0.12/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.12/0.13 % Command : java -jar /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/mcs_scs.jar %d %s 0.12/0.34 % Computer : n014.cluster.edu 0.12/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.12/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.12/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.12/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.12/0.34 % CPULimit : 1200 0.12/0.34 % WCLimit : 120 0.12/0.34 % DateTime : Tue Jul 13 12:23:49 EDT 2021 0.19/0.34 % CPUTime : 0.19/0.56 start to proof:theBenchmark 16.64/16.70 %------------------------------------------- 16.64/16.70 % File :CSE---1.4 16.64/16.70 % Problem :theBenchmark 16.64/16.70 % Transform :cnf 16.64/16.70 % Format :tptp:raw 16.64/16.70 % Command :java -jar mcs_scs.jar %d %s 16.64/16.70 16.64/16.70 % Result :Theorem 16.030000s 16.64/16.70 % Output :CNFRefutation 16.030000s 16.64/16.70 %------------------------------------------- 16.64/16.70 include('Axioms/SWB002+0.ax'). 16.64/16.70 fof(testcase_conclusion_fullish_012_Template_Class,conjecture, 16.64/16.70 ( iext(uri_rdf_type,uri_ex_name,uri_owl_FunctionalProperty) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_type,uri_ex_alice,uri_foaf_Person) )). 16.64/16.70 16.64/16.70 fof(testcase_premise_fullish_012_Template_Class,axiom,( 16.64/16.70 ? [BNODE_l1,BNODE_l2,BNODE_l3,BNODE_r] : 16.64/16.70 ( iext(uri_rdf_first,BNODE_l2,uri_owl_FunctionalProperty) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_rest,BNODE_l2,BNODE_l3) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_type,BNODE_r,uri_owl_Restriction) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_owl_hasValue,BNODE_r,uri_foaf_Person) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_type,uri_ex_name,uri_ex_PersonAttribute) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_ex_name,uri_ex_alice,literal_plain(dat_str_alice)) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_owl_onProperty,BNODE_r,uri_rdfs_domain) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_rest,BNODE_l3,uri_rdf_nil) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_first,BNODE_l3,BNODE_r) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_rest,BNODE_l1,BNODE_l2) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_first,BNODE_l1,uri_owl_DatatypeProperty) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_owl_intersectionOf,uri_ex_PersonAttribute,BNODE_l1) 16.64/16.70 & iext(uri_rdf_type,uri_foaf_Person,uri_owl_Class) ) )). 