0.03/0.13 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.03/0.13 % Command : java -jar /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/mcs_scs.jar %d %s 0.13/0.33 % Computer : n008.cluster.edu 0.13/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.13/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.13/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.13/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 960 0.13/0.34 % WCLimit : 120 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Wed Jul 1 17:22:28 EDT 2020 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime : 0.19/0.44 openjdk version "1.8.0_171" 0.19/0.44 OpenJDK Runtime Environment (build 1.8.0_171-b10) 0.19/0.44 OpenJDK 64-Bit Server VM (build 25.171-b10, mixed mode) 0.19/0.45 file=/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 0.61/0.68 start to proof:theBenchmark 51.98/52.07 %------------------------------------------- 51.98/52.07 % File :CSE---1.3 51.98/52.07 % Problem :theBenchmark 51.98/52.07 % Transform :cnf 51.98/52.07 % Format :tptp:raw 51.98/52.07 % Command :java -jar mcs_scs.jar %d %s 51.98/52.07 51.98/52.07 % Result :Theorem 51.310000s 51.98/52.07 % Output :CNFRefutation 51.310000s 51.98/52.07 %------------------------------------------- 51.98/52.07 include('Axioms/MGT001+0.ax'). 51.98/52.07 fof(assumption_1,axiom,( 51.98/52.07 ! [X,T] : 51.98/52.07 ( ~ has_immunity(X,T) 51.98/52.07 <= ( organization(X) 51.98/52.07 & ~ has_endowment(X) ) ) )). 51.98/52.07 51.98/52.07 fof(assumption_18d,axiom,( 51.98/52.07 greater(high,mod2) )). 51.98/52.07 51.98/52.07 fof(assumption_18b,axiom,( 51.98/52.07 greater(mod1,low) )). 51.98/52.07 51.98/52.07 fof(theorem_7,conjecture,( 51.98/52.07 ! [X,T0,T1,T2] : 51.98/52.08 ( ( greater(sigma,zero) 51.98/52.08 & greater(age(X,T2),sigma) 51.98/52.08 & smaller_or_equal(age(X,T1),sigma) 51.98/52.08 & zero = age(X,T0) 51.98/52.08 & ~ has_endowment(X) 51.98/52.08 & fragile_position(X) 51.98/52.08 & organization(X) ) 51.98/52.08 => ( greater(hazard_of_mortality(X,T2),hazard_of_mortality(X,T1)) 51.98/52.08 & hazard_of_mortality(X,T1) = hazard_of_mortality(X,T0) ) ) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(assumption_18a,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 greater(high,mod1) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(definition_2,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 ! [X,T0,T] : 51.98/52.08 ( ( ~ ( is_aligned(X,T) 51.98/52.08 <=> is_aligned(X,T0) ) 51.98/52.08 & organization(X) ) 51.98/52.08 <=> dissimilar(X,T0,T) ) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(assumption_18e,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 greater(mod2,low) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(assumption_15,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 ! [X,T0,T] : 51.98/52.08 ( ( zero = age(X,T0) 51.98/52.08 & organization(X) ) 51.98/52.08 => ( greater(age(X,T),sigma) 51.98/52.08 <=> dissimilar(X,T0,T) ) ) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(assumption_18c,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 greater(low,very_low) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(definition_3,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 ! [X] : 51.98/52.08 ( fragile_position(X) 51.98/52.08 <=> ! [T] : 51.98/52.08 ( ( smaller_or_equal(age(X,T),sigma) 51.98/52.08 => positional_advantage(X,T) ) 51.98/52.08 & ( ~ positional_advantage(X,T) 51.98/52.08 <= greater(age(X,T),sigma) ) ) ) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(assumption_17,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 ! [X,T] : 51.98/52.08 ( ( ( ( ( ( is_aligned(X,T) 51.98/52.08 & ~ positional_advantage(X,T) ) 51.98/52.08 => hazard_of_mortality(X,T) = mod2 ) 51.98/52.08 & ( ( ~ positional_advantage(X,T) 51.98/52.08 & ~ is_aligned(X,T) ) 51.98/52.08 => hazard_of_mortality(X,T) = high ) 51.98/52.08 & ( hazard_of_mortality(X,T) = mod1 51.98/52.08 <= ( positional_advantage(X,T) 51.98/52.08 & ~ is_aligned(X,T) ) ) 51.98/52.08 & ( low = hazard_of_mortality(X,T) 51.98/52.08 <= ( is_aligned(X,T) 51.98/52.08 & positional_advantage(X,T) ) ) ) 51.98/52.08 <= ~ has_immunity(X,T) ) 51.98/52.08 & ( has_immunity(X,T) 51.98/52.08 => very_low = hazard_of_mortality(X,T) ) ) 51.98/52.08 <= organization(X) ) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 fof(assumption_13,axiom,( 51.98/52.08 ! [X,T] : 51.98/52.08 ( is_aligned(X,T) 51.98/52.08 <= ( age(X,T) = zero 51.98/52.08 & organization(X) ) ) )). 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 %------------------------------------------- 51.98/52.08 % Proof found 51.98/52.08 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 51.98/52.08 % SZS output start Proof 51.98/52.08 %ClaNum:73(EqnAxiom:29) 51.98/52.08 %VarNum:182(SingletonVarNum:66) 51.98/52.08 %MaxLitNum:5 51.98/52.08 %MaxfuncDepth:2 51.98/52.08 %SharedTerms:31 51.98/52.08 %goalClause: 30 31 32 38 39 40 41 70 51.98/52.08 %singleGoalClaCount:7 51.98/52.08 [30]P1(a1) 51.98/52.08 [31]P2(a1) 51.98/52.08 [33]P4(a5,a11) 51.98/52.08 [34]P4(a5,a12) 51.98/52.08 [35]P4(a11,a13) 51.98/52.08 [36]P4(a12,a13) 51.98/52.08 [37]P4(a13,a14) 51.98/52.08 [38]P4(a15,a4) 51.98/52.08 [41]~P5(a1) 51.98/52.08 [32]E(f2(a1,a3),a4) 51.98/52.08 [39]P4(f2(a1,a6),a15) 51.98/52.08 [40]P9(f2(a1,a7),a15) 51.98/52.08 [70]~P4(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a7))+~E(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3)) 51.98/52.08 [42]~E(x421,x422)+P9(x421,x422) 51.98/52.08 [43]~E(x431,x432)+P6(x431,x432) 51.98/52.08 [46]~P4(x462,x461)+P10(x461,x462) 51.98/52.08 [47]~P10(x472,x471)+P4(x471,x472) 51.98/52.08 [48]~P10(x481,x482)+P9(x481,x482) 51.98/52.08 [49]~P4(x491,x492)+P6(x491,x492) 51.98/52.08 [54]~P4(x542,x541)+~P4(x541,x542) 51.98/52.08 [64]P1(x641)+~P3(x641,x642,x643) 51.98/52.08 [55]P2(x551)+P11(x551,f9(x551))+~P11(x551,f10(x551)) 51.98/52.08 [60]P2(x601)+P11(x601,f9(x601))+P9(f2(x601,f10(x601)),a15) 51.98/52.08 [63]P2(x631)+~P11(x631,f10(x631))+P4(f2(x631,f9(x631)),a15) 51.98/52.08 [68]P2(x681)+P4(f2(x681,f9(x681)),a15)+P9(f2(x681,f10(x681)),a15) 51.98/52.08 [44]P10(x441,x442)+P4(x441,x442)+E(x441,x442) 51.98/52.08 [45]~P1(x451)+P5(x451)+~P7(x451,x452) 51.98/52.08 [50]P10(x501,x502)+~P9(x501,x502)+E(x501,x502) 51.98/52.08 [51]P4(x511,x512)+~P6(x511,x512)+E(x511,x512) 51.98/52.08 [52]~P1(x521)+~P7(x521,x522)+E(f8(x521,x522),a14) 51.98/52.08 [53]~P1(x531)+P8(x531,x532)+~E(f2(x531,x532),a4) 51.98/52.08 [62]~P2(x621)+P11(x621,x622)+~P9(f2(x621,x622),a15) 51.98/52.08 [65]~P2(x651)+~P11(x651,x652)+~P4(f2(x651,x652),a15) 51.98/52.08 [56]~P4(x561,x563)+P4(x561,x562)+~P4(x563,x562) 51.98/52.08 [69]~P3(x691,x692,x693)+P8(x691,x692)+P8(x691,x693) 51.98/52.08 [71]~P3(x711,x712,x713)+~P8(x711,x712)+~P8(x711,x713) 51.98/52.08 [66]~P1(x661)+~P8(x661,x663)+P8(x661,x662)+P3(x661,x662,x663) 51.98/52.08 [67]~P1(x671)+~P8(x671,x673)+P8(x671,x672)+P3(x671,x673,x672) 51.98/52.08 [72]~P1(x721)+P3(x721,x722,x723)+~E(f2(x721,x722),a4)+~P4(f2(x721,x723),a15) 51.98/52.08 [73]~P1(x731)+~P3(x731,x733,x732)+P4(f2(x731,x732),a15)+~E(f2(x731,x733),a4) 51.98/52.08 [57]P7(x571,x572)+P8(x571,x572)+P11(x571,x572)+~P1(x571)+E(f8(x571,x572),a5) 51.98/52.08 [58]P7(x581,x582)+P11(x581,x582)+~P1(x581)+~P8(x581,x582)+E(f8(x581,x582),a11) 51.98/52.08 [59]P7(x591,x592)+P8(x591,x592)+~P1(x591)+~P11(x591,x592)+E(f8(x591,x592),a12) 51.98/52.08 [61]P7(x611,x612)+~P1(x611)+~P8(x611,x612)+~P11(x611,x612)+E(f8(x611,x612),a13) 51.98/52.08 %EqnAxiom 51.98/52.08 [1]E(x11,x11) 51.98/52.08 [2]E(x22,x21)+~E(x21,x22) 51.98/52.08 [3]E(x31,x33)+~E(x31,x32)+~E(x32,x33) 51.98/52.08 [4]~E(x41,x42)+E(f2(x41,x43),f2(x42,x43)) 51.98/52.08 [5]~E(x51,x52)+E(f2(x53,x51),f2(x53,x52)) 51.98/52.08 [6]~E(x61,x62)+E(f8(x61,x63),f8(x62,x63)) 51.98/52.08 [7]~E(x71,x72)+E(f8(x73,x71),f8(x73,x72)) 51.98/52.08 [8]~E(x81,x82)+E(f10(x81),f10(x82)) 51.98/52.08 [9]~E(x91,x92)+E(f9(x91),f9(x92)) 51.98/52.08 [10]~P1(x101)+P1(x102)+~E(x101,x102) 51.98/52.08 [11]~P2(x111)+P2(x112)+~E(x111,x112) 51.98/52.08 [12]P4(x122,x123)+~E(x121,x122)+~P4(x121,x123) 51.98/52.08 [13]P4(x133,x132)+~E(x131,x132)+~P4(x133,x131) 51.98/52.08 [14]P3(x142,x143,x144)+~E(x141,x142)+~P3(x141,x143,x144) 51.98/52.08 [15]P3(x153,x152,x154)+~E(x151,x152)+~P3(x153,x151,x154) 51.98/52.08 [16]P3(x163,x164,x162)+~E(x161,x162)+~P3(x163,x164,x161) 51.98/52.08 [17]P8(x172,x173)+~E(x171,x172)+~P8(x171,x173) 51.98/52.08 [18]P8(x183,x182)+~E(x181,x182)+~P8(x183,x181) 51.98/52.08 [19]P7(x192,x193)+~E(x191,x192)+~P7(x191,x193) 51.98/52.08 [20]P7(x203,x202)+~E(x201,x202)+~P7(x203,x201) 51.98/52.08 [21]P11(x212,x213)+~E(x211,x212)+~P11(x211,x213) 51.98/52.08 [22]P11(x223,x222)+~E(x221,x222)+~P11(x223,x221) 51.98/52.08 [23]P9(x232,x233)+~E(x231,x232)+~P9(x231,x233) 51.98/52.08 [24]P9(x243,x242)+~E(x241,x242)+~P9(x243,x241) 51.98/52.08 [25]P10(x252,x253)+~E(x251,x252)+~P10(x251,x253) 51.98/52.08 [26]P10(x263,x262)+~E(x261,x262)+~P10(x263,x261) 51.98/52.08 [27]P6(x272,x273)+~E(x271,x272)+~P6(x271,x273) 51.98/52.08 [28]P6(x283,x282)+~E(x281,x282)+~P6(x283,x281) 51.98/52.08 [29]~P5(x291)+P5(x292)+~E(x291,x292) 51.98/52.08 51.98/52.08 %------------------------------------------- 51.98/52.09 cnf(74,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(x741,x741)), 51.98/52.09 inference(equality_inference,[],[42])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(75,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(x751,x751)), 51.98/52.09 inference(equality_inference,[],[43])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(76,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(a4,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,2])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(77,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a4,a15)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[38,32,2,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(79,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P7(a1,x791)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,38,41,32,2,54,45])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(81,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P8(a1,a3)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,38,41,32,2,54,45,53])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(83,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P11(a1,a7)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,31,38,41,32,40,2,54,45,53,62])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(85,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P11(a1,a6)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,31,38,41,32,39,40,2,54,45,53,62,65])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(88,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a15,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,31,38,41,32,39,40,2,54,45,53,62,65,12,13])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(94,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a4,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,31,38,41,32,39,40,74,2,54,45,53,62,65,12,13,56,71,22,23])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(95,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(x951,x951)), 51.98/52.09 inference(rename_variables,[],[74])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(99,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(x991,x991)), 51.98/52.09 inference(rename_variables,[],[75])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(102,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P3(a1,a3,a6)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,31,38,41,32,39,40,74,95,75,99,2,54,45,53,62,65,12,13,56,71,22,23,24,27,28,72])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(106,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,31,38,41,32,39,40,74,95,75,99,2,54,45,53,62,65,12,13,56,71,22,23,24,27,28,72,47,3])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(113,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a15,f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(115,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P10(f2(a1,a6),a15)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,54,47])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(117,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a4,f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,77,54,47,56])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(124,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P11(x1241