0.03/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.03/0.12 % Command : java -jar /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/mcs_scs.jar %d %s 0.12/0.33 % Computer : n029.cluster.edu 0.12/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.12/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.12/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.12/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.12/0.33 % CPULimit : 960 0.12/0.33 % WCLimit : 120 0.12/0.33 % DateTime : Tue Aug 9 02:26:24 EDT 2022 0.12/0.34 % CPUTime : 0.51/0.59 start to proof:theBenchmark 1.52/1.56 %------------------------------------------- 1.52/1.56 % File :CSE---1.5 1.52/1.56 % Problem :theBenchmark 1.52/1.56 % Transform :cnf 1.52/1.56 % Format :tptp:raw 1.52/1.56 % Command :java -jar mcs_scs.jar %d %s 1.52/1.56 1.52/1.56 % Result :Theorem 0.910000s 1.52/1.56 % Output :CNFRefutation 0.910000s 1.52/1.56 %------------------------------------------- 1.52/1.57 include('Axioms/CSR001+0.ax'). 1.52/1.57 include('Axioms/CSR001+2.ax'). 1.52/1.57 fof(plus0_0,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n0 = plus(n0,n0) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus0_2,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n2 = plus(n0,n2) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus3_3,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n6 = plus(n3,n3) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less_property,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X,Y] : 1.52/1.57 ( less(X,Y) 1.52/1.57 <=> ( X != Y 1.52/1.57 & ~ less(Y,X) ) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(not_releasedAt,hypothesis, 1.52/1.57 ! [Fluent,Time] : ~ releasedAt(Fluent,Time) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less1,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less_or_equal(X,n0) 1.52/1.57 <=> less(X,n1) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less9,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less_or_equal(X,n8) 1.52/1.57 <=> less(X,n9) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus0_1,axiom, 1.52/1.57 plus(n0,n1) = n1 ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less3,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less(X,n3) 1.52/1.57 <=> less_or_equal(X,n2) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus1_1,axiom, 1.52/1.57 plus(n1,n1) = n2 ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less4,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less_or_equal(X,n3) 1.52/1.57 <=> less(X,n4) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less0,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ~ ? [X] : less(X,n0) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less5,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less_or_equal(X,n4) 1.52/1.57 <=> less(X,n5) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus2_2,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n4 = plus(n2,n2) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less7,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less(X,n7) 1.52/1.57 <=> less_or_equal(X,n6) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less_or_equal,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X,Y] : 1.52/1.57 ( less_or_equal(X,Y) 1.52/1.57 <=> ( X = Y 1.52/1.57 | less(X,Y) ) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(not_forwards_0,hypothesis, 1.52/1.57 ~ holdsAt(forwards,n0) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus2_3,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n5 = plus(n2,n3) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(not_splinning_0,hypothesis, 1.52/1.57 ~ holdsAt(spinning,n0) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less6,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less(X,n6) 1.52/1.57 <=> less_or_equal(X,n5) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus1_2,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n3 = plus(n1,n2) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(not_backwards_0,hypothesis, 1.52/1.57 ~ holdsAt(backwards,n0) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less8,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less_or_equal(X,n7) 1.52/1.57 <=> less(X,n8) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus0_3,axiom, 1.52/1.57 plus(n0,n3) = n3 ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(less2,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X] : 1.52/1.57 ( less(X,n2) 1.52/1.57 <=> less_or_equal(X,n1) ) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(symmetry_of_plus,axiom, 1.52/1.57 ! [X,Y] : plus(X,Y) = plus(Y,X) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(plus1_3,axiom, 1.52/1.57 n4 = plus(n1,n3) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 fof(not_spinning_1,conjecture, 1.52/1.57 ~ holdsAt(spinning,n1) ). 1.52/1.57 1.52/1.57 %------------------------------------------- 1.52/1.57 % Proof found 1.52/1.57 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 1.52/1.57 % SZS output start Proof 1.52/1.57 %ClaNum:245(EqnAxiom:67) 1.52/1.57 %VarNum:595(SingletonVarNum:258) 1.52/1.57 %MaxLitNum:6 1.52/1.57 %MaxfuncDepth:1 1.52/1.57 %SharedTerms:43 1.52/1.57 %goalClause: 78 1.52/1.57 %singleGoalClaCount:1 1.52/1.57 [78]P1(a22,a14) 1.52/1.57 [80]~E(a2,a3) 1.52/1.57 [81]~E(a23,a24) 1.52/1.57 [82]~E(a3,a22) 1.52/1.57 [83]~E(a2,a22) 1.52/1.57 [84]~P1(a3,a1) 1.52/1.57 [85]~P1(a2,a1) 1.52/1.57 [86]~P1(a22,a1) 1.52/1.57 [68]E(f12(a1,a1),a1) 1.52/1.57 [69]E(f12(a1,a13),a13) 1.52/1.57 [70]E(f12(a15,a15),a16) 1.52/1.57 [71]E(f12(a14,a13),a15) 1.52/1.57 [72]E(f12(a14,a15),a17) 1.52/1.57 [73]E(f12(a13,a13),a17) 1.52/1.57 [74]E(f12(a13,a15),a18) 1.52/1.57 [75]E(f12(a14,a14),a13) 1.52/1.57 [76]E(f12(a1,a14),a14) 1.52/1.57 [77]E(f12(a1,a15),a15) 1.52/1.57 [87]~P7(x871,a1) 1.52/1.57 [88]~P9(x881,x882) 1.52/1.57 [79]E(f12(x791,x792),f12(x792,x791)) 1.52/1.57 [89]~P11(x891,x892,x893) 1.52/1.57 [113]~P10(x1131,a1)+P7(x1131,a14) 1.52/1.57 [114]~P10(x1141,a14)+P7(x1141,a13) 1.52/1.57 [115]~P10(x1151,a18)+P7(x1151,a16) 1.52/1.57 [116]~P10(x1161,a13)+P7(x1161,a15) 1.52/1.57 [117]~P10(x1171,a20)+P7(x1171,a19) 1.52/1.57 [118]~P10(x1181,a19)+P7(x1181,a21) 1.52/1.57 [119]~P10(x1191,a15)+P7(x1191,a17) 1.52/1.57 [120]~P10(x1201,a17)+P7(x1201,a18) 1.52/1.57 [121]~P10(x1211,a16)+P7(x1211,a20) 1.52/1.57 [122]~P7(x1221,a13)+P10(x1221,a14) 1.52/1.57 [123]~P7(x1231,a14)+P10(x1231,a1) 1.52/1.57 [124]~P7(x1241,a15)+P10(x1241,a13) 1.52/1.57 [125]~P7(x1251,a20)+P10(x1251,a16) 1.52/1.57 [126]~P7(x1261,a17)+P10(x1261,a15) 1.52/1.57 [127]~P7(x1271,a21)+P10(x1271,a19) 1.52/1.57 [128]~P7(x1281,a18)+P10(x1281,a17) 1.52/1.57 [129]~P7(x1291,a16)+P10(x1291,a18) 1.52/1.57 [130]~P7(x1301,a19)+P10(x1301,a20) 1.52/1.57 [90]~E(x901,x902)+P10(x901,x902) 1.52/1.57 [96]~P7(x961,x962)+~E(x961,x962) 1.52/1.57 [131]~P7(x1311,x1312)+P10(x1311,x1312) 1.52/1.57 [133]~P7(x1332,x1331)+~P7(x1331,x1332) 1.52/1.57 [143]~P6(x1432,x1431,x1433)+E(a24,x1431) 1.52/1.57 [192]~P4(x1923,x1921,x1922)+P8(x1921,x1922,x1923) 1.52/1.57 [193]~P3(x1931,x1933,x1932)+P12(x1931,x1932,x1933) 1.52/1.57 [194]~P8(x1942,x1943,x1941)+P4(x1941,x1942,x1943) 1.52/1.57 [195]~P6(x1953,x1951,x1952)+P3(x1951,x1952,x1953) 1.52/1.57 [196]~P12(x1961,x1963,x1962)+P3(x1961,x1962,x1963) 1.52/1.57 [233]~P13(x2331,x2333,x2332)+P7(x2331,f6(x2331,x2332,x2333)) 1.52/1.57 [234]~P14(x2341,x2342,x2343)+P7(x2341,f10(x2341,x2342,x2343)) 1.52/1.57 [235]~P13(x2351,x2353,x2352)+P7(f6(x2351,x2352,x2353),x2352) 1.52/1.57 [236]~P14(x2361,x2362,x2363)+P7(f10(x2361,x2362,x2363),x2363) 1.52/1.57 [240]~P13(x2401,x2403,x2402)+P2(f7(x2401,x2402,x2403),f6(x2401,x2402,x2403)) 1.52/1.57 [241]~P14(x2411,x2412,x2413)+P2(f11(x2411,x2412,x2413),f10(x2411,x2412,x2413)) 1.52/1.57 [242]~P13(x2421,x2423,x2422)+P8(f7(x2421,x2422,x2423),x2423,f6(x2421,x2422,x2423)) 1.52/1.57 [243]~P14(x2431,x2432,x2433)+P12(f11(x2431,x2432,x2433),x2432,f10(x2431,x2432,x2433)) 1.52/1.57 [91]P2(x911,x912)+~E(x911,a23)+~E(a13,x912) 1.52/1.57 [92]P2(x921,x922)+~E(x922,a1)+~E(a23,x921) 1.52/1.57 [93]P2(x931,x932)+~E(x932,a14)+~E(a24,x931) 1.52/1.57 [94]P2(x941,x942)+~E(a24,x941)+~E(a13,x942) 1.52/1.57 [95]~P2(x951,x952)+E(a23,x951)+E(a24,x951) 1.52/1.57 [112]P7(x1122,x1121)+P7(x1121,x1122)+E(x1121,x1122) 1.52/1.57 [132]P7(x1321,x1322)+~P10(x1321,x1322)+E(x1321,x1322) 1.52/1.57 [144]~P6(x1441,x1442,x1443)+E(x1441,a2)+E(x1441,a3) 1.52/1.57 [145]~P4(x1452,x1451,x1453)+E(x1451,a23)+E(x1451,a24) 1.52/1.57 [148]~P4(x1483,x1481,x1482)+E(x1481,a24)+E(a3,x1482) 1.52/1.57 [160]~P6(x1601,x1603,x1602)+E(x1601,a3)+P2(a23,x1602) 1.52/1.57 [161]~P6(x1613,x1611,x1612)+E(x1611,a24)+P2(a23,x1612) 1.52/1.57 [162]~P6(x1621,x1623,x1622)+E(a3,x1621)+P2(a23,x1622) 1.52/1.57 [174]~P4(x1742,x1741,x1743)+E(x1741,a24)+~P2(a24,x1742) 1.52/1.57 [206]~P8(x2063,x2061,x2062)+~P2(x2063,x2062)+P1(x2061,f12(x2062,a14)) 1.52/1.57 [225]~P2(x2251,x2252)+~P12(x2251,x2253,x2252)+~P1(x2253,f12(x2252,a14)) 1.52/1.57 [97]~P2(x971,x972)+E(a24,x971)+E(x971,a23)+E(x972,a1) 1.52/1.57 [98]~P2(x982,x981)+E(x981,a1)+E(a13,x981)+E(x981,a14) 1.52/1.57 [101]~P2(x1012,x1011)+E(a13,x1011)+E(x1011,a14)+E(a23,x1012) 1.52/1.57 [103]~P2(x1032,x1031)+E(a13,x1031)+E(x1031,a1)+E(a24,x1032) 1.52/1.58 [191]~P1(x1911,x1912)+P2(f8(x1911,x1912),x1912)+P1(x1911,f12(x1912,a14))+P9(x1911,f12(x1912,a14)) 1.52/1.58 [207]P1(x2071,x2072)+P2(f9(x2071,x2072),x2072)+~P1(x2071,f12(x2072,a14))+P9(x2071,f12(x2072,a14)) 1.52/1.58 [226]~P1(x2261,x2262)+P12(f8(x2261,x2262),x2261,x2262)+P1(x2261,f12(x2262,a14))+P9(x2261,f12(x2262,a14)) 1.52/1.58 [232]P1(x2321,x2322)+P8(f9(x2321,x2322),x2321,x2322)+~P1(x2321,f12(x2322,a14))+P9(x2321,f12(x2322,a14)) 1.52/1.58 [134]P3(x1342,x1341,x1343)+~E(x1343,a22)+~E(x1342,a23)+P2(a24,x1341) 1.52/1.58 [135]P4(x1351,x1352,x1353)+~E(x1352,a23)+~E(a3,x1353)+P2(a24,x1351) 1.52/1.58 [136]P3(x1362,x1361,x1363)+~E(x1363,a2)+~E(a23,x1362)+P2(a24,x1361) 1.52/1.58 [137]P4(x1371,x1372,x1373)+~E(x1372,a24)+~E(a2,x1373)+P2(a23,x1371) 1.52/1.58 [138]P3(x1382,x1381,x1383)+~E(x1382,a24)+~E(a22,x1383)+P2(a23,x1381) 1.52/1.58 [139]P6(x1392,x1393,x1391)+~E(x1393,a24)+~E(a3,x1392)+P2(a23,x1391) 1.52/1.58 [140]P4(x1401,x1402,x1403)+~E(x1403,a22)+~E(a24,x1402)+~P2(a23,x1401) 1.52/1.58 [141]P6(x1411,x1412,x1413)+~E(x1411,a2)+~E(a24,x1412)+~P2(a23,x1413) 1.52/1.58 [142]P6(x1421,x1422,x1423)+~E(x1421,a3)+~E(a24,x1422)+~P2(a23,x1423) 1.52/1.58 [154]~P4(x1543,x1542,x1541)+E(a2,x1541)+E(x1541,a22)+E(x1542,a23) 1.52/1.58 [156]~P4(x1563,x1561,x1562)+E(a24,x1561)+E(x1561,a23)+E(a2,x1562) 1.52/1.58 [157]~P4(x1572,x1573,x1571)+E(a3,x1571)+E(a2,x1571)+E(x1571,a22) 1.52/1.58 [158]~P4(x1583,x1582,x1581)+E(a2,x1581)+E(a3,x1581)+E(a24,x1582) 1.52/1.58 [170]~P4(x1703,x1701,x1702)+E(x1701,a23)+E(a2,x1702)+P2(a23,x1703) 1.52/1.58 [173]~P4(x1732,x1733,x1731)+E(a2,x1731)+E(a3,x1731)+P2(a23,x1732) 1.52/1.58 [177]~P4(x1773,x1772,x1771)+E(x1771,a22)+E(x1772,a23)+~P2(a23,x1773) 1.52/1.58 [180]~P4(x1802,x1803,x1801)+E(a2,x1801)+E(x1801,a22)+~P2(a24,x1802) 1.52/1.58 [182]~P4(x1822,x1821,x1823)+E(a24,x1821)+E(x1821,a23)+~P2(a23,x1822) 1.52/1.58 [183]~P4(x1832,x1833,x1831)+E(a3,x1831)+E(x1831,a22)+~P2(a23,x1832) 1.52/1.58 [184]~P4(x1843,x1842,x1841)+E(a3,x1841)+E(a24,x1842)+~P2(a23,x1843) 1.52/1.58 [185]~P4(x1853,x1852,x1851)+E(a2,x1851)+E(a24,x1852)+~P2(a24,x1853) 1.52/1.58 [188]~P4(x1882,x1883,x1881)+~P2(a24,x1882)+E(a2,x1881)+P2(a23,x1882) 1.52/1.58 [189]~P4(x1892,x1893,x1891)+~P2(a23,x1892)+E(x1891,a22)+~P2(a24,x1892) 1.52/1.58 [190]~P4(x1902,x1901,x1903)+~P2(a23,x1902)+E(a24,x1901)+~P2(a24,x1902) 1.52/1.58 [197]~P3(x1972,x1973,x1971)+P6(x1971,x1972,x1973)+E(a22,x1971)+E(x1971,a2) 1.52/1.58 [198]~P3(x1981,x1983,x1982)+P6(x1982,x1981,x1983)+E(a23,x1981)+E(x1981,a24) 1.52/1.58 [200]~P3(x2001,x2003,x2002)+P6(x2002,x2001,x2003)+E(a23,x2001)+E(a22,x2002) 1.52/1.58 [209]~P3(x2091,x2093,x2092)+P6(x2092,x2091,x2093)+~P2(a24,x2093)+E(x2091,a24) 1.52/1.58 [210]~P3(x2101,x2103,x2102)+P6(x2102,x2101,x2103)+~P2(a23,x2103)+E(a23,x2101) 1.52/1.58 [212]~P3(x2122,x2123,x2121)+P6(x2121,x2122,x2123)+~P2(a24,x2123)+E(a22,x2121) 1.52/1.58 [227]~P3(x2272,x2273,x2271)+P6(x2271,x2272,x2273)+~P2(a24,x2273)+~P2(a23,x2273) 1.52/1.58 [201]~P3(x2011,x2013,x2012)+P6(x2012,x2011,x2013)+E(x2011,a23)+E(x2011,a24)+E(x2012,a2) 1.52/1.58 [202]~P3(x2021,x2023,x2022)+P6(x2022,x2021,x2023)+E(x2022,a22)+E(x2021,a24)+E(x2022,a2) 1.52/1.58 [213]~P3(x2131,x2133,x2132)+P6(x2132,x2131,x2133)+~P2(a23,x2133)+E(x2131,a23)+E(x2132,a2) 1.52/1.58 [217]~P3(x2172,x2173,x2171)+P6(x2171,x2172,x2173)+E(x2171,a22)+~P2(a23,x2173)+E(x2171,a2) 1.52/1.58 [237]~P7(x2371,x2375)+~P7(x2375,x2373)+~P8(x2374,x2372,x2375)+P13(x2371,x2372,x2373)+~P2(x2374,x2375) 1.52/1.58 [238]~P7(x2381,x2385)+~P7(x2385,x2383)+~P12(x2384,x2382,x2385)+P14(x2381,x2382,x2383)+~P2(x2384,x2385) 1.52/1.58 [244]~P12(x2445,x2444,x2442)+~P5(x2444,x2442,x2441,x2443)+~P2(x2445,x2442)+P13(x2442,x2444,f12(x2442,x2443))+~P7(a1,x2443)+P1(x2441,f12(x2442,x2443)) 1.52/1.58 [245]~P8(x2455,x2454,x2452)+~P15(x2454,x2452,x2451,x2453)+~P2(x2455,x2452)+P14(x2452,x2454,f12(x2452,x2453))+~P7(a1,x2453)+P1(x2451,f12(x2452,x2453)) 1.52/1.58 %EqnAxiom 1.52/1.58 [1]E(x11,x11) 1.52/1.58 [2]E(x22,x21)+~E(x21,x22) 1.52/1.58 [3]E(x31,x33)+~E(x31,x32)+~E(x32,x33) 1.52/1.58 [4]~E(x41,x42)+E(f12(x41,x43),f12(x42,x43)) 1.52/1.58 [5]~E(x51,x52)+E(f12(x53,x51),f12(x53,x52)) 1.52/1.58 [6]~E(x61,x62)+E(f10(x61,x63,x64),f10(x62,x63,x64)) 1.52/1.58 [7]~E(x71,x72)+E(f10(x73,x71,x74),f10(x73,x72,x74)) 1.52/1.58 [8]~E(x81,x82)+E(f10(x83,x84,x81),f10(x83,x84,x82)) 1.52/1.58 [9]~E(x91,x92)+E(f11(x91,x93,x94),f11(x92,x93,x94)) 1.52/1.58 [10]~E(x101,x102)+E(f11(x103,x101,x104),f11(x103,x102,x104)) 1.52/1.58 [11]~E(x111,x112)+E(f11(x113,x114,x111),f11(x113,x114,x112)) 1.52/1.58 [12]~E(x121,x122)+E(f6(x121,x123,x124),f6(x122,x123,x124)) 1.52/1.58 [13]~E(x131,x132)+E(f6(x133,x131,x134),f6(x133,x132,x134)) 1.52/1.58 [14]~E(x141,x142)+E(f6(x143,x144,x141),f6(x143,x144,x142)) 1.52/1.58 [15]~E(x151,x152)+E(f7(x151,x153,x154),f7(x152,x153,x154)) 1.52/1.58 [16]~E(x161,x162)+E(f7(x163,x161,x164),f7(x163,x162,x164)) 1.52/1.58 [17]~E(x171,x172)+E(f7(x173,x174,x171),f7(x173,x174,x172)) 1.52/1.58 [18]~E(x181,x182)+E(f9(x181,x183),f9(x182,x183)) 1.52/1.58 [19]~E(x191,x192)+E(f9(x193,x191),f9(x193,x192)) 1.52/1.58 [20]~E(x201,x202)+E(f8(x201,x203),f8(x202,x203)) 1.52/1.58 [21]~E(x211,x212)+E(f8(x213,x211),f8(x213,x212)) 1.52/1.58 [22]~E(x221,x222)+E(f4(x221,x223),f4(x222,x223)) 1.52/1.58 [23]~E(x231,x232)+E(f4(x233,x231),f4(x233,x232)) 1.52/1.58 [24]~E(x241,x242)+E(f5(x241,x243),f5(x242,x243)) 1.52/1.58 [25]~E(x251,x252)+E(f5(x253,x251),f5(x253,x252)) 1.52/1.58 [26]P1(x262,x263)+~E(x261,x262)+~P1(x261,x263) 1.52/1.58 [27]P1(x273,x272)+~E(x271,x272)+~P1(x273,x271) 1.52/1.58 [28]P15(x282,x283,x284,x285)+~E(x281,x282)+~P15(x281,x283,x284,x285) 1.52/1.58 [29]P15(x293,x292,x294,x295)+~E(x291,x292)+~P15(x293,x291,x294,x295) 1.52/1.58 [30]P15(x303,x304,x302,x305)+~E(x301,x302)+~P15(x303,x304,x301,x305) 1.52/1.58 [31]P15(x313,x314,x315,x312)+~E(x311,x312)+~P15(x313,x314,x315,x311) 1.52/1.58 [32]P8(x322,x323,x324)+~E(x321,x322)+~P8(x321,x323,x324) 1.52/1.58 [33]P8(x333,x332,x334)+~E(x331,x332)+~P8(x333,x331,x334) 1.52/1.58 [34]P8(x343,x344,x342)+~E(x341,x342)+~P8(x343,x344,x341) 1.52/1.58 [35]P7(x352,x353)+~E(x351,x352)+~P7(x351,x353) 1.52/1.58 [36]P7(x363,x362)+~E(x361,x362)+~P7(x363,x361) 1.52/1.58 [37]P9(x372,x373)+~E(x371,x372)+~P9(x371,x373) 1.52/1.58 [38]P9(x383,x382)+~E(x381,x382)+~P9(x383,x381) 1.52/1.58 [39]P3(x392,x393,x394)+~E(x391,x392)+~P3(x391,x393,x394) 1.52/1.58 [40]P3(x403,x402,x404)+~E(x401,x402)+~P3(x403,x401,x404) 1.52/1.58 [41]P3(x413,x414,x412)+~E(x411,x412)+~P3(x413,x414,x411) 1.52/1.58 [42]P11(x422,x423,x424)+~E(x421,x422)+~P11(x421,x423,x424) 1.52/1.58 [43]P11(x433,x432,x434)+~E(x431,x432)+~P11(x433,x431,x434) 1.52/1.58 [44]P11(x443,x444,x442)+~E(x441,x442)+~P11(x443,x444,x441) 1.52/1.58 [45]P10(x452,x453)+~E(x451,x452)+~P10(x451,x453) 1.52/1.58 [46]P10(x463,x462)+~E(x461,x462)+~P10(x463,x461) 1.52/1.58 [47]P2(x472,x473)+~E(x471,x472)+~P2(x471,x473) 1.52/1.58 [48]P2(x483,x482)+~E(x481,x482)+~P2(x483,x481) 1.52/1.58 [49]P12(x492,x493,x494)+~E(x491,x492)+~P12(x491,x493,x494) 1.52/1.58 [50]P12(x503,x502,x504)+~E(x501,x502)+~P12(x503,x501,x504) 1.52/1.58 [51]P12(x513,x514,x512)+~E(x511,x512)+~P12(x513,x514,x511) 1.52/1.58 [52]P13(x522,x523,x524)+~E(x521,x522)+~P13(x521,x523,x524) 1.52/1.58 [53]P13(x533,x532,x534)+~E(x531,x532)+~P13(x533,x531,x534) 1.52/1.58 [54]P13(x543,x544,x542)+~E(x541,x542)+~P13(x543,x544,x541) 1.52/1.58 [55]P5(x552,x553,x554,x555)+~E(x551,x552)+~P5(x551,x553,x554,x555) 1.52/1.58 [56]P5(x563,x562,x564,x565)+~E(x561,x562)+~P5(x563,x561,x564,x565) 1.52/1.58 [57]P5(x573,x574,x572,x575)+~E(x571,x572)+~P5(x573,x574,x571,x575) 1.52/1.58 [58]P5(x583,x584,x585,x582)+~E(x581,x582)+~P5(x583,x584,x585,x581) 1.52/1.58 [59]P6(x592,x593,x594)+~E(x591,x592)+~P6(x591,x593,x594) 1.52/1.58 [60]P6(x603,x602,x604)+~E(x601,x602)+~P6(x603,x601,x604) 1.52/1.58 [61]P6(x613,x614,x612)+~E(x611,x612)+~P6(x613,x614,x611) 1.52/1.58 [62]P4(x622,x623,x624)+~E(x621,x622)+~P4(x621,x623,x624) 1.52/1.58 [63]P4(x633,x632,x634)+~E(x631,x632)+~P4(x633,x631,x634) 1.52/1.58 [64]P4(x643,x644,x642)+~E(x641,x642)+~P4(x643,x644,x641) 1.52/1.58 [65]P14(x652,x653,x654)+~E(x651,x652)+~P14(x651,x653,x654) 1.52/1.58 [66]P14(x663,x662,x664)+~E(x661,x662)+~P14(x663,x661,x664) 1.52/1.58 [67]P14(x673,x674,x672)+~E(x671,x672)+~P14(x673,x674,x671) 1.52/1.58 1.52/1.58 %------------------------------------------- 1.52/1.58 cnf(246,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(a1,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,2])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(248,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(x2481,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(rename_variables,[],[87])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(251,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(x2511,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(rename_variables,[],[87])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(253,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(f12(x2531,x2532),f12(x2532,x2531))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,248,79,68,2,236,235,96])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(256,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~E(a14,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(257,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x2571,a23,a22)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(259,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P7(a1,a14)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(260,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(x2601,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(rename_variables,[],[87])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(268,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(f9(x2681,f12(a1,a1)),f9(x2681,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(270,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(f7(x2701,x2702,f12(a1,a1)),f7(x2701,x2702,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(271,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(f7(x2711,f12(a1,a1),x2712),f7(x2711,a1,x2712))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(282,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(f12(x2821,f12(a1,a1)),f12(x2821,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(283,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(f12(f12(a1,a1),x2831),f12(a1,x2831))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(284,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(a1,a14)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(286,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(a1,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(288,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P7(a1,a13)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123,114])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(290,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(f12(x2901,x2902),f12(x2902,x2901))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123,114,90])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(292,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P14(x2921,x2922,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123,114,90,67])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(294,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P13(x2941,x2942,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123,114,90,67,64,54])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(295,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(x2951,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,260,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123,114,90,67,64,54,36])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(296,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P10(a14,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[78,87,248,251,260,81,82,86,79,68,2,236,235,96,27,3,148,112,25,24,23,22,21,20,19,18,17,16,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,131,123,114,90,67,64,54,36,132])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(326,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(a14,a14)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[296,123])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(328,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~E(a1,a14)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[259,296,123,96])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(330,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P7(f12(a1,a1),a13)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[259,288,296,246,123,96,35])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(332,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P7(f12(a1,a1),a14)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[84,68,259,288,296,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(335,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(a14,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[84,76,68,259,288,296,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(336,