TSTP Solution File: PRO017+3 by SPASS---3.9
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : SPASS---3.9
% Problem : PRO017+3 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp
% Command : run_spass %d %s
% Computer : n026.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Mon Jul 18 17:53:53 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 9.58s 9.76s
% Output : Refutation 9.63s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.03/0.13 % Problem : PRO017+3 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v4.0.0.
% 0.03/0.13 % Command : run_spass %d %s
% 0.13/0.35 % Computer : n026.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.35 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.35 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.35 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.35 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.35 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.35 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.13/0.35 % DateTime : Mon Jun 13 02:50:20 EDT 2022
% 0.13/0.35 % CPUTime :
% 9.58/9.76
% 9.58/9.76 SPASS V 3.9
% 9.58/9.76 SPASS beiseite: Proof found.
% 9.58/9.76 % SZS status Theorem
% 9.58/9.76 Problem: /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 9.58/9.76 SPASS derived 12208 clauses, backtracked 2053 clauses, performed 43 splits and kept 6827 clauses.
% 9.58/9.76 SPASS allocated 109280 KBytes.
% 9.58/9.76 SPASS spent 0:00:09.39 on the problem.
% 9.58/9.76 0:00:00.03 for the input.
% 9.58/9.76 0:00:00.13 for the FLOTTER CNF translation.
% 9.58/9.76 0:00:00.21 for inferences.
% 9.58/9.76 0:00:00.13 for the backtracking.
% 9.58/9.76 0:00:08.72 for the reduction.
% 9.58/9.76
% 9.58/9.76
% 9.58/9.76 Here is a proof with depth 9, length 155 :
% 9.58/9.76 % SZS output start Refutation
% 9.58/9.76 1[0:Inp] || -> arboreal(skc3)*.
% 9.58/9.76 3[0:Inp] || -> atomic(tptp4)*.
% 9.58/9.76 4[0:Inp] || -> atomic(tptp2)*.
% 9.58/9.76 5[0:Inp] || -> atomic(tptp1)*.
% 9.58/9.76 7[0:Inp] || -> subactivity_occurrence(skc3,skc2)*l.
% 9.58/9.76 8[0:Inp] || -> occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 11[0:Inp] || leaf_occ(skc3,skc2)* -> .
% 9.58/9.76 13[0:Inp] || equal(tptp4,tptp3)** -> .
% 9.58/9.76 16[0:Inp] || equal(tptp2,tptp3)** -> .
% 9.58/9.76 17[0:Inp] || equal(tptp1,tptp3)** -> .
% 9.58/9.76 20[0:Inp] || occurrence_of(u,v)* -> activity(v).
% 9.58/9.76 21[0:Inp] || occurrence_of(u,v)* -> activity_occurrence(u).
% 9.58/9.76 23[0:Inp] || precedes(u,v)* -> legal(v).
% 9.58/9.76 27[0:Inp] activity_occurrence(u) || -> occurrence_of(u,skf19(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 32[0:Inp] || next_subocc(u,v,w)* -> arboreal(v).
% 9.58/9.76 35[0:Inp] || min_precedes(u,v,w)* -> precedes(u,v).
% 9.58/9.76 38[0:Inp] atomic(u) || occurrence_of(v,u)* -> arboreal(v).
% 9.58/9.76 43[0:Inp] || leaf(u,v) min_precedes(u,w,v)* -> .
% 9.58/9.76 44[0:Inp] || next_subocc(u,v,w)* -> min_precedes(u,v,w).
% 9.58/9.76 58[0:Inp] || occurrence_of(u,v)*+ occurrence_of(u,w)* -> equal(w,v)*.
% 9.58/9.76 61[0:Inp] || min_precedes(u,v,w) -> occurrence_of(skf28(v,u,w),w)*.
% 9.58/9.76 63[0:Inp] || min_precedes(u,v,w)*+ -> subactivity_occurrence(v,skf28(v,x,y))*r.
% 9.58/9.76 73[0:Inp] || leaf_occ(u,v)* occurrence_of(v,w)* min_precedes(u,x,w)*+ -> .
