,X40)|(~r1(X40,X41)|(~r1(X41,X42)|(~r1(X42,X43)|((p1(X43)|p2(X43))&(~p2(X43)|~p1(X43))))))))))))))))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0013)&(r1(skolem0013,skolem0014)&(r1(skolem0014,skolem0015)&(r1(skolem0015,skolem0016)&(r1(skolem0016,skolem0017)&(r1(skolem0017,skolem0018)&(((((~p6(skolem0018)|~p5(skolem0018))|~p4(skolem0018))|~p3(skolem0018))|~p2(skolem0018))|~p1(skolem0018))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),inference(shift_quantors,status(thm),[fof(c4,negated_conjecture,((((r1(skolem0001,skolem0002)&(r1(skolem0002,skolem0003)&(r1(skolem0003,skolem0004)&(r1(skolem0004,skolem0005)&(r1(skolem0005,skolem0006)&(r1(skolem0006,skolem0007)&(((((p12(skolem0007)|p10(skolem0007))|p8(skolem0007))|p6(skolem0007))|p4(skolem0007))|p2(skolem0007))))))))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0008)&~p7(skolem0008)))&(![X10]:(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(((![X11]:(~r1(X10,X11)|(![X12]:(~r1(X11,X12)|(![X13]:(~r1(X12,X13)|(![X14]:(~r1(X13,X14)|(![X15]:(~r1(X14,X15)|(![X16]:(~r1(X15,X16)|(![X17]:(~r1(X16,X17)|((p5(X17)|p1(X17))&(~p1(X17)|~p5(X17)))))))))))))))))&(r1(X10,skolem0009(X10))&~p6(skolem0009(X10))))&(![X19]:(~r1(X10,X19)|(((![X20]:(~r1(X19,X20)|(![X21]:(~r1(X20,X21)|(![X22]:(~r1(X21,X22)|(![X23]:(~r1(X22,X23)|(![X24]:(~r1(X23,X24)|(![X25]:(~r1(X24,X25)|((p4(X25)|p5(X25))&(~p5(X25)|~p4(X25)))))))))))))))&(r1(X19,skolem0010(X10,X19))&~p5(skolem0010(X10,X19))))&(![X27]:(~r1(X19,X27)|(((![X28]:(~r1(X27,X28)|(![X29]:(~r1(X28,X29)|(![X30]:(~r1(X29,X30)|(![X31]:(~r1(X30,X31)|(![X32]:(~r1(X31,X32)|((p3(X32)|p4(X32))&(~p4(X32)|~p3(X32)))))))))))))&(r1(X27,skolem0011(X10,X19,X27))&~p4(skolem0011(X10,X19,X27))))&(![X34]:(~r1(X27,X34)|(((![X35]:(~r1(X34,X35)|(![X36]:(~r1(X35,X36)|(![X37]:(~r1(X36,X37)|(![X38]:(~r1(X37,X38)|((p2(X38)|p3(X38))&(~p3(X38)|~p2(X38)))))))))))&(r1(X34,skolem0012(X10,X19,X27,X34))&~p3(skolem0012(X10,X19,X27,X34))))&(![X40]:(~r1(X34,X40)|(![X41]:(~r1(X40,X41)|(![X42]:(~r1(X41,X42)|(![X43]:(~r1(X42,X43)|((p1(X43)|p2(X43))&(~p2(X43)|~p1(X43))))))))))))))))))))))))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0013)&(r1(skolem0013,skolem0014)&(r1(skolem0014,skolem0015)&(r1(skolem0015,skolem0016)&(r1(skolem0016,skolem0017)&(r1(skolem0017,skolem0018)&(((((~p6(skolem0018)|~p5(skolem0018))|~p4(skolem0018))|~p3(skolem0018))|~p2(skolem0018))|~p1(skolem0018))))))))),inference(skolemize,status(esa),[c3])).])).
