TSTP Solution File: SYN036+1 by GKC---0.8
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : GKC---0.8
% Problem : SYN036+1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : gkc %s
% Computer : n005.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Fri Sep 1 02:59:26 EDT 2023
% Result : Theorem 7.77s 1.45s
% Output : CNFRefutation 7.77s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.11/0.12 % Problem : SYN036+1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.0.0.
% 0.11/0.13 % Command : gkc %s
% 0.14/0.34 % Computer : n005.cluster.edu
% 0.14/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.14/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.14/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.14/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.14/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.14/0.34 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.14/0.34 % DateTime : Sat Aug 26 16:48:53 EDT 2023
% 0.14/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 input clause set summed statistics:
% 0.20/0.39 ----------------------------------
% 0.20/0.39 in_clause_count: 507
% 0.20/0.39 in_rule_clause_count: 507
% 0.20/0.39 in_fact_clause_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_answer_clause_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_ground_clause_count: 6
% 0.20/0.39 in_unit_clause_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_horn_clause_count: 320
% 0.20/0.39 in_pos_clause_count: 31
% 0.20/0.39 in_neg_clause_count: 180
% 0.20/0.39 in_poseq_clause_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_negeq_clause_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_unitposeq_clause_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_chain_clause_count: 16
% 0.20/0.39 in_min_length: 2
% 0.20/0.39 in_max_length: 6
% 0.20/0.39 in_min_depth: 1
% 0.20/0.39 in_max_depth: 2
% 0.20/0.39 in_min_size: 4
% 0.20/0.39 in_max_size: 36
% 0.20/0.39 in_min_vars: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_max_vars: 28
% 0.20/0.39 in_extaxiom_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_axiom_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_assumption_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39 in_goal_count: 507
% 0.20/0.39 in_neg_goal_count: 180
% 0.20/0.39 in_pos_goal_count: 31
% 0.20/0.39 in_posunit_goal_count: 0
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 auto guide:
% 0.20/0.39 -----------
% 0.20/0.39 {
% 0.20/0.39 "print":1,
% 0.20/0.39 "print_level": 15,
% 0.20/0.39 "max_size": 0,
% 0.20/0.39 "max_depth": 0,
% 0.20/0.39 "max_length": 0,
% 0.20/0.39 "max_dseconds": 0,
% 0.20/0.39 "equality":0,
% 0.20/0.39 "runs":[
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "sine":5, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "sine":5, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "sine":5, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0, "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_ground_weight"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":1, "depth_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":1, "reverse_clauselist":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":1, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":1, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":2, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "sine":1, "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "sine":2, "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "max_ground_weight"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":1, "var_weight":1, "weight_select_ratio":100, "repeat_var_weight":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":1, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "double"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"weight_select_ratio":20, "length_penalty":100, "query_preference":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "max_dseconds":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":20, "depth_penalty":50, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"length_penalty":100, "query_preference":0, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "max_dseconds":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_weight"], "length_penalty":100, "depth_penalty":50, "max_depth":3, "var_weight":10, "repeat_var_weight":10, "max_dseconds":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"sine":2, "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "max_depth":0, "length_penalty":100, "query_preference":2, "strategy":["unit"], "max_dseconds":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus", "positive_pref"], "query_preference":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "max_depth":3, "query_preference":0, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "max_dseconds":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit", "posunitpara"], "query_preference":0, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":3},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":1, "var_weight":1, "repeat_var_weight":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":1, "var_weight":1, "repeat_var_weight":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "var_weight":1, "depth_penalty":100, "repeat_var_weight":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"weight_select_ratio":100, "length_penalty":100, "query_preference":1, "strategy":["query_focus"], "max_dseconds":1},
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "sine":5, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "sine":5, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "sine":5, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["unit"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0, "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["query_focus", "positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_ground_weight"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":20, "depth_penalty":50, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"length_penalty":100, "query_preference":0, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "max_dseconds":10},
% 0.20/0.39 {"strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_weight"], "length_penalty":100, "depth_penalty":50, "max_depth":3, "var_weight":10, "repeat_var_weight":10, "max_dseconds":10},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "max_depth":3, "query_preference":0, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "max_dseconds":10},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["unit", "posunitpara"], "query_preference":0, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":3},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":10, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "var_weight":1, "depth_penalty":100, "repeat_var_weight":1},
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["unit"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "weight_select_ratio":100, "query_preference":0, "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["query_focus", "positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_ground_weight"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":20, "depth_penalty":50, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"length_penalty":100, "query_preference":0, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "max_dseconds":50},
% 0.20/0.39 {"strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_weight"], "length_penalty":100, "depth_penalty":50, "max_depth":3, "var_weight":10, "repeat_var_weight":10, "max_dseconds":50},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "max_depth":3, "query_preference":0, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "max_dseconds":50},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["unit", "posunitpara"], "query_preference":0, "sine":2},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["query_focus"], "query_preference":3},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":50, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "var_weight":1, "depth_penalty":100, "repeat_var_weight":1},
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0, "weight_select_ratio":100, "depth_penalty":100, "length_penalty":100},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["query_focus", "positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_ground_weight"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":250, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["query_focus", "positive_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0, "sine":1},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["negative_pref"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["hardness_pref", "max_ground_weight"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["query_focus", "unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["unit"], "query_preference":0},