,a7)+~E(a1,x1241)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[38,39,81,83,77,54,47,56,13,17,44,18,21])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(134,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(f2(a1,a3),a15)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[88,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(138,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,88,117,54,47,56])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(140,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(f2(a1,a3),f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,88,113,117,54,47,56,13])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(148,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(f2(a1,a3),f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[138,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(152,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a5,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[138,134,33,35,54,47,56])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(162,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a12,a5)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[148,34,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(164,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a12,a14)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[148,34,36,37,47,54,56])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(166,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a13,a5)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[148,34,36,37,47,54,56,13])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(170,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(a15,a4)+P10(a4,a15)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,148,34,36,37,77,47,54,56,13,44,3,2])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(175,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a13,a5)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[152,162,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(177,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P10(a13,a5)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[152,162,166,47,54,44])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(179,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a5,a14)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[152,162,164,166,34,47,54,44,56])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(183,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P10(x1831,a5)+~E(a13,x1831)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[38,152,162,164,166,34,47,54,44,56,13,12,25])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(192,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P10(a5,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[175,47])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(194,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a14,a5)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[175,179,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(207,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a11,a5)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[194,33,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(220,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P10(a5,a11)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[207,47])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(222,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a13,a11)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[35,207,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(224,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a11,a14)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[35,37,207,47,54,56])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(226,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a5,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[35,37,207,33,47,54,56,12])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(234,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P10(a11,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[222,47])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(236,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a13,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[36,222,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(242,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P10(a13,a11)+~E(a14,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[36,37,222,177,47,54,13,44,25,3])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(248,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P10(a12,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[236,47])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(250,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a14,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[37,236,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(252,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a11,a14)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[37,35,236,47,54,12])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(253,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a14,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[37,35,236,47,54,12,13])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(254,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(a13,a12)+P10(a13,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[37,35,236,47,54,12,13,44])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(257,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P10(a13,a12)+~E(a14,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[37,35,236,177,47,54,12,13,44,25,3])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(264,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a14,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[164,250,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(268,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a5,a14)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[164,250,253,177,47,54,44,26])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(277,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P4(a14,a11)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[224,264,47,54])