% 78.29/78.63 fof(c6,negated_conjecture,(![X10]:(![X11]:(![X12]:(![X13]:(![X14]:(![X15]:(![X16]:(![X17]:(![X19]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X24]:(![X25]:(![X27]:(![X28]:(![X29]:(![X30]:(![X31]:(![X32]:(![X34]:(![X35]:(![X36]:(![X37]:(![X38]:(![X40]:(![X41]:(![X42]:(![X43]:((((r1(skolem0001,skolem0002)&(r1(skolem0002,skolem0003)&(r1(skolem0003,skolem0004)&(r1(skolem0004,skolem0005)&(r1(skolem0005,skolem0006)&(r1(skolem0006,skolem0007)&(((((p12(skolem0007)|p10(skolem0007))|p8(skolem0007))|p6(skolem0007))|p4(skolem0007))|p2(skolem0007))))))))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0008)&~p7(skolem0008)))&((((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X11)|(~r1(X11,X12)|(~r1(X12,X13)|(~r1(X13,X14)|(~r1(X14,X15)|(~r1(X15,X16)|(~r1(X16,X17)|(p5(X17)|p1(X17))))))))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X11)|(~r1(X11,X12)|(~r1(X12,X13)|(~r1(X13,X14)|(~r1(X14,X15)|(~r1(X15,X16)|(~r1(X16,X17)|(~p1(X17)|~p5(X17)))))))))))&((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|r1(X10,skolem0009(X10)))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|~p6(skolem0009(X10)))))&((((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X20)|(~r1(X20,X21)|(~r1(X21,X22)|(~r1(X22,X23)|(~r1(X23,X24)|(~r1(X24,X25)|(p4(X25)|p5(X25))))))))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X20)|(~r1(X20,X21)|(~r1(X21,X22)|(~r1(X22,X23)|(~r1(X23,X24)|(~r1(X24,X25)|(~p5(X25)|~p4(X25)))))))))))&((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|r1(X19,skolem0010(X10,X19))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|~p5(skolem0010(X10,X19))))))&((((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X28)|(~r1(X28,X29)|(~r1(X29,X30)|(~r1(X30,X31)|(~r1(X31,X32)|(p3(X32)|p4(X32))))))))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X28)|(~r1(X28,X29)|(~r1(X29,X30)|(~r1(X30,X31)|(~r1(X31,X32)|(~p4(X32)|~p3(X32)))))))))))&((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|r1(X27,skolem0011(X10,X19,X27)))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|~p4(skolem0011(X10,X19,X27)))))))&((((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X34)|(~r1(X34,X35)|(~r1(X35,X36)|(~r1(X36,X37)|(~r1(X37,X38)|(p2(X38)|p3(X38))))))))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X34)|(~r1(X34,X35)|(~r1(X35,X36)|(~r1(X36,X37)|(~r1(X37,X38)|(~p3(X38)|~p2(X38)))))))))))&((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X34)|r1(X34,skolem0012(X10,X19,X27,X34))))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X34)|~p3(skolem0012(X10,X19,X27,X34))))))))&((~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X34)|(~r1(X34,X40)|(~r1(X40,X41)|(~r1(X41,X42)|(~r1(X42,X43)|(p1(X43)|p2(X43))))))))))&(~r1(skolem0001,X10)|(~r1(X10,X19)|(~r1(X19,X27)|(~r1(X27,X34)|(~r1(X34,X40)|(~r1(X40,X41)|(~r1(X41,X42)|(~r1(X42,X43)|(~p2(X43)|~p1(X43))))))))))))))))&(r1(skolem0001,skolem0013)&(r1(skolem0013,skolem0014)&(r1(skolem0014,skolem0015)&(r1(skolem0015,skolem0016)&(r1(skolem0016,skolem0017)&(r1(skolem0017,skolem0018)&(((((~p6(skolem0018)|~p5(skolem0018))|~p4(skolem0018))|~p3(skolem0018))|~p2(skolem0018))|~p1(skolem0018))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),inference(distribute,status(thm),[c5])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c27,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X114)|~r1(X114,X115)|~r1(X115,X113)|~p4(skolem0011(X114,X115,X113)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c26,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X108)|~r1(X108,X109)|~r1(X109,X107)|r1(X107,skolem0011(X108,X109,X107)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c261,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X110)|~r1(X110,X111)|r1(X111,skolem0011(X110,X111,X111)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c26, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c315,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X112)|r1(X112,skolem0011(X112,X112,X112)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c261, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c333,plain,r1(skolem0001,skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c315, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c24,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X93)|~r1(X93,X98)|~r1(X98,X95)|~r1(X95,X92)|~r1(X92,X97)|~r1(X97,X96)|~r1(X96,X91)|~r1(X91,X94)|p3(X94)|p4(X94),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c188,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1012)|~r1(X1012,X1010)|~r1(X1010,X1006)|~r1(X1006,X1009)|~r1(X1009,X1011)|~r1(X1011,X1007)|~r1(X1007,X1008)|p3(X1008)|p4(X1008),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c24, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c4898,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3880)|~r1(X3880,X3876)|~r1(X3876,X3877)|~r1(X3877,X3875)|~r1(X3875,X3879)|~r1(X3879,X3878)|p3(X3878)|p4(X3878),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c188, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c10798,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3885)|~r1(X3885,X3881)|~r1(X3881,X3882)|~r1(X3882,X3884)|~r1(X3884,X3883)|p3(X3883)|p4(X3883),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4898, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c10992,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3893)|~r1(X3893,X3895)|~r1(X3895,X3892)|~r1(X3892,X3894)|p3(X3894)|p4(X3894),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c10798, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c11188,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3896)|~r1(X3896,X3897)|~r