0.07/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.07/0.13 % Command : tptp2X_and_run_prover9 %d %s 0.12/0.34 % Computer : n007.cluster.edu 0.12/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.12/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.12/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.12/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.12/0.34 % CPULimit : 180 0.12/0.34 % DateTime : Thu Aug 29 09:34:21 EDT 2019 0.12/0.34 % CPUTime : 0.98/1.26 ============================== Prover9 =============================== 0.98/1.26 Prover9 (32) version 2009-11A, November 2009. 0.98/1.26 Process 7438 was started by sandbox on n007.cluster.edu, 0.98/1.26 Thu Aug 29 09:34:22 2019 0.98/1.26 The command was "/export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/prover9 -t 180 -f /tmp/Prover9_7282_n007.cluster.edu". 0.98/1.26 ============================== end of head =========================== 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 ============================== INPUT ================================= 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 % Reading from file /tmp/Prover9_7282_n007.cluster.edu 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 set(prolog_style_variables). 0.98/1.26 set(auto2). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> set(auto). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto) -> set(auto_inference). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto) -> set(auto_setup). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto_setup) -> set(predicate_elim). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto_setup) -> assign(eq_defs, unfold). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto) -> set(auto_limits). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto_limits) -> assign(max_weight, "100.000"). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto_limits) -> assign(sos_limit, 20000). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto) -> set(auto_denials). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto) -> set(auto_process). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(new_constants, 1). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(fold_denial_max, 3). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(max_weight, "200.000"). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(max_hours, 1). 0.98/1.26 % assign(max_hours, 1) -> assign(max_seconds, 3600). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(max_seconds, 0). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(max_minutes, 5). 0.98/1.26 % assign(max_minutes, 5) -> assign(max_seconds, 300). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> set(sort_initial_sos). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(sos_limit, -1). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(lrs_ticks, 3000). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(max_megs, 400). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> assign(stats, some). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> clear(echo_input). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> set(quiet). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> clear(print_initial_clauses). 0.98/1.26 % set(auto2) -> clear(print_given). 0.98/1.26 assign(lrs_ticks,-1). 0.98/1.26 assign(sos_limit,10000). 0.98/1.26 assign(order,kbo). 0.98/1.26 set(lex_order_vars). 0.98/1.26 clear(print_given). 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 % formulas(sos). % not echoed (1 formulas) 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 ============================== end of input ========================== 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 % From the command line: assign(max_seconds, 180). 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 ============================== PROCESS NON-CLAUSAL FORMULAS ========== 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 % Formulas that are not ordinary clauses: 0.98/1.26 1 --(exists X -((all Y (p17(Y) | -r1(X,Y))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (p15(X) & p14(X) & p13(X) & p12(X) & p10(X) & p6(X) & p5(X) & p3(X) & p1(X) & p2(X) & p4(X) & p7(X) & p8(X) & p9(X) & p11(X) & p16(X) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))))))))))))) | -(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | -(-(all X (-(-(all Y (-(-(all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(p13(X) & p14(X) | -p13(X) & -p14(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | (all X (p14(X) | -r1(Y,X))) | -(all X (-(-(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-p13(X) & -p12(X) | p13(X) & p12(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p13(Y))) | -(all Y (-(-(all X (-(-(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | -(-(all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-(all Y (-(-(all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(p7(X) & p8(X) | -p8(X) & -p7(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -(all X (-(-(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | -((all X (-r1(Y,X) | p6(X))) | -(all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-p5(X) & -p4(X) | p4(X) & p5(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -(all Y (-(-(all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-(-p3(X) & -p4(X) | p3(X) & p4(X)) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -(all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-(all Y (--(all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-p2(X) & -p1(X) | p1(X) & p2(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p3(Y))) | -(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-p3(X) & -p2(X) | p3(X) & p2(X))))))))) | (all X (p4(X) | -r1(Y,X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p5(Y)))))) | -(all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-(p6(X) & p5(X) | -p6(X) & -p5(X)) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y)))))))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p7(Y))) | -(all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-(-p7(X) & -p6(X) | p6(X) & p7(X)) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X)))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | (all X (p8(X) | -r1(Y,X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p9(Y))) | -(all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-p9(X) & -p8(X) | p8(X) & p9(X)))))))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y)))))) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | p10(X))) | -(all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-(p10(X) & p9(X) | -p10(X) & -p9(X)) | -r1(Y,X))))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X)))))))))))))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p11(Y))) | -(all Y ((all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(p11(X) & p10(X) | -p11(X) & -p10(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y)))) | -r1(Y,X))) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | p12(X))) | -(all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(-p12(X) & -p11(X) | p12(X) & p11(X)))))) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -r1(Y,X))))))))) | -r1(Y,X))))) | -r1(Y,X)))) | -r1(X,Y)))) | -r1(Y,X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | p15(Y))) | -(all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | -(p14(X) & p15(X) | -p14(X) & -p15(X)))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))))) | -r1(X,Y)))) | -r1(Y,X))) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | p16(X))) | -(all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-(-p15(X) & -p1(X) | p15(X) & p1(X)) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))))))))))) | -r1(Y,X))))))))))))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X)))))) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y ((all X (-r1(Y,X) | (all Y (-r1(X,Y) | (all X ((all Y ((all X ((all Y ((all X (-p32(X) & -p30(X) & -p28(X) & -p22(X) & -p16(X) & -p14(X) & -p12(X) & -p2(X) & -p4(X) & -p6(X) & -p8(X) & -p10(X) & -p18(X) & -p20(X) & -p24(X) & -p26(X) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))))) | -r1(X,Y))) | -r1(Y,X))))))) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture) # label(non_clause). [assumption]. 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 ============================== end of process non-clausal formulas === 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 ============================== PROCESS INITIAL CLAUSES =============== 0.98/1.26 0.98/1.26 ============================== PREDICATE ELIMINATION ================= 0.98/1.26 2 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | p14(V8) | p15(V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 0.98/1.26 3 -r1(c1,A) | -p15(f13(A,B)) | -r1(A,B) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 0.98/1.26 4 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -p14(V8) | -p15(V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 0.98/1.26 5 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | -p15(V12) | -p1(V12) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V11,V13) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 1.41/1.71 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f13(V8,V9)) | p14(f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V10,V7) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(V6,V14) | -r1(V15,E) | -r1(D,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V8,V9). [resolve(2,h,3,b)]. 1.41/1.71 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | p14(V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V24) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V25,V26) | -r1(V26,V27) | -p1(V8) | -r1(V28,V8) | -r1(V27,V28) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V29,V17) | -r1(V30,V29) | -r1(V16,V30). [resolve(2,h,5,k)]. 1.41/1.71 6 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | p15(V12) | p1(V12) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V11,V13) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 1.41/1.71 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | p1(f13(V12,V13)) | -r1(V14,f13(V12,V13)) | -r1(V11,V14) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(V16,V15) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V12) | -r1(V12,V13). [resolve(6,k,3,b)]. 1.41/1.71 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | p1(V12) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V11,V13) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V12) | -p14(V12) | -r1(V24,V23) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V26,V25) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V22,V28) | -r1(V29,V20) | -r1(V19,V29) | -r1(V30,V17) | -r1(V16,V30). [resolve(6,k,4,h)]. 