TSTP Solution File: REL027-3 by Fiesta---2
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Fiesta---2
% Problem : REL027-3 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : dedam
% Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% Computer : n025.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Mon Jul 18 19:23:33 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 10.07s 10.47s
% Output : CNFRefutation 10.07s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.08/0.12 % Problem : REL027-3 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% 0.08/0.13 % Command : fiesta-wrapper %s
% 0.12/0.34 % Computer : n025.cluster.edu
% 0.12/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.12/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.12/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.12/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.12/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.12/0.34 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.12/0.34 % DateTime : Fri Jul 8 08:04:14 EDT 2022
% 0.12/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 10.07/10.47 Theorem Proved.
% 10.07/10.47 % SZS status Unsatisfiable
% 10.07/10.47 % SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 10.07/10.47 [1=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(sk1,one) = one].
% 10.07/10.47 [3=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(composition(X10,X11),X12),meet(composition(X10,meet(X11,composition(converse(X10),X12))),X12)) = meet(composition(X10,meet(X11,composition(converse(X10),X12))),X12)].
% 10.07/10.47 [5=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(X10)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [6=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,complement(X10)) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [7=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(composition(converse(X10),complement(composition(X10,X11))),complement(X11)) = complement(X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [8=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(composition(X10,X11)) = composition(converse(X11),converse(X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [9=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(converse(X10),converse(X11)) = converse(join(X10,X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [10=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(converse(X10)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [11=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(composition(X10,X12),composition(X11,X12)) = composition(join(X10,X11),X12)].
% 10.07/10.47 [12=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(X10,one) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [13=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(composition(X10,X11),X12) = composition(X10,composition(X11,X12))].
% 10.07/10.47 [14=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(complement(X10),complement(X11))) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [15=axiom,[14],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(X10,X11),complement(join(complement(X10),X11))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [16=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(join(X10,X11),X12) = join(X10,join(X11,X12))].
% 10.07/10.47 [17=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,X11) = join(X11,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [19=demod(7),[17],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),composition(converse(X11),complement(composition(X11,X10)))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [20=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 thtop(X10,X10) = thmfalse].
% 10.07/10.47 [21=axiom,[],
% 10.07/10.47 thtop(meet(complement(composition(sk1,top)),one),meet(complement(sk1),one)) = thmtrue].
% 10.07/10.47 [23=param(9,10),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(converse(X10),X11) = converse(join(X10,converse(X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [25=param(10,8),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(composition(converse(X10),converse(X11))) = composition(X11,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [27=param(8,12),[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(one),converse(X10)) = converse(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [28=param(8,10),[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(X10,converse(X11)) = converse(composition(X11,converse(X10)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [29=param(8,10),[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(X10),X11) = converse(composition(converse(X11),X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [31=param(27,10),[10],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(one),X10) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [32=param(31,12),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(one) = one].
% 10.07/10.47 [33=demod(31),[32],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(one,X10) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [35=param(11,33),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,composition(X11,X10)) = composition(join(one,X11),X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [36=param(11,33),[17],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,composition(X11,X10)) = composition(join(X11,one),X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [39=param(23,6),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(X10,converse(complement(converse(X10))))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [41=param(23,17),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(X10,converse(X11))) = join(X11,converse(X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [42=param(23,32),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(one,converse(X10))) = join(one,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [46=param(42,10),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(one,converse(X10)) = converse(join(one,X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [48=param(14,6),[5],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(top) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [49=param(6,14),[16],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),join(complement(X11),meet(X10,X11))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [50=param(14,14),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(meet(X10,X11),complement(X12))) = meet(join(complement(X10),complement(X11)),X12)].
