TSTP Solution File: SYO652-1 by JavaRes---1.3.0
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : JavaRes---1.3.0
% Problem : SYO652-1 : TPTP v7.5.0. Released v7.3.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : java -Xmx15G -cp /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin atp.ProverFOF -i /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark --eqax --proof --forward-subsumption --backward_subsumption --delete-tautologies --timeout 0 %s
% Computer : n028.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Tue Mar 29 03:33:55 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 43.18s 38.05s
% Output : CNFRefutation 43.18s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : ERROR: Analysing output (Could not find formula named input)
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
cnf(clause_99,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_17,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(X2))
| 'LE'(f(X2),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c0,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(X3))
| 'LE'(f(X3),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_17,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c1,plain,
'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c0,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_001,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_002,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_191,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))
| 'LE'(f(X8),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c4,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))
| 'LE'(f(X9),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_191,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c5,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_003,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_004,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_17_005,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(X2))
| 'LE'(f(X2),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c0_006,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(X3))
| 'LE'(f(X3),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_17,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c1_007,plain,
'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c0,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_008,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_009,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_191_010,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))
| 'LE'(f(X8),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c4_011,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))
| 'LE'(f(X9),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_191,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c5_012,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_013,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_014,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_3,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(suc(X10))),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X10))))
| 'LE'(f(X10),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c6,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X11))))
| 'LE'(f(X11),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_3,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c7,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z)))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c6,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_015,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_016,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_17_017,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(X2))
| 'LE'(f(X2),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c0_018,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(X3))
| 'LE'(f(X3),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_17,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c1_019,plain,
'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c0,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_020,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_021,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_191_022,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))
| 'LE'(f(X8),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c4_023,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))
| 'LE'(f(X9),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_191,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c5_024,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_44,axiom,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(X16))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X16)))
| 'E'(f(X16),f(suc(X16)))
| iLEQ(suc(X16),suc(X16)) ),
input ).
cnf(c10,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| 'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_44,c5]) ).
cnf(c15,plain,
( 'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c10,c1]) ).
cnf(clause_149,axiom,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X24))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X24)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X24),f(suc(X24)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X24))
| iLEQ(suc(X24),suc(X24)) ),
input ).
cnf(c38,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_149,c15]) ).
cnf(c51,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c38,c7]) ).
cnf(c55,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c51,c5]) ).
cnf(c58,plain,
iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c55,c1]) ).
cnf(clause_99_025,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_026,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_3_027,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(suc(X10))),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X10))))
| 'LE'(f(X10),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c6_028,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X11))))
| 'LE'(f(X11),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_3,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c7_029,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z)))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c6,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_030,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_031,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_17_032,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(X2))
| 'LE'(f(X2),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c0_033,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(X3))
| 'LE'(f(X3),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_17,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c1_034,plain,
'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c0,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_035,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_036,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_191_037,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))
| 'LE'(f(X8),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c4_038,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))
| 'LE'(f(X9),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_191,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c5_039,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_040,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_041,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_17_042,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(X2))
| 'LE'(f(X2),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c0_043,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(X3))
| 'LE'(f(X3),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_17,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c1_044,plain,
'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c0,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_045,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_046,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_191_047,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))
| 'LE'(f(X8),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c4_048,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))
| 'LE'(f(X9),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_191,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c5_049,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_050,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_051,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_3_052,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(suc(X10))),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X10))))
| 'LE'(f(X10),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c6_053,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X11))))
| 'LE'(f(X11),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_3,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c7_054,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z)))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c6,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_055,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_056,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_17_057,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(X2))
| 'LE'(f(X2),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c0_058,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(X3))
| 'LE'(f(X3),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_17,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c1_059,plain,
'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c0,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_99_060,axiom,
~ 'LE'(f(z),'0'),
input ).
cnf(clause_199_061,axiom,
'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),
input ).
cnf(clause_191_062,axiom,
( ~ 'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))
| 'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))
| 'LE'(f(X8),'0') ),
input ).
cnf(c4_063,plain,
( 'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))
| 'LE'(f(X9),'0') ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_191,clause_199]) ).
cnf(c5_064,plain,
'E'('0',f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c4,clause_99]) ).
cnf(clause_44_065,axiom,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(X16))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X16)))
| 'E'(f(X16),f(suc(X16)))
| iLEQ(suc(X16),suc(X16)) ),
input ).
cnf(c10_066,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| 'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_44,c5]) ).
cnf(c15_067,plain,
( 'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c10,c1]) ).
