TSTP Solution File: LAT085-1 by Fiesta---2
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Fiesta---2
% Problem : LAT085-1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.6.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : dedam
% Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% Computer : n009.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Sun Jul 17 04:55:46 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 5.34s 5.72s
% Output : CNFRefutation 5.34s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.10/0.12 % Problem : LAT085-1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.6.0.
% 0.10/0.13 % Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% 0.12/0.34 % Computer : n009.cluster.edu
% 0.12/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.12/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.12/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.12/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.12/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.12/0.34 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.12/0.34 % DateTime : Tue Jun 28 21:48:07 EDT 2022
% 0.12/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 5.34/5.72 Theorem Proved.
% 5.34/5.72 % SZS status Unsatisfiable
% 5.34/5.72 % SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 5.34/5.72 [1=axiom,[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12),meet(join(meet(X10,join(join(meet(X13,X11),meet(X11,X14)),X11)),meet(join(meet(X11,meet(meet(join(X13,join(X11,X14)),join(X15,X11)),X11)),meet(X16,join(X11,meet(meet(join(X13,join(X11,X14)),join(X15,X11)),X11)))),join(X10,join(join(meet(X13,X11),meet(X11,X14)),X11)))),join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12))) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [2=axiom,[],
% 5.34/5.72 thtop(X10,X10) = thmfalse].
% 5.34/5.72 [3=axiom,[],
% 5.34/5.72 thtop(join(join(a,b),c),join(a,join(b,c))) = thmtrue].
% 5.34/5.72 [4=param(1,1),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))),meet(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),join(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))))),X13),meet(join(meet(X10,join(join(meet(X14,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))),meet(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),X15)),join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))))),meet(X12,join(X10,join(join(meet(X14,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))),meet(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),X15)),join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))))))),join(join(meet(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))),meet(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),join(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))))),X13))) = join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))].
% 5.34/5.72 [6=param(1,1),[1],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(join(meet(join(meet(X12,X10),meet(X10,join(X12,X10))),join(join(meet(X13,join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10))))),meet(join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))),X18)),join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))))),meet(join(meet(join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))),meet(meet(join(X13,join(join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))),X18)),join(X19,join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))))),join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))))),meet(X110,join(join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))),meet(meet(join(X13,join(join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))),X18)),join(X19,join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))))),join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))))))),join(join(meet(X12,X10),meet(X10,join(X12,X10))),join(join(meet(X13,join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10))))),meet(join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))),X18)),join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)))))))),join(X10,X11))) = join(meet(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)),meet(X17,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X14,join(X10,X15)),join(X16,X10)),X10)))),join(X12,join(join(meet(X14,X10),meet(X10,X15)),X10))))].
% 5.34/5.72 [8=param(1,6),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12),meet(join(meet(X10,join(join(meet(X13,X11),meet(X11,X14)),X11)),meet(join(meet(X15,join(join(meet(X16,X11),meet(X11,X17)),X11)),meet(join(meet(X11,meet(meet(join(X16,join(X11,X17)),join(X18,X11)),X11)),meet(X19,join(X11,meet(meet(join(X16,join(X11,X17)),join(X18,X11)),X11)))),join(X15,join(join(meet(X16,X11),meet(X11,X17)),X11)))),join(X10,join(join(meet(X13,X11),meet(X11,X14)),X11)))),join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12))) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [9=param(8,1),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X11),meet(X11,join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X11))),X12),meet(X11,join(join(meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X11),meet(X11,join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X11))),X12))) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [17=param(4,9),[9],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12),meet(join(meet(join(meet(join(meet(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),join(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))))),join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),join(join(meet(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),join(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))))),join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))))),join(join(meet(X14,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X15)),join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))))),meet(X11,join(join(meet(join(meet(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),join(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))))),join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),join(join(meet(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),join(X13,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))))),join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))))),join(join(meet(X14,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))),meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X15)),join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))))))),join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12))) = join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11)))].
% 5.34/5.72 [19=param(4,9),[9],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))),meet(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),join(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))))),X13),meet(join(meet(X10,join(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))))),meet(X12,join(X10,join(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))))))),join(join(meet(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))),meet(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12))),join(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))))),X13))) = join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X12)))].