% 10.07/10.47 [51=param(14,14),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(complement(X10),meet(X11,X12))) = meet(X10,join(complement(X11),complement(X12)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [52=param(14,17),[14],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,X11) = meet(X11,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [53=demod(3),[52,52],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(composition(X10,X11),X12),meet(X12,composition(X10,meet(X11,composition(converse(X10),X12))))) = meet(X12,composition(X10,meet(X11,composition(converse(X10),X12))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [58=param(14,48),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(zero,complement(X10))) = meet(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [59=param(15,5),[14],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,meet(X10,X10)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [60=param(15,6),[48,17],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,meet(X10,complement(complement(X10)))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [62=param(15,17),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(X10,X11),complement(join(X11,complement(X10)))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [65=param(16,1),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(sk1,join(one,X10)) = join(one,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [68=param(16,15),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(X10,X12),join(complement(join(complement(X10),X12)),X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [69=param(16,17),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,join(X11,X12)) = join(X12,join(X10,X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [70=param(16,17),[16],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,join(X11,X12)) = join(X11,join(X10,X12))].
% 10.07/10.47 [73=param(15,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(X10,X11),complement(join(complement(X11),X10))) = X11].
% 10.07/10.47 [74=param(21,52),[52],
% 10.07/10.47 thtop(meet(one,complement(composition(sk1,top))),meet(one,complement(sk1))) = thmtrue].
% 10.07/10.47 [86=param(19,8),[10],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(converse(X10)),composition(X11,complement(converse(composition(X10,X11))))) = complement(converse(X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [87=param(19,10),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),composition(X11,complement(composition(converse(X11),X10)))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [90=param(19,32),[33,33],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),complement(X10)) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [91=param(19,48),[48],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,composition(converse(X10),complement(composition(X10,top)))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [93=param(14,90),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,X10) = complement(complement(X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [95=demod(59),[93],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,complement(complement(X10))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [97=param(90,48),[48,48],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,zero) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [98=param(16,97),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,join(zero,X10)) = join(zero,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [103=param(95,14),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),complement(X11)) = join(zero,complement(meet(X10,X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [105=demod(50),[103],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(meet(X10,X11),complement(X12))) = meet(join(zero,complement(meet(X10,X11))),X12)].
% 10.07/10.47 [107=demod(51),[103],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(complement(X10),meet(X11,X12))) = meet(X10,join(zero,complement(meet(X11,X12))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [122=param(98,17),[16],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,join(X10,zero)) = join(zero,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [123=param(98,95),[95],
% 10.07/10.47 join(zero,X10) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [124=demod(60),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(complement(X10))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [125=demod(58),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(top,X10) = complement(complement(X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [130=demod(95),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(complement(X10)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [131=demod(125),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(top,X10) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [132=demod(124),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,X10) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [134=demod(105),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(meet(X10,X11),complement(X12))) = meet(complement(meet(X10,X11)),X12)].
% 10.07/10.47 [135=demod(103),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),complement(X11)) = complement(meet(X10,X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [136=demod(107),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(complement(X10),meet(X11,X12))) = meet(X10,complement(meet(X11,X12)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [137=demod(91),[123],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(X10),complement(composition(X10,top))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [138=demod(122),[123,123],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,zero) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [143=param(138,23),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(X10,converse(zero))) = converse(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [175=param(130,48),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(zero) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [189=param(36,1),[33],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,composition(sk1,X10)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [193=param(36,23),[32],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(join(X10,one)),X11) = join(X11,composition(converse(X10),X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [207=param(189,28),[23,10],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(X10,composition(X10,converse(sk1)))) = converse(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [223=param(10,39),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,converse(complement(converse(X10)))) = converse(top)].
% 10.07/10.47 [242=param(10,143),[10],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,converse(zero)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [263=param(242,123),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(zero) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [286=param(49,132),[17,6,17],
% 10.07/10.47 join(top,complement(X10)) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [291=param(286,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(top,X10) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [296=param(291,17),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,top) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [298=param(36,291),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,composition(top,X10)) = composition(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [299=param(41,291),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,converse(top)) = converse(top)].
% 10.07/10.47 [302=param(299,291),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(top) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [304=demod(223),[302],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,converse(complement(converse(X10)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [313=param(25,302),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(composition(top,converse(X10))) = composition(X10,top)].