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1250, "strategy":["hardness_pref"], "var_weight":70, "repeat_var_weight":70, "query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 ]}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 1 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 2 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"sine":5,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 3 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"sine":5,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 4 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"sine":5,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 5 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 8 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 6 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"weight_select_ratio":100,"query_preference":0}{"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"weight_select_ratio":100,"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"weight_select_ratio":100,"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.39
% 0.20/0.39 **** run 7 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.39 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0,"weight_select_ratio":100,"depth_penalty":100,"length_penalty":100}
% 0.20/0.44
% 0.20/0.44 fork 7: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.44
% 0.20/0.44 fork 3: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.46
% 0.20/0.46 **** run 16 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.46 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref","max_ground_weight"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.47
% 0.20/0.47 **** run 12 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.47 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","positive_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.51
% 0.20/0.51 fork 2: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.52
% 0.20/0.52 fork 0: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.52
% 0.20/0.52 fork 1: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.52
% 0.20/0.52 fork 5: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.52
% 0.20/0.52 fork 4: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.52
% 0.20/0.52
% 0.20/0.52 fork 6: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.53
% 0.20/0.53 **** run 11 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.53 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"query_preference":1}
% 0.20/0.54
% 0.20/0.54 **** run 10 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.54 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0,"weight_select_ratio":100,"depth_penalty":100,"length_penalty":100}
% 0.20/0.54
% 0.20/0.54 **** run 14 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.54 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.54
% 0.20/0.54 **** run 13 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.54 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0,"sine":1}
% 0.20/0.54
% 0.20/0.54 **** run 15 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.54
% 0.20/0.54 **** run 9 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.54 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"weight_select_ratio":100,"query_preference":0,"var_weight":70,"repeat_var_weight":70}
% 0.20/0.54 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":1}
% 0.20/0.57
% 0.20/0.57 fork 1: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.58
% 0.20/0.58 fork 7: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.59
% 0.20/0.59 **** run 18 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.59 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":1,"reverse_clauselist":1}
% 0.20/0.59
% 0.20/0.59
% 0.20/0.59 fork 3: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.60
% 0.20/0.60 **** run 24 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.60 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":1,"sine":1}
% 0.20/0.61
% 0.20/0.61 **** run 20 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.61 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","unit"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.62
% 0.20/0.62 fork 1: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.64
% 0.20/0.64 **** run 26 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.64 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":2,"sine":1}
% 0.20/0.65
% 0.20/0.65
% 0.20/0.65 fork 2: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66 fork 3: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66 fork 5: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66 fork 4: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66
% 0.20/0.66 fork 6: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.67
% 0.20/0.67
% 0.20/0.67 fork 0: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.67
% 0.20/0.67 **** run 19 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.67 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"query_preference":2}
% 0.20/0.67
% 0.20/0.67 **** run 28 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.67 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"sine":2,"query_preference":1}
% 0.20/0.68
% 0.20/0.68 **** run 22 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.68 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":2}
% 0.20/0.68
% 0.20/0.68 **** run 21 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.68 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.68
% 0.20/0.68 **** run 23 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.68 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"var_weight":70,"repeat_var_weight":70,"query_preference":0}
% 0.20/0.68
% 0.20/0.68 **** run 17 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.68 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"query_preference":1,"depth_penalty":100}
% 0.20/0.73
% 0.20/0.73 fork 5: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.73
% 0.20/0.73 fork 4: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.74
% 0.20/0.74
% 0.20/0.74 fork 7: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.74
% 0.20/0.74 **** run 30 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.74 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","max_ground_weight"],"query_preference":1}
% 0.20/0.74
% 0.20/0.74 **** run 29 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.74 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","unit"],"query_preference":1}
% 0.20/0.76
% 0.20/0.76 **** run 32 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.76 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","unit"],"query_preference":2}
% 0.20/0.76
% 0.20/0.76
% 0.20/0.76 fork 1: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.78
% 0.20/0.78 **** run 34 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.78 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","double"],"query_preference":1}
% 0.20/0.78
% 0.20/0.78 fork 4: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.80
% 0.20/0.80 fork 3: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.80
% 0.20/0.80 **** run 37 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.80 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"query_preference":0,"weight_select_ratio":20,"depth_penalty":50,"length_penalty":100}
% 0.20/0.80
% 0.20/0.80 fork 7: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.81
% 0.20/0.81
% 0.20/0.81 fork 2: search terminated without proof.
% 0.20/0.81
% 0.20/0.81 fork 6: search finished without proof.
% 0.20/0.82
% 0.20/0.82 **** run 36 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.82 {"weight_select_ratio":20,"length_penalty":100,"query_preference":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"max_dseconds":1}
% 0.20/0.82
% 0.20/0.82 **** run 40 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.82 {"sine":2,"var_weight":70,"repeat_var_weight":70,"max_depth":0,"length_penalty":100,"query_preference":2,"strategy":["unit"],"max_dseconds":1}
% 0.20/0.83
% 0.20/0.83 **** run 27 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 0.20/0.83 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"sine":1,"query_preference":1}
% 2.57/0.83
% 2.57/0.83 **** run 31 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 2.57/0.83 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"query_preference":1,"var_weight":1,"weight_select_ratio":100,"repeat_var_weight":1}
% 3.75/0.87
% 3.75/0.87
% 3.75/0.87 fork 5: search terminated without proof.
