0.08/0.09 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.08/0.09 % Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s 0.09/0.29 % Computer : n003.cluster.edu 0.09/0.29 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.09/0.29 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.09/0.29 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.09/0.29 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.09/0.29 % CPULimit : 960 0.09/0.29 % DateTime : Thu Jul 2 06:51:26 EDT 2020 0.09/0.30 % CPUTime : 5.28/5.46 # Version: 1.3 5.28/5.46 # SZS status Theorem 5.28/5.46 # SZS output start CNFRefutation 5.28/5.46 fof(co1,conjecture,(~((~(?[X5]:((?[X6]:(?[X7]:(?[X8]:(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:(?[X9]:(?[X10]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((of(X5,X7,X6)&man(X5,X6))&jules_forename(X5,X7))&forename(X5,X8))&of(X5,W,V))&man(X5,V))&vincent_forename(X5,W))&agent(X5,X,V))&think_believe_consider(X5,X))&of(X5,Z,X1))&man(X5,X1))&forename(X5,Z))&man(X5,X1))&state(X5,X2))&theme(X5,X9,X10))&think_believe_consider(X5,X9))&accessible_world(X5,X10))&(?[X11]:(((event(X10,X11)&smoke(X10,X11))&present(X10,X11))&agent(X10,X11,X6))))&present(X5,X9))&event(X5,X9))&agent(X5,X9,V))&proposition(X5,X10))&be(X5,X2,X1,X1))&jules_forename(X5,Z))&(![X3]:((?[X4]:(((smoke(Y,X4)&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))&event(Y,X4)))<=man(Y,X3))))&accessible_world(X5,Y))&present(X5,X))&event(X5,X))&theme(X5,X,Y))&proposition(X5,Y))&forename(X5,W))&vincent_forename(X5,X8))&of(X5,X8,V))&forename(X5,X7))))))))))))))&actual_world(X5))))&(?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&be(U,X2,X1,X1))&state(U,X2))&jules_forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&of(U,Z,X1))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4))&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))))))&forename(U,W))))))))))))),input). 5.28/5.46 fof(c287,negated_conjecture,(~(~((~(?[X5]:((?[X6]:(?[X7]:(?[X8]:(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:(?[X9]:(?[X10]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((of(X5,X7,X6)&man(X5,X6))&jules_forename(X5,X7))&forename(X5,X8))&of(X5,W,V))&man(X5,V))&vincent_forename(X5,W))&agent(X5,X,V))&think_believe_consider(X5,X))&of(X5,Z,X1))&man(X5,X1))&forename(X5,Z))&man(X5,X1))&state(X5,X2))&theme(X5,X9,X10))&think_believe_consider(X5,X9))&accessible_world(X5,X10))&(?[X11]:(((event(X10,X11)&smoke(X10,X11))&present(X10,X11))&agent(X10,X11,X6))))&present(X5,X9))&event(X5,X9))&agent(X5,X9,V))&proposition(X5,X10))&be(X5,X2,X1,X1))&jules_forename(X5,Z))&(![X3]:((?[X4]:(((smoke(Y,X4)&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))&event(Y,X4)))<=man(Y,X3))))&accessible_world(X5,Y))&present(X5,X))&event(X5,X))&theme(X5,X,Y))&proposition(X5,Y))&forename(X5,W))&vincent_forename(X5,X8))&of(X5,X8,V))&forename(X5,X7))))))))))))))&actual_world(X5))))&(?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&be(U,X2,X1,X1))&state(U,X2))&jules_forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&of(U,Z,X1))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4))&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))))))&forename(U,W)))))))))))))),inference(assume_negation,status(cth),[co1])). 5.28/5.46 fof(c288,negated_conjecture,(~(~((~(?[X5]:((?[X6]:(?[X7]:(?[X8]:(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:(?[X9]:(?[X10]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((of(X5,X7,X6)&man(X5,X6))&jules_forename(X5,X7))&forename(X5,X8))&of(X5,W,V))&man(X5,V))&vincent_forename(X5,W))&agent(X5,X,V))&think_believe_consider(X5,X))&of(X5,Z,X1))&man(X5,X1))&forename(X5,Z))&man(X5,X1))&state(X5,X2))&theme(X5,X9,X10))&think_believe_consider(X5,X9))&accessible_world(X5,X10))&(?[X11]:(((event(X10,X11)&smoke(X10,X11))&present(X10,X11))&agent(X10,X11,X6))))&present(X5,X9))&event(X5,X9))&agent(X5,X9,V))&proposition(X5,X10))&be(X5,X2,X1,X1))&jules_forename(X5,Z))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((smoke(Y,X4)&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))&event(Y,X4))))))&accessible_world(X5,Y))&present(X5,X))&event(X5,X))&theme(X5,X,Y))&proposition(X5,Y))&forename(X5,W))&vincent_forename(X5,X8))&of(X5,X8,V))&forename(X5,X7))))))))))))))&actual_world(X5))))&(?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&be(U,X2,X1,X1))&state(U,X2))&jules_forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&of(U,Z,X1))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4))&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))))))&forename(U,W)))))))))))))),inference(fof_simplification,status(thm),[c287])). 5.28/5.46 fof(c289,negated_conjecture,((![X5]:((![X6]:(![X7]:(![X8]:(![V]:(![W]:(![X]:(![Y]:(![Z]:(![X1]:(![X2]:(![X9]:(![X10]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X5,X7,X6)|~man(X5,X6))|~jules_forename(X5,X7))|~forename(X5,X8))|~of(X5,W,V))|~man(X5,V))|~vincent_forename(X5,W))|~agent(X5,X,V))|~think_believe_consider(X5,X))|~of(X5,Z,X1))|~man(X5,X1))|~forename(X5,Z))|~man(X5,X1))|~state(X5,X2))|~theme(X5,X9,X10))|~think_believe_consider(X5,X9))|~accessible_world(X5,X10))|(![X11]:(((~event(X10,X11)|~smoke(X10,X11))|~present(X10,X11))|~agent(X10,X11,X6))))|~present(X5,X9))|~event(X5,X9))|~agent(X5,X9,V))|~proposition(X5,X10))|~be(X5,X2,X1,X1))|~jules_forename(X5,Z))|(?[X3]:(man(Y,X3)&(![X4]:(((~smoke(Y,X4)|~present(Y,X4))|~agent(Y,X4,X3))|~event(Y,X4))))))|~accessible_world(X5,Y))|~present(X5,X))|~event(X5,X))|~theme(X5,X,Y))|~proposition(X5,Y))|~forename(X5,W))|~vincent_forename(X5,X8))|~of(X5,X8,V))|~forename(X5,X7))))))))))))))|~actual_world(X5)))&(?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&be(U,X2,X1,X1))&state(U,X2))&jules_forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&of(U,Z,X1))&(![X3]:(~man(Y,X3)|(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4))&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))))))&forename(U,W)))))))))))),inference(fof_nnf,status(thm),[c288])). 