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(288,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P10(a11,a14)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[277,47])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(297,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(a14,a13)+P10(a14,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[250,44])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(300,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P10(a14,a13)+P10(a13,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[250,44,242,257])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(344,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(x3441,a14)+~E(a13,x3441)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[37,12])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(404,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a5,x4041)+~E(a13,x4041)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[152,13])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(410,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a4,a15)+E(a15,a4)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[170,48])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(418,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a13,a12)+E(a13,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[254,48])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(425,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a14,a13)+E(a14,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[297,48])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(427,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a14,a13)+P10(a13,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[300,48])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(434,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(f2(a1,a3),a15)+E(a15,a4)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[76,410,23])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(444,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a13,a12)+E(f8(x4441,a13),f8(x4441,a12))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[418,7])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(454,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a14,a13)+E(f9(a14),f9(a13))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[425,9])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(456,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a13,a12)+P9(a14,a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[427,48])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(468,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a14,x4681)+~E(a13,x4681)+P9(a13,a12)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[456,24])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(490,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P11(a1,a3)+E(a15,a4)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[31,434,62])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(491,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(a15,a4)+E(f8(a1,a3),a13)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,81,79,490,61])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(495,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(a14,x4951)+~E(a13,x4951)+E(f9(a14),f9(a13))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[454,24])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(507,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(f2(f8(a1,a3),x5071),f2(a13,x5071))+E(a15,a4)), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[491,4])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(554,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(x5541,a12)+~E(a13,x5541)+E(f8(x5542,a13),f8(x5542,a12))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[444,23])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(587,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a7,a3)+~P4(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[70,7])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(588,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~E(a3,a7)+~P4(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[587,2])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(589,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P4(a3,a7)+P10(a3,a7)+~P4(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[588,44])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(772,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(f2(a4,x7721),f2(f2(a1,a3),x7721))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,2,4])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(820,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(f2(x8201,a4),f2(x8201,f2(a1,a3)))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,2,5])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(821,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(f2(x8211,f2(a1,a3)),f2(x8211,a4))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[820,2])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(943,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(f2(f2(a1,a3),x9431),f2(a4,x9431))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[772,75,27])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(944,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(x9441,x9441)), 51.98/52.09 inference(rename_variables,[],[75])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(947,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(f2(f2(a1,a3),x9471),f2(a4,x9471))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[772,74,75,944,27,28,23])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(954,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(x9541,x9541)), 51.98/52.09 inference(rename_variables,[],[75])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(955,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(f2(x9551,a4),f2(x9551,f2(a1,a3)))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[820,75,954,27,28])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(957,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(f2(x9571,f2(a1,a3)),f2(x9571,a4))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[820,74,75,954,27,28,23])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(1066,plain, 51.98/52.09 (E(f8(x10661,a4),f8(x10661,f2(a1,a3)))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,2,7])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(1214,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P6(x12141,x12141)), 51.98/52.09 inference(rename_variables,[],[75])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(1217,plain, 51.98/52.09 (P9(f8(x12171,f2(a1,a3)),f8(x12171,a4))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[1066,74,75,1214,27,28,23])). 