% 3.75/0.87
% 3.75/0.87 fork 7: search finished without proof.
% 3.75/0.88
% 3.75/0.88 **** run 38 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 3.75/0.88 {"length_penalty":100,"query_preference":0,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"max_dseconds":1}
% 3.75/0.89
% 3.75/0.89 **** run 48 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 3.75/0.89 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":1,"var_weight":1,"repeat_var_weight":1}
% 3.75/0.90
% 3.75/0.90
% 3.75/0.90 fork 0: search terminated without proof.
% 4.24/0.91
% 4.24/0.91
% 4.24/0.91 fork 1: search terminated without proof.
% 4.24/0.92
% 4.24/0.92 **** run 25 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 4.24/0.92 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":1,"sine":2}
% 4.24/0.93
% 4.24/0.93
% 4.24/0.93 fork 4: search terminated without proof.
% 4.24/0.93
% 4.24/0.93 **** run 42 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 4.24/0.93 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","positive_pref"],"query_preference":1}
% 4.24/0.94
% 4.24/0.94 **** run 45 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 4.24/0.94 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit","posunitpara"],"query_preference":0,"sine":2}
% 4.24/0.94
% 4.24/0.94
% 4.24/0.94 fork 3: search terminated without proof.
% 4.24/0.95
% 4.24/0.95 fork 2: search finished without proof.
% 4.24/0.95
% 4.24/0.95
% 4.24/0.95 fork 6: search terminated without proof.
% 4.63/0.96
% 4.63/0.96 **** run 44 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 4.63/0.96 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0,"sine":2}
% 4.63/0.97
% 4.63/0.97 **** run 35 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 4.63/0.97 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":1}
% 4.63/0.97
% 4.63/0.97 **** run 39 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 4.63/0.97 {"strategy":["hardness_pref","max_weight"],"length_penalty":100,"depth_penalty":50,"max_depth":3,"var_weight":10,"repeat_var_weight":10,"max_dseconds":1}
% 4.63/0.98
% 4.63/0.98 fork 4: search finished without proof.
% 4.63/1.00
% 4.63/1.00 **** run 53 fork 4 starts with strategy
% 4.63/1.00 {"max_dseconds":10,"sine":5,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 4.63/1.00
% 4.63/1.00 fork 3: search finished without proof.
% 4.63/1.01
% 4.63/1.01 fork 2: search finished without proof.
% 4.63/1.01
% 4.63/1.01
% 4.63/1.01 fork 5: search terminated without proof.
% 4.63/1.02
% 4.63/1.02 **** run 52 fork 3 starts with strategy
% 4.63/1.02 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 4.63/1.02
% 4.63/1.02
% 4.63/1.02 fork 7: search terminated without proof.
% 4.63/1.02
% 4.63/1.02 **** run 43 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 4.63/1.02 {"var_weight":70,"repeat_var_weight":70,"max_depth":3,"query_preference":0,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"max_dseconds":1}
% 4.63/1.03
% 4.63/1.03 **** run 46 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 4.63/1.03 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"query_preference":3}
% 5.31/1.04
% 5.31/1.04 **** run 56 fork 7 starts with strategy
% 5.31/1.04 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"weight_select_ratio":100,"query_preference":0}
% 5.31/1.04
% 5.31/1.04
% 5.31/1.04 fork 0: search terminated without proof.
% 5.31/1.06 No candidate clauses found.
% 5.31/1.06
% 5.31/1.06
% 5.31/1.06 fork 5: search terminated without proof.
% 5.31/1.06
% 5.31/1.06
% 5.31/1.06 fork 1: search terminated without proof.
% 5.31/1.06
% 5.31/1.06 **** run 33 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 5.31/1.06 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus","unit"],"query_preference":1,"sine":1}
% 5.31/1.07
% 5.31/1.07 **** run 54 fork 5 starts with strategy
% 5.31/1.07 {"max_dseconds":10,"sine":5,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 5.31/1.07
% 5.31/1.07 **** run 50 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 5.31/1.07 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0,"var_weight":1,"depth_penalty":100,"repeat_var_weight":1}
% 5.62/1.09
% 5.62/1.09 fork 6: search finished without proof.
% 5.62/1.10
% 5.62/1.10 fork 0: search finished without proof.
% 5.62/1.11
% 5.62/1.11 **** run 47 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 5.62/1.11 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"query_preference":1,"var_weight":1,"repeat_var_weight":1}
% 5.62/1.11
% 5.62/1.11 fork 1: search finished without proof.
% 5.62/1.11
% 5.62/1.11 **** run 41 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 5.62/1.11 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["positive_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 5.62/1.13
% 5.62/1.13 **** run 58 fork 1 starts with strategy
% 5.62/1.13 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0,"weight_select_ratio":100,"depth_penalty":100,"length_penalty":100}
% 6.13/1.15
% 6.13/1.15
% 6.13/1.15 fork 2: search terminated without proof.
