TSTP Solution File: PUZ017-1 by Gandalf---c-2.6
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Gandalf---c-2.6
% Problem : PUZ017-1 : TPTP v3.4.2. Released v1.0.0.
% Transfm : add_equality:r
% Format : otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
% Command : gandalf-wrapper -time %d %s
% Computer : art10.cs.miami.edu
% Model : i686 unknown
% CPU : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
% Memory : 1000MB
% OS : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
% CPULimit : 600s
% Result : Unsatisfiable 29.5s
% Output : Assurance 29.5s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax : Number of formulae : 0
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----NO SOLUTION OUTPUT BY SYSTEM
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
%
% Gandalf c-2.6 r1 starting to prove: /home/graph/tptp/TSTP/PreparedTPTP/otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)---add_equality:r/PUZ/PUZ017-1+noeq.in
% Using automatic strategy selection.
% Time limit in seconds: 600
%
% prove-all-passes started
%
% detected problem class: nne
% detected subclass: big
%
% strategies selected:
% (hyper 30 #f 1 49)
% (binary-unit 30 #f 1 49)
% (binary-double 18 #f 1 49)
% (binary 90 #t 1 49)
% (binary-order 30 #f 1 49)
% (binary-posweight-order 54 #f)
% (binary-order-sos 30 #t)
% (binary-unit-uniteq 30 #f)
% (binary-weightorder 30 #f)
% (binary-weightorder-sos 30 #f)
% (binary-order 30 #f)
% (hyper-order 30 #f)
% (binary 168 #t)
%
%
% ********* EMPTY CLAUSE DERIVED *********
%
%
% timer checkpoints: c(148,40,1,322,0,2,17699,5,3003,17703,1,3003,17703,50,3003,17703,40,3003,17877,0,3003,18871,50,3008,19045,0,3008,19969,50,3013,20143,0,3013,21067,50,3018,21241,0,3018,22165,50,3024,22339,0,3024,23263,50,3029,23437,0,3029,24361,50,3035,24535,0,3035,25459,50,3040,25633,0,3041,26557,50,3047,26731,0,3047,27655,50,3053,27829,0,3053,28753,50,3059,28927,0,3059,29851,50,3065,30025,0,3065,30949,50,3072,31123,0,3072,32047,50,3078,32221,0,3079,33145,50,3085,33319,0,3086,34243,50,3093,34417,0,3093,35341,50,3100,35515,0,3100,36439,50,3108,36613,0,3108,37537,50,3115,37711,0,3116,38635,50,3124,38809,0,3124,39733,50,3132,39907,0,3133,40831,50,3141,40831,40,3141,41005,0,3141)
%
%
% START OF PROOF
% 40223 [?] ?
% 40224 [?] ?
% 40503 [?] ?
% 40832 [] samehouse(X,X).
% 40833 [] -samehouse(n1,n2).
% 40834 [] -samehouse(n1,n3).
% 40835 [] -samehouse(n1,n4).
% 40836 [] -samehouse(n1,n5).
% 40837 [] -samehouse(n2,n3).
% 40838 [] -samehouse(n2,n4).
% 40839 [] -samehouse(n2,n5).
% 40840 [] -samehouse(n3,n4).
% 40841 [] -samehouse(n3,n5).
% 40842 [] -samehouse(n4,n5).
% 40844 [] -sameperson(englishman,italian).
% 40845 [] -sameperson(englishman,swede).
% 40846 [] -sameperson(englishman,russian).
% 40848 [] -sameperson(italian,swede).
% 40849 [] -sameperson(italian,russian).
% 40850 [] -sameperson(italian,american).
% 40851 [] -sameperson(swede,russian).
% 40852 [] -sameperson(swede,american).
% 40855 [] -samecolor(red,white).
% 40856 [] -samecolor(red,green).
% 40858 [] -samecolor(red,blue).
% 40862 [] -samecolor(green,yellow).
% 40864 [] -samecolor(yellow,blue).
% 40866 [] -samedrink(lemonade,coffee).
% 40868 [] -samedrink(lemonade,vodka).
% 40870 [] -samedrink(coffee,milk).
% 40871 [] -samedrink(coffee,vodka).
% 40873 [] -samedrink(milk,vodka).
% 40877 [] -samegame(backgammon,racquetball).
% 40879 [] -samegame(backgammon,solitaire).
% 40880 [] -samegame(backgammon,charades).
% 40882 [] -samegame(racquetball,solitaire).
% 40886 [] -samegame(solitaire,charades).
% 40888 [] -samepet(guppy,toad).
% 40890 [] -samepet(guppy,rat).
% 40893 [] -samepet(toad,rat).
% 40898 [] -nextto(X,Y) | nextto(Y,X).
% 40901 [] -left(X,Y) | nextto(X,Y).
% 40902 [] -nextto(X,Y) | -samehouse(X,Y).
% 40903 [] -left(X,X).
% 40904 [] -nextto(X,X).
% 40905 [] hasperson(X,russian) | hasperson(X,american) | hasperson(X,swede) | hasperson(X,englishman) | hasperson(X,italian).
% 40906 [] hasperson(n4,X) | hasperson(n5,X) | hasperson(n3,X) | hasperson(n1,X) | hasperson(n2,X).
% 40907 [] hascolor(X,yellow) | hascolor(X,blue) | hascolor(X,green) | hascolor(X,red) | hascolor(X,white).
% 40908 [] hascolor(n4,X) | hascolor(n5,X) | hascolor(n3,X) | hascolor(n1,X) | hascolor(n2,X).
% 40909 [] hasdrink(X,vodka) | hasdrink(X,unknown_drink) | hasdrink(X,milk) | hasdrink(X,lemonade) | hasdrink(X,coffee).