5.28/5.46 fof(c290,negated_conjecture,((![X5]:((![X6]:(![X7]:((![X8]:(![V]:(((![W]:((![X]:(![Y]:(((((((![Z]:((![X1]:(![X2]:((![X9]:(![X10]:(((((((((((((((((((((~of(X5,X7,X6)|~man(X5,X6))|~jules_forename(X5,X7))|~forename(X5,X8))|~of(X5,W,V))|~man(X5,V))|~vincent_forename(X5,W))|~agent(X5,X,V))|~think_believe_consider(X5,X))|~of(X5,Z,X1))|~man(X5,X1))|~forename(X5,Z))|~man(X5,X1))|~state(X5,X2))|~theme(X5,X9,X10))|~think_believe_consider(X5,X9))|~accessible_world(X5,X10))|(![X11]:(((~event(X10,X11)|~smoke(X10,X11))|~present(X10,X11))|~agent(X10,X11,X6))))|~present(X5,X9))|~event(X5,X9))|~agent(X5,X9,V))|~proposition(X5,X10))))|~be(X5,X2,X1,X1))))|~jules_forename(X5,Z)))|(?[X3]:(man(Y,X3)&(![X4]:(((~smoke(Y,X4)|~present(Y,X4))|~agent(Y,X4,X3))|~event(Y,X4))))))|~accessible_world(X5,Y))|~present(X5,X))|~event(X5,X))|~theme(X5,X,Y))|~proposition(X5,Y))))|~forename(X5,W)))|~vincent_forename(X5,X8))|~of(X5,X8,V))))|~forename(X5,X7))))|~actual_world(X5)))&(?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:((?[X]:(?[Y]:((?[Z]:(?[X1]:((((?[X2]:(((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&be(U,X2,X1,X1))&state(U,X2)))&jules_forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&of(U,Z,X1))))&(![X3]:(~man(Y,X3)|(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&smoke(Y,X4))&present(Y,X4))&agent(Y,X4,X3))))))))&forename(U,W))))))),inference(shift_quantors,status(thm),[c289])). 5.28/5.46 fof(c291,negated_conjecture,((![X191]:((![X192]:(![X193]:((![X194]:(![X195]:(((![X196]:((![X197]:(![X198]:(((((((![X199]:((![X200]:(![X201]:((![X202]:(![X203]:(((((((((((((((((((((~of(X191,X193,X192)|~man(X191,X192))|~jules_forename(X191,X193))|~forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X196,X195))|~man(X191,X195))|~vincent_forename(X191,X196))|~agent(X191,X197,X195))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X197))|~of(X191,X199,X200))|~man(X191,X200))|~forename(X191,X199))|~man(X191,X200))|~state(X191,X201))|~theme(X191,X202,X203))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X202))|~accessible_world(X191,X203))|(![X204]:(((~event(X203,X204)|~smoke(X203,X204))|~present(X203,X204))|~agent(X203,X204,X192))))|~present(X191,X202))|~event(X191,X202))|~agent(X191,X202,X195))|~proposition(X191,X203))))|~be(X191,X201,X200,X200))))|~jules_forename(X191,X199)))|(?[X205]:(man(X198,X205)&(![X206]:(((~smoke(X198,X206)|~present(X198,X206))|~agent(X198,X206,X205))|~event(X198,X206))))))|~accessible_world(X191,X198))|~present(X191,X197))|~event(X191,X197))|~theme(X191,X197,X198))|~proposition(X191,X198))))|~forename(X191,X196)))|~vincent_forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X194,X195))))|~forename(X191,X193))))|~actual_world(X191)))&(?[X207]:(actual_world(X207)&(?[X208]:(?[X209]:((?[X210]:(?[X211]:((?[X212]:(?[X213]:((((?[X214]:(((((((((((((of(X207,X209,X208)&man(X207,X208))&vincent_forename(X207,X209))&proposition(X207,X211))&agent(X207,X210,X208))&theme(X207,X210,X211))&event(X207,X210))&present(X207,X210))&think_believe_consider(X207,X210))&accessible_world(X207,X211))&forename(X207,X212))&man(X207,X213))&be(X207,X214,X213,X213))&state(X207,X214)))&jules_forename(X207,X212))&man(X207,X213))&of(X207,X212,X213))))&(![X215]:(~man(X211,X215)|(?[X216]:(((event(X211,X216)&smoke(X211,X216))&present(X211,X216))&agent(X211,X216,X215))))))))&forename(X207,X209))))))),inference(variable_rename,status(thm),[c290])). 5.28/5.47 fof(c293,negated_conjecture,(![X191]:(![X192]:(![X193]:(![X194]:(![X195]:(![X196]:(![X197]:(![X198]:(![X199]:(![X200]:(![X201]:(![X202]:(![X203]:(![X204]:(![X206]:(![X215]:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X191,X193,X192)|~man(X191,X192))|~jules_forename(X191,X193))|~forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X196,X195))|~man(X191,X195))|~vincent_forename(X191,X196))|~agent(X191,X197,X195))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X197))|~of(X191,X199,X200))|~man(X191,X200))|~forename(X191,X199))|~man(X191,X200))|~state(X191,X201))|~theme(X191,X202,X203))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X202))|~accessible_world(X191,X203))|(((~event(X203,X204)|~smoke(X203,X204))|~present(X203,X204))|~agent(X203,X204,X192)))|~present(X191,X202))|~event(X191,X202))|~agent(X191,X202,X195))|~proposition(X191,X203))|~be(X191,X201,X200,X200))|~jules_forename(X191,X199))|(man(X198,skolem0001(X191,X192,X193,X194,X195,X196,X197,X198))&(((~smoke(X198,X206)|~present(X198,X206))|~agent(X198,X206,skolem0001(X191,X192,X193,X194,X195,X196,X197,X198)))|~event(X198,X206))))|~accessible_world(X191,X198))|~present(X191,X197))|~event(X191,X197))|~theme(X191,X197,X198))|~proposition(X191,X198))|~forename(X191,X196))|~vincent_forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X194,X195))|~forename(X191,X193))|~actual_world(X191))&(actual_world(skolem0002)&((((((((((((((((((of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)&man(skolem0002,skolem0003))&vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004))&proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006))&agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003))&theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006))&event(skolem0002,skolem0005))&present(skolem0002,skolem0005))&think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005))&accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006))&forename(skolem0002,skolem0007))&man(skolem0002,skolem0008))&be(skolem0002,skolem0009,skolem0008,skolem0008))&state(skolem0002,skolem0009))&jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007))&man(skolem0002,skolem0008))&of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008))&(~man(skolem0006,X215)|(((event(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215))&smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215)))&present(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215)))&agent(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215),X215))))&forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