% 9.58/9.76 76[0:Inp] || min_precedes(u,v,w)*+ -> leaf(v,w) min_precedes(v,skf25(w,v),w)*.
% 9.58/9.76 78[0:Inp] || min_precedes(skf40(u),v,tptp0)* -> equal(v,skf36(u)) equal(v,skf38(u)).
% 9.58/9.76 91[0:Inp] arboreal(u) || subactivity_occurrence(u,v)+ occurrence_of(v,tptp0) -> leaf_occ(u,v)* occurrence_of(skf40(u),tptp3)*.
% 9.58/9.76 92[0:Inp] arboreal(u) || subactivity_occurrence(u,v) occurrence_of(v,tptp0) -> occurrence_of(skf38(w),tptp4)* leaf_occ(u,v)*.
% 9.58/9.76 94[0:Inp] arboreal(u) || subactivity_occurrence(u,v)+ occurrence_of(v,tptp0) -> leaf_occ(u,v)* next_subocc(u,skf40(u),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 95[0:Inp] arboreal(u) || subactivity_occurrence(u,v)+ occurrence_of(v,tptp0) -> leaf_occ(u,v)* min_precedes(skf38(u),skf36(u),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 96[0:Inp] arboreal(u) || subactivity_occurrence(u,v)+ occurrence_of(v,tptp0) -> leaf_occ(u,v)* min_precedes(skf40(u),skf38(u),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 99[0:Inp] arboreal(u) || subactivity_occurrence(u,v) occurrence_of(v,tptp0) -> occurrence_of(skf36(w),tptp2) occurrence_of(skf36(w),tptp1)* leaf_occ(u,v)*.
% 9.58/9.76 102[0:Inp] || leaf(u,tptp0) occurrence_of(v,tptp3) occurrence_of(u,tptp1) min_precedes(v,u,tptp0)*+ next_subocc(skc3,v,tptp0)* -> .
% 9.58/9.76 103[0:Inp] || leaf(u,tptp0) occurrence_of(v,tptp3) occurrence_of(u,tptp2) min_precedes(v,u,tptp0)*+ next_subocc(skc3,v,tptp0)* -> .
% 9.58/9.76 161[0:Res:7.0,99.1] arboreal(skc3) || occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0) -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2) occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp1)* leaf_occ(skc3,skc2).
% 9.58/9.76 162[0:Res:7.0,96.1] arboreal(skc3) || occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0) -> min_precedes(skf40(skc3),skf38(skc3),tptp0)* leaf_occ(skc3,skc2).
% 9.58/9.76 163[0:Res:7.0,95.1] arboreal(skc3) || occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0) -> min_precedes(skf38(skc3),skf36(skc3),tptp0)* leaf_occ(skc3,skc2).
% 9.58/9.76 164[0:Res:7.0,94.1] arboreal(skc3) || occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0) -> next_subocc(skc3,skf40(skc3),tptp0)* leaf_occ(skc3,skc2).
% 9.58/9.76 165[0:Res:7.0,92.1] arboreal(skc3) || occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0) -> occurrence_of(skf38(u),tptp4)* leaf_occ(skc3,skc2).
% 9.58/9.76 166[0:Res:7.0,91.1] arboreal(skc3) || occurrence_of(skc2,tptp0) -> occurrence_of(skf40(skc3),tptp3)* leaf_occ(skc3,skc2).
% 9.58/9.76 187[0:MRR:165.0,165.1,165.3,1.0,8.0,11.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf38(u),tptp4)*.
% 9.58/9.76 188[0:MRR:166.0,166.1,166.3,1.0,8.0,11.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf40(skc3),tptp3)*.
% 9.58/9.76 189[0:MRR:164.0,164.1,164.3,1.0,8.0,11.0] || -> next_subocc(skc3,skf40(skc3),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 190[0:MRR:162.0,162.1,162.3,1.0,8.0,11.0] || -> min_precedes(skf40(skc3),skf38(skc3),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 191[0:MRR:163.0,163.1,163.3,1.0,8.0,11.0] || -> min_precedes(skf38(skc3),skf36(skc3),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 193[0:MRR:161.0,161.1,161.4,1.0,8.0,11.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp1)* occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2).