51.98/52.09 cnf(1386,plain, 51.98/52.09 (~P6(f2(a1,a3),f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.09 inference(scs_inference,[],[106,148,2,51])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1387,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P9(a5,a13)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[166,192,2,50])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1388,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P8(a1,a6)+E(a5,f8(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[85,30,79,2,57])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1399,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P8(a1,a7)+E(a13,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[83,30,79,2,61])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1400,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(a13,x14001),f2(f8(a1,a7),x14001))+~P8(a1,a7)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1399,4])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1402,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(f2(a1,a6),a15)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[31,85,42,62])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1434,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P9(f8(a1,a7),a13)+~P8(a1,a7)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[83,30,79,42,61])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1489,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P6(f8(a1,a7),a13)+~P8(a1,a7)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[83,30,79,43,61])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1493,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f2(a1,a3),x14931)+~E(a15,x14931)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[88,46,26])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1530,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P9(a15,f2(a1,a3))+E(a15,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[134,47,50])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1531,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f2(a1,a3),f2(a1,a3))+~P9(a15,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1530,1493])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1532,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f2(a1,a3),f2(a1,a3))+~P9(a15,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1531,47])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1533,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P9(a15,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1532,54])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1534,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(a15,f2(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1533,42])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1536,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(a4,a15)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[94,1533,42,23])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1654,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(a1,a3),a13)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,3,491])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1655,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(f8(a1,a3),x16551),f2(a13,x16551))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,3,491,507])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1656,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(a13,f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,3,491,507,2])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1659,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f8(a1,a3),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,177,3,491,507,2,495,25])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1660,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f8(a1,a3),a14)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,37,177,3,491,507,2,495,25,12])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1661,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(a5,f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,37,152,177,3,491,507,2,495,25,12,13])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1662,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P4(a14,f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1534,76,37,152,177,3,491,507,2,495,25,12,13,54])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1673,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P4(f8(a1,a3),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1661,1662,47,54])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1675,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(a13,x16751),f2(f8(a1,a3),x16751))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1655,1661,1662,47,54,2])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1676,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(f8(a1,a3),f2(a1,a3)),f2(a13,a4))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[821,1655,1661,1662,47,54,2,3])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1684,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P10(a5,f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1673,47])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1687,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(a13,f2(a1,a3)),f2(f8(a1,a3),a4))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[821,1675,1676,1673,47,2,3])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(1693,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(f8(a1,a3),a4),f2(a13,f2(a1,a3)))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1687,2])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2030,