TSTP Solution File: GRP120-1 by Fiesta---2
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Fiesta---2
% Problem : GRP120-1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v1.2.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : dedam
% Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% Computer : n010.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Sat Jul 16 09:12:31 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 0.58s 0.96s
% Output : CNFRefutation 0.58s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.04/0.07 % Problem : GRP120-1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v1.2.0.
% 0.04/0.07 % Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% 0.06/0.26 % Computer : n010.cluster.edu
% 0.06/0.26 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.06/0.26 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.06/0.26 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.06/0.26 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.06/0.26 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.06/0.26 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.06/0.26 % DateTime : Mon Jun 13 03:59:39 EDT 2022
% 0.06/0.26 % CPUTime :
% 0.58/0.96 Theorem Proved.
% 0.58/0.96 % SZS status Unsatisfiable
% 0.58/0.96 % SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 0.58/0.96 [1=axiom,[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,identity) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [2=axiom,[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12)))) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [3=axiom,[],
% 0.58/0.96 thtop(X10,X10) = thmfalse].
% 0.58/0.96 [4=axiom,[],
% 0.58/0.96 thtop(multiply(identity,a),a) = thmtrue].
% 0.58/0.96 [6=param(2,1),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X11,identity))),identity)) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [7=param(6,1),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,identity))),identity)) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [8=param(7,6),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,X10),identity)) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,identity)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [9=demod(7),[8,8],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity)))) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [10=param(8,8),[8,8,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,X10),identity),identity))) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [11=param(8,10),[8,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(identity,X10),identity) = multiply(identity,multiply(X10,identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [12=param(2,1),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)))) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [13=param(2,11),[1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity)))),identity)) = multiply(identity,X11)].
% 0.58/0.96 [14=param(11,2),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11))),identity)) = multiply(X10,identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [18=param(13,6),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)),identity)) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [20=param(12,9),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity))))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [23=param(11,14),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11))),identity),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [24=param(11,20),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity)))),identity)) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [25=param(12,24),[1,1,1,1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity)))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [26=param(12,23),[1,1,11],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),identity))) = multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11))),identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [27=param(2,18),[1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity))))),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [30=param(27,9),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),multiply(X11,identity)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [31=param(2,27),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X11,X12),identity))))),identity)),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12)))) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [35=param(2,30),[1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity)),identity)) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [36=param(35,2),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X11,identity)),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [38=param(35,18),[11,11,11,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)),identity) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [39=demod(18),[38],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [40=param(35,25),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [41=param(35,27),[1,1,1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity)),identity)) = multiply(X10,X10)].
% 0.58/0.96 [42=param(35,35),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X11,identity)),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity)),identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [47=param(39,11),[11,1,1,1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(identity,X10),multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,X10),multiply(identity,X10)),multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity)))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [48=param(39,38),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11),identity)))) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [49=param(36,30),[38,39,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(multiply(X11,X11),multiply(multiply(X11,X10),X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [51=param(47,11),[11],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)),multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)),multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10))),multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity))))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [66=param(51,11),[11,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10))),multiply(multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10))),multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)))),X10)) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [85=param(12,2),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,X10),multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)),multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)))))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X11)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [90=param(12,49),[85],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,X10),X11))) = multiply(X12,multiply(multiply(X12,X12),multiply(multiply(X12,X10),X11)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [91=param(90,1),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X11,multiply(multiply(X11,X11),multiply(multiply(X11,identity),X10))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [92=param(90,2),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X11,multiply(multiply(X11,X11),multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))) = multiply(identity,X10)].
% 0.58/0.96 [103=param(38,91),[11,11,11],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X11,X11),multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(multiply(X11,identity),X10)),identity)) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,identity))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [104=param(2,103),[1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity))))),identity)) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [105=demod(27),[104],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),X11)) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [106=demod(30),[105],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity)) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(X11,identity)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [109=demod(104),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity))))),identity)) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [114=demod(31),[109],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12)))) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [115=param(35,103),[11,11,11,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11)),identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [116=param(39,103),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11),identity)))) = multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity)))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [119=param(35,106),[-42,105],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(X11,identity)),identity)),identity))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [120=param(106,38),[39],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X11,multiply(multiply(X11,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X11,X11),X10),identity))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,identity))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [121=demod(119),[120,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(X11,identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity)].
% 0.58/0.96 [132=demod(41),[-121],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),identity))) = multiply(X10,X10)].