% 5.34/5.72 [23=param(9,9),[9],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X10,join(X10,X11))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [41=param(6,23),[1,23],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X11,join(join(meet(X12,X10),meet(X10,X13)),X10)),meet(join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X12,join(X10,X13)),join(X14,X10)),X10)),meet(X15,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X12,join(X10,X13)),join(X14,X10)),X10)))),join(X11,join(join(meet(X12,X10),meet(X10,X13)),X10)))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [43=demod(1),[41],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12),meet(X11,join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X11))),X12))) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [44=demod(17),[43,43,43,43],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X11,X10),meet(X10,join(X11,X10))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [51=demod(19),[44,44,44,44,44,44,44,44,44,44,44,44,44],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(join(meet(X12,join(X10,X10)),meet(X10,join(X12,join(X10,X10)))),join(X10,X11))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [60=param(44,23),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(X10,join(X10,X11))),meet(meet(X10,join(X10,X11)),X10)) = meet(X10,join(X10,X11))].
% 5.34/5.72 [63=param(41,23),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,meet(meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10)),X10)),meet(X14,join(X10,meet(meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10)),X10)))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [64=demod(41),[63],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,join(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,X13)),X12)),meet(X12,join(X10,join(join(meet(X11,X12),meet(X12,X13)),X12)))) = X12].
% 5.34/5.72 [86=param(51,44),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X11,join(X10,X10)),meet(X10,join(X11,join(X10,X10)))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [118=param(63,44),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10)),X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [120=demod(63),[118,118],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X10),meet(X11,join(X10,X10))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [125=param(120,64),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,X12)),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [129=param(120,86),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [132=demod(120),[129],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X10),meet(X11,X10)) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [136=param(132,129),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [138=demod(132),[136],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(X11,X10)) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [193=param(23,125),[129],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,X12)),X11) = join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,X12))].
% 5.34/5.72 [194=param(125,136),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,meet(X10,X11)),X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [196=param(125,138),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [198=param(23,196),[129],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),X11) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [221=param(23,194),[129],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,meet(X10,X11)),X10) = join(X10,meet(X10,X11))].
% 5.34/5.72 [225=param(138,221),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(X10,meet(X10,X11))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [230=param(118,23),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(join(X10,X11),join(X12,meet(X11,X13))),meet(X11,X13)) = meet(X11,X13)].
% 5.34/5.72 [232=param(23,118),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10)),join(meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10)),X10))) = meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [241=param(118,125),[198],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,join(X11,X12)),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [243=param(118,129),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(join(X10,X11),join(X12,X11)),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [249=param(118,225),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,join(X11,X10)),X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [261=param(23,249),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(meet(X10,join(X11,X10)),join(meet(X10,join(X11,X10)),X10))) = meet(X10,join(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [282=param(241,23),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),meet(X11,X12)) = meet(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [284=param(241,44),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),meet(X12,X11)) = meet(X12,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [288=param(241,125),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [289=demod(221),[288],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(X10,X11)) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [291=param(125,241),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(meet(X10,join(X11,join(X12,X13))),X12),join(X11,join(X12,X13))) = join(X11,join(X12,X13))].
% 5.34/5.72 [292=param(241,129),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [300=param(60,292),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,meet(join(X11,X10),join(join(X11,X10),X10))),meet(meet(join(X11,X10),join(join(X11,X10),X10)),join(X11,X10))) = meet(join(X11,X10),join(join(X11,X10),X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [302=param(125,292),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(meet(X10,join(X11,X12)),X12),join(X11,X12)) = join(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [303=param(292,138),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,meet(X11,X10)) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [306=param(23,289),[136],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,meet(X10,X11)),X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [308=param(289,118),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(X10,join(X11,X12)),join(X13,X11)),X11) = meet(join(X10,join(X11,X12)),join(X13,X11))].