1.41/1.71 7 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | p13(V8) | p14(V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V6,V9) | -r1(V10,F) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(E,V12) | -r1(V13,D) | -r1(C,V13) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 1.41/1.71 8 -r1(c1,A) | -p14(f1(A,B,C)) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(A,B) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 1.41/1.71 9 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -p13(V8) | -p14(V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V6,V9) | -r1(V10,F) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(E,V12) | -r1(V13,D) | -r1(C,V13) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 1.41/1.71 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f1(V8,V9,V10)) | p13(f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V11,V7) | -r1(V6,V11) | -r1(V12,F) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(E,V14) | -r1(V15,D) | -r1(C,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(V17,V16) | -r1(A,V17) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V8,V9). [resolve(7,g,8,b)]. 1.41/1.71 10 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f13(V8,V9)) | p14(f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V10,V7) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(V6,V14) | -r1(V15,E) | -r1(D,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V8,V9). [resolve(2,h,3,b)]. 1.41/1.71 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V10,V7) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(V6,V14) | -r1(V15,E) | -r1(D,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(c1,V17) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V24,f13(V8,V9)) | -p13(f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V23,V25) | -r1(V26,V22) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V21,V28) | -r1(V29,V20) | -r1(V19,V29) | -r1(V30,V18) | -r1(V31,V30) | -r1(V17,V31). [resolve(10,g,9,g)]. 1.41/1.71 11 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | p14(V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V24) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V25,V26) | -r1(V26,V27) | -p1(V8) | -r1(V28,V8) | -r1(V27,V28) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V29,V17) | -r1(V30,V29) | -r1(V16,V30). [resolve(2,h,5,k)]. 23.74/24.08 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V11,V7) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(V6,V15) | -r1(V16,E) | -r1(D,V16) | -r1(V17,B) | -r1(A,V17) | -r1(c1,V18) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V23,V24) | -r1(V25,V26) | -r1(V26,V27) | -r1(V27,V28) | -r1(V28,V29) | -p1(f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V30,f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V29,V30) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V31,V19) | -r1(V32,V31) | -r1(V18,V32) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V8,V9). [resolve(11,g,8,b)]. 23.74/24.08 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V24) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V25,V26) | -r1(V26,V27) | -p1(V8) | -r1(V28,V8) | -r1(V27,V28) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V29,V17) | -r1(V30,V29) | -r1(V16,V30) | -r1(c1,V31) | -r1(V32,V33) | -r1(V34,V35) | -r1(V36,V37) | -r1(V38,V8) | -p13(V8) | -r1(V39,V38) | -r1(V37,V39) | -r1(V40,V36) | -r1(V41,V40) | -r1(V42,V41) | -r1(V35,V42) | -r1(V43,V34) | -r1(V33,V43) | -r1(V44,V32) | -r1(V45,V44) | -r1(V31,V45). [resolve(11,g,9,g)]. 23.74/24.08 12 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | p1(V12) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V11,V13) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V12) | -p14(V12) | -r1(V24,V23) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V26,V25) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V22,V28) | -r1(V29,V20) | -r1(V19,V29) | -r1(V30,V17) | -r1(V16,V30). [resolve(6,k,4,h)]. 23.74/24.08 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | p1(V12) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V11,V13) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V12) | -r1(V24,V23) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V26,V25) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V22,V28) | -r1(V29,V20) | -r1(V19,V29) | -r1(V30,V17) | -r1(V16,V30) | -r1(c1,V31) | -r1(V32,V33) | -r1(V34,V35) | -r1(V36,V37) | -r1(V38,V12) | p13(V12) | -r1(V39,V38) | -r1(V37,V39) | -r1(V40,V36) | -r1(V41,V40) | -r1(V42,V41) | -r1(V35,V42) | -r1(V43,V34) | -r1(V33,V43) | -r1(V44,V32) | -r1(V45,V44) | -r1(V31,V45). [resolve(12,x,7,g)]. 23.74/24.08 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V10,V11) | p1(f13(V12,V13)) | -r1(V14,f13(V12,V13)) | -r1(V11,V14) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(V16,V15) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V17) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V24,f13(V12,V13)) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V26,V25) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V29,V28) | -r1(V23,V29) | -r1(V30,V21) | -r1(V20,V30) | -r1(V31,V18) | -r1(V17,V31) | -r1(c1,V32) | -r1(V33,V34) | -r1(V34,V35) | -r1(V36,V37) | -r1(V37,V38) | -r1(V39,f13(V12,V13)) | -r1(V40,V39) | -r1(V41,V40) | -r1(V42,V41) | -r1(V43,V42) | -r1(V44,V43) | -r1(V38,V44) | -r1(V45,V36) | -r1(V35,V45) | -r1(V46,V33) | -r1(V32,V46) | -r1(c1,V12) | -r1(V12,V13). [resolve(12,x,10,g)]. 