)))))))))))))))))))),inference(shift_quantors,status(thm),[fof(c292,negated_conjecture,((![X191]:((![X192]:(![X193]:((![X194]:(![X195]:(((![X196]:((![X197]:(![X198]:(((((((![X199]:((![X200]:(![X201]:((![X202]:(![X203]:(((((((((((((((((((((~of(X191,X193,X192)|~man(X191,X192))|~jules_forename(X191,X193))|~forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X196,X195))|~man(X191,X195))|~vincent_forename(X191,X196))|~agent(X191,X197,X195))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X197))|~of(X191,X199,X200))|~man(X191,X200))|~forename(X191,X199))|~man(X191,X200))|~state(X191,X201))|~theme(X191,X202,X203))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X202))|~accessible_world(X191,X203))|(![X204]:(((~event(X203,X204)|~smoke(X203,X204))|~present(X203,X204))|~agent(X203,X204,X192))))|~present(X191,X202))|~event(X191,X202))|~agent(X191,X202,X195))|~proposition(X191,X203))))|~be(X191,X201,X200,X200))))|~jules_forename(X191,X199)))|(man(X198,skolem0001(X191,X192,X193,X194,X195,X196,X197,X198))&(![X206]:(((~smoke(X198,X206)|~present(X198,X206))|~agent(X198,X206,skolem0001(X191,X192,X193,X194,X195,X196,X197,X198)))|~event(X198,X206)))))|~accessible_world(X191,X198))|~present(X191,X197))|~event(X191,X197))|~theme(X191,X197,X198))|~proposition(X191,X198))))|~forename(X191,X196)))|~vincent_forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X194,X195))))|~forename(X191,X193))))|~actual_world(X191)))&(actual_world(skolem0002)&((((((((((((((((((of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)&man(skolem0002,skolem0003))&vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004))&proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006))&agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003))&theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006))&event(skolem0002,skolem0005))&present(skolem0002,skolem0005))&think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005))&accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006))&forename(skolem0002,skolem0007))&man(skolem0002,skolem0008))&be(skolem0002,skolem0009,skolem0008,skolem0008))&state(skolem0002,skolem0009))&jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007))&man(skolem0002,skolem0008))&of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008))&(![X215]:(~man(skolem0006,X215)|(((event(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215))&smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215)))&present(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215)))&agent(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215),X215)))))&forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)))),inference(skolemize,status(esa),[c291])).])). 5.28/5.47 fof(c294,negated_conjecture,(![X191]:(![X192]:(![X193]:(![X194]:(![X195]:(![X196]:(![X197]:(![X198]:(![X199]:(![X200]:(![X201]:(![X202]:(![X203]:(![X204]:(![X206]:(![X215]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X191,X193,X192)|~man(X191,X192))|~jules_forename(X191,X193))|~forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X196,X195))|~man(X191,X195))|~vincent_forename(X191,X196))|~agent(X191,X197,X195))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X197))|~of(X191,X199,X200))|~man(X191,X200))|~forename(X191,X199))|~man(X191,X200))|~state(X191,X201))|~theme(X191,X202,X203))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X202))|~accessible_world(X191,X203))|(((~event(X203,X204)|~smoke(X203,X204))|~present(X203,X204))|~agent(X203,X204,X192)))|~present(X191,X202))|~event(X191,X202))|~agent(X191,X202,X195))|~proposition(X191,X203))|~be(X191,X201,X200,X200))|~jules_forename(X191,X199))|man(X198,skolem0001(X191,X192,X193,X194,X195,X196,X197,X198)))|~accessible_world(X191,X198))|~present(X191,X197))|~event(X191,X197))|~theme(X191,X197,X198))|~proposition(X191,X198))|~forename(X191,X196))|~vincent_forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X194,X195))|~forename(X191,X193))|~actual_world(X191))&((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X191,X193,X192)|~man(X191,X192))|~jules_forename(X191,X193))|~forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X196,X195))|~man(X191,X195))|~vincent_forename(X191,X196))|~agent(X191,X197,X195))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X197))|~of(X191,X199,X200))|~man(X191,X200))|~forename(X191,X199))|~man(X191,X200))|~state(X191,X201))|~theme(X191,X202,X203))|~think_believe_consider(X191,X202))|~accessible_world(X191,X203))|(((~event(X203,X204)|~smoke(X203,X204))|~present(X203,X204))|~agent(X203,X204,X192)))|~present(X191,X202))|~event(X191,X202))|~agent(X191,X202,X195))|~proposition(X191,X203))|~be(X191,X201,X200,X200))|~jules_forename(X191,X199))|(((~smoke(X198,X206)|~present(X198,X206))|~agent(X198,X206,skolem0001(X191,X192,X193,X194,X195,X196,X197,X198)))|~event(X198,X206)))|~accessible_world(X191,X198))|~present(X191,X197))|~event(X191,X197))|~theme(X191,X197,X198))|~proposition(X191,X198))|~forename(X191,X196))|~vincent_forename(X191,X194))|~of(X191,X194,X195))|~forename(X191,X193))|~actual_world(X191)))&(actual_world(skolem0002)&((((((((((((((((((of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)&man(skolem0002,skolem0003))&vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004))&proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006))&agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003))&theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006))&event(skolem0002,skolem0005))&present(skolem0002,skolem0005))&think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005))&accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006))&forename(skolem0002,skolem0007))&man(skolem0002,skolem0008))&be(skolem0002,skolem0009,skolem0008,skolem0008))&state(skolem0002,skolem0009))&jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007))&man(skolem0002,skolem0008))&of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008))&((((~man(skolem0006,X215)|event(