0.00/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.13/0.13 % Command : do_CVC4 %s %d 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n021.cluster.edu 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 960 0.13/0.34 % WCLimit : 120 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Thu Jul 2 07:22:22 EDT 2020 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime : 0.21/0.47 %----Proving TF0_NAR, FOF, or CNF 0.21/0.48 ------- cvc4-fof casc j10 : /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p at 960... 0.21/0.48 --- Run --decision=internal --simplification=none --no-inst-no-entail --no-quant-cf --full-saturate-quant at 20... 0.21/0.55 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 0.21/0.55 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark 0.21/0.55 (skolem (forall ((E $$unsorted)) (or (not (environment E)) (not (stable E)) (not (forall ((To $$unsorted)) (or (not (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (greater_or_equal T To)) (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers E T)) (outcompetes efficient_producers first_movers T)) )) (not (in_environment E To))) ))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (skolem (forall ((To $$unsorted)) (or (not (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers skv_1 T)) (not (greater_or_equal T To)) (greater (growth_rate efficient_producers T) (growth_rate first_movers T))) )) (not (in_environment skv_1 To))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (skolem (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (in_environment skv_1 T)) (not (greater_or_equal T (equilibrium skv_1)))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (skolem (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (greater_or_equal T skv_2)) (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers skv_1 T)) (outcompetes efficient_producers first_movers T)) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (skolem (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (greater_or_equal T skv_3)) (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers skv_1 T)) (outcompetes efficient_producers first_movers T)) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (skolem (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (greater_or_equal T skv_4)) (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers skv_1 T)) (outcompetes efficient_producers first_movers T)) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((X $$unsorted) (Y $$unsorted)) (= (or (= X Y) (greater X Y)) (greater_or_equal X Y)) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_3) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_3) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_2) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_2) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_6) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_6) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (equilibrium skv_1), skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( (equilibrium skv_1), skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_3), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_3), (growth_rate first_movers skv_3) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_3), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_3), (growth_rate first_movers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), (growth_rate first_movers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4), (growth_rate first_movers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_2), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_2), (growth_rate first_movers skv_2) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_2), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_6), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_6), (growth_rate first_movers skv_6) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_6), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((E $$unsorted) (T $$unsorted)) (let ((_let_0 (growth_rate efficient_producers T))) (let ((_let_1 (growth_rate first_movers T))) (or (not (environment E)) (not (greater_or_equal T (equilibrium E))) (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers E T)) (and (greater zero _let_0) (greater _let_1 zero)) (and (greater _let_0 zero) (greater zero _let_1)) (and (= zero _let_0) (= zero _let_1))))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_6 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((E $$unsorted)) (or (not (stable E)) (not (environment E)) (not (forall ((To $$unsorted)) (or (not (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers E T)) (not (greater_or_equal T To)) (greater (growth_rate efficient_producers T) (growth_rate first_movers T))) )) (not (in_environment E To))) ))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((E $$unsorted) (T1 $$unsorted) (T2 $$unsorted)) (or (not (in_environment E T1)) (not (in_environment E T2)) (greater T2 T1) (= T1 T2) (greater T1 T2)) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, (equilibrium skv_1), (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, (equilibrium skv_1), skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, (equilibrium skv_1), skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, (equilibrium skv_1), skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_2, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_2, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_2, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_2, skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_3, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_3, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_3, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_3, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_4, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_4, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_4, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_4, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_4, skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, skv_5, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((E $$unsorted) (S1 $$unsorted) (S2 $$unsorted) (T $$unsorted)) (or (not (environment E)) (not (subpopulations S1 S2 E T)) (= (and (greater zero (growth_rate S1 T)) (greater_or_equal (growth_rate S2 T) zero)) (outcompetes S2 S1 T))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, first_movers, efficient_producers, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, first_movers, efficient_producers, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, first_movers, efficient_producers, skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1, first_movers, efficient_producers, skv_6 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((X $$unsorted) (Y $$unsorted) (Z $$unsorted)) (or (not (greater X Y)) (not (greater Y Z)) (greater X Z)) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_3), (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_3) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), (growth_rate first_movers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4), (growth_rate first_movers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4), (growth_rate first_movers skv_2) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_2), (growth_rate first_movers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_2), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_3, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_3, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_3, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_4, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_5, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2, skv_5, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3, skv_4, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_3), zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_3), zero, zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_3), (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_2, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_2, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_3, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_3, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_3, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_4, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4, skv_5, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, (equilibrium skv_1), skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_3, (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_3, skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_3, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5, skv_4, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_5) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_5), (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_5), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4), (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), zero ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_4) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_4), zero, (growth_rate efficient_producers skv_2) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (growth_rate first_movers skv_2), zero, (growth_rate first_movers skv_2) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6, skv_2, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6, skv_4, skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6, skv_4, skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((E $$unsorted)) (or (not (environment E)) (not (stable E)) (not (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (in_environment E T)) (not (greater_or_equal T (equilibrium E)))) ))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_1 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((To $$unsorted)) (or (not (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (greater_or_equal T To)) (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers skv_1 T)) (outcompetes efficient_producers first_movers T)) )) (not (in_environment skv_1 To))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( (equilibrium skv_1) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 (instantiation (forall ((T $$unsorted)) (or (not (subpopulations first_movers efficient_producers skv_1 T)) (not (greater_or_equal T skv_2)) (greater (growth_rate efficient_producers T) (growth_rate first_movers T))) ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_2 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_3 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_4 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_5 ) 0.21/0.55 ( skv_6 ) 0.21/0.55 ) 0.21/0.55 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark 0.21/0.55 EOF