% 6.13/1.17
% 6.13/1.17 **** run 51 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 6.13/1.17 {"weight_select_ratio":100,"length_penalty":100,"query_preference":1,"strategy":["query_focus"],"max_dseconds":1}
% 6.64/1.24
% 6.64/1.24
% 6.64/1.24 fork 6: search terminated without proof.
% 6.64/1.24
% 6.64/1.24
% 6.64/1.24 fork 0: search terminated without proof.
% 6.64/1.25
% 6.64/1.25 **** run 55 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 6.64/1.25 {"max_dseconds":10,"sine":5,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0}
% 7.01/1.26
% 7.01/1.26 **** run 49 fork 0 starts with strategy
% 7.01/1.26 {"max_dseconds":1,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0,"weight_select_ratio":100,"depth_penalty":100,"length_penalty":100}
% 7.01/1.29
% 7.01/1.29 fork 6: search finished without proof.
% 7.01/1.29
% 7.01/1.29
% 7.01/1.29 fork 2: search terminated without proof.
% 7.01/1.30
% 7.01/1.30 **** run 63 fork 6 starts with strategy
% 7.01/1.30 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["negative_pref"],"query_preference":0,"sine":1}
% 7.01/1.31
% 7.01/1.31 **** run 59 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 7.01/1.31 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["unit"],"weight_select_ratio":100,"query_preference":0}
% 7.01/1.35
% 7.01/1.35 fork 2: search finished without proof.
% 7.01/1.36
% 7.01/1.36 **** run 67 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 7.01/1.36 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["unit"],"query_preference":0}
% 7.01/1.40
% 7.01/1.40 fork 2: search finished without proof.
% 7.01/1.42
% 7.01/1.42 **** run 75 fork 2 starts with strategy
% 7.01/1.42 {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["unit","posunitpara"],"query_preference":0,"sine":2}
% 7.01/1.45
% 7.01/1.45
% 7.01/1.45 fork 0: search terminated without proof.
% 7.77/1.45
% 7.77/1.45
% 7.77/1.45 result: proof found
% 7.77/1.45 for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 7.77/1.45 by run 52 fork 3 strategy {"max_dseconds":10,"strategy":["hardness_pref"],"query_preference":0}
% 7.77/1.45 % SZS status Theorem for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 7.77/1.45
% 7.77/1.45 % SZS output start CNFRefutation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 7.77/1.45 fof('pel34_$sk', plain, ((((((big_p(X1) & ~big_p($sk1(X1))) | (~big_p(X1) & big_p($sk2(X1)))) | ((~big_q(X2) | big_q(X3)) & (big_q($sk3) | ~big_q($sk4)))) & (((~big_p($sk5) | big_p(X4)) & (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X5))) | ((big_q($sk6) & ~big_q($sk7)) | (~big_q(X6) & big_q(X7))))) & ((((~big_q($sk8) | big_q(X8)) & (big_q($sk8) | ~big_q(X9))) & ((big_p($sk9) & ~big_p($sk10)) | (~big_p(X10) & big_p(X11)))) | (((big_q(X12) & ~big_q($sk11(X12))) | (~big_q(X12) & big_q($sk12(X12)))) & ((~big_p(X13) | big_p(X14)) & (big_p($sk13) | ~big_p($sk14)))))) | (((((~big_p($sk15) | big_p(X15)) & (big_p($sk15) | ~big_p(X16))) & ((big_q($sk16) & ~big_q($sk17)) | (~big_q(X17) & big_q(X18)))) | (((big_p(X19) & ~big_p($sk18(X19))) | (~big_p(X19) & big_p($sk19(X19)))) & ((~big_q(X20) | big_q(X21)) & (big_q($sk20) | ~big_q($sk21))))) & ((((big_q(X22) & ~big_q($sk22(X22))) | (~big_q(X22) & big_q($sk23(X22)))) | ((~big_p(X23) | big_p(X24)) & (big_p($sk24) | ~big_p($sk25)))) & (((~big_q($sk26) | big_q(X25)) & (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X26))) | ((big_p($sk27) & ~big_p($sk28)) | (~big_p(X27) & big_p(X28))))))),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(negpush_and_skolemize,[],['pel34'])).