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~E(a3,a2)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,84,76,68,259,288,296,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36,2])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(337,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P14(x3371,x3372,f12(a1,f12(a1,a1)))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,84,76,68,259,288,296,292,282,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36,2,67])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(338,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(f12(x3381,f12(a1,a1)),f12(x3381,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(rename_variables,[],[282])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(342,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P13(x3421,x3422,f12(a1,f12(a1,a1)))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,84,76,68,259,284,286,288,296,292,294,282,338,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36,2,67,46,45,3,54])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(347,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P6(x3471,x3472,f12(a1,a13))+P6(x3471,x3472,a13)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,84,69,76,88,68,259,284,286,288,296,292,294,282,338,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36,2,67,46,45,3,54,232,61])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(349,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x3491,a23,x3492)+P6(a13,x3493,a13)+~P2(a24,x3491)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,84,69,76,81,88,68,259,284,286,288,296,292,294,282,338,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36,2,67,46,45,3,54,232,61,59,174])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(355,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P6(a2,x3551,x3552)+P6(a13,x3553,a13)+P2(a23,x3552)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,84,69,76,81,88,82,68,259,284,286,288,296,292,294,282,338,295,246,256,123,96,35,27,112,36,2,67,46,45,3,54,232,61,59,174,162,161,160])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(373,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x3731,a23,a2)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,81,336,332,123,96,148])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(376,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(f12(a1,a14),a14)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,76,81,326,336,332,123,96,148,27,35])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(377,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~E(a13,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,76,81,326,336,332,330,123,96,148,27,35,36])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(380,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P10(a14,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,76,81,326,336,332,330,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(381,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P10(f12(a1,a14),a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,76,81,326,336,332,330,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(385,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x3851,x3852,a2)+~P2(a23,x3851)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,76,81,326,336,332,330,270,271,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(387,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P2(a24,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,76,81,328,326,336,332,330,270,271,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(395,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P2(a23,a1)+~P10(f12(a15,a15),a18)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,76,81,328,326,336,332,330,335,270,271,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101,62,90,48,112,115])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(397,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P12(f8(a22,a14),a22,a14)+~P2(a23,a1)+P1(a22,f12(a14,a14))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,88,76,81,328,326,336,332,330,335,270,271,78,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101,62,90,48,112,115,226])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(398,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P9(x3981,x3982)), 1.52/1.58 inference(rename_variables,[],[88])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(400,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P2(a23,a1)+P2(f9(a2,a1),a1)+~P1(a2,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,88,398,76,81,328,326,336,332,330,335,270,271,78,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101,62,90,48,112,115,226,207])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(403,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x4031,x4032,a22)+~P2(a23,a1)+~P2(a24,x4031)+E(a24,x4032)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,88,398,76,81,328,326,336,332,330,335,270,271,78,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101,62,90,48,112,115,226,207,185])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(407,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x4071,x4072,a3)+~P2(a24,x4071)+~P2(a23,a1)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,80,88,398,76,82,81,328,326,336,332,330,335,270,271,78,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101,62,90,48,112,115,226,207,185,184,180])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(409,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P4(x4091,x4092,a3)+~P2(a23,a1)+~P2(a23,x4091)+E(x4092,a23)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,85,70,87,83,80,88,398,76,82,81,328,326,336,332,330,335,270,271,78,296,123,96,148,27,35,36,2,46,45,3,183,101,62,90,48,112,115,226,207,185,184,180,177])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(413,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(f12(a14,a13),a15)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,330,96,90])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(416,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~E(a22,a2)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,83,76,376,330,96,90,36,2])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(417,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(a15,f12(a13,a14))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,83,76,376,290,330,96,90,36,2,45])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(418,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(f12(x4181,x4182),f12(x4182,x4181))), 1.52/1.58 inference(rename_variables,[],[290])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(419,plain, 1.52/1.58 (P10(f12(a13,a14),a15)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,83,76,376,290,418,330,96,90,36,2,45,46])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(425,plain, 1.52/1.58 (E(a14,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,83,76,81,79,376,290,418,330,335,96,90,36,2,45,46,3,200,112])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(427,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P1(a22,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,71,86,83,76,81,79,376,290,418,330,335,96,90,36,2,45,46,3,200,112,27])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(428,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~E(a1,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,71,86,83,76,81,79,376,290,418,259,330,335,96,90,36,2,45,46,3,200,112,27,35])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(440,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P3(a24,x4401,a22)+~P3(a24,f12(a1,a13),a2)+~P2(a23,x4401)+E(a22,a3)), 1.52/1.58 inference(scs_inference,[],[68,71,86,83,76,81,79,376,290,418,259,330,335,96,90,36,2,45,46,3,200,112,27,35,347,195,119,355,144,227,210])). 