TSTP Solution File: GEO124-1 by CSE---1.6
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : CSE---1.6
% Problem : GEO124-1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : java -jar /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/mcs_scs.jar %s %d
% Computer : n029.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Wed Aug 30 22:43:03 EDT 2023
% Result : Unsatisfiable 1.38s 1.50s
% Output : CNFRefutation 1.41s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.10/0.11 % Problem : GEO124-1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.10/0.12 % Command : java -jar /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/mcs_scs.jar %s %d
% 0.11/0.32 % Computer : n029.cluster.edu
% 0.11/0.32 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.11/0.32 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.11/0.32 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.11/0.32 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.11/0.32 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.11/0.32 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.11/0.32 % DateTime : Tue Aug 29 21:16:42 EDT 2023
% 0.11/0.33 % CPUTime :
% 0.17/0.57 start to proof:theBenchmark
% 1.38/1.49 %-------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.49 % File :CSE---1.6
% 1.38/1.49 % Problem :theBenchmark
% 1.38/1.49 % Transform :cnf
% 1.38/1.49 % Format :tptp:raw
% 1.38/1.49 % Command :java -jar mcs_scs.jar %d %s
% 1.38/1.49
% 1.38/1.49 % Result :Theorem 0.850000s
% 1.38/1.49 % Output :CNFRefutation 0.850000s
% 1.38/1.49 %-------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.50 %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.50 % File : GEO124-1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% 1.38/1.50 % Domain : Geometry (Oriented curves)
% 1.38/1.50 % Problem : Every oriented curve has at most one starting point
% 1.38/1.50 % Version : [EHK99] axioms.
% 1.38/1.50 % English :
% 1.38/1.50
% 1.38/1.50 % Refs : [KE99] Kulik & Eschenbach (1999), A Geometry of Oriented Curv
% 1.38/1.50 % : [EHK99] Eschenbach et al. (1999), Representing Simple Trajecto
% 1.38/1.50 % Source : [TPTP]
% 1.38/1.50 % Names :
% 1.38/1.50
% 1.38/1.50 % Status : Unsatisfiable
% 1.38/1.50 % Rating : 0.19 v8.1.0, 0.11 v7.5.0, 0.16 v7.4.0, 0.12 v7.3.0, 0.17 v7.1.0, 0.08 v7.0.0, 0.07 v6.4.0, 0.00 v6.3.0, 0.09 v6.2.0, 0.10 v6.1.0, 0.21 v6.0.0, 0.10 v5.5.0, 0.25 v5.4.0, 0.30 v5.3.0, 0.33 v5.2.0, 0.31 v5.1.0, 0.35 v5.0.0, 0.21 v4.1.0, 0.15 v4.0.1, 0.18 v4.0.0, 0.09 v3.7.0, 0.00 v3.3.0, 0.07 v3.2.0, 0.15 v3.1.0, 0.09 v2.7.0, 0.17 v2.6.0, 0.00 v2.4.0
% 1.38/1.50 % Syntax : Number of clauses : 99 ( 6 unt; 42 nHn; 89 RR)
% 1.38/1.50 % Number of literals : 302 ( 41 equ; 153 neg)
% 1.38/1.50 % Maximal clause size : 12 ( 3 avg)
% 1.38/1.50 % Maximal term depth : 3 ( 1 avg)
% 1.38/1.50 % Number of predicates : 14 ( 13 usr; 0 prp; 1-4 aty)
% 1.38/1.50 % Number of functors : 29 ( 29 usr; 3 con; 0-5 aty)
% 1.38/1.50 % Number of variables : 276 ( 17 sgn)
% 1.38/1.50 % SPC : CNF_UNS_RFO_SEQ_NHN
% 1.38/1.50
% 1.38/1.50 % Comments : Created by tptp2X -f tptp -t clausify:otter GEO124+1.p
% 1.38/1.50 %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.50 %----Include simple curve axioms
% 1.38/1.50 include('Axioms/GEO004-0.ax').
% 1.38/1.50 %----Include axioms of betweenness for simple curves
% 1.38/1.50 include('Axioms/GEO004-1.ax').
% 1.38/1.50 %----Include oriented curve axioms
% 1.38/1.50 include('Axioms/GEO004-2.ax').
% 1.38/1.50 %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.50 cnf(corollary_4_10_1_133,negated_conjecture,
% 1.38/1.50 start_point(sk26,sk25) ).
% 1.38/1.50
% 1.38/1.50 cnf(corollary_4_10_1_134,negated_conjecture,
% 1.38/1.50 start_point(sk27,sk25) ).
% 1.38/1.50
% 1.38/1.50 cnf(corollary_4_10_1_135,negated_conjecture,
% 1.38/1.50 sk26 != sk27 ).