% 10.07/10.47 [318=param(15,304),[48,17,123],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,converse(complement(converse(complement(X10))))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [324=param(35,304),[32],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,composition(converse(complement(one)),X10)) = composition(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [336=param(298,291),[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(top,top) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [337=param(13,336),[],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(top,composition(top,X10)) = composition(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [389=param(70,6),[296],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,join(X11,complement(X10))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [393=param(70,36),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,composition(join(X11,one),X12)) = join(X12,join(X10,composition(X11,X12)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [398=param(70,65),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(one,join(sk1,X10)) = join(one,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [415=param(398,304),[17,291,46],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(one,complement(converse(sk1)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [420=param(73,5),[130,123],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(join(X10,X10)) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [426=param(70,73),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(meet(X12,X11),join(X10,complement(join(complement(X11),X12)))) = join(X10,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [442=param(130,420),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,X10) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [451=param(69,442),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X11,join(X10,X11)) = join(X10,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [478=param(451,68),[17,15],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,meet(X10,X11)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [484=param(478,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,meet(X11,X10)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [487=param(398,478),[17,1],
% 10.07/10.47 join(one,meet(sk1,X10)) = one].
% 10.07/10.47 [541=param(10,415),[302],
% 10.07/10.47 join(one,complement(converse(sk1))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [546=param(62,541),[52,48,17,123],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(one,converse(sk1)) = converse(sk1)].
% 10.07/10.47 [558=param(389,68),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,complement(meet(X10,X11))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [559=param(389,69),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),join(X10,X11)) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [563=param(559,11),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(composition(X10,X11)),composition(join(X10,X12),X11)) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [575=param(559,73),[17],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,complement(meet(X11,X10))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [601=param(70,575),[296],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,join(X11,complement(meet(X12,X10)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [619=param(62,558),[52,48,17,123],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,meet(X10,X11)) = meet(X10,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [655=param(19,337),[302,35,17,291],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(top,complement(composition(top,X10))) = complement(composition(top,X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [664=param(134,73),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(meet(X11,X10)),join(complement(X10),X11)) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [671=param(69,135),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,complement(meet(X11,X12))) = join(complement(X12),join(X10,complement(X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [672=param(70,135),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,complement(meet(X11,X12))) = join(complement(X11),join(X10,complement(X12)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [674=param(135,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,complement(X11)) = complement(meet(complement(X10),X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [700=demod(426),[674,674],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(meet(X10,X11)),meet(complement(X12),join(complement(X11),X10)))) = join(X12,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [718=demod(601),[674,674],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),meet(complement(X11),meet(X12,X10)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [723=demod(558),[674],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),meet(X10,X11))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [729=demod(671),[674,674,674,130],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),meet(X11,X12))) = complement(meet(X12,meet(complement(X10),X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [733=demod(672),[674,674,674,130],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),meet(X11,X12))) = complement(meet(X11,meet(complement(X10),X12)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [736=demod(723),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),meet(X10,X11))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [741=param(136,52),[136],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(meet(X11,X12))) = meet(X10,complement(meet(X12,X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [752=param(86,137),[10,263,175,-313,10],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X10),converse(composition(top,converse(complement(composition(X10,top)))))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [756=param(674,17),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(complement(X11),X10) = complement(meet(complement(X10),X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [764=demod(664),[756],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(meet(X10,X11)),complement(meet(complement(X10),X11))) = complement(X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [771=demod(87),[756,52],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(X10,complement(composition(X11,complement(composition(converse(X11),X10)))))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [772=demod(19),[756,52],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(X10,complement(composition(converse(X11),complement(composition(X11,X10)))))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [777=demod(563),[756,52],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(composition(X10,X11),complement(composition(join(X10,X12),X11)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [802=demod(752),[756,52],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(X10,complement(converse(composition(top,converse(complement(composition(X10,top)))))))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [804=demod(700),[756],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(meet(X10,X11)),meet(complement(X12),complement(meet(complement(X10),X11))))) = join(X12,X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [822=param(674,23),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(join(X10,converse(complement(X11)))) = complement(meet(complement(converse(X10)),X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [825=param(65,674),[674,674],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(sk1),meet(complement(one),X10))) = complement(meet(complement(one),X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [827=param(674,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 join(X10,X11) = complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [828=demod(1),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(sk1),complement(one))) = one].