% 40910 [] hasdrink(n4,X) | hasdrink(n5,X) | hasdrink(n3,X) | hasdrink(n1,X) | hasdrink(n2,X).
% 40911 [] hasgame(X,solitaire) | hasgame(X,charades) | hasgame(X,quoits) | hasgame(X,backgammon) | hasgame(X,racquetball).
% 40912 [] hasgame(n4,X) | hasgame(n5,X) | hasgame(n3,X) | hasgame(n1,X) | hasgame(n2,X).
% 40913 [] haspet(X,rat) | haspet(X,no_pet) | haspet(X,camel) | haspet(X,guppy) | haspet(X,toad).
% 40914 [] haspet(n4,X) | haspet(n5,X) | haspet(n3,X) | haspet(n1,X) | haspet(n2,X).
% 40915 [] -hascolor(Z,Y) | -hascolor(X,Y) | samehouse(Z,X).
% 40916 [] -hasperson(Z,Y) | -hasperson(X,Y) | samehouse(Z,X).
% 40917 [] -hasdrink(Z,Y) | -hasdrink(X,Y) | samehouse(Z,X).
% 40918 [] -hasgame(Z,Y) | -hasgame(X,Y) | samehouse(Z,X).
% 40920 [] -hasperson(X,Z) | -hasperson(X,Y) | sameperson(Z,Y).
% 40921 [] -hascolor(X,Z) | -hascolor(X,Y) | samecolor(Z,Y).
% 40922 [] -hasdrink(X,Z) | -hasdrink(X,Y) | samedrink(Z,Y).
% 40923 [] -hasgame(X,Z) | -hasgame(X,Y) | samegame(Z,Y).
% 40924 [] -haspet(X,Z) | -haspet(X,Y) | samepet(Z,Y).
% 40926 [] hasperson(n1,russian).
% 40927 [] hasdrink(n3,milk).
% 40929 [] -nextto(n2,n5).
% 40930 [] -nextto(n2,n4).
% 40931 [] -nextto(n1,n5).
% 40932 [] -nextto(n1,n4).
% 40933 [] -nextto(n1,n3).
% 40934 [] left(n4,n5).
% 40935 [] left(n3,n4).
% 40936 [] left(n2,n3).
% 40937 [] left(n1,n2).
% 40938 [] -left(n5,X).
% 40939 [] -left(X,n1).
% 40943 [] -hascolor(X,blue) | -hasperson(Y,russian) | nextto(Y,X).
% 40944 [] -hasperson(X,russian) | -samehouse(X,n5) | hascolor(Y,blue) | -nextto(X,Y).
% 40945 [] -hasperson(X,russian) | -samehouse(n1,X) | hascolor(Y,blue) | -nextto(X,Y).
% 40947 [] -hasgame(X,charades) | hasperson(X,american).
% 40948 [] -hasperson(X,american) | hasgame(X,charades).
% 40949 [] -hasdrink(X,vodka) | hasgame(X,solitaire).
% 40950 [] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | hasdrink(X,vodka).
% 40952 [] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -samehouse(n1,X) | haspet(Y,rat) | -nextto(X,Y).
% 40954 [] -haspet(X,rat) | -hasgame(Y,racquetball) | nextto(X,Y).
% 40956 [] -haspet(X,rat) | -samehouse(n1,X) | hasgame(Y,racquetball) | -nextto(X,Y).
% 40961 [] -haspet(X,camel) | -hasgame(Y,quoits) | nextto(X,Y).
% 40965 [] -hascolor(X,yellow) | hasgame(X,racquetball).
% 40966 [] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | hascolor(X,yellow).
% 40967 [] -hasgame(X,backgammon) | haspet(X,toad).
% 40968 [] -haspet(X,toad) | hasgame(X,backgammon).
% 40969 [] -hasdrink(X,coffee) | hasperson(X,swede).
% 40970 [] -hasperson(X,swede) | hasdrink(X,coffee).
% 40971 [] -hascolor(X,green) | hasdrink(X,lemonade).
% 40972 [] -hasdrink(X,lemonade) | hascolor(X,green).
% 40973 [] -haspet(X,guppy) | hasperson(X,italian).
% 40974 [] -hasperson(X,italian) | haspet(X,guppy).
% 40975 [] -hascolor(X,green) | hascolor(Y,white) | -left(Y,X).
% 40976 [] -hascolor(X,white) | hascolor(Y,green) | -left(X,Y).
% 40977 [] -hascolor(Y,green) | -hascolor(X,white) | left(X,Y).
% 40978 [] -hascolor(X,red) | hasperson(X,englishman).
% 40979 [] -hasperson(X,englishman) | hascolor(X,red).
% 40980 [?] ?
% 40981 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst52) | -hasperson(n2,X).
% 40982 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst53) | -hasperson(n3,X).
% 40983 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst54) | -hasperson(n4,X).
% 40984 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst55) | -hasperson(n5,X).
% 40985 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst56) | -hascolor(n1,X).
% 40986 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst57) | -hascolor(n2,X).
% 40987 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst58) | -hascolor(n3,X).
% 40988 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst59) | -hascolor(n4,X).
% 40989 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst60) | -hascolor(n5,X).
% 40990 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst61) | -hasdrink(n1,X).
% 40991 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst62) | -hasdrink(n2,X).
% 40992 [?] ?
% 40993 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst64) | -hasdrink(n4,X).
% 40994 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst65) | -hasdrink(n5,X).
% 40995 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst66) | -hasgame(n1,X).
% 40996 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst67) | -hasgame(n2,X).
% 40997 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst68) | -hasgame(n3,X).
% 40998 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst69) | -hasgame(n4,X).
% 40999 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst70) | -hasgame(n5,X).
% 41000 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst71) | -haspet(n1,X).