% 1.38/1.50
% 1.38/1.50 %--------------------------------------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.50 %-------------------------------------------
% 1.38/1.50 % Proof found
% 1.38/1.50 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark
% 1.38/1.50 % SZS output start Proof
% 1.41/1.50 %ClaNum:177(EqnAxiom:89)
% 1.41/1.50 %VarNum:701(SingletonVarNum:245)
% 1.41/1.50 %MaxLitNum:12
% 1.41/1.50 %MaxfuncDepth:2
% 1.41/1.50 %SharedTerms:6
% 1.41/1.50 %goalClause: 91 92 95
% 1.41/1.50 %singleGoalClaCount:3
% 1.41/1.50 [91]P11(a19,a20)
% 1.41/1.50 [92]P11(a27,a20)
% 1.41/1.50 [95]~E(a27,a19)
% 1.41/1.50 [90]P1(f1(x901))
% 1.41/1.50 [93]P2(f2(x931),x931)
% 1.41/1.50 [94]P11(f21(x941),x941)
% 1.41/1.50 [96]P3(x961)+P6(f3(x961),x961)
% 1.41/1.50 [98]~P1(x981)+P6(f13(x981),x981)
% 1.41/1.50 [97]P1(x971)+~P6(x972,x971)
% 1.41/1.50 [100]~P3(x1001)+~P6(x1002,x1001)
% 1.41/1.50 [101]~P6(x1011,x1012)+P7(x1011,x1012)
% 1.41/1.50 [102]~P2(x1021,x1022)+P7(x1021,x1022)
% 1.41/1.50 [103]~P11(x1031,x1032)+P9(x1031,x1032)
% 1.41/1.50 [104]~P8(x1041,x1042)+P9(x1041,x1042)
% 1.41/1.50 [106]~P2(x1061,x1062)+~P6(x1061,x1062)
% 1.41/1.50 [105]~P9(x1051,x1052)+P7(x1051,f1(x1052))
% 1.41/1.50 [109]~P6(x1091,x1092)+~E(f4(x1091,x1092),x1091)
% 1.41/1.50 [110]P9(x1101,x1102)+~P7(x1101,f1(x1102))
% 1.41/1.50 [112]P12(x1121,x1122)+P7(f5(x1121,x1122),x1121)
% 1.41/1.50 [118]~P6(x1181,x1182)+P6(f4(x1181,x1182),x1182)
% 1.41/1.50 [127]P12(x1271,x1272)+~P7(f5(x1271,x1272),x1272)
% 1.41/1.50 [139]~P2(x1391,x1392)+P10(x1391,f15(x1391,x1392),f6(x1391,x1392))
% 1.41/1.50 [130]~P2(x1301,x1302)+E(f29(f15(x1301,x1302),f6(x1301,x1302)),x1302)
% 1.41/1.50 [131]P7(x1311,x1312)+~P10(x1311,x1313,x1312)
% 1.41/1.50 [132]P7(x1321,x1322)+~P10(x1321,x1322,x1323)
% 1.41/1.50 [133]P9(x1331,x1332)+~P13(x1332,x1333,x1331)
% 1.41/1.50 [134]P9(x1341,x1342)+~P13(x1342,x1341,x1343)
% 1.41/1.50 [137]~P10(x1373,x1372,x1371)+E(f9(x1371,x1372),f29(x1372,x1371))
% 1.41/1.50 [159]~E(x1591,x1592)+~P4(x1593,x1591,x1594,x1592)
% 1.41/1.50 [169]~P4(x1694,x1693,x1692,x1691)+P6(x1691,f16(x1691,x1692,x1693,x1694))
% 1.41/1.50 [170]~P4(x1704,x1701,x1703,x1702)+P6(x1701,f16(x1702,x1703,x1701,x1704))
% 1.41/1.50 [171]~P4(x1714,x1713,x1711,x1712)+P2(x1711,f16(x1712,x1711,x1713,x1714))
% 1.41/1.50 [172]~P4(x1724,x1723,x1722,x1721)+P12(f16(x1721,x1722,x1723,x1724),x1724)
% 1.41/1.50 [174]~P5(x1741,x1744,x1743,x1742)+P4(f22(x1741,x1742,x1743,x1744),x1744,x1743,x1742)
% 1.41/1.50 [99]P1(x991)+~P12(x991,x992)+E(x991,x992)
% 1.41/1.50 [111]P2(x1111,x1112)+~P7(x1111,x1112)+P6(x1111,x1112)
% 1.41/1.50 [116]~P9(x1161,x1162)+P11(x1161,x1162)+~E(f14(x1162,x1161),x1161)
% 1.41/1.50 [117]~P9(x1171,x1172)+P8(x1171,x1172)+~E(f17(x1172,x1171),x1171)
% 1.41/1.50 [121]~P7(x1211,x1212)+P6(x1211,x1212)+P7(x1211,f7(x1212,x1211))
% 1.41/1.50 [122]~P7(x1221,x1222)+P6(x1221,x1222)+P7(x1221,f11(x1222,x1221))
% 1.41/1.50 [123]~P7(x1231,x1232)+P6(x1231,x1232)+P12(f7(x1232,x1231),x1232)
% 1.41/1.50 [124]~P7(x1241,x1242)+P6(x1241,x1242)+P12(f11(x1242,x1241),x1242)
% 1.41/1.50 [125]~P9(x1251,x1252)+P11(x1251,x1252)+P9(f14(x1252,x1251),x1252)
% 1.41/1.50 [126]~P9(x1261,x1262)+P8(x1261,x1262)+P9(f17(x1262,x1261),x1262)
% 1.41/1.50 [128]E(x1281,x1282)+P7(f8(x1281,x1282),x1282)+P7(f8(x1281,x1282),x1281)
% 1.41/1.50 [129]P7(f18(x1292,x1291),x1291)+P9(f18(x1292,x1291),x1292)+E(x1291,f28(x1292))
% 1.41/1.50 [138]E(x1381,x1382)+~P7(f8(x1381,x1382),x1382)+~P7(f8(x1381,x1382),x1381)
% 1.41/1.50 [140]~P7(f18(x1402,x1401),x1401)+~P9(f18(x1402,x1401),x1402)+E(x1401,f28(x1402))
% 1.41/1.50 [141]~P7(x1411,x1412)+P6(x1411,x1412)+~P12(f7(x1412,x1411),f11(x1412,x1411))
% 1.41/1.50 [142]~P7(x1421,x1422)+P6(x1421,x1422)+~P12(f11(x1422,x1421),f7(x1422,x1421))
% 1.41/1.50 [146]~P9(x1461,x1462)+P11(x1461,x1462)+~P13(x1462,x1461,f14(x1462,x1461))
% 1.41/1.50 [147]~P9(x1471,x1472)+P8(x1471,x1472)+~P13(x1472,f17(x1472,x1471),x1471)
% 1.41/1.50 [150]E(x1501,x1502)+P13(x1502,f25(x1502,x1501),f26(x1502,x1501))+P13(x1501,f25(x1502,x1501),f26(x1502,x1501))
% 1.41/1.50 [156]E(x1561,x1562)+~P13(x1562,f25(x1561,x1562),f26(x1561,x1562))+~P13(x1561,f25(x1561,x1562),f26(x1561,x1562))
% 1.41/1.50 [113]~P7(x1131,x1133)+P7(x1131,x1132)+~P12(x1133,x1132)
% 1.41/1.50 [107]~P9(x1071,x1073)+P7(x1071,x1072)+~E(x1072,f28(x1073))
% 1.41/1.51 [108]~P7(x1081,x1083)+P9(x1081,x1082)+~E(x1083,f28(x1082))
% 1.41/1.51 [160]~P7(f10(x1603,x1602,x1601),x1601)+~P7(f10(x1603,x1602,x1601),x1602)+E(x1601,f29(x1602,x1603))
% 1.41/1.51 [161]~P7(f10(x1613,x1612,x1611),x1611)+~P7(f10(x1613,x1612,x1611),x1613)+E(x1611,f29(x1612,x1613))