% 10.07/10.47 [844=demod(53),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(meet(composition(X10,X11),X12)),complement(meet(X12,composition(X10,meet(X11,composition(converse(X10),X12))))))) = meet(X12,composition(X10,meet(X11,composition(converse(X10),X12))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [852=demod(484),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(meet(X11,X10)))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [855=demod(487),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(one),complement(meet(sk1,X10)))) = one].
% 10.07/10.47 [867=demod(804),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(meet(X10,X11)),meet(complement(X12),complement(meet(complement(X10),X11))))) = complement(meet(complement(X12),complement(X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [876=demod(35),[827,827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(X11,X10)))) = composition(complement(meet(complement(one),complement(X11))),X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [883=demod(193),[827,827],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(one)))),X11) = complement(meet(complement(X11),complement(composition(converse(X10),X11))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [886=demod(324),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(converse(complement(one)),X10)))) = composition(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [890=demod(207),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(X10,converse(sk1)))))) = converse(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [896=demod(189),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(sk1,X10)))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [916=demod(777),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(composition(X10,X11),complement(composition(complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(X12))),X11)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [950=demod(304),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(converse(complement(converse(X10)))))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [953=demod(822),[827],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(converse(X10)),X11)) = converse(complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(converse(complement(X11))))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1076=demod(393),[827,827,827,827,130],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(complement(meet(complement(X11),complement(one))),X12)))) = complement(meet(complement(X12),meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(X11,X12)))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1101=param(130,828),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),complement(one)) = complement(one)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1119=param(5,736),[52,131],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),meet(X10,X11)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1121=param(1119,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,meet(complement(X10),X11)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1138=param(655,28),[302],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(top,complement(converse(composition(X10,top)))) = complement(composition(top,converse(X10)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1159=param(130,896),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(sk1,X10))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1179=param(130,855),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(one),complement(meet(sk1,X10))) = complement(one)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1181=param(130,852),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(meet(X11,X10))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1187=param(1181,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(meet(X10,X11))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1191=param(1181,1159),[130,130,52,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,composition(sk1,X10)) = composition(sk1,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1199=param(1187,546),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(one),complement(converse(sk1))) = complement(one)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1209=param(5,718),[52,131],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),meet(complement(X11),meet(X12,X10))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1213=param(1209,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),meet(X11,meet(X12,X10))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1225=param(1213,1159),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(composition(sk1,X10),meet(X11,complement(X10))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1230=param(1213,1187),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(X12,complement(X10))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1238=param(1230,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(complement(X10),X12)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1253=param(130,729),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,meet(complement(X11),X12)) = meet(complement(X11),meet(X12,X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1294=param(130,733),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,meet(complement(X11),X12)) = meet(complement(X11),meet(X10,X12))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1295=demod(1238),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(complement(X10),X12)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1328=param(1295,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(meet(X10,X11),meet(complement(X11),X12)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1409=param(764,741),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(meet(X11,X10)),complement(meet(X10,complement(X11)))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1432=param(130,771),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(composition(X11,complement(composition(converse(X11),X10))))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [1441=param(130,772),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(composition(converse(X11),complement(composition(X11,X10))))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [1499=param(130,802),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(converse(composition(top,converse(complement(composition(X10,top))))))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [1540=param(130,825),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),meet(complement(one),X10)) = meet(complement(one),X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1629=param(1187,1540),[130,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(sk1,complement(meet(complement(one),X10))) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [1738=param(867,1187),[130,52,130],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(X10,complement(meet(X10,X11)))) = complement(meet(X10,complement(X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1742=param(130,1738),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(meet(X10,X11))) = meet(X10,complement(X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1743=param(1742,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(meet(X11,X10))) = meet(X10,complement(X11))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1830=param(1743,1225),[175,52,131,52,-1253],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(X11)) = meet(complement(X11),meet(complement(composition(sk1,X11)),X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [1912=param(876,1199),[130,33],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(converse(sk1),X10)))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [1917=param(130,1912),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(converse(sk1),X10))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1923=param(1181,1917),[130,130,52,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,composition(converse(sk1),X10)) = composition(converse(sk1),X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1927=param(1328,1917),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),meet(composition(converse(sk1),X10),X11)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1928=param(1742,1917),[130,52,5,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),composition(converse(sk1),X10)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1929=param(1928,8),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(converse(X10)),converse(composition(X10,sk1))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [1946=param(1179,1923),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(one),complement(composition(converse(sk1),sk1))) = complement(one)].