% 9.58/9.76 233[0:Res:187.0,20.0] || -> activity(tptp4)*.
% 9.58/9.76 235[0:Res:188.0,21.0] || -> activity_occurrence(skf40(skc3))*.
% 9.58/9.76 236[0:Res:187.0,21.0] || -> activity_occurrence(skf38(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 245[0:Res:189.0,32.0] || -> arboreal(skf40(skc3))*.
% 9.58/9.76 252[0:Res:193.0,21.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2)* activity_occurrence(skf36(u)).
% 9.58/9.76 254[0:MRR:252.0,21.0] || -> activity_occurrence(skf36(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 271[0:Res:187.0,38.1] atomic(tptp4) || -> arboreal(skf38(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 273[0:Res:193.0,38.1] atomic(tptp1) || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2)* arboreal(skf36(u)).
% 9.58/9.76 275[0:SSi:271.0,3.0,233.0] || -> arboreal(skf38(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 277[0:SSi:273.0,5.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2)* arboreal(skf36(u)).
% 9.58/9.76 279[0:Res:277.0,38.1] atomic(tptp2) || -> arboreal(skf36(u))* arboreal(skf36(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 283[0:Obv:279.1] atomic(tptp2) || -> arboreal(skf36(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 284[0:SSi:283.0,4.0] || -> arboreal(skf36(u))*.
% 9.58/9.76 339[0:Res:190.0,43.1] || leaf(skf40(skc3),tptp0)* -> .
% 9.58/9.76 342[0:Res:189.0,44.0] || -> min_precedes(skc3,skf40(skc3),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 351[0:Res:342.0,35.0] || -> precedes(skc3,skf40(skc3))*.
% 9.58/9.76 356[0:Res:351.0,23.0] || -> legal(skf40(skc3))*.
% 9.58/9.76 455[0:Res:187.0,58.0] || occurrence_of(skf38(u),v)* -> equal(v,tptp4).
% 9.58/9.76 456[0:Res:27.1,58.0] activity_occurrence(u) || occurrence_of(u,v)* -> equal(v,skf19(u)).
% 9.58/9.76 458[0:Res:193.0,58.0] || occurrence_of(skf36(u),v)*+ -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2)* equal(v,tptp1).
% 9.58/9.76 463[0:MRR:456.0,21.1] || occurrence_of(u,v)* -> equal(v,skf19(u)).
% 9.58/9.76 475[0:Res:27.1,455.0] activity_occurrence(skf38(u)) || -> equal(skf19(skf38(u)),tptp4)**.
% 9.58/9.76 479[0:SSi:475.0,236.0,275.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf38(u)),tptp4)**.
% 9.58/9.76 557[0:Res:193.0,463.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp2)* equal(skf19(skf36(u)),tptp1).
% 9.58/9.76 650[0:Res:557.0,20.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf36(u)),tptp1)** activity(tptp2).
% 9.58/9.76 651[1:Spt:650.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf36(u)),tptp1)**.
% 9.58/9.76 655[1:SpR:651.0,27.1] activity_occurrence(skf36(u)) || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp1)*.
% 9.58/9.76 659[1:SSi:655.0,254.0,284.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(u),tptp1)*.
% 9.58/9.76 669[0:Res:190.0,73.2] || leaf_occ(skf40(skc3),u)* occurrence_of(u,tptp0) -> .
% 9.58/9.76 809[0:Res:191.0,76.0] || -> leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0) min_precedes(skf36(skc3),skf25(tptp0,skf36(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 814[0:Res:342.0,76.0] || -> leaf(skf40(skc3),tptp0) min_precedes(skf40(skc3),skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 820[0:MRR:814.0,339.0] || -> min_precedes(skf40(skc3),skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 848[0:Res:820.0,78.0] || -> equal(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3)) equal(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.58/9.76 957[0:Res:342.0,63.0] || -> subactivity_occurrence(skf40(skc3),skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v))*r.