% 1.41/1.51 [162]~P13(x1621,x1623,x1622)+~P13(x1621,x1624,x1623)+P5(x1621,x1622,x1623,x1624)
% 1.41/1.51 [163]~P13(x1631,x1633,x1634)+~P13(x1631,x1632,x1633)+P5(x1631,x1632,x1633,x1634)
% 1.41/1.51 [165]P13(x1651,x1653,x1652)+P13(x1651,x1652,x1653)+~P5(x1651,x1654,x1653,x1652)
% 1.41/1.51 [166]~P5(x1661,x1664,x1663,x1662)+P13(x1661,x1662,x1663)+P13(x1661,x1664,x1663)
% 1.41/1.51 [167]~P5(x1671,x1674,x1672,x1673)+P13(x1671,x1672,x1673)+P13(x1671,x1672,x1674)
% 1.41/1.51 [168]P13(x1681,x1683,x1682)+P13(x1681,x1682,x1683)+~P5(x1681,x1683,x1682,x1684)
% 1.41/1.51 [114]~P7(x1141,x1144)+P7(x1141,x1142)+~E(x1142,f29(x1143,x1144))
% 1.41/1.51 [115]~P7(x1151,x1153)+P7(x1151,x1152)+~E(x1152,f29(x1153,x1154))
% 1.41/1.51 [173]~P9(x1731,x1732)+~P5(x1732,x1735,x1734,x1733)+P7(x1731,f22(x1732,x1733,x1734,x1735))
% 1.41/1.51 [175]P9(x1751,x1752)+~P5(x1752,x1753,x1754,x1755)+~P7(x1751,f22(x1752,x1755,x1754,x1753))
% 1.41/1.51 [135]~P9(x1352,x1353)+~P8(x1351,x1353)+E(x1351,x1352)+P13(x1353,x1352,x1351)
% 1.41/1.51 [136]~P11(x1361,x1363)+~P9(x1362,x1363)+E(x1361,x1362)+P13(x1363,x1361,x1362)
% 1.41/1.51 [152]~P7(x1521,x1523)+~P7(x1521,x1522)+P10(x1521,x1522,x1523)+P7(f12(x1523,x1522,x1521),x1523)
% 1.41/1.51 [153]~P7(x1531,x1533)+~P7(x1531,x1532)+P10(x1531,x1532,x1533)+P7(f12(x1533,x1532,x1531),x1532)
% 1.41/1.51 [158]P7(f10(x1583,x1582,x1581),x1581)+P7(f10(x1583,x1582,x1581),x1582)+P7(f10(x1583,x1582,x1581),x1583)+E(x1581,f29(x1582,x1583))
% 1.41/1.51 [144]~P7(x1441,x1442)+P6(x1441,x1442)+~P10(x1444,x1443,x1442)+~P7(x1441,x1443)
% 1.41/1.51 [145]~P7(x1451,x1452)+P6(x1451,x1452)+~P10(x1454,x1452,x1453)+~P7(x1451,x1453)
% 1.41/1.51 [120]~P7(x1201,x1204)+P7(x1201,x1202)+P7(x1201,x1203)+~E(x1204,f29(x1203,x1202))
% 1.41/1.51 [176]~P4(x1765,x1762,x1763,x1764)+P5(x1761,x1762,x1763,x1764)+P7(f23(x1765,x1761,x1764,x1763,x1762),x1765)+P9(f23(x1765,x1761,x1764,x1763,x1762),x1761)
% 1.41/1.51 [177]P5(x1771,x1772,x1773,x1774)+~P4(x1775,x1772,x1773,x1774)+~P7(f23(x1775,x1771,x1774,x1773,x1772),x1775)+~P9(f23(x1775,x1771,x1774,x1773,x1772),x1771)
% 1.41/1.51 [151]~P1(x1513)+~P7(x1512,x1513)+~P7(x1511,x1513)+E(x1511,x1512)+P13(f24(x1513,x1512,x1511),x1511,x1512)
% 1.41/1.51 [164]~P7(x1641,x1643)+~P7(x1641,x1642)+P10(x1641,x1642,x1643)+~P6(f12(x1643,x1642,x1641),x1643)+~P6(f12(x1643,x1642,x1641),x1642)
% 1.41/1.51 [148]~P3(x1484)+~P6(x1481,x1482)+P10(x1481,x1482,x1483)+~P10(x1485,x1482,x1483)+~E(x1484,f29(x1482,x1483))
% 1.41/1.51 [119]E(x1193,x1191)+~P6(x1191,x1194)+~P6(x1193,x1194)+E(x1191,x1192)+E(x1193,x1192)+~P6(x1192,x1194)
% 1.41/1.51 [149]~P1(x1494)+~P7(x1493,x1494)+~P7(x1492,x1494)+~P7(x1491,x1494)+E(x1491,x1492)+P9(x1493,f24(x1494,x1492,x1491))
% 1.41/1.51 [155]~P1(x1554)+~P7(x1552,x1554)+~P7(x1551,x1554)+E(x1551,x1552)+P7(x1553,x1554)+~P9(x1553,f24(x1554,x1552,x1551))
% 1.41/1.51 [157]~P6(x1572,x1575)+~P6(x1571,x1575)+~P2(x1574,x1575)+E(x1571,x1572)+P4(x1573,x1571,x1574,x1572)+~P12(x1575,x1573)
% 1.41/1.51 [143]P12(x1432,x1431)+~P12(x1432,x1433)+~P7(x1434,x1432)+~P6(x1434,x1433)+P12(x1431,x1432)+~P12(x1431,x1433)+~P7(x1434,x1431)
% 1.41/1.51 [154]P12(x1542,x1541)+P12(x1542,x1543)+P12(x1543,x1541)+P12(x1543,x1542)+~P12(x1542,x1544)+~P12(x1543,x1544)+~P6(x1545,x1542)+~P6(x1545,x1543)+P12(x1541,x1542)+P12(x1541,x1543)+~P12(x1541,x1544)+~P6(x1545,x1541)
% 1.41/1.51 %EqnAxiom
% 1.41/1.51 [1]E(x11,x11)
% 1.41/1.51 [2]E(x22,x21)+~E(x21,x22)
% 1.41/1.51 [3]E(x31,x33)+~E(x31,x32)+~E(x32,x33)
% 1.41/1.51 [4]~E(x41,x42)+E(f1(x41),f1(x42))
% 1.41/1.51 [5]~E(x51,x52)+E(f2(x51),f2(x52))
% 1.41/1.51 [6]~E(x61,x62)+E(f21(x61),f21(x62))
% 1.41/1.51 [7]~E(x71,x72)+E(f3(x71),f3(x72))
% 1.41/1.51 [8]~E(x81,x82)+E(f13(x81),f13(x82))
% 1.41/1.51 [9]~E(x91,x92)+E(f23(x91,x93,x94,x95,x96),f23(x92,x93,x94,x95,x96))
% 1.41/1.51 [10]~E(x101,x102)+E(f23(x103,x101,x104,x105,x106),f23(x103,x102,x104,x105,x106))
% 1.41/1.51 [11]~E(x111,x112)+E(f23(x113,x114,x111,x115,x116),f23(x113,x114,x112,x115,x116))
% 1.41/1.51 [12]~E(x121,x122)+E(f23(x123,x124,x125,x121,x126),f23(x123,x124,x125,x122,x126))
% 1.41/1.51 [13]~E(x131,x132)+E(f23(x133,x134,x135,x136,x131),f23(x133,x134,x135,x136,x132))
% 1.41/1.51 [14]~E(x141,x142)+E(f28(x141),f28(x142))
% 1.41/1.51 [15]~E(x151,x152)+E(f22(x151,x153,x154,x155),f22(x152,x153,x154,x155))
% 1.41/1.51 [16]~E(x161,x162)+E(f22(x163,x161,x164,x165),f22(x163,x162,x164,x165))
% 1.41/1.51 [17]~E(x171,x172)+E(f22(x173,x174,x171,x175),f22(x173,x174,x172,x175))
% 1.41/1.51 [18]~E(x181,x182)+E(f22(x183,x184,x185,x181),f22(x183,x184,x185,x182))
% 1.41/1.51 [19]~E(x191,x192)+E(f4(x191,x193),f4(x192,x193))
% 1.41/1.51 [20]~E(x201,x202)+E(f4(x203,x201),f4(x203,x202))
