System:    CARINE
Version:   0.72
URL:       http://www.cs.mcgill.ca/~pharoun/atp_carine_site
Command:   carine %s t=%d xo=off
Format:    carine
Transform: none
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = A proof was found
GaveUp:    GIVE UP!
StartSoln: Refutation = --------------- Start of Proof ---------------
EndSoln:   Refutation = --------------- End of Proof ---------------
Statistic: Generated = Total number of generated clauses: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Units = Number of unit clauses generated: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX
CASCProb:  NoTransform/carine
Status:    READY

System:    CiME
Version:   2.01
URL:       http://cime.lri.fr/
Command:   tptp2cime %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF_UEQ
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = status : string = "unsatisfiable"
Solved:    Satisfiable = status : string = "satisfiable"
StartSoln: Refutation = The current conjecture is true and the solution is the identity
EndSoln:   Refutation = All conjectures have been proven
StartSoln: Saturation = Initializing completion
EndSoln:   Saturation = Warning: some conjectures remain
CASCDiv:   UEQ
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    DCTP
Version:   1.3
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~stenz/dctp-sb.html
Command:   dctp-wrapper -negpref -complexity -fullrewrite -alternate -resisol %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = PROOF found
Solved:    Satisfiable = MODEL found
GaveUp:    ERROR
Statistic: Linkings = Linking steps.*: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: ClausesInTableau = Clauses in tableau.*: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    DCTP
Version:   1.3-SAT
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~stenz/dctp-sb.html
Command:   dctp-wrapper -global -negpref -fullrewrite -alternate -resisol -complexity -minselect -split %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF_NKT
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = PROOF found
Solved:    Satisfiable = MODEL found
GaveUp:    ERROR
Statistic: Linkings = Linking steps.*: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: ClausesInTableau = Clauses in tableau.*: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   SAT
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    DCTP
Version:   1.3-EPR
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~stenz/dctp-sb.html
Command:   dctp-wrapper -global -pospref -fullrewrite -alternate -resisol %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF_EPR
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = PROOF found
Solved:    Satisfiable = MODEL found
GaveUp:    ERROR
Statistic: Linkings = Linking steps.*: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: ClausesInTableau = Clauses in tableau.*: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   EPR
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    DCTP
Version:   10.2p
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~stenz/dctp-sb.html
Command:   bin/dctp-10.2p %s %d
Format:    tptp
Transform: none
SPCs:      CNF FOF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = PROOF found
Solved:    Satisfiable = MODEL found
GaveUp:    ERROR
CASCDiv:   MIX FOF EPR
CASCProb:  NoTransform/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    DCTP
Version:   10.2p-SAT
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~stenz/dctp-sb.html
Command:   bin/dctp-10.2p-sat %s %d
Format:    tptp
Transform: none
SPCs:      CNF_NKT FOF_NKT
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = PROOF found
Solved:    Satisfiable = MODEL found
GaveUp:    ERROR
CASCDiv:   SAT
CASCProb:  NoTransform/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    E
Version:   0.8
URL:       http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/eprover.html
Command:   eprover -s --print-statistics -xAuto -tAuto --memory-limit=384 --tptp-in --cpu-limit=%d %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = TSTP exit status: Unsatisfiable
Solved:    Satisfiable = TSTP exit status: Satisfiable
GaveUp:    TSTP exit status: GaveUp
Statistic: Generated = Generated clauses *: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: NonTrivial = the previous two non-trivial *: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Processed = Processed clauses *: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX EPR UEQ
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    EP
Version:   0.8
URL:       http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/eprover.html
Command:   eproof --print-statistics -xAuto -tAuto --memory-limit=384 --tptp-in --cpu-limit=%d %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = TSTP exit status: Unsatisfiable
Solved:    Satisfiable = TSTP exit status: Satisfiable
GaveUp:    TSTP exit status: GaveUp
StartSoln: Refutation = Proof object starts here
EndSoln:   Refutation = Proof object ends here
StartSoln: Saturation = Saturation derivation starts here
EndSoln:   Saturation = Saturation derivation ends here
Statistic: Clauses = Generated clauses *: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: NonTrivial = the previous two non-trivial *: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Processed = Processed clauses *: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    E-SETHEO
Version:   csp02
URL:       http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/e-setheo.html
Command:   bin/run-e-setheo %s %d
Format:    tptp
Transform: none
NoSPCs:      CNF FOF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = SUCCESS (proof
Solved:    Satisfiable = SUCCESS (model
GaveUp:    FAIL (resources
CASCDiv:   EPR
CASCProb:  NoTransform/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    E-SETHEO
Version:   csp03
URL:       http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/e-setheo.html
Command:   bin/run-e-setheo %s %d
Format:    tptp
Transform: none
SPCs:      CNF FOF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = SUCCESS (proof
Solved:    Satisfiable = SUCCESS (model
GaveUp:    FAIL (resources
CASCDiv:   MIX UEQ FOF EPR
CASCProb:  NoTransform/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    E-SETHEO
Version:   csp03-SAT
URL:       http://www4.informatik.tu-muenchen.de/~schulz/WORK/e-setheo.html
Command:   bin/run-e-setheo-sat %s %d
Format:    tptp
Transform: none
SPCs:      CNF_NKT FOF_NKT
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = SUCCESS (proof
Solved:    Satisfiable = SUCCESS (model
GaveUp:    FAIL (resources
CASCDiv:   SAT
CASCProb:  NoTransform/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    Gandalf
Version:   c-2.5-SAT
URL:       http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~tammet/gandalf/
Command:   gandalf-wrapper -sat %s %d
Format:    otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given),set(tptp_eq)
Transform: rm_equality:stfp
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = EMPTY 
Solved:    Satisfiable = SATISFIABLE
GaveUp:    time limit exhausted: proof search terminated
CASCDiv:   SAT
CASCProb:  RmEq_stfp/otter_auto
Status:    READY