% 7.77/1.45 fof('pel34', conjecture, (((? [X] : (! [Y] : (big_p(X) <=> big_p(Y)))) <=> ((? [U] : big_q(U)) <=> (! [W] : big_q(W)))) <=> ((? [X1] : (! [Y1] : (big_q(X1) <=> big_q(Y1)))) <=> ((? [U1] : big_p(U1)) <=> (! [W1] : big_p(W1))))),
% 7.77/1.45 input).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('1', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | $df19(X2013,X2012,X2011,X2010) | $df28(X2009,X2008,X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('2', plain, ($df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | $df37(X2014,X2015,X2016,X2017,X2018,X2019,X2020,X2021,X2022,X2023,X2024,X2025,X2026,X2027)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('3', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | $df19(X2014,X2015,X2016,X2017) | $df28(X2018,X2019,X2020)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['1','2'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('4', plain, (~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | $df1(X2006,W,V,U) | $df10(Z,Y,X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('5', plain, ($df19(X,Y,Z,U) | $df1(V,W,X2006,X2007) | $df28(X2008,X2009,X2010) | $df10(X2011,X2012,X2013)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['3','4'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('6', plain, (big_p($sk15) | ~$df19(X,Y,Z,U) | ~big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('7', plain, (~big_p($sk15) | ~$df19(X,Y,Z,U) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('8', plain, (~$df19(X,Y,Z,U) | ~$df19(V,W,X2006,X2007) | ~big_p(X2006) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['6','7'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('9', plain, (~$df19(X,Y,Z,U) | ~big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['8'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('10', plain, ($df1(X,Y,Z,U) | $df28(V,W,X2006) | $df10(X2007,X2008,X2009) | ~big_p(X2010) | big_p(X2011)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['5','9'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('11', plain, (big_q($sk8) | ~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | ~big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('12', plain, (~big_q($sk8) | ~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('13', plain, (~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | ~$df1(V,W,X2006,X2007) | ~big_q(X2006) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['11','12'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('14', plain, (~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | ~big_q(Z) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['13'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('15', plain, ($df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | ~big_q(X2006) | ~big_p(X2007) | big_q(X2008) | big_p(X2009)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['10','14'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('16', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(Y) | big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('17', plain, ($df10(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(U) | ~big_q(V) | ~big_p(W) | big_q(X2006) | big_q(X2007) | big_p(X2008)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['15','16'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('18', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | ~big_p(Y) | big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('19', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y) | ~big_p(Z) | ~big_p(U) | big_q(V) | big_q(W) | big_p(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['17','18'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('20', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Y) | ~big_p(Z) | big_q(U) | big_q(V) | big_p(W) | big_p(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['19'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('21', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_p(V) | big_p(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['20'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('22', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['21'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('23', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['22'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('24', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | big_q($sk23(X2006)) | ~big_p(W) | big_q(X2006) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('25', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(W) | ~big_p(X2014) | big_q(X2006) | big_q(X2015) | big_p(V) | big_p(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['23','24'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('26', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(W) | big_q(X2014) | big_q(X2006) | big_p(X2015) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['25'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('27', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(W) | big_q(X2006) | big_p(X2014) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['26'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('28', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(W) | big_q(X2006) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['27'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('29', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(X2014) | big_q(X2015) | big_p(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['28','2'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('30', plain, (~big_p($sk5) | big_q($sk6) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | big_q(X2008) | big_p(X2010)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('31', plain, (~big_p($sk5) | big_q($sk6) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,$sk6,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | big_p(X2009)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['30'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('32', plain, (~big_p($sk5) | big_q($sk6) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['29','31'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('33', plain, (~big_p($sk5) | big_q($sk6) | big_q(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['32'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('34', plain, (~big_p($sk5) | big_q($sk6) | big_p(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['33'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('35', plain, (~big_p($sk5) | big_q($sk6) | big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['34'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('36', plain, (big_q($sk6) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(X2007) | big_q(X2008)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('37', plain, (big_q($sk6) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,$sk6,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | ~big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['36'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('38', plain, (big_q($sk6) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['29','37'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('39', plain, (big_q($sk6) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['38'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('40', plain, (big_q($sk6) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['39'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('41', plain, (big_q($sk6) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['40'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('42', plain, (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['41','23'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('43', plain, (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['42'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('44', plain, (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['43'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('45', plain, (big_q($sk6) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['35','44'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('46', plain, (big_q($sk6) | ~big_p(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['45'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('47', plain, (~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['46','23'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('48', plain, (~big_p(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['47'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('49', plain, (~big_p(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['48'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('50', plain, (~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | big_p($sk2(X2013)) | ~big_q(X2012) | big_q(X2011) | big_p(X2013)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('51', plain, (~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2012) | big_q(X2011) | big_q(X2014) | big_p(X2013) | big_p(X2015)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['49','50'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('52', plain, (big_q($sk26) | big_p($sk27) | ~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('53', plain, (~big_q($sk26) | big_p($sk27) | ~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | big_q(U) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('54', plain, (big_p($sk27) | ~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df74(X2014,X2015,X2016,X2017,X2018,X2019,X2020,X2021,X2022,X2023,X2024,X2025,X2026,X2027) | ~big_q(X2014) | big_q(U) | big_p(Y) | big_p(X2015)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['52','53'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('55', plain, (big_p($sk27) | ~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X) | big_q(U) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['54'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('56', plain, (big_p($sk27) | ~$df74(X,$sk27,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | ~big_q(X) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['55'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('57', plain, (big_p($sk27) | $df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2014) | big_q(X2015)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['56','2'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('58', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2014) | big_q(X2015) | big_q(X2016) | big_p(X2017)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['49','57'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('59', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2014) | big_q(X2015) | big_p(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['58'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('60', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_q(V) | big_p(W) | big_p(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['51','59'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('61', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_p(V) | big_p(W) | big_p(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['60'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('62', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V) | big_p(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['61'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('63', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['62'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('64', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['63'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('65', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['64'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('66', plain, (big_q($sk16) | ~$df19(X,Y,Z,U) | big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('67', plain, (big_q($sk16) | ~$df19($sk16,X,Y,Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['66'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('68', plain, (big_q($sk16) | $df1(X,Y,Z,U) | $df28(V,W,X2006) | $df10(X2007,X2008,X2009)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['5','67'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('69', plain, ($df1(X,Y,Z,U) | $df28(V,W,X2006) | $df10(X2007,X2008,X2009) | big_q(X2010) | big_p(X2011)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['65','68'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('70', plain, (big_p($sk9) | ~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('71', plain, (big_p($sk9) | ~$df1($sk9,X,Y,Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['70'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('72', plain, (big_p($sk9) | $df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | big_q(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['69','71'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('73', plain, (big_p($sk9) | $df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | big_q(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