% 1.41/1.51 [21]~E(x211,x212)+E(f16(x211,x213,x214,x215),f16(x212,x213,x214,x215))
% 1.41/1.51 [22]~E(x221,x222)+E(f16(x223,x221,x224,x225),f16(x223,x222,x224,x225))
% 1.41/1.51 [23]~E(x231,x232)+E(f16(x233,x234,x231,x235),f16(x233,x234,x232,x235))
% 1.41/1.51 [24]~E(x241,x242)+E(f16(x243,x244,x245,x241),f16(x243,x244,x245,x242))
% 1.41/1.51 [25]~E(x251,x252)+E(f5(x251,x253),f5(x252,x253))
% 1.41/1.51 [26]~E(x261,x262)+E(f5(x263,x261),f5(x263,x262))
% 1.41/1.51 [27]~E(x271,x272)+E(f29(x271,x273),f29(x272,x273))
% 1.41/1.51 [28]~E(x281,x282)+E(f29(x283,x281),f29(x283,x282))
% 1.41/1.51 [29]~E(x291,x292)+E(f10(x291,x293,x294),f10(x292,x293,x294))
% 1.41/1.51 [30]~E(x301,x302)+E(f10(x303,x301,x304),f10(x303,x302,x304))
% 1.41/1.51 [31]~E(x311,x312)+E(f10(x313,x314,x311),f10(x313,x314,x312))
% 1.41/1.51 [32]~E(x321,x322)+E(f14(x321,x323),f14(x322,x323))
% 1.41/1.51 [33]~E(x331,x332)+E(f14(x333,x331),f14(x333,x332))
% 1.41/1.51 [34]~E(x341,x342)+E(f17(x341,x343),f17(x342,x343))
% 1.41/1.51 [35]~E(x351,x352)+E(f17(x353,x351),f17(x353,x352))
% 1.41/1.51 [36]~E(x361,x362)+E(f12(x361,x363,x364),f12(x362,x363,x364))
% 1.41/1.51 [37]~E(x371,x372)+E(f12(x373,x371,x374),f12(x373,x372,x374))
% 1.41/1.51 [38]~E(x381,x382)+E(f12(x383,x384,x381),f12(x383,x384,x382))
% 1.41/1.51 [39]~E(x391,x392)+E(f26(x391,x393),f26(x392,x393))
% 1.41/1.51 [40]~E(x401,x402)+E(f26(x403,x401),f26(x403,x402))
% 1.41/1.51 [41]~E(x411,x412)+E(f7(x411,x413),f7(x412,x413))
% 1.41/1.51 [42]~E(x421,x422)+E(f7(x423,x421),f7(x423,x422))
% 1.41/1.51 [43]~E(x431,x432)+E(f11(x431,x433),f11(x432,x433))
% 1.41/1.51 [44]~E(x441,x442)+E(f11(x443,x441),f11(x443,x442))
% 1.41/1.51 [45]~E(x451,x452)+E(f18(x451,x453),f18(x452,x453))
% 1.41/1.51 [46]~E(x461,x462)+E(f18(x463,x461),f18(x463,x462))
% 1.41/1.51 [47]~E(x471,x472)+E(f24(x471,x473,x474),f24(x472,x473,x474))
% 1.41/1.51 [48]~E(x481,x482)+E(f24(x483,x481,x484),f24(x483,x482,x484))
% 1.41/1.51 [49]~E(x491,x492)+E(f24(x493,x494,x491),f24(x493,x494,x492))
% 1.41/1.51 [50]~E(x501,x502)+E(f8(x501,x503),f8(x502,x503))
% 1.41/1.51 [51]~E(x511,x512)+E(f8(x513,x511),f8(x513,x512))
% 1.41/1.51 [52]~E(x521,x522)+E(f25(x521,x523),f25(x522,x523))
% 1.41/1.51 [53]~E(x531,x532)+E(f25(x533,x531),f25(x533,x532))
% 1.41/1.51 [54]~E(x541,x542)+E(f6(x541,x543),f6(x542,x543))
% 1.41/1.51 [55]~E(x551,x552)+E(f6(x553,x551),f6(x553,x552))
% 1.41/1.51 [56]~E(x561,x562)+E(f15(x561,x563),f15(x562,x563))
% 1.41/1.51 [57]~E(x571,x572)+E(f15(x573,x571),f15(x573,x572))
% 1.41/1.51 [58]~E(x581,x582)+E(f9(x581,x583),f9(x582,x583))
% 1.41/1.51 [59]~E(x591,x592)+E(f9(x593,x591),f9(x593,x592))
% 1.41/1.51 [60]~P1(x601)+P1(x602)+~E(x601,x602)
% 1.41/1.51 [61]P11(x612,x613)+~E(x611,x612)+~P11(x611,x613)
% 1.41/1.51 [62]P11(x623,x622)+~E(x621,x622)+~P11(x623,x621)
% 1.41/1.51 [63]P7(x632,x633)+~E(x631,x632)+~P7(x631,x633)
% 1.41/1.51 [64]P7(x643,x642)+~E(x641,x642)+~P7(x643,x641)
% 1.41/1.51 [65]P2(x652,x653)+~E(x651,x652)+~P2(x651,x653)
% 1.41/1.51 [66]P2(x663,x662)+~E(x661,x662)+~P2(x663,x661)
% 1.41/1.51 [67]P5(x672,x673,x674,x675)+~E(x671,x672)+~P5(x671,x673,x674,x675)
% 1.41/1.51 [68]P5(x683,x682,x684,x685)+~E(x681,x682)+~P5(x683,x681,x684,x685)
% 1.41/1.51 [69]P5(x693,x694,x692,x695)+~E(x691,x692)+~P5(x693,x694,x691,x695)
% 1.41/1.51 [70]P5(x703,x704,x705,x702)+~E(x701,x702)+~P5(x703,x704,x705,x701)
% 1.41/1.51 [71]~P3(x711)+P3(x712)+~E(x711,x712)
% 1.41/1.51 [72]P6(x722,x723)+~E(x721,x722)+~P6(x721,x723)
% 1.41/1.51 [73]P6(x733,x732)+~E(x731,x732)+~P6(x733,x731)
% 1.41/1.51 [74]P9(x742,x743)+~E(x741,x742)+~P9(x741,x743)
% 1.41/1.51 [75]P9(x753,x752)+~E(x751,x752)+~P9(x753,x751)
% 1.41/1.51 [76]P10(x762,x763,x764)+~E(x761,x762)+~P10(x761,x763,x764)
% 1.41/1.51 [77]P10(x773,x772,x774)+~E(x771,x772)+~P10(x773,x771,x774)
% 1.41/1.51 [78]P10(x783,x784,x782)+~E(x781,x782)+~P10(x783,x784,x781)
% 1.41/1.51 [79]P12(x792,x793)+~E(x791,x792)+~P12(x791,x793)
% 1.41/1.51 [80]P12(x803,x802)+~E(x801,x802)+~P12(x803,x801)
% 1.41/1.51 [81]P13(x812,x813,x814)+~E(x811,x812)+~P13(x811,x813,x814)
% 1.41/1.51 [82]P13(x823,x822,x824)+~E(x821,x822)+~P13(x823,x821,x824)
% 1.41/1.51 [83]P13(x833,x834,x832)+~E(x831,x832)+~P13(x833,x834,x831)
% 1.41/1.51 [84]P4(x842,x843,x844,x845)+~E(x841,x842)+~P4(x841,x843,x844,x845)
% 1.41/1.51 [85]P4(x853,x852,x854,x855)+~E(x851,x852)+~P4(x853,x851,x854,x855)
% 1.41/1.51 [86]P4(x863,x864,x862,x865)+~E(x861,x862)+~P4(x863,x864,x861,x865)
% 1.41/1.51 [87]P4(x873,x874,x875,x872)+~E(x871,x872)+~P4(x873,x874,x875,x871)
% 1.41/1.51 [88]P8(x882,x883)+~E(x881,x882)+~P8(x881,x883)
% 1.41/1.51 [89]P8(x893,x892)+~E(x891,x892)+~P8(x893,x891)
