0.03/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 1.54/1.58 % Command : python3 prover_driver.py --schedule_mode external --schedule fof_schedule --no_cores 8 --problem_version fof /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 120 --prover /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/res/iproveropt_no_z3 1.61/1.79 % Computer : n016.cluster.edu 1.61/1.79 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 1.61/1.79 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 1.61/1.79 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 1.61/1.79 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 1.61/1.79 % CPULimit : 960 1.61/1.79 % WCLimit : 120 1.61/1.79 % DateTime : Tue Aug 9 02:15:28 EDT 2022 1.61/1.79 % CPUTime : 46.66/8.58 % SZS status Started for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 %---------------- iProver v3.6 (pre CASC-J11 2022) ----------------% 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ iProver source info 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 git: date: 2022-07-26 19:47:37 +0300 46.66/8.58 git: sha1: 69e283425f6c8ae3fb9e67f2058d741e849b12e1 46.66/8.58 git: non_committed_changes: false 46.66/8.58 git: last_make_outside_of_git: false 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Parsing... 46.66/8.58 ------ Clausification by vclausify_rel & Parsing by iProver... 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Preprocessing... sf_s rm: 169 0s sf_e pe_s pe:1:0s pe:2:0s pe:4:0s pe_e sf_s rm: 10 0s sf_e pe_s pe_e sf_s rm: 0 0s sf_e pe_s pe_e 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Preprocessing... 46.66/8.58 ------ Proving... 46.66/8.58 ------ Problem Properties 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 clauses 10063 46.66/8.58 conjectures 1 46.66/8.58 EPR 9874 46.66/8.58 Horn 10060 46.66/8.58 unary 9827 46.66/8.58 binary 39 46.66/8.58 lits 10728 46.66/8.58 lits eq 0 46.66/8.58 fd_pure 0 46.66/8.58 fd_pseudo 0 46.66/8.58 fd_cond 0 46.66/8.58 fd_pseudo_cond 0 46.66/8.58 AC symbols 0 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Input Options Time Limit: Unbounded 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ 46.66/8.58 Current options: 46.66/8.58 ------ 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Proving... 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Proving... 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark.p 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 % SZS output start CNFRefutation for theBenchmark.p 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f7984,axiom,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1] : (sub(X0,X1) => ? [X2] : (arg1(X2,X0) & arg2(X2,X1) & subr(X2,sub_0)))), 46.66/8.58 file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p',sub__sub_0_expansion)). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10508,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1] : (? [X2] : (arg1(X2,X0) & arg2(X2,X1) & subr(X2,sub_0)) | ~sub(X0,X1))), 46.66/8.58 inference(ennf_transformation,[],[f7984])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10633,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1] : (? [X2] : (arg1(X2,X0) & arg2(X2,X1) & subr(X2,sub_0)) => (arg1(sK55(X0,X1),X0) & arg2(sK55(X0,X1),X1) & subr(sK55(X0,X1),sub_0)))), 46.66/8.58 introduced(choice_axiom,[])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10634,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1] : ((arg1(sK55(X0,X1),X0) & arg2(sK55(X0,X1),X1) & subr(sK55(X0,X1),sub_0)) | ~sub(X0,X1))), 46.66/8.58 inference(skolemisation,[status(esa),new_symbols(skolem,[sK55])],[f10508,f10633])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f18650,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ( ! [X0,X1] : (arg2(sK55(X0,X1),X1) | ~sub(X0,X1)) )), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10634])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10189,conjecture,( 46.66/8.58 ? [X0,X1,X2,X3,X4,X5,X6] : (attr(X3,X2) & attr(X5,X6) & obj(X4,X0) & sub(X0,firma_1_1) & sub(X2,name_1_1) & val(X1,bmw_0) & val(X2,bmw_0) & sub(X1,name_1_1) & attr(X0,X1))), 46.66/8.58 file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p',synth_qa07_007_mira_wp_480)). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10190,negated_conjecture,( 46.66/8.58 ~? [X0,X1,X2,X3,X4,X5,X6] : (attr(X3,X2) & attr(X5,X6) & obj(X4,X0) & sub(X0,firma_1_1) & sub(X2,name_1_1) & val(X1,bmw_0) & val(X2,bmw_0) & sub(X1,name_1_1) & attr(X0,X1))), 46.66/8.58 inference(negated_conjecture,[],[f10189])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10550,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1,X2,X3,X4,X5,X6] : (~attr(X3,X2) | ~attr(X5,X6) | ~obj(X4,X0) | ~sub(X0,firma_1_1) | ~sub(X2,name_1_1) | ~val(X1,bmw_0) | ~val(X2,bmw_0) | ~sub(X1,name_1_1) | ~attr(X0,X1))), 46.66/8.58 inference(ennf_transformation,[],[f10190])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f20888,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ( ! [X6,X4,X2,X0,X5,X3,X1] : (~attr(X3,X2) | ~attr(X5,X6) | ~obj(X4,X0) | ~sub(X0,firma_1_1) | ~sub(X2,name_1_1) | ~val(X1,bmw_0) | ~val(X2,bmw_0) | ~sub(X1,name_1_1) | ~attr(X0,X1)) )), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10550])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f2642,axiom,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1,X2] : ((arg1(X0,X1) & arg2(X0,X2) & subr(X0,sub_0)) => ? [X3,X4,X5] : (hsit(X0,X3) & obj(X3,X1) & sub(X5,X2) & subs(X3,bezeichnen_1_1) & subr(X4,rprs_0) & mcont(X3,X4) & arg2(X4,X5) & arg1(X4,X1)))), 46.66/8.58 file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p',sub__bezeichnen_1_1_als)). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10409,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1,X2] : (? [X3,X4,X5] : (hsit(X0,X3) & obj(X3,X1) & sub(X5,X2) & subs(X3,bezeichnen_1_1) & subr(X4,rprs_0) & mcont(X3,X4) & arg2(X4,X5) & arg1(X4,X1)) | (~arg1(X0,X1) | ~arg2(X0,X2) | ~subr(X0,sub_0)))), 46.66/8.58 inference(ennf_transformation,[],[f2642])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10410,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1,X2] : (? [X3,X4,X5] : (hsit(X0,X3) & obj(X3,X1) & sub(X5,X2) & subs(X3,bezeichnen_1_1) & subr(X4,rprs_0) & mcont(X3,X4) & arg2(X4,X5) & arg1(X4,X1)) | ~arg1(X0,X1) | ~arg2(X0,X2) | ~subr(X0,sub_0))), 46.66/8.58 inference(flattening,[],[f10409])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10585,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1,X2] : (? [X3,X4,X5] : (hsit(X0,X3) & obj(X3,X1) & sub(X5,X2) & subs(X3,bezeichnen_1_1) & subr(X4,rprs_0) & mcont(X3,X4) & arg2(X4,X5) & arg1(X4,X1)) => (hsit(X0,sK19(X0,X1,X2)) & obj(sK19(X0,X1,X2),X1) & sub(sK21(X0,X1,X2),X2) & subs(sK19(X0,X1,X2),bezeichnen_1_1) & subr(sK20(X0,X1,X2),rprs_0) & mcont(sK19(X0,X1,X2),sK20(X0,X1,X2)) & arg2(sK20(X0,X1,X2),sK21(X0,X1,X2)) & arg1(sK20(X0,X1,X2),X1)))), 46.66/8.58 introduced(choice_axiom,[])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10586,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ! [X0,X1,X2] : ((hsit(X0,sK19(X0,X1,X2)) & obj(sK19(X0,X1,X2),X1) & sub(sK21(X0,X1,X2),X2) & subs(sK19(X0,X1,X2),bezeichnen_1_1) & subr(sK20(X0,X1,X2),rprs_0) & mcont(sK19(X0,X1,X2),sK20(X0,X1,X2)) & arg2(sK20(X0,X1,X2),sK21(X0,X1,X2)) & arg1(sK20(X0,X1,X2),X1)) | ~arg1(X0,X1) | ~arg2(X0,X2) | ~subr(X0,sub_0))), 46.66/8.58 inference(skolemisation,[status(esa),new_symbols(skolem,[sK19,sK20,sK21])],[f10410,f10585])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f13295,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ( ! [X2,X0,X1] : (obj(sK19(X0,X1,X2),X1) | ~arg1(X0,X1) | ~arg2(X0,X2) | ~subr(X0,sub_0)) )), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10586])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f18651,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ( ! [X0,X1] : (arg1(sK55(X0,X1),X0) | ~sub(X0,X1)) )), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10634])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f18649,plain,( 46.66/8.58 ( ! [X0,X1] : (subr(sK55(X0,X1),sub_0) | ~sub(X0,X1)) )), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10634])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10188,axiom,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & sort(c3,o) & etype(c3,int0) & refer(c3,det) & varia(c3,varia_c) & sort(c25,d) & sort(c25,io) & card(c25,int1) & gener(c25,sp) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & gener(behandeln_1_1,ge) & sort(geschichte_1_1,ad) & card(geschichte_1_1,int1) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & quant(geschichte_1_1,one) & refer(geschichte_1_1,refer_c) & varia(geschichte_1_1,varia_c) & sort(c40,d) & card(c40,int1) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & gener(c40,sp) & varia(c40,con) & sort(c41,na) & fact(c41,real) & quant(c41,one) & sort(firma_1_1,d) & card(firma_1_1,int1) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & gener(firma_1_1,ge) & card(name_1_1,int1) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & varia(name_1_1,varia_c) & sort(bmw_0,fe) & refer(name_1_1,refer_c) & quant(name_1_1,one) & gener(name_1_1,ge) & sort(name_1_1,na) & varia(firma_1_1,varia_c) & refer(firma_1_1,refer_c) & quant(firma_1_1,one) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & sort(firma_1_1,io) & varia(c41,varia_c) & refer(c41,indet) & gener(c41,sp) & etype(c41,int0) & card(c41,int1) & refer(c40,det) & quant(c40,one) & sort(c40,io) & gener(geschichte_1_1,ge) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & sort(geschichte_1_1,io) & sort(geschichte_1_1,d) & sort(behandeln_1_1,st) & varia(c25,con) & refer(c25,det) & quant(c25,one) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & sort(c25,ad) & quant(c3,one) & gener(c3,sp) & fact(c3,real) & card(c3,int1) & gener(c11,sp) & fact(c11,real) & sort(c11,st) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p',ave07_era5_synth_qa07_007_mira_wp_480)). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10195,plain,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & sort(c3,o) & etype(c3,int0) & refer(c3,det) & varia(c3,varia_c) & sort(c25,d) & sort(c25,io) & card(c25,int1) & gener(c25,sp) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & gener(behandeln_1_1,ge) & sort(geschichte_1_1,ad) & card(geschichte_1_1,int1) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & refer(geschichte_1_1,refer_c) & varia(geschichte_1_1,varia_c) & sort(c40,d) & card(c40,int1) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & gener(c40,sp) & varia(c40,con) & sort(c41,na) & fact(c41,real) & sort(firma_1_1,d) & card(firma_1_1,int1) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & gener(firma_1_1,ge) & card(name_1_1,int1) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & varia(name_1_1,varia_c) & sort(bmw_0,fe) & refer(name_1_1,refer_c) & gener(name_1_1,ge) & sort(name_1_1,na) & varia(firma_1_1,varia_c) & refer(firma_1_1,refer_c) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & sort(firma_1_1,io) & varia(c41,varia_c) & refer(c41,indet) & gener(c41,sp) & etype(c41,int0) & card(c41,int1) & refer(c40,det) & sort(c40,io) & gener(geschichte_1_1,ge) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & sort(geschichte_1_1,io) & sort(geschichte_1_1,d) & sort(behandeln_1_1,st) & varia(c25,con) & refer(c25,det) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & sort(c25,ad) & gener(c3,sp) & fact(c3,real) & card(c3,int1) & gener(c11,sp) & fact(c11,real) & sort(c11,st) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 inference(pure_predicate_removal,[],[f10188])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10205,plain,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & sort(c3,o) & etype(c3,int0) & refer(c3,det) & sort(c25,d) & sort(c25,io) & card(c25,int1) & gener(c25,sp) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & gener(behandeln_1_1,ge) & sort(geschichte_1_1,ad) & card(geschichte_1_1,int1) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & refer(geschichte_1_1,refer_c) & sort(c40,d) & card(c40,int1) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & gener(c40,sp) & sort(c41,na) & fact(c41,real) & sort(firma_1_1,d) & card(firma_1_1,int1) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & gener(firma_1_1,ge) & card(name_1_1,int1) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & sort(bmw_0,fe) & refer(name_1_1,refer_c) & gener(name_1_1,ge) & sort(name_1_1,na) & refer(firma_1_1,refer_c) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & sort(firma_1_1,io) & refer(c41,indet) & gener(c41,sp) & etype(c41,int0) & card(c41,int1) & refer(c40,det) & sort(c40,io) & gener(geschichte_1_1,ge) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & sort(geschichte_1_1,io) & sort(geschichte_1_1,d) & sort(behandeln_1_1,st) & refer(c25,det) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & sort(c25,ad) & gener(c3,sp) & fact(c3,real) & card(c3,int1) & gener(c11,sp) & fact(c11,real) & sort(c11,st) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 inference(pure_predicate_removal,[],[f10195])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10207,plain,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & etype(c3,int0) & refer(c3,det) & card(c25,int1) & gener(c25,sp) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & gener(behandeln_1_1,ge) & card(geschichte_1_1,int1) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & refer(geschichte_1_1,refer_c) & card(c40,int1) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & gener(c40,sp) & fact(c41,real) & card(firma_1_1,int1) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & gener(firma_1_1,ge) & card(name_1_1,int1) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & refer(name_1_1,refer_c) & gener(name_1_1,ge) & refer(firma_1_1,refer_c) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & refer(c41,indet) & gener(c41,sp) & etype(c41,int0) & card(c41,int1) & refer(c40,det) & gener(geschichte_1_1,ge) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & refer(c25,det) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & gener(c3,sp) & fact(c3,real) & card(c3,int1) & gener(c11,sp) & fact(c11,real) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 inference(pure_predicate_removal,[],[f10205])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10215,plain,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & etype(c3,int0) & refer(c3,det) & card(c25,int1) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & card(geschichte_1_1,int1) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & refer(geschichte_1_1,refer_c) & card(c40,int1) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & fact(c41,real) & card(firma_1_1,int1) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & card(name_1_1,int1) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & refer(name_1_1,refer_c) & refer(firma_1_1,refer_c) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & refer(c41,indet) & etype(c41,int0) & card(c41,int1) & refer(c40,det) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & refer(c25,det) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & fact(c3,real) & card(c3,int1) & fact(c11,real) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 inference(pure_predicate_removal,[],[f10207])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10225,plain,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & etype(c3,int0) & card(c25,int1) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & card(geschichte_1_1,int1) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & card(c40,int1) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & fact(c41,real) & card(firma_1_1,int1) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & card(name_1_1,int1) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & etype(c41,int0) & card(c41,int1) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & fact(c3,real) & card(c3,int1) & fact(c11,real) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 