16.64/16.70 16.64/16.70 %------------------------------------------- 16.64/16.70 % Proof found 16.64/16.70 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 16.64/16.70 % SZS output start Proof 16.64/16.71 %ClaNum:241(EqnAxiom:0) 16.64/16.71 %VarNum:1284(SingletonVarNum:458) 16.64/16.71 %MaxLitNum:15 16.64/16.71 %MaxfuncDepth:1 16.64/16.71 %SharedTerms:142 16.64/16.71 %goalClause: 167 16.64/16.71 [1]P1(a1) 16.64/16.71 [2]P1(a38) 16.64/16.71 [3]P1(a39) 16.64/16.71 [4]P1(a40) 16.64/16.71 [5]P1(a42) 16.64/16.71 [6]P1(a43) 16.64/16.71 [7]P1(a41) 16.64/16.71 [8]P2(a2) 16.64/16.71 [9]P2(a34) 16.64/16.71 [12]P4(a66,a66,a45) 16.64/16.71 [13]P4(a66,a49,a46) 16.64/16.71 [14]P4(a66,a54,a44) 16.64/16.71 [15]P4(a66,a70,a45) 16.64/16.71 [16]P4(a66,a55,a67) 16.64/16.71 [17]P4(a66,a58,a46) 16.64/16.71 [18]P4(a66,a74,a60) 16.64/16.71 [19]P4(a66,a50,a44) 16.64/16.71 [20]P4(a66,a71,a44) 16.64/16.71 [21]P4(a66,a52,a44) 16.64/16.71 [22]P4(a66,a72,a44) 16.64/16.71 [23]P4(a66,a76,a45) 16.64/16.71 [24]P4(a66,a75,a44) 16.64/16.71 [25]P4(a66,a73,a44) 16.64/16.71 [26]P4(a66,a61,a44) 16.64/16.71 [27]P4(a66,a56,a67) 16.64/16.71 [28]P4(a66,a53,a44) 16.64/16.71 [29]P4(a66,a69,a44) 16.64/16.71 [30]P4(a66,a59,a67) 16.64/16.71 [31]P4(a49,a3,a14) 16.64/16.71 [32]P4(a49,a15,a33) 16.64/16.71 [33]P4(a49,a17,a18) 16.64/16.71 [34]P4(a54,a49,a45) 16.64/16.71 [36]P4(a54,a54,a45) 16.64/16.71 [37]P4(a54,a45,a60) 16.64/16.71 [38]P4(a54,a58,a45) 16.64/16.71 [39]P4(a54,a57,a46) 16.64/16.71 [40]P4(a54,a51,a62) 16.64/16.71 [41]P4(a54,a50,a45) 16.64/16.71 [42]P4(a54,a50,a63) 16.64/16.71 [43]P4(a54,a52,a45) 16.64/16.71 [44]P4(a54,a52,a63) 16.64/16.71 [45]P4(a54,a61,a45) 16.64/16.71 [46]P4(a54,a56,a45) 16.64/16.71 [47]P4(a54,a53,a45) 16.64/16.71 [48]P4(a54,a53,a63) 16.64/16.71 [49]P4(a54,a59,a45) 16.64/16.71 [50]P4(a54,a19,a20) 16.64/16.71 [51]P4(a54,a30,a31) 16.64/16.71 [52]P4(a54,a18,a35) 16.64/16.71 [53]P4(a70,a66,a60) 16.64/16.71 [54]P4(a70,a49,a44) 16.64/16.71 [55]P4(a70,a54,a60) 16.64/16.71 [56]P4(a70,a70,a60) 16.64/16.71 [58]P4(a70,a55,a44) 16.64/16.71 [59]P4(a70,a58,a46) 16.64/16.71 [60]P4(a70,a74,a60) 16.64/16.71 [61]P4(a70,a50,a44) 16.64/16.71 [62]P4(a70,a71,a44) 16.64/16.71 [63]P4(a70,a52,a44) 16.64/16.71 [64]P4(a70,a72,a44) 16.64/16.71 [65]P4(a70,a76,a45) 16.64/16.71 [66]P4(a70,a75,a44) 16.64/16.71 [67]P4(a70,a73,a65) 16.64/16.71 [68]P4(a70,a61,a44) 16.64/16.71 [69]P4(a70,a53,a44) 16.64/16.71 [70]P4(a70,a69,a65) 16.64/16.71 [71]P4(a70,a59,a44) 16.64/16.71 [72]P4(a58,a3,a15) 16.64/16.71 [73]P4(a58,a15,a17) 16.64/16.71 [74]P4(a58,a17,a57) 16.64/16.71 [75]P4(a74,a51,a65) 16.64/16.71 [76]P4(a74,a62,a60) 16.64/16.71 [77]P4(a74,a63,a45) 16.64/16.71 [78]P4(a74,a47,a64) 16.64/16.71 [79]P4(a74,a68,a64) 16.64/16.71 [80]P4(a74,a48,a64) 16.64/16.71 [81]P4(a39,a18,a66) 16.64/16.71 [82]P4(a40,a18,a30) 16.64/16.71 [83]P4(a42,a20,a3) 16.64/16.71 [84]P4(a76,a71,a75) 16.64/16.71 [86]P4(a19,a29,f21(a4)) 16.64/16.71 [10]P3(a44,x101) 16.64/16.71 [11]P3(a34,x111) 16.64/16.71 [85]P4(a54,x851,a44) 16.64/16.71 [87]~P3(a2,x871) 16.64/16.71 [167]~P4(a54,a19,a33)+~P4(a54,a29,a30) 16.64/16.71 [88]~P6(x881)+P1(x881) 16.64/16.71 [89]~P8(x891)+P1(x891) 16.64/16.71 [90]~P7(x901)+P1(x901) 16.64/16.71 [91]~P5(x911)+P2(x911) 16.64/16.71 [92]~P9(x921)+P3(a65,x921) 16.64/16.71 [93]~P2(x931)+P3(a60,x931) 16.64/16.71 [94]P9(x941)+~P3(a65,x941) 16.64/16.71 [95]P2(x951)+~P3(a60,x951) 16.64/16.71 [98]~P1(x981)+P4(a54,x981,a45) 16.64/16.71 [99]~P5(x991)+P4(a54,x991,a62) 16.64/16.71 [100]~P6(x1001)+P4(a54,x1001,a14) 16.64/16.71 [101]~P9(x1011)+P4(a54,x1011,a65) 16.64/16.71 [102]~P2(x1021)+P4(a54,x1021,a60) 16.64/16.71 [103]~P10(x1031)+P4(a54,x1031,a36) 16.64/16.71 [104]~P8(x1041)+P4(a54,x1041,a37) 16.64/16.71 [105]~P7(x1051)+P4(a54,x1051,a32) 16.64/16.71 [106]~P2(x1061)+P4(a74,x1061,a44) 16.64/16.71 [107]~P2(x1071)+P4(a74,x1071,x1071) 16.64/16.71 [108]~P1(x1081)+P4(a76,x1081,x1081) 16.64/16.71 [109]~P3(a62,x1091)+P4(a74,x1091,a65) 16.64/16.71 [110]~P3(a63,x1101)+P4(a76,x1101,a72) 16.64/16.71 [114]P1(x1141)+~P4(a54,x1141,a45) 16.64/16.71 [115]P9(x1151)+~P4(a54,x1151,a65) 16.64/16.71 [116]P6(x1161)+~P4(a54,x1161,a14) 16.64/16.71 [117]P2(x1171)+~P4(a54,x1171,a60) 16.64/16.71 [120]P10(x1201)+~P4(a54,x1201,a36) 16.64/16.71 [121]P8(x1211)+~P4(a54,x1211,a37) 16.64/16.71 [122]P7(x1221)+~P4(a54,x1221,a32) 16.64/16.71 [123]P5(x1231)+~P4(a54,x1231,a62) 16.64/16.71 [111]~P3(x1112,x1111)+P4(a54,x1111,x1112) 16.64/16.71 [124]P1(x1241)+~P4(a66,x1241,x1242) 16.64/16.71 [125]P1(x1251)+~P4(a70,x1252,x1251) 16.64/16.71 [126]P1(x1261)+~P4(a70,x1261,x1262) 16.64/16.71 [127]P1(x1271)+~P4(a39,x1272,x1271) 16.64/16.71 [129]P1(x1291)+~P4(a76,x1292,x1291) 16.64/16.71 [131]P1(x1311)+~P4(a76,x1311,x1312) 16.64/16.71 [132]P2(x1321)+~P4(a66,x1322,x1321) 16.64/16.71 [133]P2(x1331)+~P4(a1,x1332,x1331) 16.64/16.71 [134]P2(x1341)+~P4(a38,x1341,x1342) 16.64/16.71 [136]P2(x1361)+~P4(a74,x1362,x1361) 16.64/16.71 [138]P2(x1381)+~P4(a74,x1381,x1382) 16.64/16.71 [139]P2(x1391)+~P4(a42,x1391,x1392) 16.64/16.71 [140]P2(x1401)+~P4(a43,x1402,x1401) 16.64/16.71 [142]P2(x1421)+~P4(a41,x1422,x1421) 16.64/16.71 [144]P2(x1441)+~P4(a41,x1441,x1442) 16.64/16.71 [147]P3(x1471,x1472)+~P4(a42,x1471,a57) 16.64/16.71 [148]~P4(a38,x1482,x1481)+P3(a46,x1481) 16.64/16.71 [149]~P4(a42,x1492,x1491)+P3(a46,x1491) 16.64/16.71 [150]~P4(a1,x1501,x1502)+P3(a35,x1501) 16.64/16.71 [151]~P4(a39,x1511,x1512)+P3(a35,x1511) 16.64/16.71 [152]~P4(a40,x1521,x1522)+P3(a35,x1521) 16.64/16.71 [153]~P4(a43,x1531,x1532)+P3(a35,x1531) 16.64/16.71 [157]P3(x1571,x1572)+~P4(a54,x1572,x1571) 