% 1.41/1.51
% 1.41/1.51 %-------------------------------------------
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(178,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~E(a19,a27)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[95,2])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(179,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P6(f2(x1791),x1791)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[95,93,2,106])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(181,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P9(a19,a20)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,2,106,103])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(183,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(f2(x1831),x1831)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,2,106,103,102])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(185,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(a19,f1(a20))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,2,106,103,102,105])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(187,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P6(f13(f1(x1871)),f1(x1871))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(189,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P6(f4(f13(f1(x1891)),f1(x1891)),f1(x1891))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(191,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P10(f2(x1911),f15(f2(x1911),x1911),f6(f2(x1911),x1911))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118,139])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(193,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P6(f2(x1931),x1932)+~E(x1932,x1931)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118,139,73])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(194,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~E(f13(f1(x1941)),f2(f1(x1941)))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118,139,73,72])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(195,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P10(x1951,f1(x1952),f1(x1952))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118,139,73,72,145])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(197,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P3(f1(x1971))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118,139,73,72,145,100])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(199,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P9(f2(f1(x1991)),x1991)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[91,95,93,90,2,106,103,102,105,98,118,139,73,72,145,100,110])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(222,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(f4(f13(f1(x2221)),f1(x2221)),f1(x2221))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[189,101])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(224,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P6(f3(f1(x2241)),f1(x2241))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[189,197,101,96])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(227,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(f2(x2271),x2271)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(rename_variables,[],[183])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(229,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P12(f7(x2291,f2(x2291)),f11(x2291,f2(x2291)))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[189,179,183,227,197,101,96,142,141])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(230,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(f2(x2301),x2301)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(rename_variables,[],[183])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(232,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(f12(f1(a20),f1(a20),a19),f1(a20))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[189,179,183,227,195,197,185,101,96,142,141,153])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(233,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P10(x2331,f1(x2332),f1(x2332))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(rename_variables,[],[195])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(235,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P2(f4(f13(f1(x2351)),f1(x2351)),f1(x2351))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[189,179,183,227,195,197,185,101,96,142,141,153,106])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(237,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P12(f11(x2371,f2(x2371)