% 41001 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst72) | -haspet(n2,X).
% 41002 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst73) | -haspet(n3,X).
% 41003 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst74) | -haspet(n4,X).
% 41004 [] $spltprd0($spltcnst75) | -haspet(n5,X).
% 41005 [] -$spltprd0($spltcnst52) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst51) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst54) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst53) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst56) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst55) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst57) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst59) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst58) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst60) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst62) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst61) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst63) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst65) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst64) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst66) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst68) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst67) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst69) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst71) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst70) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst72) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst74) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst73) | -$spltprd0($spltcnst75).
% 41013 [input:40980,slowcut:40926] $spltprd0($spltcnst51).
% 41022 [binary:40904,40943.3] -hascolor(X,blue) | -hasperson(X,russian).
% 41027 [binary:40931,40943.3,cut:40926] -hascolor(n5,blue).
% 41028 [binary:40932,40943.3,cut:40926] -hascolor(n4,blue).
% 41029 [binary:40933,40943.3,cut:40926] -hascolor(n3,blue).
% 41033 [binary:40832,40945.2,cut:40926] -nextto(n1,X) | hascolor(X,blue).
% 41090 [binary:40947.2,40981.2] -hasgame(n2,charades) | $spltprd0($spltcnst52).
% 41173 [input:40992,slowcut:40927] $spltprd0($spltcnst63).
% 41203 [binary:40949.2,40998.2] -hasdrink(n4,vodka) | $spltprd0($spltcnst69).
% 41210 [binary:40949.2,40999.2] -hasdrink(n5,vodka) | $spltprd0($spltcnst70).
% 41311 [binary:40929,40898.2] -nextto(n5,n2).
% 41312 [binary:40930,40898.2] -nextto(n4,n2).
% 41313 [binary:40931,40898.2] -nextto(n5,n1).
% 41314 [binary:40932,40898.2] -nextto(n4,n1).
% 41315 [binary:40933,40898.2] -nextto(n3,n1).
% 41368 [binary:40961.3,41311] -haspet(n5,camel) | -hasgame(n2,quoits).
% 41387 [binary:40995.2,40965.2] -hascolor(n1,yellow) | $spltprd0($spltcnst66).
% 41393 [binary:40954.3,41313] -haspet(n5,rat) | -hasgame(n1,racquetball).
% 41396 [binary:40954.3,41314] -haspet(n4,rat) | -hasgame(n1,racquetball).
% 41419 [binary:40954.3,41315] -haspet(n3,rat) | -hasgame(n1,racquetball).
% 41438 [binary:41002.2,40967.2] -hasgame(n3,backgammon) | $spltprd0($spltcnst73).
% 41476 [binary:40998.2,40968.2] -haspet(n4,toad) | $spltprd0($spltcnst69).
% 41512 [binary:40991.2,40970.2] -hasperson(n2,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst62).
% 41513 [binary:40993.2,40970.2] -hasperson(n4,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 41514 [binary:40994.2,40970.2] -hasperson(n5,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 41531 [binary:40993.2,40971.2] -hascolor(n4,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 41532 [binary:40994.2,40971.2] -hascolor(n5,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 41548 [binary:40985.2,40972.2] -hasdrink(n1,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst56).
% 41551 [binary:40988.2,40972.2] -hasdrink(n4,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst59).
% 41563 [binary:40982.2,40973.2] -haspet(n3,guppy) | $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 41565 [binary:40984.2,40973.2] -haspet(n5,guppy) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 41583 [binary:41003.2,40974.2] -hasperson(n4,italian) | $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 41591 [binary:40934,40975.3] -hascolor(n5,green) | hascolor(n4,white).
% 41592 [binary:40935,40975.3] -hascolor(n4,green) | hascolor(n3,white).
% 41593 [binary:40936,40975.3,cut:40223] -hascolor(n3,green).
% 41594 [binary:40937,40975.3,cut:40224] -hascolor(n2,green).
% 41600 [binary:40972.2,41593] -hasdrink(n3,lemonade).
% 41601 [binary:40972.2,41594] -hasdrink(n2,lemonade).
% 41604 [binary:40934,40976.3] -hascolor(n4,white) | hascolor(n5,green).
% 41605 [binary:40935,40976.3] -hascolor(n3,white) | hascolor(n4,green).
% 41606 [binary:40936,40976.3,cut:41593] -hascolor(n2,white).
% 41607 [binary:40937,40976.3,cut:41594] -hascolor(n1,white).
% 41623 [binary:40903,40977.3] -hascolor(X,white) | -hascolor(X,green).
% 41624 [binary:40938,40977.3] -hascolor(n5,white) | -hascolor(X,green).
% 41625 [binary:40939,40977.3] -hascolor(n1,green) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 41643 [binary:40984.2,40978.2] -hascolor(n5,red) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 41656 [binary:40987.2,40979.2] -hasperson(n3,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst58).
% 41658 [binary:40989.2,40979.2] -hasperson(n5,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst60).
% 41842 [binary:40934,40901] nextto(n4,n5).
% 41844 [binary:40936,40901] nextto(n2,n3).
% 41845 [binary:40937,40901] nextto(n1,n2).
% 41894 [binary:40898,41842] nextto(n5,n4).
% 41957 [binary:40898,41844] nextto(n3,n2).
% 41961 [binary:40945.4,41845,cut:40832,cut:40926] hascolor(n2,blue).
% 41962 [binary:40952.4,41845,cut:40832] -hasgame(n1,racquetball) | haspet(n2,rat).
% 41967 [binary:40944.4,41894,cut:41028,cut:40832] -hasperson(n5,russian).
% 42032 [binary:40902,41957] -samehouse(n3,n2).
% 42035 [binary:40943,41961] -hasperson(X,russian) | nextto(X,n2).