1.52/1.58 cnf(447,plain, 1.52/1.58 (~P7(f12(a1,a13),a13)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,96])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(451,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(a1,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,87,428,381,96,90,112])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(454,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P1(a22,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,87,425,428,381,78,96,90,112,27])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(455,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(f12(a14,a1),a14)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,87,79,425,428,381,78,376,96,90,112,27,35])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(456,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x4561,x4562),f12(x4562,x4561))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(458,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(a13,f12(a1,a13))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,87,79,425,428,381,78,376,96,90,112,27,35,36,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(459,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(a15,a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,87,71,79,425,428,413,381,78,376,96,90,112,27,35,36,2,45])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(465,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(a1,x4651,a22)+~P12(a23,a22,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,87,83,71,82,79,456,377,425,428,413,417,381,78,376,96,90,112,27,35,36,2,45,46,3,225,173])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(487,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(x4871,f9(a22,a1),x4872)+~P12(a23,a22,a1)+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,86,87,88,80,83,246,71,82,81,79,456,387,377,425,428,413,417,381,78,376,68,96,90,112,27,35,36,2,45,46,3,225,173,113,114,162,160,207,131,47,161,61,48,206,145])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(504,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P8(f9(a22,a1),a22,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[86,88,454,232])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(507,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P4(a1,f9(a22,a1),a22)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[86,88,454,232,194])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(509,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P4(f12(a1,a1),f9(a22,a1),a22)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[86,88,246,454,232,194,62])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(512,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P8(f9(a22,a1),a22,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[86,88,246,451,454,232,194,62,131,34])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(513,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f9(a22,a1),a24)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[86,88,246,82,451,454,232,194,62,131,34,148])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(517,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(f12(a1,a13),a13)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,86,88,246,82,451,454,288,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(519,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P2(a24,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,86,88,246,82,451,454,387,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(520,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a22,a3)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,86,88,246,82,451,454,387,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(521,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(f12(a1,a1),f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,86,88,246,82,451,454,387,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(522,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(f12(a1,a14),f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,86,88,246,76,82,380,451,454,387,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(523,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(a14,a14),f12(a1,a13))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,387,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(526,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P6(a22,x5261,x5262)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(528,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(a24,f9(a22,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(530,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(532,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P12(a23,a22,f12(a1,a1))+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(533,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(f9(a22,a1),f12(a1,a14))+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(535,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a23,a1)+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(537,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(f9(a22,a1),f12(a1,a13))+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173,94])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(539,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a24,f12(a1,a14))+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173,94,47])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(540,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(a1,x5401,a2)+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173,94,47,385])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(542,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(f12(a1,a13),a15)+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173,94,47,385,116])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(544,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(f12(a1,a14),x5441,a3)+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173,94,47,385,116,407])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(558,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P3(x5581,a1,x5582)+~P4(f12(a1,a14),a3,a22)+~E(x5581,a23)+~E(x5582,a22)+E(f9(a22,a1),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[69,75,86,88,83,246,76,82,380,451,454,458,257,387,416,288,68,232,194,62,131,34,148,96,90,48,2,35,45,3,487,144,158,63,51,93,173,94,47,385,116,407,400,397,440,409,403,142,136,134])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(565,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P3(a24,f12(a1,a13),a2)+~P2(a23,x5651)+~P3(a24,x5651,a22)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[520,440])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(568,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P12(a23,a22,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[507,465])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(572,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a24,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[530,544,539])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