TSTP Solution File: PUZ061+1 by Goeland---1.0.0
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Goeland---1.0.0
% Problem : PUZ061+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v3.1.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : goeland -dmt -presko -proof %s
% Computer : n026.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Sun Sep 18 14:00:57 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 1.20s 0.80s
% Output : Proof 1.20s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.10/0.12 % Problem : PUZ061+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v3.1.0.
% 0.10/0.12 % Command : goeland -dmt -presko -proof %s
% 0.12/0.33 % Computer : n026.cluster.edu
% 0.12/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.12/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.12/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.12/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.12/0.33 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.12/0.33 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.12/0.33 % DateTime : Fri Sep 2 18:57:38 EDT 2022
% 0.12/0.33 % CPUTime :
% 0.12/0.34 [DMT] DMT loaded with preskolemization
% 0.12/0.34 [EQ] equality loaded.
% 0.12/0.34 [0.000048s][1][MAIN] Problem : theBenchmark.p
% 0.12/0.34 Start search
% 0.12/0.34 nb_step : 1 - limit : 8
% 0.12/0.34 Launch Gotab with destructive = true
% 1.20/0.79 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark.p
% 1.20/0.80 [0] DELTA_NOT_FORALL : ~! [Peanuts8_8, John9_9, Bill10_10, Sue11_11, Apples12_12, Chicken13_13] : ((((((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, Chicken13_13)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(John9_9, X16_16)))) & food(Apples12_12)) & food(Chicken13_13)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(Bill10_10, Peanuts8_8)) & alive(Bill10_10)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(Bill10_10, X19_19) => eats(Sue11_11, X19_19)))) & ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21))))) => likes(John9_9, Peanuts8_8)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [1] ~(((((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19)))) & ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21))))) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [1] ALPHA_NOT_IMPLY : ~(((((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19)))) & ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21))))) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [2] ((((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19)))) & ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21))))), ~likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [2] ALPHA_AND : ((((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19)))) & ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21)))))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [3] (((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19)))), ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21))))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [3] ALPHA_AND : (((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)) & ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19))))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [4] ((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010)), ! [X19_19] : ((eats(skolem_Bill1010, X19_19) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, X19_19)))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [4] ALPHA_AND : ((((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)) & alive(skolem_Bill1010))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [5] (((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)), alive(skolem_Bill1010)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [5] ALPHA_AND : (((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))) & eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [6] ((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))), eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [6] ALPHA_AND : ((((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)) & ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17))))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [7] (((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313)), ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [7] ALPHA_AND : (((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)) & food(skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [8] ((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212)), food(skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [8] ALPHA_AND : ((! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))) & food(skolem_Apples1212))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [9] (! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))), food(skolem_Apples1212)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [9] ALPHA_AND : (! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))) & ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16))))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [10] ! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14))), ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [10] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Y20_20] : ((alive(Y20_20) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(Y20_20, X21_21))))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [11] (alive(skolem_Bill1010) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, X21_21)))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [11] BETA_IMPLY : (alive(skolem_Bill1010) => ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, X21_21)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [12] ~alive(skolem_Bill1010)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [13] ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, X21_21))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [12] CLOSURE : ~alive(skolem_Bill1010)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [14] BETA_IMPLY : (eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88) => eats(skolem_Sue1111, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [160] ~eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [161] eats(skolem_Sue1111, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [160] CLOSURE : ~eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [161] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X17_17] : ((? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, X17_17) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, X17_17))) => food(X17_17)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [162] (? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88))) => food(skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [162] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88))) => food(skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [163] ~? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [164] food(skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [164] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [170] ((alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [170] BETA_IMPLY : ((alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [171] ~(alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [172] likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [172] CLOSURE : likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [171] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [185] ~alive(skolem_John99)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [186] ~eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [185] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [187] (food(skolem_Peanuts88) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [187] BETA_IMPLY : (food(skolem_Peanuts88) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [188] ~food(skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [189] likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [189] CLOSURE : likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [188] CLOSURE : ~food(skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [186] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [190] (food(skolem_Peanuts88) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [190] BETA_IMPLY : (food(skolem_Peanuts88) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [191] ~food(skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [192] likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [192] CLOSURE : likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [191] CLOSURE : ~food(skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [163] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X14_14, Y15_15] : (((alive(Y15_15) & eats(Y15_15, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(Y15_15, X14_14)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [165] ((alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [165] BETA_IMPLY : ((alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [166] ~(alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [167] likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [167] CLOSURE : likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [166] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(alive(skolem_John99) & eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [193] ~alive(skolem_John99)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [194] ~eats(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [193] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [195] (food(skolem_Chicken1313) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [195] BETA_IMPLY : (food(skolem_Chicken1313) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [197] ~food(skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [198] likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [197] CLOSURE : ~food(skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [198] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, X21_21))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [201] not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [201] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [203] ~(eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [203] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [205] ~eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [206] ~not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [205] CLOSURE : ~eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [206] CLOSURE : ~not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [194] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X16_16] : ((food(X16_16) => likes(skolem_John99, X16_16)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [196] (food(skolem_Chicken1313) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [196] BETA_IMPLY : (food(skolem_Chicken1313) => likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [199] ~food(skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [200] likes(skolem_John99, skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [199] CLOSURE : ~food(skolem_Chicken1313)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [200] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X21_21] : (not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, X21_21))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [202] not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [202] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y18_18] : ((eats(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(Y18_18, skolem_Peanuts88)))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [204] ~(eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [204] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88) & not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88))
% 1.20/0.80 -> [207] ~eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80 -> [208] ~not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [208] CLOSURE : ~not_killed_by(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 [207] CLOSURE : ~eats(skolem_Bill1010, skolem_Peanuts88)
% 1.20/0.80
% 1.20/0.80 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark.p
% 1.20/0.80 [0.461954s][1][Res] 2746 goroutines created
% 1.20/0.80 ==== Result ====
% 1.20/0.80 [0.462023s][1][Res] VALID
% 1.20/0.80 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark.p
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------