% 42036 [binary:40986.2,41961] $spltprd0($spltcnst57).
% 42134 [binary:40926,41022.2] -hascolor(n1,blue).
% 42144 [binary:41961,41022] -hasperson(n2,russian).
% 42150 [binary:40907.2,42134,cut:40503,cut:41607,binarydemod:41625] hascolor(n1,yellow) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 42416 [binary:40972.2,41623.2] -hasdrink(X,lemonade) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 42496 [binary:41312,42035.2] -hasperson(n4,russian).
% 42604 [binary:40834,40915.3] -hascolor(n3,X) | -hascolor(n1,X).
% 42605 [binary:40835,40915.3] -hascolor(n4,X) | -hascolor(n1,X).
% 42606 [binary:40836,40915.3] -hascolor(n5,X) | -hascolor(n1,X).
% 42610 [binary:40840,40915.3] -hascolor(n4,X) | -hascolor(n3,X).
% 42611 [binary:40841,40915.3] -hascolor(n5,X) | -hascolor(n3,X).
% 42666 [binary:40926,40916] -hasperson(X,russian) | samehouse(n1,X).
% 42673 [binary:40838,40916.3] -hasperson(n4,X) | -hasperson(n2,X).
% 42675 [binary:40840,40916.3] -hasperson(n4,X) | -hasperson(n3,X).
% 42725 [binary:40927,40917] -hasdrink(X,milk) | samehouse(n3,X).
% 42726 [binary:40927,40917.2] -hasdrink(X,milk) | samehouse(X,n3).
% 42727 [binary:40833,40917.3] -hasdrink(n2,X) | -hasdrink(n1,X).
% 42729 [binary:40835,40917.3] -hasdrink(n4,X) | -hasdrink(n1,X).
% 42730 [binary:40836,40917.3] -hasdrink(n5,X) | -hasdrink(n1,X).
% 42736 [binary:40842,40917.3] -hasdrink(n5,X) | -hasdrink(n4,X).
% 42748 [binary:40837,40918.3] -hasgame(n3,X) | -hasgame(n2,X).
% 42749 [binary:40838,40918.3] -hasgame(n4,X) | -hasgame(n2,X).
% 42750 [binary:40839,40918.3] -hasgame(n5,X) | -hasgame(n2,X).
% 42787 [binary:40966.2,42604] -hasgame(n3,racquetball) | -hascolor(n1,yellow).
% 42788 [binary:40966.2,42604,binarydemod:42150] -hasgame(n3,racquetball) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 42826 [binary:40966.2,42605] -hasgame(n4,racquetball) | -hascolor(n1,yellow).
% 42827 [binary:40966.2,42605,binarydemod:42150] -hasgame(n4,racquetball) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 42841 [binary:40966.2,42606] -hasgame(n5,racquetball) | -hascolor(n1,yellow).
% 42842 [binary:40966.2,42606,binarydemod:42150] -hasgame(n5,racquetball) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 42872 [binary:40926,40920.2] -hasperson(n1,X) | sameperson(X,russian).
% 42873 [binary:40844,40920.3] -hasperson(X,italian) | -hasperson(X,englishman).
% 42874 [binary:40845,40920.3] -hasperson(X,swede) | -hasperson(X,englishman).
% 42877 [binary:40848,40920.3] -hasperson(X,swede) | -hasperson(X,italian).
% 42879 [binary:40850,40920.3] -hasperson(X,american) | -hasperson(X,italian).
% 42881 [binary:40852,40920.3] -hasperson(X,american) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 42905 [binary:40979.2,42610] -hascolor(n3,red) | -hasperson(n4,englishman).
% 42915 [binary:40979.2,42611] -hascolor(n3,red) | -hasperson(n5,englishman).
% 42952 [binary:40855,40921.3] -hascolor(X,white) | -hascolor(X,red).
% 42953 [binary:40856,40921.3] -hascolor(X,green) | -hascolor(X,red).
% 42955 [binary:40858,40921.3] -hascolor(X,blue) | -hascolor(X,red).
% 42958 [binary:40862,40921.3] -hascolor(X,yellow) | -hascolor(X,green).
% 42959 [binary:40864,40921.3] -hascolor(X,blue) | -hascolor(X,yellow).
% 42990 [binary:40834,42666.2] -hasperson(n3,russian).
% 43004 [binary:40927,40922] -hasdrink(n3,X) | samedrink(milk,X).
% 43005 [binary:40927,40922.2] -hasdrink(n3,X) | samedrink(X,milk).
% 43006 [binary:40866,40922.3] -hasdrink(X,coffee) | -hasdrink(X,lemonade).
% 43008 [binary:40868,40922.3] -hasdrink(X,vodka) | -hasdrink(X,lemonade).
% 43011 [binary:40871,40922.3] -hasdrink(X,vodka) | -hasdrink(X,coffee).
% 43049 [binary:40840,42725.2] -hasdrink(n4,milk).
% 43050 [binary:40841,42725.2] -hasdrink(n5,milk).
% 43052 [binary:42032,42725.2] -hasdrink(n2,milk).
% 43063 [binary:40877,40923.3] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -hasgame(X,backgammon).
% 43065 [binary:40879,40923.3] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hasgame(X,backgammon).
% 43066 [binary:40880,40923.3] -hasgame(X,charades) | -hasgame(X,backgammon).
% 43068 [binary:40882,40923.3] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hasgame(X,racquetball).
% 43072 [binary:40886,40923.3] -hasgame(X,charades) | -hasgame(X,solitaire).
% 43115 [binary:40888,40924.3] -haspet(X,toad) | -haspet(X,guppy).
% 43117 [binary:40890,40924.3] -haspet(X,rat) | -haspet(X,guppy).