23.74/24.08 13 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V8,V9) | p13(V9) | p12(V9) | -r1(V10,V8) | -r1(V7,V10) | -r1(V11,V6) | -r1(F,V11) | -r1(V12,E) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(D,V13) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 23.74/24.08 14 -r1(c1,A) | -p13(f2(A,B,C,D)) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(A,B) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 23.74/24.08 15 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V8,V9) | -p13(V9) | -p12(V9) | -r1(V10,V8) | -r1(V7,V10) | -r1(V11,V6) | -r1(F,V11) | -r1(V12,E) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(D,V13) | -r1(V14,B) | -r1(V15,V14) | -r1(A,V15) # label(main) # label(negated_conjecture). [clausify(1)]. 34.43/34.69 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(V6,V7) | -r1(V8,f2(V9,V10,V11,V12)) | p12(f2(V9,V10,V11,V12)) | -r1(V13,V8) | -r1(V7,V13) | -r1(V14,V6) | -r1(F,V14) | -r1(V15,E) | -r1(V16,V15) | -r1(D,V16) | -r1(V17,B) | -r1(V18,V17) | -r1(A,V18) | -r1(c1,V9) | -r1(V11,V12) | -r1(V10,V11) | -r1(V9,V10). [resolve(13,g,14,b)]. 34.43/34.69 16 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f1(V8,V9,V10)) | p13(f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V11,V7) | -r1(V6,V11) | -r1(V12,F) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(E,V14) | -r1(V15,D) | -r1(C,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(V17,V16) | -r1(A,V17) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V8,V9). [resolve(7,g,8,b)]. 34.43/34.69 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(D,E) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V11,V7) | -r1(V6,V11) | -r1(V12,F) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(E,V14) | -r1(V15,D) | -r1(C,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(V17,V16) | -r1(A,V17) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V9,V10) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(c1,V18) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V26,f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -p12(f1(V8,V9,V10)) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V25,V27) | -r1(V28,V24) | -r1(V23,V28) | -r1(V29,V22) | -r1(V30,V29) | -r1(V21,V30) | -r1(V31,V19) | -r1(V32,V31) | -r1(V18,V32). [resolve(16,f,15,g)]. 34.43/34.69 17 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V10,V7) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(V6,V14) | -r1(V15,E) | -r1(D,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(c1,V17) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V24,f13(V8,V9)) | -p13(f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V23,V25) | -r1(V26,V22) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V21,V28) | -r1(V29,V20) | -r1(V19,V29) | -r1(V30,V18) | -r1(V31,V30) | -r1(V17,V31). [resolve(10,g,9,g)]. 34.43/34.69 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V10,V7) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V14,V13) | -r1(V6,V14) | -r1(V15,E) | -r1(D,V15) | -r1(V16,B) | -r1(A,V16) | -r1(c1,V8) | -r1(V8,V9) | -r1(c1,V17) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V24,f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V25,V24) | -r1(V23,V25) | -r1(V26,V22) | -r1(V27,V26) | -r1(V28,V27) | -r1(V21,V28) | -r1(V29,V20) | -r1(V19,V29) | -r1(V30,V18) | -r1(V31,V30) | -r1(V17,V31) | -r1(c1,V32) | -r1(V33,V34) | -r1(V34,V35) | -r1(V36,V37) | -r1(V38,V39) | -r1(V40,f13(V8,V9)) | p12(f13(V8,V9)) | -r1(V41,V40) | -r1(V39,V41) | -r1(V42,V38) | -r1(V37,V42) | -r1(V43,V36) | -r1(V44,V43) | -r1(V35,V44) | -r1(V45,V33) | -r1(V46,V45) | -r1(V32,V46). [resolve(17,x,13,g)]. 34.43/34.69 18 -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V24) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V25,V26) | -r1(V26,V27) | -p1(V8) | -r1(V28,V8) | -r1(V27,V28) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V29,V17) | -r1(V30,V29) | -r1(V16,V30) | -r1(c1,V31) | -r1(V32,V33) | -r1(V34,V35) | -r1(V36,V37) | -r1(V38,V8) | -p13(V8) | -r1(V39,V38) | -r1(V37,V39) | -r1(V40,V36) | -r1(V41,V40) | -r1(V42,V41) | -r1(V35,V42) | -r1(V43,V34) | -r1(V33,V43) | -r1(V44,V32) | -r1(V45,V44) | -r1(V31,V45). [resolve(11,g,9,g)]. 34.43/34.69 Derived: -r1(c1,A) | -r1(B,C) | -r1(C,D) | -r1(E,F) | -r1(F,V6) | -r1(V7,V8) | -r1(V9,V7) | -r1(V10,V9) | -r1(V11,V10) | -r1(V12,V11) | -r1(V13,V12) | -r1(V6,V13) | -r1(V14,E) | -r1(D,V14) | -r1(V15,B) | -r1(A,V15) | -r1(c1,V16) | -r1(V17,V18) | -r1(V18,V19) | -r1(V19,V20) | -r1(V20,V21) | -r1(V21,V22) | -r1(V23,V24) | -r1(V24,V25) | -r1(V25,V26) | -r1(V26,V27) | -p1(V8) | -r1(V28,V8) | -r1(V27,V28) | -r1(V22,V23) | -r1(V29,V17) | -r1(V30,V29) | -r1(V16,V30) | -r1(c1,V31) | -r1(V32,V33) | -r1(V34,V35) | -r1(V36,V37) | -r1(V38,V8) | -r1(V39,V38) | -r1(V37,V39) | -r1(V40,V36) | -r1(V41,V40) | -r1(V42,V41) | -r1(V35,V42) | -r1(V43,V34) | -r1(V33,V43) | -r1(V44,V32) | -r1(V45,V44) | -r1(V31,V45) | -r1(c1,V46) | -r1(V47,V48) | -r1(V48Cputime limit exceeded (core dumped) (core dumped) 180.02/180.30 Prover9 interrupted 180.02/180.31 Cputime limit exceeded (core dumped) 180.02/180.31 EOF