inference(pure_predicate_removal,[],[f10215])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f10230,plain,( 46.66/8.58 arg1(c11,c3) & arg2(c11,c25) & subs(c11,behandeln_1_1) & sub(c25,geschichte_1_1) & mcont(c3,c25) & attr(c40,c41) & sub(c40,firma_1_1) & etype(c3,int0) & fact(behandeln_1_1,real) & etype(geschichte_1_1,int0) & etype(c40,int0) & fact(c40,real) & fact(c41,real) & etype(firma_1_1,int0) & etype(name_1_1,int0) & fact(name_1_1,real) & fact(firma_1_1,real) & etype(c41,int0) & fact(geschichte_1_1,real) & fact(c25,hypo) & etype(c25,int0) & fact(c3,real) & fact(c11,real) & val(c41,bmw_0) & sub(c41,name_1_1) & attch(c40,c25)), 46.66/8.58 inference(pure_predicate_removal,[],[f10225])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f20882,plain,( 46.66/8.58 attr(c40,c41)), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10230])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f20881,plain,( 46.66/8.58 sub(c40,firma_1_1)), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10230])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f20864,plain,( 46.66/8.58 val(c41,bmw_0)), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10230])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 fof(f20863,plain,( 46.66/8.58 sub(c41,name_1_1)), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f10230])). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_8048,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ sub(X0,X1) | arg2(sK55(X0,X1),X1) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f18650]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63166,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) | arg2(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),firma_1_1) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_8048]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_10286,negated_conjecture, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(X0,X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X1,X2) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X3,X4) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X5,X6) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(X1,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(X2,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(X4,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(X2,bmw_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(X4,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f20888]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60128,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ attr(X0,X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X2,X3) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(X1,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(X4,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ obj(X5,c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,X4) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(X1,bmw_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(X4,bmw_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_10286]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60132,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ attr(X0,X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(X2,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ obj(X3,c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X4,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,X2) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(X2,bmw_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60128]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60138,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ attr(X0,X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ obj(X2,c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X3,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60132]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60140,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(sK19(X0,c40,X1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X2,X3) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X4,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60138]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60142,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(sK19(X0,c40,X1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X2,X3) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60140]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63146,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(sK19(sK55(c40,X0),c40,X1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(X2,X3) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60142]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63148,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(sK19(sK55(c40,X0),c40,X1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_63146]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63155,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(sK19(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40,X0),c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_63148]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63164,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ obj(sK19(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40,firma_1_1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ sub(c41,name_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ attr(c40,c41) 46.66/8.58 | ~ val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_63155]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_2688,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ arg2(X0,X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ arg1(X0,X2) 46.66/8.58 | ~ subr(X0,sub_0) 46.66/8.58 | obj(sK19(X0,X2,X1),X2) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f13295]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60144,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ arg2(X0,X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ subr(X0,sub_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ arg1(X0,c40) 46.66/8.58 | obj(sK19(X0,c40,X1),c40) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_2688]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_60146,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ arg2(sK55(X0,X1),X2) 46.66/8.58 | ~ subr(sK55(X0,X1),sub_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ arg1(sK55(X0,X1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | obj(sK19(sK55(X0,X1),c40,X2),c40) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60144]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_62642,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ arg2(sK55(c40,X0),X1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ subr(sK55(c40,X0),sub_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ arg1(sK55(c40,X0),c40) 46.66/8.58 | obj(sK19(sK55(c40,X0),c40,X1),c40) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_60146]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63151,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ arg2(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),X0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ subr(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),sub_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ arg1(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | obj(sK19(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40,X0),c40) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_62642]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63160,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ arg2(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),firma_1_1) 46.66/8.58 | ~ subr(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),sub_0) 46.66/8.58 | ~ arg1(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40) 46.66/8.58 | obj(sK19(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40,firma_1_1),c40) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_63151]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_8047,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ sub(X0,X1) | arg1(sK55(X0,X1),X0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f18651]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_63158,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) | arg1(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),c40) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_8047]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_8049,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ sub(X0,X1) | subr(sK55(X0,X1),sub_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f18649]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_61139,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( ~ sub(c40,firma_1_1) | subr(sK55(c40,firma_1_1),sub_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(instantiation,[status(thm)],[c_8049]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_10265,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( attr(c40,c41) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f20882]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_10266,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( sub(c40,firma_1_1) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f20881]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_10283,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( val(c41,bmw_0) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f20864]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(c_10284,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( sub(c41,name_1_1) ), 46.66/8.58 inference(cnf_transformation,[],[f20863]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 cnf(contradiction,plain, 46.66/8.58 ( $false ), 46.66/8.58 inference(minisat, 46.66/8.58 [status(thm)], 46.66/8.58 [c_63166,c_63164,c_63160,c_63158,c_61139,c_10265,c_10266, 46.66/8.58 c_10283,c_10284]) ). 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 % SZS output end CNFRefutation for theBenchmark.p 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Statistics 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 ------ Selected 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.58 total_time: 2.746 46.66/8.58 46.66/8.59 EOF