% 10.07/10.47 [1997=param(1181,1946),[130,130,52,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(one,composition(converse(sk1),sk1)) = composition(converse(sk1),sk1)].
% 10.07/10.47 [2002=param(1629,883),[29,32,33],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(sk1,converse(complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(one))))) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [2011=param(2002,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(sk1,converse(complement(meet(X10,complement(one))))) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [2012=param(2011,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(sk1,converse(complement(meet(complement(one),X10)))) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [2024=param(2012,1923),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(sk1,converse(complement(composition(converse(sk1),complement(one))))) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [2031=param(886,25),[10],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(converse(composition(converse(X10),complement(one)))))) = composition(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [2072=param(10,890),[10],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(X10,converse(sk1))))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [2075=param(130,2072),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(X10,converse(sk1)))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [2080=param(1181,2075),[130,130,52,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,composition(X10,converse(sk1))) = composition(X10,converse(sk1))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2330=param(916,5),[175],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(composition(X10,X11),complement(composition(top,X11)))) = top].
% 10.07/10.47 [2332=param(5,2330),[52,131],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(composition(X10,X11),complement(composition(top,X11))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2336=param(2332,52),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(composition(top,X10)),composition(X11,X10)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2359=param(2336,2080),[28,302,28],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(composition(sk1,converse(complement(converse(composition(sk1,top)))))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2362=param(10,2359),[263],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(sk1,converse(complement(converse(composition(sk1,top))))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2526=param(1927,1191),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),composition(sk1,composition(converse(sk1),X10))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2534=param(1742,2526),[175,52,131],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(sk1,composition(converse(sk1),X10)))) = complement(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [2535=param(1743,2526),[175,52,131,130,52],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,composition(sk1,composition(converse(sk1),X10))) = composition(sk1,composition(converse(sk1),X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2579=param(5,950),[52,131],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(converse(complement(converse(X10))))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2588=param(1743,2579),[175,52,131,130,52],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,complement(converse(complement(converse(X10))))) = complement(converse(complement(converse(X10))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2592=param(953,318),[130,130,10,2588,130,10],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(converse(complement(X10))) = converse(X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [2594=demod(953),[2592],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(converse(X10)),X11)) = converse(complement(meet(complement(X10),converse(X11))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2649=param(2592,130),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(converse(X10)) = converse(complement(X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2654=demod(2594),[2649],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(converse(complement(X10)),X11)) = converse(complement(meet(complement(X10),converse(X11))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2674=demod(1929),[2649],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(converse(complement(X10)),converse(composition(X10,sk1))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2710=demod(1499),[2649],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,converse(complement(composition(top,converse(complement(composition(X10,top))))))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [2731=demod(1138),[2649],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(top,converse(complement(composition(X10,top)))) = complement(composition(top,converse(X10)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [2732=demod(2710),[2731,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,converse(composition(top,converse(X10)))) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [2749=demod(2031),[2649],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(complement(X10),converse(complement(composition(converse(X10),complement(one)))))) = composition(top,X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [2800=demod(2362),[2649,10],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(sk1,complement(composition(sk1,top))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [2917=param(2732,8),[10,302],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,composition(X10,top)) = X10].
% 10.07/10.47 [2933=param(1181,2917),[52],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),complement(composition(X10,top))) = complement(composition(X10,top))].