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215)))&(~man(skolem0006,X215)|smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215))))&(~man(skolem0006,X215)|present(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215))))&(~man(skolem0006,X215)|agent(skolem0006,skolem0010(X215),X215))))&forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)))))))))))))))))))),inference(distribute,status(thm),[c293])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c297,negated_conjecture,actual_world(skolem0002),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c309,negated_conjecture,man(skolem0002,skolem0008),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c312,negated_conjecture,jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c319,negated_conjecture,forename(skolem0002,skolem0004),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c299,negated_conjecture,man(skolem0002,skolem0003),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c300,negated_conjecture,vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c306,negated_conjecture,think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c308,negated_conjecture,forename(skolem0002,skolem0007),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c311,negated_conjecture,state(skolem0002,skolem0009),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c307,negated_conjecture,accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c305,negated_conjecture,present(skolem0002,skolem0005),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c304,negated_conjecture,event(skolem0002,skolem0005),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c301,negated_conjecture,proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c314,negated_conjecture,of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c298,negated_conjecture,of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c302,negated_conjecture,agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c303,negated_conjecture,theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 fof(ax49,axiom,(![U]:(![V]:(![W]:((man(V,U)&accessible_world(V,W))=>man(W,U))))),input). 5.28/5.47 fof(c205,axiom,(![U]:(![V]:(![W]:((~man(V,U)|~accessible_world(V,W))|man(W,U))))),inference(fof_nnf,status(thm),[ax49])). 5.28/5.47 fof(c206,axiom,(![X133]:(![X134]:(![X135]:((~man(X134,X133)|~accessible_world(X134,X135))|man(X135,X133))))),inference(variable_rename,status(thm),[c205])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c207,axiom,~man(X592,X590)|~accessible_world(X592,X591)|man(X591,X590),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c206])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c712,plain,~man(skolem0002,X628)|man(skolem0006,X628),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c207, c307])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c741,plain,man(skolem0006,skolem0008),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c712, c309])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c315,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0006,X684)|event(skolem0006,skolem0010(X684)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c776,plain,event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c315, c741])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c316,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0006,X685)|smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(X685)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c783,plain,smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c316, c741])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c317,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0006,X686)|present(skolem0006,skolem0010(X686)),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c800,plain,present(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c317, c741])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c318,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0006,X687)|agent(skolem0006,skolem0010(X687),X687),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c812,plain,agent(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008),skolem0008),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c318, c741])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c310,negated_conjecture,be(skolem0002,skolem0009,skolem0008,skolem0008),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c295,negated_conjecture,~of(X658,X652,X663)|~man(X658,X663)|~jules_forename(X658,X652)|~forename(X658,X651)|~of(X658,X653,X660)|~man(X658,X660)|~vincent_forename(X658,X653)|~agent(X658,X662,X660)|~think_believe_consider(X658,X662)|~of(X658,X659,X654)|~man(X658,X654)|~forename(X658,X659)|~man(X658,X654)|~state(X658,X661)|~theme(X658,X655,X657)|~think_believe_consider(X658,X655)|~accessible_world(X658,X657)|~event(X657,X656)|~smoke(X657,X656)|~present(X657,X656)|~agent(X657,X656,X663)|~present(X658,X655)|~event(X658,X655)|~agent(X658,X655,X660)|~proposition(X658,X657)|~be(X658,X661,X654,X654)|~jules_forename(X658,X659)|man(X650,skolem0001(X658,X663,X652,X651,X660,X653,X662,X650))|~accessible_world(X658,X650)|~present(X658,X662)|~event(X658,X662)|~theme(X658,X662,X650)|~proposition(X658,X650)|~forename(X658,X653)|~vincent_forename(X658,X651)|~of(X658,X651,X660)|~forename(X658,X652)|~actual_world(X658),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c768,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1164,X1170)|~man(skolem0002,X1170)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1164)|~forename(skolem0002,X1160)|~of(skolem0002,X1169,X1161)|~man(skolem0002,X1161)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1169)|~agent(skolem0002,X1167,X1161)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1167)|~of(skolem0002,X1163,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1163)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,X1165,X1166)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1165)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1166)|~event(