% 9.58/9.76 1199[0:Res:820.0,102.3] || leaf(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf40(skc3),tptp3) occurrence_of(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp1) next_subocc(skc3,skf40(skc3),tptp0) -> .
% 9.58/9.76 1205[0:MRR:1199.1,1199.3,188.0,189.0] || leaf(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp1) -> .
% 9.58/9.76 1293[2:Spt:809.0] || -> leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 2206[0:Res:957.0,94.1] arboreal(skf40(skc3)) || occurrence_of(skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v),tptp0) -> leaf_occ(skf40(skc3),skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v))* next_subocc(skf40(skc3),skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0).
% 9.58/9.76 2207[0:Res:957.0,91.1] arboreal(skf40(skc3)) || occurrence_of(skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v),tptp0) -> leaf_occ(skf40(skc3),skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v))* occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp3).
% 9.58/9.76 2249[0:SSi:2207.0,235.0,245.0,356.0] || occurrence_of(skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v),tptp0) -> leaf_occ(skf40(skc3),skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v))* occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp3).
% 9.58/9.76 2250[0:MRR:2249.1,669.0] || occurrence_of(skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v),tptp0)* -> occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp3).
% 9.58/9.76 2251[0:SSi:2206.0,235.0,245.0,356.0] || occurrence_of(skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v),tptp0) -> leaf_occ(skf40(skc3),skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v))* next_subocc(skf40(skc3),skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0).
% 9.58/9.76 2252[0:MRR:2251.1,669.0] || occurrence_of(skf28(skf40(skc3),u,v),tptp0)*+ -> next_subocc(skf40(skc3),skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.58/9.76 2370[0:Res:61.1,2250.0] || min_precedes(u,skf40(skc3),tptp0)* -> occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp3).
% 9.63/9.83 2372[0:Res:342.0,2370.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp3)*.
% 9.63/9.83 2389[0:Res:2372.0,463.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf40(skf40(skc3))),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 2714[3:Spt:848.0] || -> equal(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 2736[3:Rew:2714.0,1205.0] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0) occurrence_of(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),tptp1)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 2761[3:Rew:2714.0,2736.1] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp1) -> .
% 9.63/9.83 2762[3:MRR:2761.0,2761.1,1293.0,659.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 2776[3:Spt:2762.0,848.0,2714.0] || equal(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))** -> .
% 9.63/9.83 2777[3:Spt:2762.0,848.1] || -> equal(skf25(tptp0,skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 7196[0:Res:61.1,2252.0] || min_precedes(u,skf40(skc3),tptp0)*+ -> next_subocc(skf40(skc3),skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.63/9.83 7200[0:Res:342.0,7196.0] || -> next_subocc(skf40(skc3),skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.63/9.83 7210[0:Res:7200.0,44.0] || -> min_precedes(skf40(skc3),skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.63/9.83 7214[0:Res:7210.0,102.3] || leaf(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0) occurrence_of(skf40(skc3),tptp3) occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp1) next_subocc(skc3,skf40(skc3),tptp0)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 7215[0:Res:7210.0,103.3] || leaf(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0) occurrence_of(skf40(skc3),tptp3) occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp2) next_subocc(skc3,skf40(skc3),tptp0)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 7218[0:Res:7210.0,78.0] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3)) equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 7242[0:MRR:7215.1,7215.3,188.0,189.0] || leaf(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp2) -> .
% 9.63/9.83 7243[0:MRR:7214.1,7214.3,188.0,189.0] || leaf(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp1) -> .
% 9.63/9.83 7963[4:Spt:7218.0] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 8023[4:Rew:7963.0,7243.0] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0) occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp1)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 8049[4:Rew:7963.0,8023.1] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp1) -> .
% 9.63/9.83 8050[4:MRR:8049.0,8049.1,1293.0,659.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 8071[4:Spt:8050.0,7218.0,7963.0] || equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))** -> .