),x2372)+~E(x2372,f7(x2371,f2(x2371)))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[189,179,183,227,195,197,185,101,96,142,141,153,106,80])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(238,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P13(a20,a27,a19)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[92,95,189,179,183,227,195,197,181,185,101,96,142,141,153,106,80,136])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(240,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P6(f12(f1(a20),f1(a20),a19),f1(a20))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[92,95,189,179,183,227,195,233,197,181,185,101,96,142,141,153,106,80,136,164])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(243,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P12(f7(x2431,f2(x2431)),x2431)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[92,95,189,179,183,227,230,195,233,197,181,185,101,96,142,141,153,106,80,136,164,123])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(244,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (~P6(f2(x2441),x2441)),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(rename_variables,[],[179])).
% 1.41/1.51 cnf(246,plain,
% 1.41/1.51 (P7(f2(x2461),f7(x2461,f2(x2461)))),
% 1.41/1.51 inference(scs_inference,[],[92,95,189,179,244,183,227,230,195,233,197,181,185,101,96,142,141,153,106,80,136,164,123,121])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(247,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P6(f2(x2471),x2471)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(rename_variables,[],[179])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(249,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~E(f3(f1(x2491)),f2(f1(x2491)))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[92,95,189,179,244,247,183,227,230,195,233,197,181,185,101,96,142,141,153,106,80,136,164,123,121,72])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(280,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P2(f12(f1(a20),f1(a20),a19),f1(a20))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[232,240,111])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(301,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P10(f2(x3011),f7(x3011,f2(x3011)),x3011)+~E(x3012,f1(x3013))+P7(f12(x3011,f7(x3011,f2(x3011)),f2(x3011)),x3011)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[93,235,194,246,183,199,66,65,135,152])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(316,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f12(x3161,f7(x3161,f2(x3161)),f2(x3161)),x3161)+P10(f2(x3161),f7(x3161,f2(x3161)),x3161)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(equality_inference,[],[301])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(326,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P10(f2(x3261),f15(f2(x3261),x3261),x3262)+~E(f6(f2(x3261),x3261),x3262)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[178,90,222,91,191,60,110,120,136,78])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(327,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a19,a27,a19)+~P9(a27,a20)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[178,90,222,238,91,191,60,110,120,136,78,163])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(329,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a27,a19,a27)+~P9(a27,a20)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[178,90,222,238,91,191,60,110,120,136,78,163,162])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(345,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P9(f21(x3451),x3451)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[94,103])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(352,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f12(x3521,f7(x3521,f2(x3521)),f2(x3521)),x3521)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[94,179,249,246,183,103,2,144,316])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(355,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f2(x3551),f15(f2(x3551),x3551))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[95,94,179,249,246,191,183,103,2,144,316,3,132])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(357,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f2(x3571),f6(f2(x3571),x3571))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[95,94,179,249,246,191,183,103,2,144,316,3,132,131])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(385,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P6(f2(x3851),f15(f2(x3851),x3851))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[355,357,191,145])