System:    Gandalf
Version:   c-2.6
URL:       http://www.ttu.ee/it/gandalf/
Command:   gandalf-wrapper -time %d %s
Format:    otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
Transform: rm_equality:stfp
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = GANDALF_FOUND_A_REFUTATION
Solved:    Satisfiable = SATISFIABLE
GaveUp:    dummy_never_found
Statistic: Given = given clauses: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Derived = derived clauses: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Kept = kept clauses: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX UEQ
CASCProb:  RmEq_stfp/otter_auto
Status:    READY

System:    Gandalf
Version:   c-2.6-PRF
URL:       http://www.ttu.ee/it/gandalf/
Command:   gandalf-wrapper -time %d -proof %s
Format:    otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
Transform: rm_equality:stfp
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = GANDALF_FOUND_A_REFUTATION
Solved:    Satisfiable = SATISFIABLE
GaveUp:    dummy_never_found
StartSoln: Refutation = START OF PROOF
EndSoln:   Refutation = END OF PROOF
Statistic: Given = given clauses: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Derived = derived clauses: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Kept = kept clauses: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX
CASCProb:  RmEq_stfp/otter_auto
Status:    READY

System:    Gandalf
Version:   c-2.6-SAT
URL:       http://www.ttu.ee/it/gandalf/
Command:   gandalf-wrapper -time %d -sat %s
Format:    otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
Transform: rm_equality:stfp
SPCs:      CNF_NKT CNF_EPR
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = GANDALF_FOUND_A_REFUTATION
Solved:    Satisfiable = SATISFIABLE
GaveUp:    dummy_never_found
StartSoln: Model = MODEL STARTS
EndSoln:   Model = MODEL ENDS
Statistic: Clauses = clauses generated: *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Size = model size: *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   SAT EPR
CASCProb:  RmEq_stfp/otter_auto
Status:    READY