% 5.34/5.72 [309=demod(232),[308,136],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10))) = meet(join(X11,join(X10,X12)),join(X13,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [311=param(118,289),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(join(X10,join(meet(X11,X12),X13)),X11),meet(X11,X12)) = meet(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [313=param(289,249),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,join(X11,X10)),X10) = meet(X10,join(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [314=demod(261),[313,136,289],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,join(X11,X10)) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [316=param(289,292),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),X11) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [317=demod(300),[316,136,314,316,136,136,316,136],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(X11,X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [318=param(292,289),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,meet(X10,X11)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [319=demod(306),[318],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),X10) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [322=param(23,319),[129],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),X10) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [324=param(125,314),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,meet(join(X11,X10),X12)),join(X11,X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [326=param(138,193),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(meet(X11,X10),meet(X10,X12))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [327=param(23,288),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(join(X10,X11),join(join(X10,X11),X10))) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [330=param(289,288),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),X10) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [331=demod(327),[330,136],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(X10,X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [332=param(23,331),[129],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,join(X10,X11)) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [339=param(230,138),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(join(X10,X11),X12),meet(X11,X12)) = meet(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [375=param(241,317),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,join(X11,X12)),X12) = X12].
% 5.34/5.72 [386=param(125,303),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X12,X11)),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [391=param(322,375),[375],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,join(X11,join(X12,X10))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [392=param(375,330),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(join(X10,X11),X12),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [404=param(322,392),[392],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,join(join(X11,X10),X12)) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [413=param(243,330),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(join(X10,X11),join(X11,X12)),X11) = X11].
% 5.34/5.72 [436=param(282,330),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),meet(X10,X12)) = meet(X10,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [441=param(289,436),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),meet(X10,X12)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [443=param(322,436),[436],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),join(X10,X12)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [452=param(284,330),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),meet(X12,X10)) = meet(X12,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [458=param(319,452),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),join(X11,X12)) = join(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [459=param(322,452),[452],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),join(X11,X12)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [470=param(436,458),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),meet(meet(X12,X10),X13)) = meet(meet(X12,X10),X13)].
% 5.34/5.72 [487=param(291,332),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X10,join(X11,X12))) = join(X10,join(X11,X12))].
% 5.34/5.72 [489=param(291,391),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X12,join(X11,X10))) = join(X12,join(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [508=param(302,404),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(join(X12,X10),X11)) = join(join(X12,X10),X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [511=param(302,443),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(meet(X10,X11),X12),join(X10,X12)) = join(X10,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [513=param(302,459),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(meet(X10,X11),X12),join(X11,X12)) = join(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [583=param(309,441),[441],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(join(X12,join(meet(X10,X11),X13)),join(X10,X14))) = meet(join(X12,join(meet(X10,X11),X13)),join(X10,X14))].
% 5.34/5.72 [712=param(324,288),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X11,X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [722=param(324,436),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,meet(X11,X12)),join(X11,X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [730=param(241,712),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,join(X11,X12)),join(X12,X11)) = join(X12,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [731=param(288,712),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(X11,X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [735=param(330,712),[712,712],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,X11) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [779=demod(513),[735],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(meet(X12,X10),X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [793=demod(511),[735],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(meet(X10,X12),X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [795=demod(386),[735],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(meet(X11,X10),meet(X12,X10))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [833=param(311,795),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,X10)) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [835=param(795,322),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X12,X10))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [850=param(289,833),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,X10)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [852=param(322,833),[833,833],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,X11) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [896=demod(339),[852],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(join(X12,X10),X11)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [948=demod(413),[852],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,meet(join(X11,X10),join(X10,X12))) = X10].
% 5.34/5.72 [1013=param(282,850),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(meet(X11,X10),X12)) = meet(meet(X11,X10),X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1014=param(284,850),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(X12,meet(X11,X10))) = meet(X12,meet(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [1078=param(948,850),[1013],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),join(meet(X11,X10),X12)) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1099=param(835,833),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),join(meet(X11,X10),meet(X12,meet(X10,X11)))) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1269=param(1078,317),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),join(X12,meet(X11,X10))) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1276=param(833,1078),[852,1014,1078],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(meet(X10,X11),X12),meet(X11,X10)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1283=param(795,1276),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),join(meet(X12,meet(X10,X11)),meet(X11,X10))) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1284=param(1269,731),[731,731],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(X12,join(X11,X10))) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1468=param(896,735),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(join(X10,X12),X11)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1516=param(487,735),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X11,join(X10,X12))) = join(X11,join(X10,X12))].