% 9.63/9.83 8072[4:Spt:8050.0,7218.1] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 8083[4:Rew:8072.0,2389.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf38(skc3)),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 8085[4:Rew:479.0,8083.0] || -> equal(tptp4,tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 8086[4:MRR:8085.0,13.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 8159[2:Spt:8086.0,809.0,1293.0] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 8160[2:Spt:8086.0,809.1] || -> min_precedes(skf36(skc3),skf25(tptp0,skf36(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.63/9.83 10170[3:Spt:7218.0] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 10176[3:Rew:10170.0,2389.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf36(skc3)),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 10260[3:Rew:651.0,10176.0] || -> equal(tptp1,tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 10261[3:MRR:10260.0,17.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 10296[3:Spt:10261.0,7218.0,10170.0] || equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))** -> .
% 9.63/9.83 10297[3:Spt:10261.0,7218.1] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 10308[3:Rew:10297.0,2389.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf38(skc3)),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 10313[3:Rew:479.0,10308.0] || -> equal(tptp4,tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 10314[3:MRR:10313.0,13.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 10393[1:Spt:10314.0,650.1] || -> activity(tptp2)*.
% 9.63/9.83 10899[2:Spt:809.0] || -> leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)*.
% 9.63/9.83 12324[3:Spt:7218.0] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 12328[3:Rew:12324.0,2372.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp3)*.
% 9.63/9.83 12358[3:Rew:12324.0,7242.0] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0) occurrence_of(skf40(skf40(skc3)),tptp2)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12437[3:Rew:12324.0,12358.1] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)* occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp2) -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12438[3:MRR:12437.0,10899.0] || occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp2)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12500[3:Res:12328.0,458.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp2)* equal(tptp1,tptp3).
% 9.63/9.83 12501[3:MRR:12500.1,17.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp2)*.
% 9.63/9.83 12502[3:MRR:12501.0,12438.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12503[3:Spt:12502.0,7218.0,12324.0] || equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))** -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12504[3:Spt:12502.0,7218.1] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 12515[3:Rew:12504.0,2389.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf38(skc3)),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 12520[3:Rew:479.0,12515.0] || -> equal(tptp4,tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 12521[3:MRR:12520.0,13.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12603[2:Spt:12521.0,809.0,10899.0] || leaf(skf36(skc3),tptp0)* -> .
% 9.63/9.83 12604[2:Spt:12521.0,809.1] || -> min_precedes(skf36(skc3),skf25(tptp0,skf36(skc3)),tptp0)*.
% 9.63/9.83 14353[3:Spt:7218.0] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 14357[3:Rew:14353.0,2372.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp3)*.
% 9.63/9.83 14359[3:Rew:14353.0,2389.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf36(skc3)),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 14530[3:Res:14357.0,458.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp2)* equal(tptp1,tptp3).
% 9.63/9.83 14531[3:MRR:14530.1,17.0] || -> occurrence_of(skf36(skc3),tptp2)*.
% 9.63/9.83 14568[3:Res:14531.0,463.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf36(skc3)),tptp2)**.
% 9.63/9.83 14574[3:Rew:14359.0,14568.0] || -> equal(tptp2,tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 14575[3:MRR:14574.0,16.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 14577[3:Spt:14575.0,7218.0,14353.0] || equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf36(skc3))** -> .
% 9.63/9.83 14578[3:Spt:14575.0,7218.1] || -> equal(skf40(skf40(skc3)),skf38(skc3))**.
% 9.63/9.83 14589[3:Rew:14578.0,2389.0] || -> equal(skf19(skf38(skc3)),tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 14594[3:Rew:479.0,14589.0] || -> equal(tptp4,tptp3)**.
% 9.63/9.83 14595[3:MRR:14594.0,13.0] || -> .
% 9.63/9.83 % SZS output end Refutation
% 9.63/9.83 Formulae used in the proof : goals sos_52 sos_53 sos_54 sos_56 sos_59 sos_60 sos sos_10 sos_01 sos_44 sos_15 sos_07 sos_21 sos_22 sos_02 sos_25 sos_37 sos_49 sos_46 sos_51
% 9.63/9.83
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------