X1166,X1168)|~smoke(X1166,X1168)|~present(X1166,X1168)|~agent(X1166,X1168,X1170)|~present(skolem0002,X1165)|~event(skolem0002,X1165)|~agent(skolem0002,X1165,X1161)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1166)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1163)|man(X1162,skolem0001(skolem0002,X1170,X1164,X1160,X1161,X1169,X1167,X1162))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1162)|~present(skolem0002,X1167)|~event(skolem0002,X1167)|~theme(skolem0002,X1167,X1162)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1162)|~forename(skolem0002,X1169)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1160)|~of(skolem0002,X1160,X1161)|~forename(skolem0002,X1164)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c295, c310])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c1161,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1358,X1359)|~man(skolem0002,X1359)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1358)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1363,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1363)|~agent(skolem0002,X1357,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1357)|~of(skolem0002,X1360,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1360)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,X1362,X1361)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1362)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1361)|~event(X1361,X1355)|~smoke(X1361,X1355)|~present(X1361,X1355)|~agent(X1361,X1355,X1359)|~present(skolem0002,X1362)|~event(skolem0002,X1362)|~agent(skolem0002,X1362,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1361)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1360)|man(X1356,skolem0001(skolem0002,X1359,X1358,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1363,X1357,X1356))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1356)|~present(skolem0002,X1357)|~event(skolem0002,X1357)|~theme(skolem0002,X1357,X1356)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1356)|~forename(skolem0002,X1363)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1358)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c768, c298])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c1249,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1387,X1386)|~man(skolem0002,X1386)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1387)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1392,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1392)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1390,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1390)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,X1389,X1391)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1389)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1391)|~event(X1391,X1388)|~smoke(X1391,X1388)|~present(X1391,X1388)|~agent(X1391,X1388,X1386)|~present(skolem0002,X1389)|~event(skolem0002,X1389)|~agent(skolem0002,X1389,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1391)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1390)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,X1386,X1387,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1392,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,X1392)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1387)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1161, c303])). 5.28/5.47 cnf(c1252,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1397,X1393)|~man(skolem0002,X1393)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1397)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1396,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1396)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1395,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1395)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,X1394)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1394)|~event(X1394,X1398)|~smoke(X1394,X1398)|~present(X1394,X1398)|~agent(X1394,X1398,X1393)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1394)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1395)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,X1393,X1397,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1396,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,X1396)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1397)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1249, c302])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1256,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1436,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1436)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1435,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1435)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1437,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1437)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1437)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1436,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1435,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1435)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1436)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1252, c812])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1274,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1455,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1455)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1457,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1457)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1456,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1456)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1456)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1455,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1457,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1457)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1455)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1256, c800])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