% 5.34/5.72 [1569=param(489,850),[850,850],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),join(X12,meet(X11,X10))) = join(X12,meet(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [1570=demod(1283),[1569],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,meet(X11,X12)),meet(X12,X11)) = meet(X11,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1578=param(712,1570),[1099],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X11,X10),meet(X12,meet(X10,X11))) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1580=param(1570,852),[735],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(meet(X11,X10),X12)) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1595=param(1580,731),[731,731],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),meet(join(X11,X10),X12)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [1617=param(1595,470),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),meet(meet(X12,X11),X13)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [2129=param(332,508),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(join(X12,X10),X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [2424=param(1578,1468),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,join(X11,X12)),meet(X11,X10)) = meet(join(X11,X12),X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [2644=param(793,735),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X11,meet(X10,X12))) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [2786=param(779,735),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X11,meet(X12,X10))) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [2933=param(730,2644),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(meet(X10,X12),X11)) = join(meet(X10,X12),X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [2934=param(730,2786),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(meet(X12,X10),X11)) = join(meet(X12,X10),X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [3179=param(2934,852),[2933],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),X12) = join(meet(X11,X10),X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [3294=param(1617,3179),[1617],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,meet(X11,X12)) = join(X10,meet(X12,X11))].
% 5.34/5.72 [3332=param(3294,730),[1284],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(X11,X12)) = join(X10,join(X12,X11))].
% 5.34/5.72 [3479=param(3332,722),[735],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X10,meet(X11,X12))) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [3481=param(3332,735),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(X11,X12)) = join(join(X12,X11),X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [3609=param(3481,2644),[-3481],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(meet(X11,X12),X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [4631=param(583,326),[326],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X10,X12))) = meet(X11,join(X10,X12))].
% 5.34/5.72 [4699=param(4631,317),[317],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(X10,X11),meet(X11,join(X12,X10))) = meet(X11,join(X12,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [4759=param(4631,712),[712],
% 5.34/5.72 join(meet(join(X10,X11),X12),meet(X12,join(X11,X10))) = meet(X12,join(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [4760=param(4631,735),[4699],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,join(X11,X12)) = meet(X10,join(X12,X11))].
% 5.34/5.72 [4829=param(850,4760),[4759],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(X10,join(X11,X12)) = meet(join(X12,X11),X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5026=param(4829,2129),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,join(X11,X12)),join(X12,X10)) = join(X12,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5095=param(4829,4760),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(X12,X13)) = meet(join(X13,X12),join(X11,X10))].
% 5.34/5.72 [5096=demod(5026),[5095],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(join(X12,X11),X10)) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5483=param(5096,735),[],
% 5.34/5.72 meet(join(X10,X11),join(X10,join(X12,X11))) = join(X11,X10)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5515=param(5096,3479),[-3481,-2424,5483,332,-3481,331],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(X11,meet(X10,X12))) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5525=param(5096,3609),[-3481,5515,136],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(meet(X10,X12),X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5605=param(5525,303),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(X10,join(meet(X11,X10),X12)) = join(X10,X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5659=param(5605,314),[],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X11,X12)) = join(join(X10,X11),X12)].
% 5.34/5.72 [5660=demod(1516),[5659],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X10,X11),join(X10,X12)) = join(X11,join(X10,X12))].
% 5.34/5.72 [5703=param(5605,332),[5660],
% 5.34/5.72 join(join(X11,X10),X12) = join(X10,join(X11,X12))].
% 5.34/5.72 [6933=param(3,5703),[735,735],
% 5.34/5.72 thtop(join(b,join(c,a)),join(a,join(c,b))) = thmtrue].
% 5.34/5.72 [6998=param(6933,735),[5703,2],
% 5.34/5.72 thmtrue = thmfalse].
% 5.34/5.72 % SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 5.34/5.72 Space: 14814 KB
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------