['72'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('74', plain, ($df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | big_q(X2006) | big_q(X2007) | big_p(X2008)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['73','49'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('75', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | big_p($sk19(Z)) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('76', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | big_q(U) | big_p(Z) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['49','75'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('77', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | big_q(U) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['76'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('78', plain, ($df10(X,Y,Z) | big_q(U) | big_q(V) | big_q(W) | big_p(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['74','77'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('79', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | big_q($sk12(Z)) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('80', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['65','79'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('81', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['80'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('82', plain, (big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_p(V) | big_p(W) | big_p(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['78','81'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('83', plain, (big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V) | big_p(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['82'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('84', plain, (big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['83'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('85', plain, (big_q(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['84'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('86', plain, (big_q(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['85'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('87', plain, (big_q(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['86'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('88', plain, (~big_q($sk17) | ~$df19(X,Y,Z,U) | ~big_q(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('89', plain, (~big_q($sk17) | ~$df19(X,$sk17,Y,Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['88'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('90', plain, (~big_q($sk17) | $df1(X,Y,Z,U) | $df28(V,W,X2006) | $df10(X2007,X2008,X2009)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['5','89'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('91', plain, ($df1(X,Y,Z,U) | $df28(V,W,X2006) | $df10(X2007,X2008,X2009) | big_p(X2010)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['87','90'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('92', plain, ($df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q($sk22(X)) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('93', plain, ($df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['87','92'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('94', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q($sk22(X2006)) | ~big_q(X2006) | ~big_p(W) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('95', plain, (~$df94(X,Y,Z) | big_q($sk22(X))),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('96', plain, (~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df94(X2006,X2014,X2015) | ~big_q(X2006) | ~big_p(W) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['94','95'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('97', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df94(X2014,X2015,X2016) | ~big_q(X2014) | ~big_p(X2017) | big_p(X2018)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['96','2'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('98', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2009) | big_p(X2010)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('99', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,$sk7,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | big_p(X2009)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['98'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('100', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~$df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(U) | big_p(V) | big_p(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['97','99'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('101', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~$df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['100'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('102', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~$df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['101'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('103', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~$df94($sk7,X,Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['102'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('104', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X3) | big_p(U3) | big_p(Z3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['93','103'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('105', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2009) | ~big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('106', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,$sk7,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | ~big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['105'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('107', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(U) | ~big_p(V) | big_p(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['97','106'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('108', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(U) | ~big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['107'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('109', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df94(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['108'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('110', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~$df94($sk7,X,Y) | ~big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['109'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('111', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['93','110'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('112', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['111'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('113', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | ~big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['112'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('114', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['113'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('115', plain, (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['114','87'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('116', plain, (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['115'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('117', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['104','116'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('118', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['117'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('119', plain, (~big_q($sk7) | ~big_p(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['118'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('120', plain, (~big_p(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['119','87'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('121', plain, (~big_p(X) | big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['120'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('122', plain, (big_p(X3) | ~$df1(Y3,Z3,U3,V3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['121','70'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('123', plain, (~big_p(X3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['120'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('124', plain, (~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['122','123'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('125', plain, ($df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | big_p(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['91','124'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('126', plain, (big_p(X3) | big_p(Y3) | ~$df28(Z3,U3,V3) | big_p(V3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['120','75'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('127', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | big_p(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['126','123'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('128', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['127'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('129', plain, ($df10(X3,Y3,Z3) | big_p(U3) | big_p(V3) | big_p(W3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['125','128'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('130', plain, (big_p($sk5) | ~big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['115'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('131', plain, (big_p(X3) | big_p(Y3) | ~big_p(Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['120','130'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('132', plain, (~big_p(V3) | big_p(U3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['131','123'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('133', plain, ($df10(X,Y,Z) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['129','132'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('134', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q($sk11(Z)) | ~big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('135', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(Z) | big_p(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['87','134'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('136', plain, (big_p(X3) | big_p(Y3) | ~big_q(Z3) | big_p(U3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['133','135'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('137', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_p(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['136','123'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('138', plain, (~big_q(X3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['137'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('139', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['86'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('140', plain, (big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['138','139'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('141', plain, ($df57(X,Y,Z) | ~big_p($sk1(X)) | ~big_q(Y) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('142', plain, (big_p(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['140','121'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('143', plain, ($df57(X,Y,Z) | ~big_q(Y) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['140','141','142'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('144', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | ~big_q($sk26) | ~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p(Z) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('145', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | ~big_q($sk26) | ~$df74(X,Y,$sk28,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['144'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('146', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | ~big_q($sk26) | $df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | big_q(X2014)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['145','2'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('147', plain, (big_p($sk28) | ~$df84(X,Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('148', plain, (~big_q($sk26) | $df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df84(X2014,X2015) | big_q(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['146','147'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('149', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~$df84(X,Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('150', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df84(X2014,X2015) | ~$df84(X2016,X2017) | big_q(X2018)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['148','149'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('151', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df84(X2014,X2015) | big_q(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['150'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('152', plain, (~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_p($sk1(X2013)) | ~big_q(X2012) | ~big_p