16.64/16.71 [158]~P3(x1581,x1582)+~P4(a38,x1581,a57) 16.64/16.71 [145]P1(x1451)+~P4(x1451,x1452,x1453) 16.64/16.71 [112]~P2(x1121)+P3(x1121,f22(x1121))+P4(a38,x1121,a57) 16.64/16.71 [146]~P2(x1461)+~P3(x1461,f5(x1461))+P4(a42,x1461,a57) 16.64/16.71 [96]~P3(x962,x961)+P9(x961)+~P5(x962) 16.64/16.71 [154]P9(x1541)+~P4(x1542,x1543,x1541)+~P6(x1542) 16.64/16.71 [155]P10(x1551)+~P4(x1552,x1553,x1551)+~P8(x1552) 16.64/16.71 [156]P10(x1561)+~P4(x1562,x1561,x1563)+~P8(x1562) 16.64/16.71 [160]P3(x1601,x1602)+P3(x1603,x1602)+~P4(a41,x1601,x1603) 16.64/16.71 [162]P3(x1621,x1622)+~P3(x1623,x1622)+~P4(a74,x1623,x1621) 16.64/16.71 [163]~P3(x1631,x1632)+~P3(x1633,x1632)+~P4(a41,x1633,x1631) 16.64/16.71 [175]~P4(a74,x1751,x1753)+P4(a74,x1751,x1752)+~P4(a74,x1753,x1752) 16.64/16.71 [176]~P4(a76,x1761,x1763)+P4(a76,x1761,x1762)+~P4(a76,x1763,x1762) 16.64/16.71 [172]P3(x1721,x1722)+~P4(x1723,x1724,x1722)+~P4(a70,x1723,x1721) 16.64/16.71 [174]P3(x1741,x1742)+~P4(x1743,x1742,x1744)+~P4(a66,x1743,x1741) 16.64/16.71 [178]P4(x1781,x1782,x1783)+~P4(x1784,x1782,x1783)+~P4(a76,x1784,x1781) 16.64/16.71 [159]~P2(x1592)+~P2(x1591)+P4(a74,x1591,x1592)+P3(x1591,f6(x1591,x1592)) 16.64/16.71 [164]~P1(x1641)+~P2(x1642)+P4(a66,x1641,x1642)+~P3(x1642,f7(x1641,x1642)) 16.64/16.71 [165]~P1(x1651)+~P1(x1652)+P4(a70,x1651,x1652)+~P3(x1652,f23(x1651,x1652)) 16.64/16.71 [166]~P2(x1661)+~P2(x1662)+P4(a74,x1661,x1662)+~P3(x1662,f6(x1661,x1662)) 16.64/16.71 [168]~P1(x1681)+~P2(x1682)+P4(x1681,f7(x1681,x1682),f8(x1681,x1682))+P4(a66,x1681,x1682) 16.64/16.71 [169]~P1(x1692)+~P1(x1691)+P4(x1691,f24(x1691,x1692),f23(x1691,x1692))+P4(a70,x1691,x1692) 16.64/16.71 [170]~P1(x1702)+~P1(x1701)+P4(x1701,f10(x1701,x1702),f13(x1701,x1702))+P4(a76,x1701,x1702) 16.64/16.71 [179]~P1(x1791)+~P1(x1792)+~P4(x1792,f10(x1791,x1792),f13(x1791,x1792))+P4(a76,x1791,x1792) 16.64/16.71 [181]P2(x1811)+~P4(a49,x1812,x1811)+~P4(a38,x1813,x1812)+~P4(a58,x1812,a57) 16.64/16.71 [182]P2(x1821)+~P4(a49,x1822,x1821)+~P4(a42,x1823,x1822)+~P4(a58,x1822,a57) 16.64/16.71 [180]P4(x1801,x1802,x1803)+~P3(x1804,x1802)+~P4(a39,x1804,x1801)+~P4(a40,x1804,x1803) 16.64/16.71 [185]P3(x1851,x1852)+~P4(x1853,x1852,x1854)+~P4(a39,x1851,x1853)+~P4(a40,x1851,x1854) 16.64/16.71 [224]~P3(x2242,x2244)+~P4(a39,x2242,x2243)+~P4(a43,x2242,x2241)+P3(x2241,f27(x2242,x2243,x2241,x2244)) 16.64/16.71 [225]P3(x2251,x2252)+~P4(a1,x2251,x2254)+~P4(a39,x2251,x2253)+P4(x2253,x2252,f28(x2251,x2253,x2254,x2252)) 16.64/16.71 [226]~P3(x2263,x2262)+~P4(a39,x2263,x2261)+~P4(a43,x2263,x2264)+P4(x2261,x2262,f27(x2263,x2261,x2264,x2262)) 16.64/16.71 [227]P3(x2271,x2272)+~P4(a1,x2271,x2273)+~P4(a39,x2271,x2274)+~P3(x2273,f28(x2271,x2274,x2273,x2272)) 16.64/16.71 [186]P3(x1861,x1862)+~P3(x1863,x1862)+~P4(a38,x1863,x1864)+~P4(a49,x1864,x1861)+~P4(a58,x1864,a57) 16.64/16.71 [187]P3(x1871,x1872)+~P3(x1873,x1872)+~P4(a42,x1873,x1874)+~P4(a49,x1874,x1871)+~P4(a58,x1874,a57) 16.64/16.71 [188]P3(x1881,x1882)+~P3(x1883,x1882)+~P4(a38,x1881,x1884)+~P4(a49,x1884,x1883)+~P4(a58,x1884,a57) 16.64/16.71 [189]P3(x1891,x1892)+~P3(x1893,x1892)+~P4(a42,x1891,x1894)+~P4(a49,x1894,x1893)+~P4(a58,x1894,a57) 16.64/16.71 [190]P3(x1901,x1902)+~P4(x1905,x1904,x1902)+~P3(x1903,x1904)+~P4(a1,x1903,x1901)+~P4(a39,x1903,x1905) 16.64/16.71 [191]P3(x1911,x1912)+~P4(x1915,x1912,x1914)+~P3(x1913,x1914)+~P4(a39,x1911,x1915)+~P4(a43,x1911,x1913) 16.64/16.71 [192]P2(x1921)+~P4(a58,x1923,x1922)+~P4(a49,x1922,x1921)+~P4(a49,x1923,x1924)+~P4(a38,x1925,x1923)+~P4(a58,x1922,a57) 16.64/16.71 [193]P2(x1931)+~P4(a58,x1933,x1932)+~P4(a49,x1932,x1931)+~P4(a49,x1933,x1934)+~P4(a42,x1935,x1933)+~P4(a58,x1932,a57) 16.64/16.71 [194]P2(x1941)+~P4(a58,x1944,x1942)+~P4(a49,x1942,x1943)+~P4(a49,x1944,x1941)+~P4(a38,x1945,x1944)+~P4(a58,x1942,a57) 16.64/16.71 [195]P2(x1951)+~P4(a58,x1954,x1952)+~P4(a49,x1952,x1953)+~P4(a49,x1954,x1951)+~P4(a42,x1955,x1954)+~P4(a58,x1952,a57) 16.64/16.71 [203]~P2(x2033)+~P2(x2031)+~P4(a49,x2032,x2033)+P4(a38,x2031,x2032)+P3(x2031,f26(x2031,x2032,x2033))+P3(x2033,f26(x2031,x2032,x2033))+~P4(a58,x2032,a57) 16.64/16.71 [204]~P2(x2043)+~P2(x2041)+~P4(a49,x2042,x2043)+P4(a42,x2041,x2042)+P3(x2041,f25(x2041,x2042,x2043))+P3(x2043,f25(x2041,x2042,x2043))+~P4(a58,x2042,a57) 16.64/16.71 [214]~P2(x2141)+~P2(x2143)+~P4(a49,x2142,x2143)+P4(a38,x2141,x2142)+~P3(x2143,f26(x2141,x2142,x2143))+~P3(x2141,f26(x2141,x2142,x2143))+~P4(a58,x2142,a57) 16.64/16.71 [215]~P2(x2151)+~P2(x2153)+~P4(a49,x2152,x2153)+P4(a42,x2151,x2152)+~P3(x2153,f25(x2151,x2152,x2153))+~P3(x2151,f25(x2151,x2152,x2153))+~P4(a58,x2152,a57) 16.64/16.71 [198]P3(x1981,x1982)+~P3(x1983,x1982)+~P4(a38,x1981,x1985)+~P4(a58,x1985,x1984)+~P4(a49,x1984,x1983)+~P4(a49,x1985,x1986)+~P4(a58,x1984,a57) 16.64/16.71 [199]P3(x1991,x1992)+~P3(x1993,x1992)+~P4(a38,x1991,x1996)+~P4(a58,x1996,x1994)+~P4(a49,x1994,x1995)+~P4(a49,x1996,x1993)+~P4(a58,x1994,a57) 16.64/16.71 [200]P3(x2001,x2002)+~P3(x2003,x2002)+~P4(a58,x2005,x2004)+~P4(a42,x2003,x2005)+~P4(a49,x2004,x2001)+~P4(a49,x2005,x2006)+~P4(a58,x2004,a57) 16.64/16.71 [201]P3(x2011,x2012)+~P3(x2013,x2012)+~P4(a58,x2016,x2014)+~P4(a42,x2013,x2016)+~P4(a49,x2014,x2015)+~P4(a49,x2016,x2011)+~P4(a58,x2014,a57) 16.64/16.71 [202]P3(x2021,x2022)+P3(x2023,x2022)+~P3(x2024,x2022)+~P4(a38,x2024,x2026)+~P4(a58,x2026,x2025)+~P4(a49,x2025,x2023)+~P4(a49,x2026,x2021)+~P4(a58,x2025,a57) 16.64/16.71 [205]P3(x2051,x2052)+~P3(x2053,x2052)+~P3(x2054,x2052)+~P4(a58,x2056,x2055)+~P4(a42,x2051,x2056)+~P4(a49,x2055,x2053)+~P4(a49,x2056,x2054)+~P4(a58,x2055,a57) 16.64/16.71 [206]P2(x2061)+~P4(a58,x2062,x2063)+~P4(a58,x2065,x2062)+~P4(a49,x2062,x2061)+~P4(a49,x2063,x2064)+~P4(a49,x2065,x2066)+~P4(a38,x2067,x2065)+~P4(a58,x2063,a57) 16.64/16.71 [207]P2(x2071)+~P4(a58,x2072,x2074)+~P4(a58,x2075,x2072)+~P4(a49,x2072,x2073)+~P4(a49,x2074,x2071)+~P4(a49,x2075,x2076)+~P4(a38,x2077,x2075)+~P4(a58,x2074,a57) 16.64/16.71 [208]P2(x2081)+~P4(a58,x2082,x2084)+~P4(a58,x2086,x2082)+~P4(a49,x2082,x2083)+~P4(a49,x2084,x2085)+~P4(a49,x2086,x2081)+~P4(a38,x2087,x2086)+~P4(a58,x2084,a57) 16.64/16.71 [209]P2(x2091)+~P4(a58,x2094,x2092)+~P4(a58,x2096,x2094)+~P4(a49,x2092,x2093)+~P4(a49,x2094,x2095)+~P4(a49,x2096,x2091)+~P4(a42,x2097,x2096)+~P4(a58,x2092,a57) 16.64/16.71 [211]P2(x2111)+~P4(a58,x2113,x2112)+~P4(a58,x2115,x2113)+~P4(a49,x2112,x2111)+~P4(a49,x2113,x2114)+~P4(a49,x2115,x2116)+~P4(a42,x2117,x2115)+~P4(a58,x2112,a57) 16.64/16.71 [212]P2(x2121)+~P4(a58,x2124,x2122)+~P4(a58,x2125,x2124)+~P4(a49,x2122,x2123)+~P4(a49,x2124,x2121)+~P4(a49,x2125,x2126)+~P4(a42,x2127,x2125)+~P4(a58,x2122,a57) 16.64/16.71 [216]P3(x2161,x2162)+~P3(x2163,x2162)+~P4(a38,x2161,x2167)+~P4(a58,x2164,x2165)+~P4(a58,x2167,x2164)+~P4(a49,x2164,x2163)+~P4(a49,x2165,x2166)+~P4(a49,x2167,x2168)+~P4(a58,x2165,a57) 16.64/16.71 [217]P3(x2171,x2172)+~P3(x2173,x2172)+~P4(a38,x2171,x2177)+~P4(a58,x2174,x2176)+~P4(a58,x2177,x2174)+~P4(a49,x2174,x2175)+~P4(a49,x2176,x2173)+~P4(a49,x2177,x2178)+~P4(a58,x2176,a57) 16.64/16.71 [218]P3(x2181,x2182)+~P3(x2183,x2182)+~P4(a38,x2181,x2188)+~P4(a58,x2184,x2186)+~P4(a58,x2188,x2184)+~P4(a49,x2184,x2185)+~P4(a49,x2186,x2187)+~P4(a49,x2188,x2183)+~P4(a58,x2186,a57) 16.64/16.71 [219]P3(x2191,x2192)+~P3(x2193,x2192)+~P4(a58,x2196,x2194)+~P4(a58,x2198,x2196)+~P4(a42,x2193,x2198)+~P4(a49,x2194,x2195)+~P4(a49,x2196,x2197)+~P4(a49,x2198,x2191)+~P4(a58,x2194,a57) 16.64/16.71 [220]P3(x2201,x2202)+~P3(x2203,x2202)+~P4(a58,x2205,x2204)+~P4(a58,x2207,x2205)+~P4(a42,x2203,x2207)+~P4(a49,x2204,x2201)+~P4(a49,x2205,x2206)+~P4(a49,x2207,x2208)+~P4(a58,x2204,a57) 16.64/16.71 [221]P3(x2211,x2212)+~P3(x2213,x2212)+~P4(a58,x2216,x2214)+~P4(a58,x2217,x2216)+~P4(a42,x2213,x2217)+~P4(a49,x2214,x2215)+~P4(a49,x2216,x2211)+~P4(a49,x2217,x2218)+~P4(a58,x2214,a57) 16.64/16.71 [228]~P2(x2283)+~P2(x2281)+~P2(x2285)+~P4(a49,x2284,x2285)+~P4(a49,x2282,x2283)+~P4(a58,x2282,x2284)+P4(a42,x2281,x2282)+P3(x2281,f11(x2281,x2282,x2283,x2284,x2285))+P3(x2285,f11(x2281,x2282,x2283,x2284,x2285))+~P4(a58,x2284,a57) 16.64/16.71 [229]~P2(x2295)+~P2(x2291)+~P2(x2293)+~P4(a49,x2294,x2295)+~P4(a49,x2292,x2293)+~P4(a58,x2292,x2294)+P4(a42,x2291,x2292)+P3(x2291,f11(x2291,x2292,x2293,x2294,x2295))+P3(x2293,f11(x2291,x2292,x2293,x2294,x2295))+~P4(a58,x2294,a57) 