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P8(a1,a7)+E(f8(a1,a7),a13)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[102,83,79,64,61])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2091,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P4(f2(a1,a7),a15)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[31,124,65])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2094,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P4(f2(a1,a7),f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,2091,47,56])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2096,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[39,2091,47,56,12])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2099,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P8(a1,a7)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,39,30,81,2091,47,56,12,73,67])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2107,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P9(f2(a1,a6),a15)+P10(f2(a1,a7),f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[32,40,39,30,81,2091,140,47,56,12,73,67,5,71,44,3,23])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2110,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(a13,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2099,1399])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2111,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(a13,x21111),f2(f8(a1,a7),x21111))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2099,1400])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2113,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P9(f8(a1,a7),a13)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2099,1434])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2114,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P6(f8(a1,a7),a13)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2099,1489])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2115,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(a1,a7),a13)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2099,2030])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2116,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a7))+P9(f2(a1,a6),a15)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2107,47])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2117,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f8(a1,a7),a14)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2110,344])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2118,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(a5,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2110,344,404])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2119,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f8(a1,a7),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2110,344,404,183])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2120,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P10(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2110,2094,344,404,183,47])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2122,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P4(a14,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2110,2094,344,404,183,47,54])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2124,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(f8(a1,a7),x21241),f2(a13,x21241))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2111,2110,2094,344,404,183,47,54,2])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2125,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(a5,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2115,2111,2110,226,2094,344,404,183,47,54,2,3])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2128,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(f8(a1,a7),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1656,2115,2111,2114,2113,2110,226,1387,2094,344,404,183,47,54,2,3,28,24,23])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2136,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))+P4(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1656,2115,2111,2114,2113,2110,226,1387,2094,344,404,183,47,54,2,3,28,24,23,554,27,468,495,51])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2138,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))+P10(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1656,2115,2111,2114,2113,2110,226,1387,2094,344,404,183,47,54,2,3,28,24,23,554,27,468,495,51,50])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2156,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P4(f8(a1,a7),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2118,2122,47,54])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2158,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(f8(a1,a7),f2(a1,a3)),f2(a13,a4))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[821,2124,2118,2122,47,54,3])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2169,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P10(a5,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2156,47])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2171,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(a13,f2(a1,a3)),f2(f8(a1,a7),a4))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[821,2111,2156,47,3])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2357,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P6(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a7))+P9(f2(a1,a6),a15)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2116,49])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2380,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P6(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1402,115,2357,50])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2381,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f2(a1,a6),f2(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2096,2380,51])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2395,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(f8(a1,a7),x23951),f8(a13,x23951))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2115,8,9,6])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2396,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(x23961