(573,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(f9(a22,a1),f12(a1,a13))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[530,544,539,537])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(574,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(f9(a22,a1),f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[530,544,539,537,533])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(575,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(x5751,f9(a22,a1),a3)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,82,530,544,539,537,533,154])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(577,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a23,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,83,82,509,530,544,539,537,533,154,170])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(580,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P6(a22,x5801,x5802)), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[526])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(593,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x5931,f12(a15,a15)),f12(x5931,a16))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,80,83,81,82,526,509,530,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(610,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(f12(a14,a15),a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,526,373,512,513,509,530,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(614,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P2(f9(a22,a1),f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,526,373,522,512,513,519,509,530,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(615,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(f12(a1,a13),f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,526,373,522,512,513,519,509,530,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(618,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(a17,f12(a14,a15))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,526,373,253,522,521,512,513,519,509,530,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48,35,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(623,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(f12(a1,a13),a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,79,526,373,253,522,521,512,513,519,509,530,290,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48,35,2,45,3,542])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(625,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a23,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,79,526,373,253,522,521,512,513,519,509,530,290,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48,35,2,45,3,542,540,535])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(626,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P12(a23,a22,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,79,526,373,253,522,521,512,513,519,509,530,290,336,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48,35,2,45,3,542,540,535,532])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(630,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P6(a22,x6301,x6302)), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[526])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(634,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(f12(a1,a14),a23,x6341)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,81,82,79,526,580,373,253,522,521,512,513,519,509,530,290,336,416,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48,35,2,45,3,542,540,535,532,565,213,133,174])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(644,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P3(a24,a1,a22)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,72,80,83,246,81,82,79,526,580,630,373,253,522,521,512,513,519,509,530,290,336,416,544,539,537,533,154,170,210,183,22,21,18,17,15,12,11,10,6,5,4,32,194,25,24,23,20,19,16,14,13,9,8,7,63,96,90,47,48,35,2,45,3,542,540,535,532,565,213,133,174,209,195,119,60,40])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(645,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(f12(a15,a15),a18)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[625,395])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(650,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(x6501,x6502,a3)+~P2(a24,x6501)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[625,407])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(651,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(x6511,x6512,a3)+E(x6512,a23)+~P2(a23,x6511)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[625,409])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(659,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(f12(a1,a14),a3,a22)+P3(x6591,a1,x6592)+~E(x6592,a22)+~E(x6591,a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[530,558])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(661,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P3(f9(a22,a1),a1,a22)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[644,513,39])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(662,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(a15,a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[644,459,513,39,119])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(666,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a13,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[644,459,614,623,528,513,39,119,131,94])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(669,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x6691,x6692),f12(x6692,x6691))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(671,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x6711,x6712),f12(x6712,x6711))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(672,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(f12(a1,a13),a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[79,669,644,459,614,623,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(676,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a23,f9(a22,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,79,669,644,459,614,577,623,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(678,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a15,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,79,669,644,459,614,577,574,623,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(680,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(f12(a15,a14),a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,79,669,671,644,459,614,577,574,610,623,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(681,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x6811,x6812),f12(x6812,x6811))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(682,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(f12(a13,a1),a13)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,79,669,671,681,644,459,614,577,574,610,623,517,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(683,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x6831,x6832),f12(x6832,x6831))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(684,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a24,a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,81,79,669,671,681,644,459,614,577,574,610,623,517,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(687,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