cnf(clause_149_068,axiom,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X24))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X24)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X24),f(suc(X24)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X24))
| iLEQ(suc(X24),suc(X24)) ),
input ).
cnf(c38_069,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[clause_149,c15]) ).
cnf(c51_070,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c38,c7]) ).
cnf(c55_071,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c51,c5]) ).
cnf(c58_072,plain,
iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c55,c1]) ).
cnf(clause_16,axiom,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X17)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X18),suc(X19))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X20)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X17))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X20))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X19))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X18)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X20),suc(X17))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X19)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X18))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X17),suc(X18))
| 'E'(f(X20),f(suc(X20)))
| 'E'(f(X17),f(suc(X17)))
| 'E'(f(X18),f(suc(X18)))
| 'E'(f(X19),f(suc(X19))) ),
input ).
cnf(c18,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X127)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X127),suc(X127))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X128)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X127))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X128))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X128),suc(X127))
| 'E'(f(X128),f(suc(X128)))
| 'E'(f(X127),f(suc(X127))) ),
inference(factor,status(thm),[clause_16]) ).
cnf(c252,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X129)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X129),suc(X129))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X129))
| 'E'(f(X129),f(suc(X129))) ),
inference(factor,status(thm),[c18]) ).
cnf(c270,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| 'E'(f(z),f(suc(z))) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c252,c58]) ).
cnf(c277,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(z))
| 'E'(f(z),f(suc(z))) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c270,c5]) ).
cnf(c281,plain,
'E'(f(z),f(suc(z))),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c277,c1]) ).
cnf(clause_96,axiom,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X47)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X48),suc(X49))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X47))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X50)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X50))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X47))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X50))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X49))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X48)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X48),f(suc(X48)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X48))))
| ~ 'E'(f(X50),f(suc(X50)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X47),f(suc(X47)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X50),suc(X47))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X49)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X48))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X49))))
| ~ 'E'(f(X49),f(suc(X49)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X47),suc(X48)) ),
input ).
cnf(c96,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X335)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X336),suc(X336))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X335))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X337)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X337))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X335))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X337))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X336))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X336)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X336),f(suc(X336)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X336))))
| ~ 'E'(f(X337),f(suc(X337)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X335),f(suc(X335)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X337),suc(X335))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X335),suc(X336)) ),
inference(factor,status(thm),[clause_96]) ).
cnf(c638,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X655)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X655),suc(X655))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X655))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X656)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X656))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X655))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X656))
| ~ 'E'(f(X655),f(suc(X655)))
| ~ 'E'(f(X656),f(suc(X656)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X656),suc(X655)) ),
inference(factor,status(thm),[c96]) ).
cnf(c1024,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(X657)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(X657),suc(X657))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X657))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(X657))
| ~ 'E'(f(X657),f(suc(X657))) ),
inference(factor,status(thm),[c638]) ).
cnf(c1047,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z))))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1024,c281]) ).
cnf(c1049,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1047,c7]) ).
cnf(c1054,plain,
( ~ 'E'('0',f(suc(z)))
| ~ 'E'('0',f(z)) ),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1049,c58]) ).
cnf(c1057,plain,
~ 'E'('0',f(z)),
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1054,c5]) ).
cnf(c1061,plain,
$false,
inference(resolution,status(thm),[c1057,c1]) ).
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.07/0.12 % Problem : SYO652-1 : TPTP v7.5.0. Released v7.3.0.