System:    MUSCADET
Version:   2.4
URL:       http://www.math-info.univ-paris5.fr/~pastre/muscadet/muscadet.html
Command:   muscadet %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      FOF
Solved:    Theorem = proved
GaveUp:    no solution found
CASCDiv:   FOF
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY SSCPA

System:    Otter
Version:   3.2
URL:       http://www.mcs.anl.gov/home/mccune/ar/otter
Command:   otter-script %s
Format:    otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
Transform: rm_equality:stfp
SPCs:      CNF FOF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = ---------------- PROOF ----------------
GaveUp:    Search stopped because sos empty
StartSoln: Refutation = ---------------- PROOF ----------------
EndSoln:   Refutation = ------------ end of proof -------------
Statistic: Given = clauses given *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Generated = clauses generated *([0-9]*)
Statistic: Kept = clauses kept *([0-9]*)
CASCDiv:   MIX UEQ FOF
CASCProb:  RmEq_stfp/otter_auto
Status:    READY SSCPA

System:    Paradox
Version:   1.0-casc
URL:       http://www.cs.chalmers.se/~koen/paradox
Command:   paradox --print Model %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = CONTRADICTION
Solved:    Satisfiable = == Model ======
GaveUp:    INCONCLUSIVE
StartSoln: Model = == Model ==============
EndSoln:   Model = == Result =============
Statistic: Size = SATISFIABLE .size = (\d*)
CASCDiv:   SAT EPR
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    THEO
Version:   J2003
URL:
Command:   theo %s -l L0 t%d tptp
Format:    tptp
Transform: none
SPCs:      CNF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = Proof Found
NotLookingFor:    Satisfiable = THE RESULTS
StartSoln: Refutation = THE PROOF
EndSoln:   Refutation = END OF PROOF
CASCDiv:   MIX
CASCProb:  NoTransform/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    Vampire
Version:   5.0
URL:       http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~riazanoa/Vampire/
Command:   vampire -t %d --casc on %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF FOF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = Proof found. Thanks to Tanya!
Solved:    Satisfiable = Unprovable
GaveUp:    CANNOT PROVE
StartSoln: Refutation = ====== Proof: ======
EndSoln:   Refutation = =====  End of proof. ====
CASCDiv:   MIX FOF
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    Vampire
Version:   6.0
URL:       http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~riazanoa/Vampire/
Command:   vampire --mode casc-19 -t %d %s
Format:    tptp
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF FOF
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = --- PROVED ---
Solved:    Satisfiable = --- UNPROVABLE ---
GaveUp:    --- CANNOT PROVE ---
StartSoln: Refutation = === Refutation ===
EndSoln:   Refutation = ==== End of refutation ===
CASCDiv:   MIX UEQ FOF EPR
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/tptp
Status:    READY

System:    Waldmeister
Version:   702
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~hillen/waldmeister/
Command:   WaldmeisterII.comp %s
Format:    waldmeister
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF_UEQ
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = Goal proved
Solved:    Satisfiable = System completed
GaveUp:    Unfair completion run out of critical pairs
StartSoln: Refutation = P R O O F   P R O T O C O L
EndSoln:   Refutation = Waldmeister states: Goal proved
CASCDiv:   UEQ
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/waldmeister
Status:    READY

System:    Waldmeister
Version:   703
URL:       http://www.mpi-sb.mpg.de/~hillen/waldmeister/
Command:   WaldmeisterII.comp %s
Format:    waldmeister
Transform: rm_equality:rstfp
SPCs:      CNF_UEQ
Solved:    Unsatisfiable = Goal proved
Solved:    Satisfiable = System completed
GaveUp:    Unfair completion run out of critical pairs
StartSoln: Refutation = P R O O F   P R O T O C O L
EndSoln:   Refutation = Waldmeister states: Goal proved
CASCDiv:   UEQ
CASCProb:  RmEq_rstfp/waldmeister
Status:    READY