P12(a24,a22,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,81,79,669,671,681,683,644,459,614,577,574,615,610,623,517,528,337,342,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45,2,3,196])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(694,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P6(x6941,a23,x6942)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,81,79,669,671,681,683,568,644,459,614,577,574,572,615,610,623,517,528,337,342,526,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45,2,3,196,193,227,143])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(696,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(a17,a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,81,79,669,671,681,683,568,644,459,614,577,574,572,615,610,623,517,528,337,342,526,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45,2,3,196,193,227,143,133])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(698,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(f12(a15,a15),a20)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,81,79,669,671,681,683,568,644,459,614,577,574,572,615,610,623,517,528,337,342,526,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45,2,3,196,193,227,143,133,121])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(700,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(f12(a1,a14),a3,a22)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,87,76,81,79,669,671,681,683,568,644,459,614,577,574,572,615,610,623,517,528,337,342,526,513,39,119,131,94,54,67,96,90,47,48,36,35,45,2,3,196,193,227,143,133,121,659])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(714,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(x7141,a23,x7142)+~P2(a24,x7141)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[694,349])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(719,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(x7191,a19)+~P10(x7191,a20)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[117,96])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(722,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(a19,a20)), 1.52/1.59 inference(equality_inference,[],[719])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(728,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P6(x7281,a23,x7282)), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[694])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(732,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P12(f9(a22,a1),a22,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[684,520,687,694,696,722,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(739,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(f12(a1,a1),x7391),f12(a1,x7391))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[283])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(744,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(a19,a20)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,81,82,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,680,698,626,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(746,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P8(a3,a22,f12(a1,a14))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,81,82,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,680,698,626,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(749,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x7491,x7492),f12(x7492,x7491))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(750,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(x7501,f9(a22,f12(a1,a1)),a3)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,575,680,698,626,268,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(752,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(f12(a14,a13),a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,575,680,698,626,268,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(754,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a19,a20)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,575,680,698,626,268,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(756,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a24,f12(a1,a13))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,573,575,680,698,626,268,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90,47])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(757,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(f12(a15,a15),f12(a13,a15))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,74,80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,573,575,645,680,698,626,268,283,572,625,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90,47,46])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(759,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P2(a24,f12(f12(a1,a1),a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,74,80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,573,575,645,680,698,626,268,283,739,572,625,519,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90,47,46,36,48])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(761,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(a15,f12(a14,a13))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,74,80,81,82,79,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,573,575,645,680,698,626,268,283,739,572,625,519,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90,47,46,36,48,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(765,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(f12(a14,a1),f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,74,253,80,81,82,79,749,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,573,575,645,680,698,626,593,268,283,739,522,572,625,519,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(777,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(f12(a1,a13),a23,x7771)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,73,74,253,88,80,81,82,79,749,684,520,687,694,728,696,722,700,573,575,645,680,698,626,593,618,447,268,283,739,522,572,454,625,519,336,513,130,651,197,116,49,154,209,51,119,133,131,194,34,63,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45,3,650,191,121,114,714])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(798,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(a15,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,678,455,113,132])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(803,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(a15,a14)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,678,455,682,113,132,116,123])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(805,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(f12(a13,a14),a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,678,419,455,682,113,132,116,123,119])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(807,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(a15,a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,678,662,419,455,682,113,132,116,123,119,131])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(811,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(a20,a19)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,678,744,662,754,419,455,682,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(814,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a15,a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[87,678,744,662,754,746,419,455,682,425,