1(X3897,X3898)|p3(X3898)|p4(X3898),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c10992, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c11382,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3900)|~r1(X3900,X3899)|p3(X3899)|p4(X3899),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c11188, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c11576,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3901)|p3(X3901)|p4(X3901),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c11382, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c11610,plain,p3(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|p4(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c11576, c333])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c11741,plain,p3(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|~r1(skolem0001,skolem0001),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c11610, c27])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c11743,plain,p3(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c11741, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c29,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X124)|~r1(X124,X130)|~r1(X130,X126)|~r1(X126,X129)|~r1(X129,X131)|~r1(X131,X125)|~r1(X125,X127)|~r1(X127,X128)|~p3(X128)|~p2(X128),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c439,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2627)|~r1(X2627,X2622)|~r1(X2622,X2623)|~r1(X2623,X2626)|~r1(X2626,X2624)|~r1(X2624,X2625)|~r1(X2625,X2628)|~p3(X2628)|~p2(X2628),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c29, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c8385,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X6534)|~r1(X6534,X6533)|~r1(X6533,X6532)|~r1(X6532,X6530)|~r1(X6530,X6531)|~r1(X6531,X6535)|~p3(X6535)|~p2(X6535),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c439, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c16593,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X6536)|~r1(X6536,X6540)|~r1(X6540,X6537)|~r1(X6537,X6539)|~r1(X6539,X6538)|~p3(X6538)|~p2(X6538),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c8385, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c16805,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X6544)|~r1(X6544,X6541)|~r1(X6541,X6542)|~r1(X6542,X6543)|~p3(X6543)|~p2(X6543),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c16593, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c17017,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X6546)|~r1(X6546,X6545)|~r1(X6545,X6547)|~p3(X6547)|~p2(X6547),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c16805, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c17229,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X6548)|~r1(X6548,X6549)|~p3(X6549)|~p2(X6549),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c17017, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c17441,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X6550)|~p3(X6550)|~p2(X6550),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c17229, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c17476,plain,~p3(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|~p2(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c17441, c333])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c17,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X63)|~r1(X63,X62)|~r1(X62,X67)|~r1(X67,X68)|~r1(X68,X64)|~r1(X64,X69)|~r1(X69,X65)|~r1(X65,X66)|~p1(X66)|~p5(X66),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c68,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X312)|~r1(X312,X313)|~r1(X313,X309)|~r1(X309,X308)|~r1(X308,X311)|~r1(X311,X307)|~r1(X307,X310)|~p1(X310)|~p5(X310),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c17, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c1428,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1484)|~r1(X1484,X1481)|~r1(X1481,X1480)|~r1(X1480,X1483)|~r1(X1483,X1485)|~r1(X1485,X1482)|~p1(X1482)|~p5(X1482),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c68, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c5375,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1487)|~r1(X1487,X1486)|~r1(X1486,X1490)|~r1(X1490,X1489)|~r1(X1489,X1488)|~p1(X1488)|~p5(X1488),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1428, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c5541,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1493)|~r1(X1493,X1491)|~r1(X1491,X1492)|~r1(X1492,X1494)|~p1(X1494)|~p5(X1494),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c5375, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c5707,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1501)|~r1(X1501,X1503)|~r1(X1503,X1502)|~p1(X1502)|~p5(X1502),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c5541, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c5875,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1505)|~r1(X1505,X1504)|~p1(X1504)|~p5(X1504),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c5707, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c6041,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X1506)|~p1(X1506)|~p5(X1506),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c5875, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c6074,plain,~p1(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|~p5(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c6041, c333])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c20,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X75)|~r1(X75,X82)|~r1(X82,X77)|~r1(X77,X81)|~r1(X81,X79)|~r1(X79,X80)|~r1(X80,X78)|~r1(X78,