1293,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1472,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1472)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1474,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1474)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1473,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1473)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1473)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1472,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1474,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1474)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1472)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1274, c783])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1303,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1480,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1480)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1479,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1479)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1478,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1478)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1478)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1480,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1479,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1479)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1480)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1293, c776])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1304,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1482,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1482)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1481,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1481)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1483,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1483)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1483)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1482,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1481,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1481)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1482)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1303, c303])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1305,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1485,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1485)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1484,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1484)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1485,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1484,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1484)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1485)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1304, c314])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1306,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1487,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1487)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,X1486,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,X1486)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1487,skolem0004,skolem0003,X1486,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1486)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~forename(skolem0002,X1487)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1305, c302])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1307,plain,~of(skolem0002,X1488,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1488)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,X1488,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~forename(skolem0002,X1488)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1306, c298])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1308,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1307, c314])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1310,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1308, c301])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1311,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1310, c304])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1312,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1311, c305])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1313,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1312, c307])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1314,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1313, c311])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1316,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1314, c308])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1317,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1316, c306])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1318,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1317, c300])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1319,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1318, c299])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1320,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1319, c319])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1322,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1320, c312])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1323,plain,man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1322, c309])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1324,plain,man(skolem0006,skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1323, c297])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1327,plain,smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1324, c316])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1330,plain,present(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1324, c317])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1329,plain,event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006))),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