(X2013) | big_q(X2011)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('153', plain, (~$df57(X,Y,Z) | big_p($sk1(X))),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('154', plain, (~$df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df57(X2013,X2014,X2015) | ~big_q(X2012) | ~big_p(X2013) | big_q(X2011)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['152','153'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('155', plain, (~$df57(X,Y,Z) | ~$df84(U,V) | ~big_q(W) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(X2006) | big_q(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['151','154'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('156', plain, (~$df57(X,Y,Z) | ~$df84(U,V) | ~big_q(W) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['155'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('157', plain, (~big_p($sk18(X)) | ~big_p(X) | $df32(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('158', plain, ($df32(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['140','157','142'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('159', plain, (~big_p($sk10) | ~$df1(X,Y,Z,U) | ~big_p(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('160', plain, (~big_p($sk10) | ~$df1(X,$sk10,Y,Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['159'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('161', plain, (~big_p($sk10) | $df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | ~big_p(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['10','160'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('162', plain, (~big_p($sk10) | $df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | big_p(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['161'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('163', plain, (big_p($sk10) | ~$df3(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('164', plain, ($df28(X,Y,Z) | $df10(U,V,W) | ~$df3(X2006) | big_p(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['162','163'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('165', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | ~big_p($sk18(Z)) | ~big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('166', plain, (big_p($sk18(X)) | ~$df32(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('167', plain, (~$df28(X,Y,Z) | ~$df32(Z) | ~big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['165','166'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('168', plain, ($df10(X,Y,Z) | ~$df32(U) | ~$df3(V) | ~big_p(U) | big_p(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['164','167'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('169', plain, (~$df32(X) | ~$df3(Y) | ~big_p(Z) | ~big_p(X) | big_p(U) | big_p(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['168','18'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('170', plain, (~big_p($sk10) | ~big_p(X) | $df3(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('171', plain, ($df3(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['140','170','142'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('172', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['140','49'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('173', plain, (big_p(Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['172','138'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('174', plain, (~$df32(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['49','166'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('175', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['158','174'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('176', plain, (big_p(Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['175','138'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('177', plain, (big_p(U3) | big_p(V3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['158','169','171','173','176'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('178', plain, (big_p(W3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['177','132'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('179', plain, (~$df84(X,Y) | ~big_q(Z) | ~big_q(U) | big_q(V) | big_q(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['143','156','178'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('180', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | ~big_q($sk26) | $df84(X,Y) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('181', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | ~big_q($sk26) | $df84($sk28,X) | big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['180'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('182', plain, (~big_p($sk24) | $df96(X0) | $df92(X0) | $df91(X0)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('183', plain, (~big_p($sk24) | ~$df92(X0)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('184', plain, (~big_p($sk24) | $df96(X) | $df91(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['182','183'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('185', plain, ($df96(X3) | $df91(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['140','184'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('186', plain, (~big_p($sk24) | ~$df91(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('187', plain, (~$df91(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['140','186'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('188', plain, ($df96(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['185','187'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('189', plain, (big_p($sk24) | ~$df96(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('190', plain, (~$df96(X) | big_q(Y) | big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['49','189'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('191', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_p(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['188','190'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('192', plain, (big_p(Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['191','138'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('193', plain, (~big_q(X3) | ~big_q(Y3) | big_q(Z3) | big_q(U3) | ~big_q($sk26) | big_q(V3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['179','181','192'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('194', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | big_q($sk26) | ~$df74(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_p(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('195', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | big_q($sk26) | ~$df74(X,Y,$sk28,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012) | ~big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['194'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('196', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | big_q($sk26) | $df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~big_q(X2014)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['195','2'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('197', plain, (big_p($sk28) | ~$df76(X,Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('198', plain, (big_q($sk26) | $df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df76(X2014,X2015) | ~big_q(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['196','197'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('199', plain, (~big_q($sk26) | ~$df76(X,Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('200', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df76(X2014,X2015) | ~$df76(X2016,X2017) | ~big_q(X2018)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['198','199'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('201', plain, ($df37(X,Y,Z,U,V,W,X2006,X2007,X2008,X2009,X2010,X2011,X2012,X2013) | ~$df76(X2014,X2015) | ~big_q(X2016)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['200'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('202', plain, (~$df57(X,Y,Z) | ~$df76(U,V) | ~big_q(W) | ~big_q(X2006) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(X2007)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['201','154'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('203', plain, (~$df57(X,Y,Z) | ~$df76(U,V) | ~big_q(W) | ~big_p(X) | big_q(X2006)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['202'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('204', plain, (~$df76(X,Y) | ~big_q(Z) | ~big_q(U) | big_q(V) | big_q(W)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['143','203','178'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('205', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | big_q($sk26) | $df76(X,Y) | ~big_q(Y) | ~big_p(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(cnf_transformation,[],['pel34_$sk'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('206', plain, (~big_p($sk28) | big_q($sk26) | $df76($sk28,X) | ~big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['205'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('207', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y) | ~big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_q(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['204','206','192'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('208', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y) | ~big_q(Z) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['207'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('209', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y) | ~big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['208'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('210', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['209'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('211', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['210'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('212', plain, (~big_q(X) | ~big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U) | big_q(V)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['193','211'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('213', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['212'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('214', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y) | big_q(Z)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['213'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('215', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_q(Y3) | ~$df10(Z3,U3,V3) | big_q(V3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['214','79'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('216', plain, (~big_q(X3) | big_q(Y3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['214'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('217', plain, (~$df10(X,Y,Z) | big_q(Z) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['215','216'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('218', plain, (~$df1(X3,Y3,Z3,U3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['140','159','173'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('219', plain, (~$df28(X3,Y3,Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['140','165','173'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('220', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_q(Y3) | $df10(X3009,X3010,X3011)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['214','68','218','219'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('221', plain, ($df10(X,Y,Z) | big_q(U)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['220','216'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('222', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_q(Y3) | big_q(Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['217','221'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('223', plain, (big_q(V3) | big_q(U3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['222','216'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('224', plain, (big_q($sk26) | ~big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['210'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('225', plain, (big_q(X3) | big_q(Y3) | ~big_q(Z3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['214','224'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('226', plain, (~big_q(V3) | big_q(U3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['225','216'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('227', plain, (big_q(X)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(simplify,[],['223','226'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('228', plain, ($df10(X3007,X3008,X3009)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['227','90','218','219'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('229', plain, (~big_q(X) | big_q(Y)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(factorization,[],['214'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('230', plain, (big_q(X3)),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[],['227','229'])).