16.64/16.71 [231]~P2(x2311)+~P2(x2313)+~P2(x2314)+~P4(a49,x2312,x2314)+~P4(a58,x2312,x2315)+P4(a38,x2311,x2312)+~P4(a49,x2315,x2313)+~P3(x2311,f16(x2311,x2312,x2314,x2315,x2313))+~P3(x2314,f16(x2311,x2312,x2314,x2315,x2313))+~P4(a58,x2315,a57) 16.64/16.71 [232]~P2(x2321)+~P2(x2323)+~P2(x2324)+~P4(a49,x2322,x2323)+~P4(a58,x2322,x2325)+P4(a38,x2321,x2322)+~P4(a49,x2325,x2324)+~P3(x2321,f16(x2321,x2322,x2323,x2325,x2324))+~P3(x2324,f16(x2321,x2322,x2323,x2325,x2324))+~P4(a58,x2325,a57) 16.64/16.71 [230]~P2(x2303)+~P2(x2304)+~P2(x2301)+~P4(a49,x2305,x2303)+~P4(a49,x2302,x2304)+~P4(a58,x2302,x2305)+P4(a38,x2301,x2302)+P3(x2303,f16(x2301,x2302,x2304,x2305,x2303))+P3(x2304,f16(x2301,x2302,x2304,x2305,x2303))+P3(x2301,f16(x2301,x2302,x2304,x2305,x2303))+~P4(a58,x2305,a57) 16.64/16.71 [233]~P2(x2331)+~P2(x2333)+~P2(x2334)+~P4(a49,x2332,x2334)+~P4(a58,x2332,x2335)+P4(a42,x2331,x2332)+~P4(a49,x2335,x2333)+~P3(x2333,f11(x2331,x2332,x2334,x2335,x2333))+~P3(x2331,f11(x2331,x2332,x2334,x2335,x2333))+~P3(x2334,f11(x2331,x2332,x2334,x2335,x2333))+~P4(a58,x2335,a57) 16.64/16.71 [222]P3(x2221,x2222)+P3(x2223,x2222)+P3(x2224,x2222)+~P3(x2225,x2222)+~P4(a38,x2225,x2228)+~P4(a58,x2226,x2227)+~P4(a58,x2228,x2226)+~P4(a49,x2226,x2223)+~P4(a49,x2227,x2221)+~P4(a49,x2228,x2224)+~P4(a58,x2227,a57) 16.64/16.71 [223]P3(x2231,x2232)+~P3(x2233,x2232)+~P3(x2234,x2232)+~P3(x2235,x2232)+~P4(a58,x2237,x2236)+~P4(a58,x2238,x2237)+~P4(a42,x2231,x2238)+~P4(a49,x2236,x2233)+~P4(a49,x2237,x2234)+~P4(a49,x2238,x2235)+~P4(a58,x2236,a57) 16.64/16.71 [234]~P2(x2345)+~P2(x2343)+~P2(x2341)+~P2(x2347)+~P4(a49,x2346,x2347)+~P4(a49,x2344,x2345)+~P4(a49,x2342,x2343)+~P4(a58,x2344,x2346)+~P4(a58,x2342,x2344)+P4(a42,x2341,x2342)+P3(x2341,f12(x2341,x2342,x2343,x2344,x2345,x2346,x2347))+P3(x2347,f12(x2341,x2342,x2343,x2344,x2345,x2346,x2347))+~P4(a58,x2346,a57) 16.64/16.71 [235]~P2(x2357)+~P2(x2353)+~P2(x2351)+~P2(x2355)+~P4(a49,x2356,x2357)+~P4(a49,x2354,x2355)+~P4(a49,x2352,x2353)+~P4(a58,x2354,x2356)+~P4(a58,x2352,x2354)+P4(a42,x2351,x2352)+P3(x2351,f12(x2351,x2352,x2353,x2354,x2355,x2356,x2357))+P3(x2355,f12(x2351,x2352,x2353,x2354,x2355,x2356,x2357))+~P4(a58,x2356,a57) 16.64/16.71 [236]~P2(x2367)+~P2(x2365)+~P2(x2361)+~P2(x2363)+~P4(a49,x2366,x2367)+~P4(a49,x2364,x2365)+~P4(a49,x2362,x2363)+~P4(a58,x2364,x2366)+~P4(a58,x2362,x2364)+P4(a42,x2361,x2362)+P3(x2361,f12(x2361,x2362,x2363,x2364,x2365,x2366,x2367))+P3(x2363,f12(x2361,x2362,x2363,x2364,x2365,x2366,x2367))+~P4(a58,x2366,a57) 16.64/16.71 [237]~P2(x2371)+~P2(x2373)+~P2(x2374)+~P2(x2375)+~P4(a49,x2372,x2375)+~P4(a58,x2377,x2376)+~P4(a58,x2372,x2377)+P4(a38,x2371,x2372)+~P4(a49,x2376,x2373)+~P4(a49,x2377,x2374)+~P3(x2371,f9(x2371,x2372,x2375,x2377,x2374,x2376,x2373))+~P3(x2375,f9(x2371,x2372,x2375,x2377,x2374,x2376,x2373))+~P4(a58,x2376,a57) 16.64/16.72 [238]~P2(x2381)+~P2(x2383)+~P2(x2384)+~P2(x2385)+~P4(a49,x2382,x2384)+~P4(a58,x2387,x2386)+~P4(a58,x2382,x2387)+P4(a38,x2381,x2382)+~P4(a49,x2386,x2383)+~P4(a49,x2387,x2385)+~P3(x2381,f9(x2381,x2382,x2384,x2387,x2385,x2386,x2383))+~P3(x2385,f9(x2381,x2382,x2384,x2387,x2385,x2386,x2383))+~P4(a58,x2386,a57) 16.64/16.72 [239]~P2(x2391)+~P2(x2393)+~P2(x2394)+~P2(x2395)+~P4(a49,x2392,x2394)+~P4(a58,x2397,x2396)+~P4(a58,x2392,x2397)+P4(a38,x2391,x2392)+~P4(a49,x2396,x2395)+~P4(a49,x2397,x2393)+~P3(x2391,f9(x2391,x2392,x2394,x2397,x2393,x2396,x2395))+~P3(x2395,f9(x2391,x2392,x2394,x2397,x2393,x2396,x2395))+~P4(a58,x2396,a57) 16.64/16.72 [240]~P2(x2403)+~P2(x2406)+~P2(x2404)+~P2(x2401)+~P4(a49,x2407,x2403)+~P4(a49,x2405,x2406)+~P4(a49,x2402,x2404)+~P4(a58,x2405,x2407)+~P4(a58,x2402,x2405)+P4(a38,x2401,x2402)+P3(x2403,f9(x2401,x2402,x2404,x2405,x2406,x2407,x2403))+P3(x2406,f9(x2401,x2402,x2404,x2405,x2406,x2407,x2403))+P3(x2404,f9(x2401,x2402,x2404,x2405,x2406,x2407,x2403))+P3(x2401,f9(x2401,x2402,x2404,x2405,x2406,x2407,x2403))+~P4(a58,x2407,a57) 16.64/16.72 [241]~P2(x2411)+~P2(x2413)+~P2(x2414)+~P2(x2415)+~P4(a49,x2412,x2415)+~P4(a58,x2417,x2416)+~P4(a58,x2412,x2417)+P4(a42,x2411,x2412)+~P4(a49,x2416,x2413)+~P4(a49,x2417,x2414)+~P3(x2413,f12(x2411,x2412,x2415,x2417,x2414,x2416,x2413))+~P3(x2414,f12(x2411,x2412,x2415,x2417,x2414,x2416,x2413))+~P3(x2411,f12(x2411,x2412,x2415,x2417,x2414,x2416,x2413))+~P3(x2415,f12(x2411,x2412,x2415,x2417,x2414,x2416,x2413))+~P4(a58,x2416,a57) 16.64/16.72 %EqnAxiom 16.64/16.72 16.64/16.72 %------------------------------------------- 16.64/16.72 cnf(509,plain, 16.64/16.72 (P3(a20,a19)), 16.64/16.72 inference(scs_inference,[],[50,157])). 16.64/16.72 cnf(519,plain, 16.64/16.72 (P4(a66,a19,a30)), 16.64/16.72 inference(scs_inference,[],[53,74,13,16,81,83,50,31,32,73,72,82,33,157,172,219,220,174,180])). 16.64/16.72 cnf(552,plain, 16.64/16.72 (P3(a30,a29)), 16.64/16.72 inference(scs_inference,[],[519,51,86,132,124,157,174])). 16.64/16.72 cnf(662,plain, 16.64/16.72 (P3(a33,a19)), 16.64/16.72 inference(scs_inference,[],[509,74,13,83,72,32,73,31,33,174,212,221])). 16.64/16.72 cnf(3176,plain, 16.64/16.72 (~P4(a54,a29,a30)), 16.64/16.72 inference(scs_inference,[],[662,167,111])). 16.64/16.72 cnf(3177,plain, 16.64/16.72 ($false), 16.64/16.72 inference(scs_inference,[],[3176,552,111]), 16.64/16.72 ['proof']). 16.64/16.72 % SZS output end Proof 16.64/16.72 % Total time :16.030000s 16.71/16.73 EOF