1324, c315])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c296,negated_conjecture,~of(X676,X670,X682)|~man(X676,X682)|~jules_forename(X676,X670)|~forename(X676,X669)|~of(X676,X671,X678)|~man(X676,X678)|~vincent_forename(X676,X671)|~agent(X676,X680,X678)|~think_believe_consider(X676,X680)|~of(X676,X677,X672)|~man(X676,X672)|~forename(X676,X677)|~man(X676,X672)|~state(X676,X679)|~theme(X676,X673,X675)|~think_believe_consider(X676,X673)|~accessible_world(X676,X675)|~event(X675,X674)|~smoke(X675,X674)|~present(X675,X674)|~agent(X675,X674,X682)|~present(X676,X673)|~event(X676,X673)|~agent(X676,X673,X678)|~proposition(X676,X675)|~be(X676,X679,X672,X672)|~jules_forename(X676,X677)|~smoke(X668,X681)|~present(X668,X681)|~agent(X668,X681,skolem0001(X676,X682,X670,X669,X678,X671,X680,X668))|~event(X668,X681)|~accessible_world(X676,X668)|~present(X676,X680)|~event(X676,X680)|~theme(X676,X680,X668)|~proposition(X676,X668)|~forename(X676,X671)|~vincent_forename(X676,X669)|~of(X676,X669,X678)|~forename(X676,X670)|~actual_world(X676),inference(split_conjunct,status(thm),[c294])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1331,plain,agent(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)),skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1324, c318])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1385,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1604,X1603)|~man(skolem0002,X1603)|~forename(skolem0002,X1604)|~state(skolem0002,X1602)|~theme(skolem0002,X1599,X1600)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1599)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1600)|~event(X1600,X1601)|~smoke(X1600,X1601)|~present(X1600,X1601)|~agent(X1600,X1601,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,X1599)|~event(skolem0002,X1599)|~agent(skolem0002,X1599,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1600)|~be(skolem0002,X1602,X1603,X1603)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1604)|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)))|~present(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)))|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1331, c296])). 5.28/5.48 cnf(c1443,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1632,X1630)|~man(skolem0002,X1630)|~forename(skolem0002,X1632)|~state(skolem0002,X1627)|~theme(skolem0002,X1628,X1629)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1628)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1629)|~event(X1629,X1631)|~smoke(X1629,X1631)|~present(X1629,X1631)|~agent(X1629,X1631,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,X1628)|~event(skolem0002,X1628)|~agent(skolem0002,X1628,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1629)|~be(skolem0002,X1627,X1630,X1630)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1632)|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)))|~present(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1385, c1329])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1460,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1635,X1638)|~man(skolem0002,X1638)|~forename(skolem0002,X1635)|~state(skolem0002,X1637)|~theme(skolem0002,X1634,X1636)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1634)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1636)|~event(X1636,X1633)|~smoke(X1636,X1633)|~present(X1636,X1633)|~agent(X1636,X1633,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,X1634)|~event(skolem0002,X1634)|~agent(skolem0002,X1634,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1636)|~be(skolem0002,X1637,X1638,X1638)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1635)|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0001(skolem0002,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0004,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006)))|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1443, c1330])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1462,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1639,X1644)|~man(skolem0002,X1644)|~forename(skolem0002,X1639)|~state(skolem0002,X1641)|~theme(skolem0002,X1643,X1642)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1643)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1642)|~event(X1642,X1640)|~smoke(X1642,X1640)|~present(X1642,X1640)|~agent(X1642,X1640,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,X1643)|~event(skolem0002,X1643)|~agent(skolem0002,X1643,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1642)|~be(skolem0002,X1641,X1644,X1644)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1639)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1460, c1327])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1463,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1648,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1648)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,X1647,X1645)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1647)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1645)|~event(X1645,X1646)|~smoke(X1645,X1646)|~present(X1645,X1646)|~agent(X1645,X1646,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,X1647)|~event(skolem0002,X1647)|~agent(skolem0002,X1647,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1645)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1648)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1462, c310])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1464,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1653,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1653)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,X1655,X1654)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,X1655)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1654)|~event(X1654,X1652)|~smoke(X1654,X1652)|~present(X1654,X1652)|~agent(X1654,X1652,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,X1655)|~event(skolem0002,X1655)|~agent(skolem0002,X1655,skolem0003)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