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(816,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(f12(a1,a15),a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[77,87,678,744,662,754,746,419,455,682,425,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(818,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P2(f9(a22,f12(a1,a1)),f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[77,87,678,744,662,754,746,419,455,682,425,268,614,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(819,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f9(x8191,f12(a1,a1)),f9(x8191,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[268])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(821,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(f12(x8211,x8212),f12(x8212,x8211))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[290])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(824,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a1,a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,77,87,678,744,662,754,756,752,746,759,419,455,682,425,268,290,614,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47,46,36,48,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(829,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(f9(a22,f12(a1,a1)),a23)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,77,87,678,744,662,754,756,752,746,672,750,759,419,455,680,682,425,268,290,821,614,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45,3,135])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(832,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P3(a23,f12(a1,a13),a2)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,77,87,678,744,662,754,756,752,746,672,750,759,419,455,694,680,682,425,268,290,821,614,416,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45,3,135,212])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(838,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(a20,a20)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,77,87,88,678,744,662,754,756,427,752,746,672,750,759,419,455,694,680,682,425,268,290,821,614,416,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45,3,135,212,207,130])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(840,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P4(f12(a14,a1),a23,x8401)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,77,87,88,79,678,744,662,754,756,427,752,634,746,672,750,759,419,455,694,680,682,425,268,290,821,614,416,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45,3,135,212,207,130,62])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(841,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x8411,x8412),f12(x8412,x8411))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(849,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(a15,a18)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[71,77,87,88,79,841,678,744,662,754,661,756,427,752,634,746,672,750,759,419,455,504,694,680,682,425,268,819,290,821,614,416,513,113,132,116,123,119,131,133,112,34,96,90,47,46,36,48,2,35,45,3,135,212,207,130,62,39,32,194,27,120])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(862,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(a13,f12(a1,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[838,829,666,295,577,416,526,719,213,132])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(870,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P10(f12(a14,a15),a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[838,832,732,829,666,523,752,610,295,268,577,416,526,719,213,132,116,49,40,119])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(872,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(a18,a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[838,849,832,732,829,666,523,752,610,295,268,577,416,526,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(882,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P1(a22,f12(a14,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,79,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,523,752,610,295,268,577,454,416,526,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(883,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(f12(x8831,x8832),f12(x8832,x8831))), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[79])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(884,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P2(f9(a22,a1),f12(f12(a1,a1),a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,79,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,523,752,610,295,759,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(885,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(a17,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,79,798,807,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,523,752,610,295,759,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47,46])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(887,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~P7(x8871,a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(rename_variables,[],[87])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(888,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(a24,f12(a13,a1))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,87,79,883,811,798,807,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,523,752,610,295,759,756,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47,46,36,48])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(891,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P10(f12(a14,a13),a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,77,87,79,883,811,798,803,807,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,761,523,752,610,295,759,756,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47,46,36,48,35,45])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(892,plain, 1.52/1.59 (E(a17,f12(a13,a13))), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,77,87,79,883,811,798,803,807,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,761,523,752,610,295,759,756,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47,46,36,48,35,45,2])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(893,plain, 1.52/1.59 (~E(f12(a14,a13),a17)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,77,87,79,883,811,798,803,807,814,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,761,523,752,610,295,759,756,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47,46,36,48,35,45,2,3])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(896,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P7(a1,a15)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[73,77,87,887,80,79,883,811,798,803,807,814,824,838,849,765,832,757,840,732,829,666,761,523,752,610,295,759,756,268,577,454,416,526,513,719,213,132,116,49,40,119,133,131,194,96,90,27,47,46,36,48,35,45,2,3,188,112])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(943,plain, 1.52/1.59 (P2(f9(a22,a1),a1)), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[72,75,86,77,88,246,80,81,82,872,885,896,870,862,882,805,891,893,888,816,892,884,818,777,523,528,829,454,416,526,124,180,93,132,62,119,133,131,96,90,27,47,46,48,36,35,45,2,3,201,174,207])). 1.52/1.59 cnf(974,plain, 1.52/1.59 ($false), 1.52/1.59 inference(scs_inference,[],[943,676,328,377,101]), 1.52/1.59 ['proof']). 1.52/1.59 % SZS output end Proof 1.52/1.59 % Total time :0.910000s 1.52/1.61 EOF