,f8(a1,a7)),f8(x23961,a13))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2115,8,9,6,7])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2403,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f2(a1,a7),f2(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2381,2119,2117,2158,2115,8,9,6,7,48,43,49,46])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2407,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(x24071,f8(a1,a7)),f2(x24071,a13))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2381,2119,2117,2158,2115,8,9,6,7,48,43,49,46,42,5])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2411,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P6(f8(a1,a7),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2381,2119,2117,2096,2156,2158,2115,31,2128,85,8,9,6,7,48,43,49,46,42,5,2,62,51])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2413,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P9(a5,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2125,2381,2169,2119,2117,2096,2156,2158,2115,31,2128,85,8,9,6,7,48,43,49,46,42,5,2,62,51,50])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2421,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P8(a1,a6)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2125,2381,2169,2119,2117,248,2096,2156,1386,2158,1533,2171,1693,236,2115,31,2128,85,76,102,81,8,9,6,7,48,43,49,46,42,5,2,62,51,50,3,26,12,27,24,19,71])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2431,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(a1,a6),a5)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[30,2125,2381,2169,2119,2117,248,2096,2156,1386,957,955,2158,1533,2171,1693,236,2115,31,2128,85,2099,79,76,102,81,8,9,6,7,48,43,49,46,42,5,2,62,51,50,3,26,12,27,24,19,71,28,23,66,67,57])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2441,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(a5,f8(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2421,1388])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2450,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(a14,f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2403,2395,1660,48,43,49,46])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2461,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P6(a4,a15)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[1536,2403,2431,2395,1660,77,1402,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6,7,4,5,2,51])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2466,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(f8(a1,a7),x24661),f8(a13,x24661))), 51.98/52.10 inference(rename_variables,[],[2395])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2477,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~P9(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[252,1536,2403,2431,2413,2411,2395,2466,2396,1684,288,234,1660,1217,194,77,1654,1402,75,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6,7,4,5,2,51,50,3,26,25,27,28,13,24,23])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2489,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(a14,f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2450,2407,2117,2118,48,43,49,46])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2493,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f10(a5),f10(f8(a1,a6)))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2450,2441,2407,2117,2118,48,43,49,46,42,8])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2495,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(a5,x24951),f8(f8(a1,a6),x24951))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2450,2441,2407,2117,2118,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2506,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a7))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[268,2450,2441,2407,2120,1659,220,253,2117,2118,264,2096,2431,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6,7,4,5,51,50,3,26,25,12])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2509,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f2(x25091,f8(a1,a7)),f2(x25091,a13))), 51.98/52.10 inference(rename_variables,[],[2407])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2516,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f8(a1,a6),f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[268,2461,2450,2477,2441,2407,2509,2120,1659,220,253,2117,2118,264,1673,943,947,2096,2110,2431,32,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6,7,4,5,51,50,3,26,25,12,27,28,13,24,23,47])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2522,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f8(a1,a6),a14)), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[268,2461,2450,2477,2441,2407,2509,2120,1659,220,253,2117,2118,264,1673,943,947,2096,2110,2431,32,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6,7,4,5,51,50,3,26,25,12,27,28,13,24,23,47,54,2,589,56])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2526,plain, 51.98/52.10 (~E(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2506,70])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2537,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2489,2506,2495,48,43,49,46])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2569,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P4(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2526,2136])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2570,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(f8(a1,a7),f8(a1,a3))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2526,2138])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2577,plain, 51.98/52.10 (P10(a14,f8(a1,a6))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2537,2493,2516,2522,48,43,49,46])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2583,plain, 51.98/52.10 (E(f8(f8(a1,a3),x25831),f8(a13,x25831))), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2537,2493,2516,2522,1654,48,43,49,46,42,8,9,6])). 51.98/52.10 cnf(2621,plain, 51.98/52.10 ($false), 51.98/52.10 inference(scs_inference,[],[2569,2570,2577,2583,2522,1656,48,43,49,46,42,47,8,9,6,7,54]), 51.98/52.10 ['proof']). 51.98/52.10 % SZS output end Proof 51.98/52.10 % Total time :51.310000s 52.15/52.12 EOF