1654)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1653)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1463, c303])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1466,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1656,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1656)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,X1657)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,X1657)|~event(X1657,X1658)|~smoke(X1657,X1658)|~present(X1657,X1658)|~agent(X1657,X1658,skolem0008)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,X1657)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1656)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1464, c302])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1467,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1659,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1659)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1659)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1466, c812])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1468,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1660,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1660)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~smoke(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1660)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1467, c800])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1469,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1661,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1661)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~event(skolem0006,skolem0010(skolem0008))|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1661)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1468, c783])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1470,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1665,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1665)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~theme(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0006)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1665)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1469, c776])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1472,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~of(skolem0002,X1666,skolem0008)|~forename(skolem0002,X1666)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,X1666)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1470, c303])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1473,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~agent(skolem0002,skolem0005,skolem0003)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1472, c314])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1474,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~of(skolem0002,skolem0004,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1473, c302])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1475,plain,~of(skolem0002,skolem0007,skolem0008)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1474, c298])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1476,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~proposition(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1475, c314])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1478,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1476, c301])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1479,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~present(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1478, c304])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1480,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~accessible_world(skolem0002,skolem0006)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1479, c305])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1481,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0002,skolem0009)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1480, c307])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1482,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1481, c311])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1484,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0002,skolem0005)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1482, c308])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1485,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~vincent_forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1484, c306])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1486,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~man(skolem0002,skolem0003)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1485, c300])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1487,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~forename(skolem0002,skolem0004)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1486, c299])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1488,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~jules_forename(skolem0002,skolem0007)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1487, c319])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1489,plain,~man(skolem0002,skolem0008)|~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1488, c312])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1490,plain,~actual_world(skolem0002),inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1489, c309])). 5.28/5.49 cnf(c1491,plain,$false,inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1490, c297])). 5.28/5.49 # SZS output end CNFRefutation 5.28/5.49 5.28/5.49 # Initial clauses : 135 5.28/5.49 # Processed clauses : 1025 5.28/5.49 # Factors computed : 3 5.28/5.49 # Resolvents computed: 1169 5.28/5.49 # Tautologies deleted: 2 5.28/5.49 # Forward subsumed : 278 5.28/5.49 # Backward subsumed : 119 5.28/5.49 # -------- CPU Time --------- 5.28/5.49 # User time : 5.172 s 5.28/5.49 # System time : 0.021 s 5.28/5.49 # Total time : 5.193 s 5.34/5.52 EOF