% 43120 [binary:40893,40924.3] -haspet(X,rat) | -haspet(X,toad).
% 43132 [binary:40969.2,42673] -hasdrink(n4,coffee) | -hasperson(n2,swede).
% 43160 [binary:40834,42726.2] -hasdrink(n1,milk).
% 43165 [binary:40947.2,42675.2] -hasgame(n3,charades) | -hasperson(n4,american).
% 43921 [binary:40846,42872.2] -hasperson(n1,englishman).
% 43922 [binary:40849,42872.2] -hasperson(n1,italian).
% 43923 [binary:40851,42872.2] -hasperson(n1,swede).
% 43924 [binary:40969.2,42872,cut:40851] -hasdrink(n1,coffee).
% 43925 [binary:40973.2,42872,cut:40849] -haspet(n1,guppy).
% 43926 [binary:40978.2,42872,cut:40846] -hascolor(n1,red).
% 43933 [binary:40973.2,42873] -haspet(X,guppy) | -hasperson(X,englishman).
% 43934 [binary:40978.2,42873.2] -hascolor(X,red) | -hasperson(X,italian).
% 43948 [binary:40978.2,42874.2] -hascolor(X,red) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 43978 [binary:40973.2,42877.2] -haspet(X,guppy) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 43992 [binary:40947.2,42879] -hasgame(X,charades) | -hasperson(X,italian).
% 44008 [binary:40947.2,42881] -hasgame(X,charades) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 44028 [binary:40979.2,42952.2] -hascolor(X,white) | -hasperson(X,englishman).
% 44038 [binary:40972.2,42953] -hasdrink(X,lemonade) | -hascolor(X,red).
% 44040 [binary:40979.2,42953.2] -hascolor(X,green) | -hasperson(X,englishman).
% 44060 [binary:41961,42955] -hascolor(n2,red).
% 44065 [binary:40979.2,44060] -hasperson(n2,englishman).
% 44082 [binary:40966.2,42958] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -hascolor(X,green).
% 44094 [binary:40966.2,42959.2] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -hascolor(X,blue).
% 44095 [binary:41961,42959] -hascolor(n2,yellow).
% 44100 [binary:40966.2,44095] -hasgame(n2,racquetball).
% 44113 [binary:40873,43004.2] -hasdrink(n3,vodka).
% 44115 [binary:40950.2,43004,cut:40873] -hasgame(n3,solitaire).
% 44124 [binary:40970.2,43005,cut:40870] -hasperson(n3,swede).
% 44127 [binary:40970.2,43006] -hasdrink(X,lemonade) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 44140 [binary:40950.2,43008] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hasdrink(X,lemonade).
% 44166 [binary:40950.2,43011] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hasdrink(X,coffee).
% 44167 [binary:40970.2,43011.2] -hasdrink(X,vodka) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 44208 [binary:40965.2,43063] -hasgame(X,backgammon) | -hascolor(X,yellow).
% 44241 [binary:40949.2,43065] -hasgame(X,backgammon) | -hasdrink(X,vodka).
% 44255 [binary:40948.2,43066] -hasgame(X,backgammon) | -hasperson(X,american).
% 44290 [binary:40949.2,43068] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -hasdrink(X,vodka).
% 44361 [binary:40948.2,43072] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hasperson(X,american).
% 44373 [binary:40967.2,43115] -haspet(X,guppy) | -hasgame(X,backgammon).
% 44402 [binary:40974.2,43117.2] -haspet(X,rat) | -hasperson(X,italian).
% 44452 [binary:40967.2,43120.2] -haspet(X,rat) | -hasgame(X,backgammon).
% 44560 [binary:40978.2,43933.2] -haspet(X,guppy) | -hascolor(X,red).
% 44881 [binary:40979.2,44038.2] -hasdrink(X,lemonade) | -hasperson(X,englishman).
% 45135 [binary:40972.2,44082.2] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -hasdrink(X,lemonade).
% 45161 [binary:41033.2,44094.2] -hasgame(X,racquetball) | -nextto(n1,X).
% 45171 [binary:40971.2,44127] -hascolor(X,green) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 45195 [binary:40971.2,44140.2] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hascolor(X,green).
% 45231 [binary:40970.2,44166.2] -hasgame(X,solitaire) | -hasperson(X,swede).
% 45275 [binary:40968.2,44208] -haspet(X,toad) | -hascolor(X,yellow).
% 45331 [binary:40968.2,44241] -haspet(X,toad) | -hasdrink(X,vodka).
% 45361 [binary:40968.2,44255] -haspet(X,toad) | -hasperson(X,american).
% 45412 [binary:40965.2,44290] -hasdrink(X,vodka) | -hascolor(X,yellow).
% 45421 [binary:40912.4,44290,cut:44100,binarydemod:42788,42827,42842] -hasdrink(n1,vodka) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 45492 [binary:40949.2,44361] -hasdrink(X,vodka) | -hasperson(X,american).
% 45515 [binary:40974.2,44373] -hasgame(X,backgammon) | -hasperson(X,italian).
% 45773 [binary:40912.4,45135,cut:44100,binarydemod:42788,42827,42842] -hasdrink(n1,lemonade) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 45779 [binary:40956.3,45161,factor:cut:40832,slowcut:41845] -haspet(n1,rat).
% 46163 [binary:40972.2,41624.2] -hascolor(n5,white) | -hasdrink(X,lemonade).
% 46172 [binary:40908,41625.2,cut:41607,cut:41606,binarycut:41624] -hascolor(n1,green) | hascolor(n3,white).
% 46176 [binary:40985.2,42150] $spltprd0($spltcnst56) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46177 [binary:41387,42150] $spltprd0($spltcnst66) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46379 [binary:40910,46163.2,cut:41600,cut:41601,binarycut:42416,binarycut:45773] -hascolor(n5,white).