% 0.58/0.96 [133=demod(38),[-121],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [134=demod(115),[-121],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10)),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11),identity)) = multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11),identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [143=demod(26),[-121,11,11,-121],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),identity))) = multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity))),multiply(multiply(X11,identity),multiply(multiply(X11,X11),identity)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [208=param(48,121),[116,-90],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(X10,identity)),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11),identity)))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity)))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [216=param(121,133),[-121],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11),identity),identity)) = multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity),identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [217=param(105,2),[105],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),identity),multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)].
% 0.58/0.96 [218=param(2,105),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [219=param(105,90),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11),X12))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,X11),X12)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [221=demod(217),[219],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X10),identity),multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)].
% 0.58/0.96 [226=param(219,121),[1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(X10,identity)),X11))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X11)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [269=param(226,90),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),X11),X12)))) = multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,X11),X12))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [277=param(269,40),[1,269,1,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity))))) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [278=param(269,121),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity),X12)))) = multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(X11,identity)),X12))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [286=param(11,277),[-121,11,11,-121,278,208,1,1,1,1],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,identity),multiply(multiply(X10,X10),identity)) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),identity))].
% 0.58/0.96 [292=demod(143),[286],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(multiply(X10,identity),identity),identity))) = multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,X11),identity))),multiply(X11,multiply(multiply(X11,X11),identity)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [299=param(2,286),[-36,-121,91,9],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,identity) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [300=demod(221),[299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)].
% 0.58/0.96 [303=demod(292),[299,299,299,299,299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [304=demod(12),[303],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10))) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [306=demod(66),[304,304,304],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X10)) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [309=demod(277),[299,299,304],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X10) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [310=demod(306),[309],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X10))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [312=demod(269),[299,304],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X11),X12) = multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(identity,X11),X12))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [320=demod(218),[299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [321=demod(216),[299,299,299,299,299,299,299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(X10,X11)) = multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [322=demod(320),[321,309,310],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [327=demod(134),[321,309,310,299,299,299,299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [328=demod(300),[327],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))) = multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11)].
% 0.58/0.96 [329=demod(132),[321,309,310,299,299,299,299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(X10,X10)) = multiply(X10,X10)].
% 0.58/0.96 [330=demod(114),[299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12)))) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [331=demod(105),[321,309,310,299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),multiply(identity,X11)) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [349=param(85,329),[327,327],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)),multiply(multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)),multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X11)))))) = multiply(identity,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [352=param(90,92),[299,303,321,331],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)) = multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(identity,X10)))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [358=param(331,304),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,X10),X11) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X11))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [359=demod(330),[358],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))))) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [375=demod(309),[358],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)))) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [378=demod(328),[358],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X12))),multiply(X12,multiply(X12,X12))))) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X11))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [379=demod(359),[378],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X11)))))) = X11].
% 0.58/0.96 [380=demod(327),[358],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X11))))) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [386=param(303,329),[329,358],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X10)))))) = multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10))].
% 0.58/0.96 [389=param(358,358),[329,329,310,358,304,358],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(identity,X10))))))) = multiply(identity,X10)].
% 0.58/0.96 [432=param(312,304),[],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X11))),X12) = multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,X12))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [435=param(312,329),[358,380],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(multiply(X10,multiply(X11,X11)),X12) = multiply(X10,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,multiply(X11,X12))))].
% 0.58/0.96 [437=demod(349),[435,310,299,435],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X11,multiply(identity,multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(X11,multiply(identity,X11)))))))) = multiply(identity,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11)))].
% 0.58/0.96 [478=param(322,375),[310,299,432,375,432,386,304],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,X10)))) = identity].
% 0.58/0.96 [479=demod(437),[478,299,299],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))) = multiply(X10,multiply(X10,X11))].
% 0.58/0.96 [492=demod(389),[479,479],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(X10,multiply(identity,X11))))) = multiply(identity,X11)].
% 0.58/0.96 [494=demod(352),[492],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,multiply(identity,X10)) = multiply(identity,X10)].
% 0.58/0.96 [549=demod(379),[494,492],
% 0.58/0.96 multiply(identity,X10) = X10].
% 0.58/0.96 [570=param(4,549),[3],
% 0.58/0.96 thmtrue = thmfalse].
% 0.58/0.96 % SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 0.58/0.96 Space: 1387 KB
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------