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(389,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~E(f15(f2(x3891),x3891),x3891)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[179,355,357,191,145,73])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(391,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f12(x3911,f7(x3911,f2(x3911)),f2(x3911)),x3912)+~E(x3912,f29(x3911,x3913))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[179,352,355,357,191,145,73,115])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(416,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f12(x4161,f7(x4161,f2(x4161)),f2(x4161)),f29(x4161,x4162))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(equality_inference,[],[391])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(419,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P6(f2(x4191),f6(f2(x4191),x4191))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[385,355,357,191,97,144])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(426,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~E(x4261,f11(x4261,f2(x4261)))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[385,416,355,357,229,243,191,97,144,193,114,80])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(432,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a27,a19,x4321)+~P13(a20,a19,x4321)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,385,416,355,357,238,229,243,191,97,144,193,114,80,147,126,163])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(434,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,x4341,a19,a27)+~P13(a20,a19,x4341)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,385,416,355,357,238,229,243,191,97,144,193,114,80,147,126,163,162])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(448,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P9(f2(x4481),x4482)+~E(x4481,f28(x4482))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[183,389,2,108])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(452,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P6(f4(f3(f1(x4521)),f1(x4521)),f1(x4521))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[183,389,232,224,2,108,110,118])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(459,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P5(a20,x4591,x4592,x4593)+~E(x4594,f28(x4595))+P7(a19,f22(a20,x4593,x4592,x4591))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,178,183,389,426,232,224,2,108,110,118,146,119,173])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(467,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P9(f2(f28(x4671)),x4671)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(equality_inference,[],[448])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(470,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P5(a20,x4702,x4703,x4704)+P7(a19,f22(a20,x4704,x4703,x4702))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(equality_inference,[],[459])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(472,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(a19,x4721)+~E(x4721,f28(a20))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,107])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(476,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P9(a27,a20)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,467,238,107,105,134])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(478,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f4(f3(f1(x4781)),f1(x4781)),f1(x4781))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,452,467,238,107,105,134,101])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(493,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(a19,f28(a20))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(equality_inference,[],[472])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(496,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a19,a27,a19)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[476,327])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(497,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a27,a19,a27)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[476,329])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(503,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P9(f2(f22(x5031,x5032,x5033,x5034)),x5031)+~P5(x5031,x5034,x5033,x5032)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[183,385,106,175])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(504,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f2(x5041),x5041)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