% 10.07/10.47 [3529=param(2654,130),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(converse(X10),X11)) = converse(complement(meet(X10,converse(X11))))].
% 10.07/10.47 [3577=param(130,3529),[2649,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(converse(X10),X11) = converse(meet(X10,converse(X11)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [3784=demod(2674),[3577,10],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(meet(complement(X10),composition(X10,sk1))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [3916=param(10,3784),[263],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),composition(X10,sk1)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [3934=param(1743,3916),[175,52,131,130,52],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(X10,composition(X10,sk1)) = composition(X10,sk1)].
% 10.07/10.47 [3948=param(1295,3934),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(composition(X10,sk1),meet(complement(X10),X11)) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [3966=param(3934,2336),[-25],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(composition(converse(sk1),converse(complement(composition(top,sk1))))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [4101=param(1743,1121),[175,52,131,1830,-1294,619],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),meet(complement(composition(sk1,X10)),X11)) = meet(complement(X10),X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [4403=param(1743,3948),[175,52,131,1830,-1294,-1294,4101],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(X10),meet(complement(composition(X10,sk1)),X11)) = meet(complement(X10),X11)].
% 10.07/10.47 [5175=param(10,3966),[263],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(sk1),converse(complement(composition(top,sk1)))) = zero].
% 10.07/10.47 [7525=param(1409,2024),[1830,4403,2749,2649,130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),composition(top,sk1)) = converse(composition(converse(sk1),complement(one)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [7593=param(1432,5175),[175,1830,4101],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(composition(sk1,top)),converse(complement(composition(top,sk1)))) = converse(complement(composition(top,sk1)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [7620=param(1441,2800),[175,-313,10,2649,7593],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(complement(composition(top,sk1))) = complement(composition(sk1,top))].
% 10.07/10.47 [7633=param(10,7620),[],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(composition(top,sk1)) = converse(complement(composition(sk1,top)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [7639=param(130,7633),[2649,130],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(top,sk1) = converse(composition(sk1,top))].
% 10.07/10.47 [7646=demod(7525),[7639],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),converse(composition(sk1,top))) = converse(composition(converse(sk1),complement(one)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [8236=param(844,1997),[12,132,2535,2534,130,1997,2535],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(sk1,composition(converse(sk1),sk1)) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [8243=param(1191,8236),[52,1923,8236],
% 10.07/10.47 composition(converse(sk1),sk1) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [8255=param(8,8243),[10,8243],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(sk1) = sk1].
% 10.07/10.47 [8285=demod(7646),[8255],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),converse(composition(sk1,top))) = converse(composition(sk1,complement(one)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [8458=param(2649,8255),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(complement(sk1)) = complement(sk1)].
% 10.07/10.47 [8492=param(3577,8458),[],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(meet(complement(sk1),converse(X10))) = meet(complement(sk1),X10)].
% 10.07/10.47 [8661=param(8492,10),[],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),converse(X10)) = converse(meet(complement(sk1),X10))].
% 10.07/10.47 [8662=demod(8285),[8661],
% 10.07/10.47 converse(meet(complement(sk1),composition(sk1,top))) = converse(composition(sk1,complement(one)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [9010=param(10,8662),[10],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),composition(sk1,top)) = composition(sk1,complement(one))].
% 10.07/10.47 [9017=param(1742,9010),[2933],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(complement(sk1),complement(composition(sk1,complement(one)))) = complement(composition(sk1,top))].
% 10.07/10.47 [14351=param(1076,9017),[130,1101,130,33,130,52],
% 10.07/10.47 complement(meet(one,complement(composition(sk1,top)))) = complement(meet(one,complement(sk1)))].
% 10.07/10.47 [14364=param(130,14351),[130],
% 10.07/10.47 meet(one,complement(composition(sk1,top))) = meet(one,complement(sk1))].
% 10.07/10.47 [14365=param(74,14364),[20],
% 10.07/10.47 thmtrue = thmfalse].
% 10.07/10.47 % SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 10.07/10.47 Space: 55013 KB
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------