% 0.07/0.13 % Command : java -Xmx15G -cp /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin atp.ProverFOF -i /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark --eqax --proof --forward-subsumption --backward_subsumption --delete-tautologies --timeout 0 %s
% 0.14/0.34 % Computer : n028.cluster.edu
% 0.14/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.14/0.34 % CPUModel : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.14/0.34 % RAMPerCPU : 8042.1875MB
% 0.14/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.14/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.14/0.34 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.14/0.34 % DateTime : Mon Mar 14 13:53:52 EDT 2022
% 0.14/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 0.20/0.47 # Using default include path : /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark
% 0.20/0.47 # INFO in ProverFOF.main(): Processing file /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 0.20/0.47 # ProverFOF.processTestFile(): filename: /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 0.20/0.47 # ProverFOF.processTestFile(): opts: {backward_subsumption=true, delete-tautologies=true, filename=/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p, forward-subsumption=true, proof=true, eqax=true, timeout=0}
% 0.20/0.47 # ProverFOF.processTestFile(): evals: [Heuristics: PickGiven5 : [SymbolCountEval21, FIFOEval] litSelect: LARGEST indexing: true delTaut: true forSub: true backSub: true]
% 0.20/0.55 # hasConjecture: false isFOF: false
% 0.20/0.56 # ProofState(): heuristics: PickGiven5 : [SymbolCountEval21, FIFOEval]
% 0.20/0.56 # HeuristicsClauseSet using eval functions: PickGiven5 : [SymbolCountEval21, FIFOEval]
% 43.18/38.05 # -----------------
% 43.18/38.05 # SZS status Unsatisfiable for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 43.18/38.05
% 43.18/38.05 % SZS output start CNFRefutation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(clause_17,axiom,~'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(X2))|'LE'(f(X2),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(c0,plain,'E'('0',f(X3))|'LE'(f(X3),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_17, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(c1,plain,'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c0, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(clause_191,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))|'LE'(f(X8),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(c4,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))|'LE'(f(X9),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_191, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.05 cnf(c5,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c4, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_17,axiom,~'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(X2))|'LE'(f(X2),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c0,plain,'E'('0',f(X3))|'LE'(f(X3),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_17, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1,plain,'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c0, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_191,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))|'LE'(f(X8),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c4,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))|'LE'(f(X9),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_191, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c5,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c4, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_3,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(suc(X10))),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X10))))|'LE'(f(X10),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c6,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X11))))|'LE'(f(X11),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_3, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c7,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z)))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c6, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_17,axiom,~'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(X2))|'LE'(f(X2),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c0,plain,'E'('0',f(X3))|'LE'(f(X3),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_17, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1,plain,'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c0, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_191,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))|'LE'(f(X8),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c4,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))|'LE'(f(X9),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_191, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c5,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c4, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_44,axiom,~'E'('0',f(X16))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X16)))|'E'(f(X16),f(suc(X16)))|iLEQ(suc(X16),suc(X16)),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c10,plain,~'E'('0',f(z))|'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_44, c5])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c15,plain,'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c10, c1])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_149,axiom,~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X24))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X24)))|~'E'(f(X24),f(suc(X24)))|~'E'('0',f(X24))|iLEQ(suc(X24),suc(X24)),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c38,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~'E'('0',f(z))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_149, c15])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c51,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~'E'('0',f(z))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c38, c7])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c55,plain,~'E'('0',f(z))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c51, c5])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c58,plain,iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c55, c1])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_3,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(suc(X10))),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X10))))|'LE'(f(X10),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c6,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X11))))|'LE'(f(X11),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_3, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c7,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z)))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c6, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_17,axiom,~'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(X2))|'LE'(f(X2),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c0,plain,'E'('0',f(X3))|'LE'(f(X3),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_17, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1,plain,'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c0, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_191,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))|'LE'(f(X8),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c4,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))|'LE'(f(X9),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_191, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c5,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c4, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_17,axiom,~'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(X2))|'LE'(f(X2),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c0,plain,'E'('0',f(X3))|'LE'(f(X3),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_17, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1,plain,'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c0, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_191,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))|'LE'(f(X8),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c4,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))|'LE'(f(X9),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_191, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c5,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c4, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_3,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(suc(X10))),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X10))))|'LE'(f(X10),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c6,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X11))))|'LE'(f(X11),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_3, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c7,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z)))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c6, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_17,axiom,~'LE'(f(X2),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(X2))|'LE'(f(X2),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c0,plain,'E'('0',f(X3))|'LE'(f(X3),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_17, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1,plain,'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c0, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_99,axiom,~'LE'(f(z),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_199,axiom,'LE'(f(X1),s('0')),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_191,axiom,~'LE'(f(suc(X8)),s('0'))|'E'('0',f(suc(X8)))|'LE'(f(X8),'0'),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c4,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(X9)))|'LE'(f(X9),'0'),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_191, clause_199])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c5,plain,'E'('0',f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c4, clause_99])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_44,axiom,~'E'('0',f(X16))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X16)))|'E'(f(X16),f(suc(X16)))|iLEQ(suc(X16),suc(X16)),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c10,plain,~'E'('0',f(z))|'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_44, c5])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c15,plain,'E'(f(z),f(suc(z)))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c10, c1])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_149,axiom,~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X24))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X24)))|~'E'(f(X24),f(suc(X24)))|~'E'('0',f(X24))|iLEQ(suc(X24),suc(X24)),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c38,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~'E'('0',f(z))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [clause_149, c15])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c51,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~'E'('0',f(z))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c38, c7])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c55,plain,~'E'('0',f(z))|iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c51, c5])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c58,plain,iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c55, c1])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_16,axiom,~'E'('0',f(suc(X17)))|~iLEQ(suc(X18),suc(X19))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X20)))|~'E'('0',f(X17))|~'E'('0',f(X20))|~'E'('0',f(X19))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X18)))|~iLEQ(suc(X20),suc(X17))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X19)))|~'E'('0',f(X18))|~iLEQ(suc(X17),suc(X18))|'E'(f(X20),f(suc(X20)))|'E'(f(X17),f(suc(X17)))|'E'(f(X18),f(suc(X18)))|'E'(f(X19),f(suc(X19))),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c18,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(X127)))|~iLEQ(suc(X127),suc(X127))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X128)))|~'E'('0',f(X127))|~'E'('0',f(X128))|~iLEQ(suc(X128),suc(X127))|'E'(f(X128),f(suc(X128)))|'E'(f(X127),f(suc(X127))),inference(factor, status(thm), [clause_16])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c252,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(X129)))|~iLEQ(suc(X129),suc(X129))|~'E'('0',f(X129))|'E'(f(X129),f(suc(X129))),inference(factor, status(thm), [c18])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c270,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~'E'('0',f(z))|'E'(f(z),f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c252, c58])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c277,plain,~'E'('0',f(z))|'E'(f(z),f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c270, c5])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c281,plain,'E'(f(z),f(suc(z))),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c277, c1])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(clause_96,axiom,~'E'('0',f(suc(X47)))|~iLEQ(suc(X48),suc(X49))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X47))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X50)))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X50))))|~'E'('0',f(X47))|~'E'('0',f(X50))|~'E'('0',f(X49))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X48)))|~'E'(f(X48),f(suc(X48)))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X48))))|~'E'(f(X50),f(suc(X50)))|~'E'(f(X47),f(suc(X47)))|~iLEQ(suc(X50),suc(X47))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X49)))|~'E'('0',f(X48))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X49))))|~'E'(f(X49),f(suc(X49)))|~iLEQ(suc(X47),suc(X48)),input).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c96,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(X335)))|~iLEQ(suc(X336),suc(X336))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X335))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X337)))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X337))))|~'E'('0',f(X335))|~'E'('0',f(X337))|~'E'('0',f(X336))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X336)))|~'E'(f(X336),f(suc(X336)))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X336))))|~'E'(f(X337),f(suc(X337)))|~'E'(f(X335),f(suc(X335)))|~iLEQ(suc(X337),suc(X335))|~iLEQ(suc(X335),suc(X336)),inference(factor, status(thm), [clause_96])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c638,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(X655)))|~iLEQ(suc(X655),suc(X655))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X655))))|~'E'('0',f(suc(X656)))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X656))))|~'E'('0',f(X655))|~'E'('0',f(X656))|~'E'(f(X655),f(suc(X655)))|~'E'(f(X656),f(suc(X656)))|~iLEQ(suc(X656),suc(X655)),inference(factor, status(thm), [c96])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1024,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(X657)))|~iLEQ(suc(X657),suc(X657))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(X657))))|~'E'('0',f(X657))|~'E'(f(X657),f(suc(X657))),inference(factor, status(thm), [c638])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1047,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z))|~'E'('0',f(suc(suc(z))))|~'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c1024, c281])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1049,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~iLEQ(suc(z),suc(z))|~'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c1047, c7])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1054,plain,~'E'('0',f(suc(z)))|~'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c1049, c58])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1057,plain,~'E'('0',f(z)),inference(resolution, status(thm), [c1054, c5])).
% 43.18/38.06 cnf(c1061,plain,$false,inference(resolution, status(thm), [c1057, c1])).
% 43.18/38.06 % SZS output end CNFRefutation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 43.18/38.06 # Filename : /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 43.18/38.06 # Indexed : true
% 43.18/38.06 # Eval function name : PickGiven5
% 43.18/38.06 # Initial clauses : 23
% 43.18/38.06 # Processed clauses : 164
% 43.18/38.06 # Factors computed : 88
% 43.18/38.06 # Resolvents computed: 974
% 43.18/38.06 # Tautologies deleted: 4
% 43.18/38.06 # Forward subsumed : 440
% 43.18/38.06 # Backward subsumed : 153
% 43.18/38.06 # SZS status Unsatisfiable for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 43.18/38.06 # SZS Expected : Unsatisfiable
% 43.18/38.06 # time : 37490ms
% 43.18/38.06
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------