% 46382 [binary:40908.2,46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n4,white) | hascolor(n3,white).
% 46389 [binary:40909,45421,cut:43160,cut:43924,binarycut:45773] hasdrink(n1,unknown_drink) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46481 [?] ?
% 46492 [?] ?
% 46494 [binary:40990.2,46389] $spltprd0($spltcnst61) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46530 [binary:40908,46494.2,cut:46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst61).
% 46555 [binary:46494.2,46530] $spltprd0($spltcnst61).
% 46742 [binary:40965.2,41393.2,binarydemod:42150] -haspet(n5,rat) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46774 [binary:40965.2,41396.2,binarydemod:42150] -haspet(n4,rat) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46810 [binary:40965.2,41419.2,binarydemod:42150] -haspet(n3,rat) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46821 [binary:40914.3,46810,cut:45779,binarycut:46774,binarycut:46742] haspet(n2,rat) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46825 [binary:41001.2,46821] $spltprd0($spltcnst72) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 46864 [binary:40908,46825.2,cut:46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst72).
% 46911 [binary:46825.2,46864] $spltprd0($spltcnst72).
% 47025 [binary:40988.2,41591.2] -hascolor(n5,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst59).
% 47031 [binary:40907.3,41591,cut:41027,cut:46379,binarycut:46492] hascolor(n5,red) | hascolor(n4,white).
% 47056 [binary:46176.2,41591.2] -hascolor(n5,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst56).
% 47057 [binary:46177.2,41591.2] -hascolor(n5,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst66).
% 47081 [binary:40972.2,47025] -hasdrink(n5,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst59).
% 47088 [binary:40972.2,47056] -hasdrink(n5,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst56).
% 47127 [binary:40910.2,47081,cut:41600,cut:41601,binarycut:41551,binarydemod:45773] $spltprd0($spltcnst59) | -hascolor(X,white).
% 47131 [binary:40908,47127.2,cut:46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst59).
% 47136 [binary:40910.2,47088,cut:41600,cut:41601,binarycut:41548] hasdrink(n4,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst56).
% 47169 [?] ?
% 47193 [binary:41625.2,47131,binarycut:47169] $spltprd0($spltcnst59).
% 47236 [binary:40972,47136] hascolor(n4,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst56).
% 47365 [binary:40972.2,41592] -hasdrink(n4,lemonade) | hascolor(n3,white).
% 47394 [binary:46176.2,41592.2,binarycut:47236] $spltprd0($spltcnst56).
% 47395 [binary:46177.2,41592.2] -hascolor(n4,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst66).
% 47430 [binary:40908,47395,cut:41593,cut:41594,binarycut:47057] hascolor(n1,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst66).
% 47454 [binary:40989.2,41604.2] -hascolor(n4,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst60).
% 47456 [binary:41532,41604.2] -hascolor(n4,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 47477 [?] ?
% 47478 [binary:45195.2,41604.2] -hasgame(n5,solitaire) | -hascolor(n4,white).
% 47487 [binary:40908,47454,cut:46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst60).
% 47511 [binary:40908,47456,cut:46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 47522 [binary:44028,47487] -hasperson(n3,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst60).
% 47574 [binary:41625.2,47511] -hascolor(n1,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 47608 [binary:40906.3,47522,cut:43921,cut:44065,binarycut:41658] hasperson(n4,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst60).
% 47663 [?] ?
% 47736 [binary:40908.4,47574,cut:41593,cut:41594,binarycut:41532] hascolor(n4,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 47912 [binary:44881.2,47608,binarycut:47663] $spltprd0($spltcnst60).
% 47962 [binary:45171,47736] -hasperson(n4,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 48109 [binary:40906,47962,cut:44124,cut:43923,binarycut:41514] hasperson(n2,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 48114 [?] ?
% 48193 [binary:45231.2,48109,binarycut:48114] $spltprd0($spltcnst65).
% 48263 [binary:41531,41605.2] -hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 48278 [?] ?
% 48286 [binary:45195.2,41605.2] -hasgame(n4,solitaire) | -hascolor(n3,white).
% 48295 [binary:40908.3,48263,cut:46379,cut:41607,cut:41606] hascolor(n4,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 48334 [binary:41604,48295] hascolor(n5,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 48534 [binary:45171,48334] -hasperson(n5,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 48621 [binary:40906.2,48534,cut:44124,cut:43923,binarycut:41513] hasperson(n2,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 48626 [?] ?
% 48694 [binary:45231.2,48621,binarycut:48626] $spltprd0($spltcnst64).
% 49267 [binary:40907.4,42905,cut:41593,cut:41029,binarycut:46481,binarycut:48278] -hasperson(n4,englishman).
% 49270 [binary:40906,49267,cut:43921,cut:44065] hasperson(n5,englishman) | hasperson(n3,englishman).
% 49292 [binary:40907.4,42915,cut:41593,cut:41029,binarycut:46481] -hasperson(n5,englishman) | hascolor(n3,white).
% 49795 [binary:40977.2,46172.2,factor:cut:40939] -hascolor(n1,green).
% 49827 [binary:40972.2,49795] -hasdrink(n1,lemonade).
% 49828 [binary:40907.3,49795,cut:42134,cut:43926,cut:41607] hascolor(n1,yellow).
% 49830 [binary:47430,49795] $spltprd0($spltcnst66).
% 49875 [binary:40965,49828] hasgame(n1,racquetball).
% 49878 [binary:42604.2,49828] -hascolor(n3,yellow).
% 49895 [binary:45275.2,49828] -haspet(n1,toad).
% 49896 [binary:45412.2,49828] -hasdrink(n1,vodka).