% 7.77/1.45 cnf('231', plain, ($false),
% 7.77/1.45 inference(resolution,[then_simplify],['227','134','228','230'])).
% 7.77/1.45
% 7.77/1.45 % SZS output end CNFRefutation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 7.77/1.45
% 7.77/1.45 run 52 fork 3 statistics:
% 7.77/1.45 ----------------------------------
% 7.77/1.45 this run seconds: 0.399998
% 7.77/1.45 total seconds: 1.052778
% 7.77/1.45 stat_given_used: 2849
% 7.77/1.45 stat_given_used_at_endgame: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_given_candidates: 12668
% 7.77/1.45 stat_given_candidates_at_endgame: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_given_candidates_h: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_binres_derived_cl: 22874
% 7.77/1.45 stat_binres_derived_cl_h: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_factor_derived_cl: 919
% 7.77/1.45 stat_para_derived_cl: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_tautologies_discarded: 471
% 7.77/1.45 stat_forward_subsumed: 401
% 7.77/1.45 stat_derived_cut: 2958
% 7.77/1.45 stat_derived_rewritten: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_weight_discarded_building: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_weight_discarded_cl: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_internlimit_discarded_cl: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_simplified: 2119 simplified 0 derived 0 given
% 7.77/1.45 stat_kept_cl: 22920
% 7.77/1.45 stat_built_cl: 30737
% 7.77/1.45 stat_hyperres_partial_cl: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_made_rewriters: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_backward_subsumed: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_propagated_subsumed: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_attempted: 297724
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_fact_groundunit_found: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_rule_groundunit_found: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_attempted: 19018087
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_failed: 18720363
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_nonpref_attempted: 19018087
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_nonpref_succeeded: 6672344
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_pref_attempted: 6672344
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_pref1_succeeded: 353969
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_pref2_succeeded: 297724
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_pref3_succeeded: 297724
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_top_meta_pref_succeeded: 297724
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_meta_attempted: 917138
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_meta_failed: 739107
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_predsymbs_attempted: 0
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_unit_attempted: 10326
% 7.77/1.45 stat_clsubs_full_attempted: 287398
% 7.77/1.45 stat_forwardsubs_attempted: 23322
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_hash_added: 1382
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_hash_computed: 459793
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_hash_match_found: 857
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_hash_match_miss: 661657
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_hash_cut_ok: 2433
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_strong_cut_ok: 925
% 7.77/1.45 stat_lit_hash_subsume_ok: 401
% 7.77/1.45 clqueue els 10000000 used 1
% 7.77/1.45 clactive els 10000000 used 2850
% 7.77/1.45 clactivesubsume els 10000000 used 17095
% 7.77/1.45 queue_termbuf els 200000000 used 1894355
% 7.77/1.45 hyper_termbuf els 100000000 used 1
% 7.77/1.45 active_termbuf els 100000000 used 123091
% 7.77/1.45 varstack els 5000 last used 1
% 7.77/1.45 given_termbuf els 10000000 last used 1
% 7.77/1.45 simplified_termbuf els 10000000 last used 1
% 7.77/1.45 derived_termbuf els 10000000 last used 32
% 7.77/1.45 wr_mallocs: 5361
% 7.77/1.45 wr_callocs: 21
% 7.77/1.45 wr_reallocs: 1494
% 7.77/1.45 wr_frees: 4
% 7.77/1.45 wr_malloc_bytes: 4162791908
% 7.77/1.45 wr_calloc_bytes: 112065536
% 7.77/1.45 wr_realloc_bytes: 585360
% 7.77/1.45 wr_realloc_freebytes: 0
% 7.77/1.45 ----------------------------------
% 7.77/1.46
% 7.77/1.46 fork 2: search finished without proof.
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------