X76)|p4(X76)|p5(X76),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c115,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X485)|~r1(X485,X481)|~r1(X481,X484)|~r1(X484,X483)|~r1(X483,X482)|~r1(X482,X479)|~r1(X479,X480)|p4(X480)|p5(X480),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c20, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c2294,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2166)|~r1(X2166,X2163)|~r1(X2163,X2167)|~r1(X2167,X2165)|~r1(X2165,X2162)|~r1(X2162,X2164)|p4(X2164)|p5(X2164),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c115, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c6992,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2174)|~r1(X2174,X2178)|~r1(X2178,X2176)|~r1(X2176,X2177)|~r1(X2177,X2175)|p4(X2175)|p5(X2175),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c2294, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c7176,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2180)|~r1(X2180,X2179)|~r1(X2179,X2181)|~r1(X2181,X2182)|p4(X2182)|p5(X2182),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c6992, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c7358,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2183)|~r1(X2183,X2184)|~r1(X2184,X2185)|p4(X2185)|p5(X2185),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c7176, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c7540,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2186)|~r1(X2186,X2187)|p4(X2187)|p5(X2187),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c7358, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c7722,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X2188)|p4(X2188)|p5(X2188),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c7540, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c7755,plain,p4(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|p5(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c7722, c333])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c8040,plain,p5(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|~r1(skolem0001,skolem0001),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c7755, c27])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c8042,plain,p5(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c8040, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c8043,plain,~p1(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c8042, c6074])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c32,negated_conjecture,~r1(skolem0001,X141)|~r1(X141,X147)|~r1(X147,X143)|~r1(X143,X144)|~r1(X144,X140)|~r1(X140,X145)|~r1(X145,X146)|~r1(X146,X142)|p1(X142)|p2(X142),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c6])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c579,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X3496)|~r1(X3496,X3497)|~r1(X3497,X3499)|~r1(X3499,X3498)|~r1(X3498,X3500)|~r1(X3500,X3502)|~r1(X3502,X3501)|p1(X3501)|p2(X3501),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c32, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c10502,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X7363)|~r1(X7363,X7367)|~r1(X7367,X7366)|~r1(X7366,X7364)|~r1(X7364,X7362)|~r1(X7362,X7365)|p1(X7365)|p2(X7365),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c579, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c20551,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X7370)|~r1(X7370,X7372)|~r1(X7372,X7369)|~r1(X7369,X7368)|~r1(X7368,X7371)|p1(X7371)|p2(X7371),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c10502, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c20800,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X7374)|~r1(X7374,X7375)|~r1(X7375,X7373)|~r1(X7373,X7376)|p1(X7376)|p2(X7376),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c20551, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21049,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X7383)|~r1(X7383,X7385)|~r1(X7385,X7384)|p1(X7384)|p2(X7384),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c20800, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21300,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X7386)|~r1(X7386,X7387)|p1(X7387)|p2(X7387),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c21049, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21549,plain,~r1(skolem0001,X7388)|p1(X7388)|p2(X7388),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c21300, c42])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21587,plain,p1(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001))|p2(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c21549, c333])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21813,plain,p2(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c21587, c8043])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21815,plain,~p3(skolem0011(skolem0001,skolem0001,skolem0001)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c21813, c17476])).
% 78.29/78.63 cnf(c21816,plain,$false,inference(resolution,status(thm),[c21815, c11743])).
% 78.29/78.63 # SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 78.29/78.63
% 78.29/78.63 # Initial clauses : 35
% 78.29/78.63 # Processed clauses : 3917
% 78.29/78.63 # Factors computed : 0
% 78.29/78.63 # Resolvents computed: 21774
% 78.29/78.63 # Tautologies deleted: 178
% 78.29/78.63 # Forward subsumed : 1637
% 78.29/78.63 # Backward subsumed : 2075
% 78.29/78.63 # -------- CPU Time ---------
% 78.29/78.63 # User time : 78.109 s
% 78.29/78.63 # System time : 0.093 s
% 78.29/78.63 # Total time : 78.202 s
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------