% 49903 [binary:42787.2,49828] -hasgame(n3,racquetball).
% 49904 [binary:42826.2,49828] -hasgame(n4,racquetball).
% 49905 [binary:42841.2,49828] -hasgame(n5,racquetball).
% 49950 [binary:41393.2,49875] -haspet(n5,rat).
% 49953 [binary:41962,49875] haspet(n2,rat).
% 49998 [binary:40913.5,49895,cut:43925,cut:45779] haspet(n1,camel) | haspet(n1,no_pet).
% 50000 [binary:40909,49896,cut:43160,cut:49827,cut:43924] hasdrink(n1,unknown_drink).
% 50098 [binary:43117,49953] -haspet(n2,guppy).
% 50099 [binary:43120,49953] -haspet(n2,toad).
% 50102 [binary:44402,49953] -hasperson(n2,italian).
% 50103 [binary:44452,49953] -hasgame(n2,backgammon).
% 50108 [binary:42727.2,50000] -hasdrink(n2,unknown_drink).
% 50109 [binary:42729.2,50000] -hasdrink(n4,unknown_drink).
% 50110 [binary:42730.2,50000] -hasdrink(n5,unknown_drink).
% 50150 [binary:40905.5,50102,cut:44065,cut:42144] hasperson(n2,swede) | hasperson(n2,american).
% 50154 [binary:40909.2,50108,cut:43052,cut:41601] hasdrink(n2,vodka) | hasdrink(n2,coffee).
% 50795 [binary:40987.2,46382.2] hascolor(n4,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst58).
% 50824 [binary:41604,50795] hascolor(n5,green) | $spltprd0($spltcnst58).
% 50834 [binary:44040,50824] -hasperson(n5,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst58).
% 50850 [binary:40906.2,50834,cut:49267,cut:43921,cut:44065,binarycut:41656] $spltprd0($spltcnst58).
% 51174 [binary:41643,47031] hascolor(n4,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51185 [binary:43934,47031] -hasperson(n5,italian) | hascolor(n4,white).
% 51187 [binary:43948,47031,binarycut:47477] -hasperson(n5,swede).
% 51192 [binary:40969.2,51187] -hasdrink(n5,coffee).
% 51229 [binary:40909.5,51192,cut:43050,cut:50110] hasdrink(n5,lemonade) | hasdrink(n5,vodka).
% 51238 [binary:42610,51174] -hascolor(n3,white) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51249 [binary:40907.5,51238,cut:41593,cut:41029,cut:49878] hascolor(n3,red) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51273 [binary:44560.2,51249] -haspet(n3,guppy) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51294 [binary:40914.3,51273,cut:43925,cut:50098,binarycut:41565] haspet(n4,guppy) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51316 [binary:43978,51294] -hasperson(n4,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51376 [binary:40906,51316,cut:51187,cut:44124,cut:43923] hasperson(n2,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51390 [?] ?
% 51546 [binary:44008.2,51376,binarycut:51390] $spltprd0($spltcnst55).
% 51897 [binary:44028,47365.2] -hasdrink(n4,lemonade) | -hasperson(n3,englishman).
% 52891 [binary:40982.2,49270.2] hasperson(n5,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 52922 [binary:43933.2,52891] -haspet(n5,guppy) | $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 52939 [binary:40914.2,52922,cut:43925,cut:50098,binarycut:41563] haspet(n4,guppy) | $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 52964 [binary:43978,52939] -hasperson(n4,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 53034 [binary:40906,52964,cut:51187,cut:44124,cut:43923] hasperson(n2,swede) | $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 53047 [?] ?
% 53161 [binary:44008.2,53034,binarycut:53047] $spltprd0($spltcnst53).
% 53204 [binary:48286.2,49292.2] -hasgame(n4,solitaire) | -hasperson(n5,englishman).
% 53259 [binary:41000.2,49998] haspet(n1,no_pet) | $spltprd0($spltcnst71).
% 53287 [binary:41000.2,53259] $spltprd0($spltcnst71).
% 53322 [binary:40981.2,50150] hasperson(n2,american) | $spltprd0($spltcnst52).
% 53343 [?] ?
% 53352 [binary:40948,53322,binarycut:41090] $spltprd0($spltcnst52).
% 53462 [binary:40969,50154.2,binarycut:53343] hasperson(n2,swede).
% 53481 [binary:41512,53462] $spltprd0($spltcnst62).
% 53486 [binary:42673.2,53462] -hasperson(n4,swede).
% 53487 [binary:44008.2,53462] -hasgame(n2,charades).
% 53488 [binary:44167.2,53462] -hasdrink(n2,vodka).
% 53489 [binary:45231.2,53462] -hasgame(n2,solitaire).
% 53490 [binary:43132.2,53462] -hasdrink(n4,coffee).
% 53498 [binary:40905.3,53486,cut:42496,cut:49267] hasperson(n4,american) | hasperson(n4,italian).
% 53506 [binary:40911.2,53487,cut:53489,cut:50103,cut:44100] hasgame(n2,quoits).
% 53508 [binary:40910.5,53488,cut:49896,cut:44113] hasdrink(n5,vodka) | hasdrink(n4,vodka).
% 53511 [binary:40996.2,53506] $spltprd0($spltcnst67).
% 53518 [binary:42748.2,53506] -hasgame(n3,quoits).
% 53519 [binary:42749.2,53506] -hasgame(n4,quoits).
% 53520 [binary:42750.2,53506] -hasgame(n5,quoits).
% 53521 [binary:41368.2,53506] -haspet(n5,camel).
% 53533 [binary:40911.3,53518,cut:44115,cut:49903] hasgame(n3,charades) | hasgame(n3,backgammon).