(rename_variables,[],[183])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(506,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P10(x5061,x5062,x5062)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[179,183,504,385,106,175,145])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(507,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P6(f2(x5071),x5071)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(rename_variables,[],[179])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(509,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P12(f11(x5091,f2(x5091)),x5091)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[179,507,183,504,385,106,175,145,124])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(512,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~E(f6(f2(x5121),x5121),f15(f2(x5121),x5121))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[179,507,183,504,385,106,175,145,124,326])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(522,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P5(a20,x5221,x5222,x5223)+P9(a19,f24(f1(a20),a27,a19))+~E(f1(a20),f29(x5224,f22(a20,x5223,x5222,x5221)))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[185,178,179,507,183,504,476,280,385,90,106,175,145,124,326,157,149,114,107,173])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(544,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P9(f2(f22(a20,a19,a27,a19)),a20)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[496,503])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(547,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P4(f22(a20,a19,a27,a19),a19,a27,a19)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[509,496,503,237,174])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(553,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P6(a19,f16(a19,a27,a19,f22(a20,a19,a27,a19)))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[509,496,503,237,174,172,171,170])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(557,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P10(x5571,x5572,x5572)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(rename_variables,[],[506])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(558,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f2(x5581),x5581)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(rename_variables,[],[183])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(571,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (~P6(a27,f16(a19,a27,a19,f22(a20,a19,a27,a19)))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,183,478,509,506,557,496,493,345,187,503,237,174,172,171,170,153,152,173,105,110,101,106])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(580,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P7(f2(x5801),x5801)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(rename_variables,[],[183])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(591,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P13(a20,a19,a19)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,185,179,183,558,580,512,478,509,506,557,496,493,497,345,419,91,187,90,503,237,174,172,171,170,153,152,173,105,110,101,106,2,470,159,522,175,149,102,97,122,136])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(595,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a27,a19,a19)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,185,179,183,558,580,512,478,509,506,557,496,493,497,345,419,91,187,90,503,237,174,172,171,170,153,152,173,105,110,101,106,2,470,159,522,175,149,102,97,122,136,434,432])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(612,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P5(a20,a19,a19,a19)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[591,162])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(689,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P4(f22(a20,a19,a19,a27),a27,a19,a19)),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,185,544,595,547,553,105,503,117,101,159,108,174])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(693,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 (P6(a27,f16(a19,a19,a27,f22(a20,a19,a19,a27)))),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[181,185,544,595,547,553,105,503,117,101,159,108,174,470,170])).
% 1.41/1.52 cnf(717,plain,
% 1.41/1.52 ($false),
% 1.41/1.52 inference(scs_inference,[],[183,693,689,571,612,171,172,175,73,106,169]),
% 1.41/1.52 ['proof']).
% 1.41/1.52 % SZS output end Proof
% 1.41/1.52 % Total time :0.850000s
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------