% 54042 [binary:47478.2,51185.2] -hasgame(n5,solitaire) | -hasperson(n5,italian).
% 54076 [binary:41210,51229.2] hasdrink(n5,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst70).
% 54099 [binary:42736,54076] -hasdrink(n4,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst70).
% 54113 [binary:40909.4,54099,cut:43049,cut:50109,cut:53490] hasdrink(n4,vodka) | $spltprd0($spltcnst70).
% 54141 [binary:45492,54113] -hasperson(n4,american) | $spltprd0($spltcnst70).
% 54159 [?] ?
% 54185 [binary:40905.2,54141,cut:42496,cut:53486,cut:49267,binarycut:54159] $spltprd0($spltcnst70).
% 54796 [binary:40983.2,53498] hasperson(n4,italian) | $spltprd0($spltcnst54).
% 54800 [binary:41583,53498.2] hasperson(n4,american) | $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 54825 [binary:40983.2,54796] $spltprd0($spltcnst54).
% 54845 [binary:42675,54800] -hasperson(n3,american) | $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 54848 [binary:45492.2,54800] -hasdrink(n4,vodka) | $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 54878 [binary:40909,54848,cut:50109,cut:43049,cut:53490] hasdrink(n4,lemonade) | $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 54902 [binary:51897,54878] -hasperson(n3,englishman) | $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 54919 [?] ?
% 54955 [binary:40905.4,54902,cut:44124,cut:42990,binarycut:54845,binarycut:54919] $spltprd0($spltcnst74).
% 54959 [binary:41203,53508.2] hasdrink(n5,vodka) | $spltprd0($spltcnst69).
% 54989 [binary:45331.2,54959] -haspet(n5,toad) | $spltprd0($spltcnst69).
% 55015 [binary:40914.2,54989,cut:49895,cut:50099,binarycut:41476] haspet(n3,toad) | $spltprd0($spltcnst69).
% 55018 [?] ?
% 55073 [binary:45361,55015,binarycut:55018] $spltprd0($spltcnst69).
% 55147 [binary:40997.2,53533] hasgame(n3,backgammon) | $spltprd0($spltcnst68).
% 55150 [binary:41438,53533.2] hasgame(n3,charades) | $spltprd0($spltcnst73).
% 55165 [binary:43992,53533,binarycut:45515] -hasperson(n3,italian).
% 55181 [binary:40997.2,55147] $spltprd0($spltcnst68).
% 55192 [binary:43165,55150] -hasperson(n4,american) | $spltprd0($spltcnst73).
% 55218 [binary:40905.2,55192,cut:42496,cut:53486,cut:49267] hasperson(n4,italian) | $spltprd0($spltcnst73).
% 55255 [?] ?
% 55272 [binary:45515.2,55218,binarycut:55255] $spltprd0($spltcnst73).
% 55369 [binary:40911,54042,cut:53520,cut:49905,binarycut:43992,binarycut:45515] -hasperson(n5,italian).
% 55370 [binary:40973.2,55369] -haspet(n5,guppy).
% 55372 [binary:40906.2,55369,cut:55165,cut:43922,cut:50102] hasperson(n4,italian).
% 55380 [binary:43992.2,55372] -hasgame(n4,charades).
% 55383 [binary:45515.2,55372] -hasgame(n4,backgammon).
% 55389 [binary:40911.2,55380,cut:53519,cut:55383,cut:49904] hasgame(n4,solitaire).
% 55407 [binary:53204,55389] -hasperson(n5,englishman).
% 55436 [binary:40905.4,55407,cut:51187,cut:41967,cut:55369] hasperson(n5,american).
% 55452 [binary:45361.2,55436] -haspet(n5,toad).
% 55464 [binary:40913.5,55452,cut:55370,cut:53521,cut:49950] haspet(n5,no_pet).
% 55480 [binary:41004.2,55464] $spltprd0($spltcnst75).
% 56206 [binary:41013,41005.2,cut:55272,cut:55480,cut:54955,cut:54185,cut:46911,cut:53287,cut:53511,cut:55073,cut:55181,cut:48694,cut:49830,cut:48193,cut:46555,cut:53481,cut:50850,cut:47912,cut:47193,cut:51546,cut:42036,cut:47394,cut:54825,cut:53161,cut:53352] -$spltprd0($spltcnst63).
% 56207 [binary:41173,56206] contradiction
% END OF PROOF
%
% Proof found by the following strategy:
%
% using binary resolution
% not using sos strategy
% using double strategy
% using dynamic demodulation
% using ordered paramodulation
% using kb ordering for equality
% preferring bigger arities for lex ordering
% using clause demodulation
% clause length limited to 49
% clause depth limited to 1
% seconds given: 18
%
%
% ***GANDALF_FOUND_A_REFUTATION***
%
% Global statistics over all passes:
%
% given clauses: 14598
% derived clauses: 146417
% kept clauses: 24095
% kept size sum: 325933
% kept mid-nuclei: 16100
% kept new demods: 0
% forw unit-subs: 38462
% forw double-subs: 9781
% forw overdouble-subs: 12381
% backward subs: 2904
% fast unit cutoff: 10116
% full unit cutoff: 323
% dbl unit cutoff: 357
% real runtime : 39.24
% process. runtime: 38.63
% specific non-discr-tree subsumption statistics:
% tried: 2721459
% length fails: 15480
% strength fails: 98920
% predlist fails: 1809280
% aux str. fails: 605
% by-lit fails: 602388
% full subs tried: 186529
% full subs fail: 176787
%
% ; program args: ("/home/graph/tptp/Systems/Gandalf---c-2.6/gandalf" "-time" "600" "/home/graph/tptp/TSTP/PreparedTPTP/otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)---add_equality:r/PUZ/PUZ017-1+noeq.in")
%
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------