TSTP Solution File: PHI014+1 by Goeland---1.0.0
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Goeland---1.0.0
% Problem : PHI014+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v7.2.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : goeland -dmt -presko -proof %s
% Computer : n022.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Sun Sep 18 13:29:49 EDT 2022
% Result : Theorem 16.89s 3.14s
% Output : Proof 16.89s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.04/0.13 % Problem : PHI014+1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v7.2.0.
% 0.04/0.13 % Command : goeland -dmt -presko -proof %s
% 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n022.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.35 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.35 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.13/0.35 % DateTime : Fri Sep 2 16:59:40 EDT 2022
% 0.13/0.35 % CPUTime :
% 0.13/0.35 [DMT] DMT loaded with preskolemization
% 0.13/0.35 [EQ] equality loaded.
% 0.13/0.35 [0.000040s][1][MAIN] Problem : theBenchmark.p
% 0.13/0.35 Start search
% 0.13/0.35 nb_step : 1 - limit : 8
% 0.13/0.35 Launch Gotab with destructive = true
% 16.61/3.14 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark.p
% 16.89/3.14 [0] ALPHA_AND : (! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6))))))) & ! [X7_7, F8_8] : ((is_the(X7_7, F8_8) => (property(F8_8) & object(X7_7)))) & ! [X9_9] : ((object(X9_9) => (exemplifies_property(none_greater, X9_9) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, X9_9) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, X9_9)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))))) & ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))) & is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6))))))), ! [X7_7, F8_8] : ((is_the(X7_7, F8_8) => (property(F8_8) & object(X7_7)))), ! [X9_9] : ((object(X9_9) => (exemplifies_property(none_greater, X9_9) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, X9_9) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, X9_9)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))))), ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))), is_the(god, none_greater), ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [3] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [4] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [3] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X7_7, F8_8] : ((is_the(X7_7, F8_8) => (property(F8_8) & object(X7_7))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [7] (is_the(god, none_greater) => (property(none_greater) & object(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [7] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => (property(none_greater) & object(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [8] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [9] (property(none_greater) & object(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [8] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [16] CLOSURE : property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [4] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [5] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [6] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [6] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X7_7, F8_8] : ((is_the(X7_7, F8_8) => (property(F8_8) & object(X7_7))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [11] (is_the(god, none_greater) => (property(none_greater) & object(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [11] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => (property(none_greater) & object(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [14] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [15] (property(none_greater) & object(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [14] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [15] ALPHA_AND : (property(none_greater) & object(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [18] property(none_greater), object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [18] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X9_9] : ((object(X9_9) => (exemplifies_property(none_greater, X9_9) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, X9_9) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, X9_9)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [20] (object(god) => (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [20] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [23] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [24] (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [24] BETA_EQUIV : (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [27] ~exemplifies_property(none_greater, god), ~(exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [28] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god), (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [27] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [32] ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [33] ~~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [33] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [36] ? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [36] DELTA_EXISTS : ? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [38] ((object(skolem_Y1010(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [38] ALPHA_AND : ((object(skolem_Y1010(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [40] (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010(god), god)), exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [40] ALPHA_AND : (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [63] object(skolem_Y1010(god)), exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [63] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [86] (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => ((is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [86] BETA_IMPLY : (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => ((is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [87] ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [88] ((is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [87] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [88] BETA_IMPLY : ((is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [369] ~(is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [370] ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [370] DELTA_EXISTS : ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [373] ((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [373] ALPHA_AND : ((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), skolem_Y1010(god))) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [375] (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), skolem_Y1010(god))), exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [375] ALPHA_AND : (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [384] object(skolem_Y1212(god)), exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [384] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [392] (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [392] BETA_IMPLY : (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [393] ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [394] (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [393] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [394] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [458] ~is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [459] exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [459] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [474] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [474] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [476] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [476] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [479] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [480] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [479] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [480] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [715] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [716] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [716] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [717] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [717] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [719] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [720] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [719] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [720] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [858] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [859] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [858] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [859] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [718] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [902] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [903] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [903] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [902] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [458] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [469] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [469] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [471] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [471] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [472] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [473] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [472] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [473] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [775] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [776] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [775] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [801] ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [801] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [802] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [803] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [802] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [803] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [777] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [956] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [957] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [956] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [957] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1047] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1048] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1047] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1048] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [369] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [371] ~is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [372] ~~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [372] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [374] exemplifies_property(existence, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [374] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [379] (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [379] BETA_IMPLY : (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [380] ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [381] (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [380] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [381] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [399] ~is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [400] exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [400] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [407] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [407] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [409] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [409] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [414] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [415] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [415] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [418] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [419] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [419] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [423] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [423] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [426] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [427] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [427] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [437] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [438] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [438] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [437] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [426] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [420] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [713] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [714] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [714] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [713] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [414] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [399] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [406] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [406] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [408] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [408] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [412] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [413] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [413] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [416] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [417] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [417] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [430] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [430] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [431] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [432] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [431] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [432] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [784] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [785] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [784] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [785] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [445] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [925] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [926] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [926] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [925] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [412] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [371] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [376] (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [376] BETA_IMPLY : (object(skolem_Y1010(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [377] ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [378] (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [377] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [378] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [410] ~is_the(skolem_Y1010(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [411] exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1010(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [411] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [422] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [422] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [429] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [429] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [435] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [436] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [436] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [443] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [444] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [444] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [449] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [449] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [452] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [453] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [453] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [456] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [457] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [456] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [457] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [452] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [460] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [796] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [797] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [796] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [797] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [435] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [410] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [421] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [421] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [428] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [428] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [433] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [434] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [433] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [434] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [827] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [828] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [828] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [832] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [832] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [833] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [834] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [833] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [834] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [998] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [999] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [998] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [999] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [840] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1049] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1050] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1049] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1050] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [32] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [42] (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [42] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [45] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [46] ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [45] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [46] BETA_IMPLY : ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [949] ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [950] ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [949] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [953] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [954] ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [954] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [955] exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [955] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [953] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [964] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [978] (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [978] BETA_IMPLY : (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [982] ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [983] (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [982] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [983] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1104] ~is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1105] exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1104] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1109] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1109] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1111] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1111] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1114] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1115] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1114] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1115] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1316] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1317] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1317] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1319] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1319] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1322] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1323] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1323] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1332] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1333] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1332] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1333] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1322] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1318] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1455] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1456] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1456] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1455] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1105] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1640] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1640] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1641] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1641] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1642] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1643] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1642] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1643] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1644] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1645] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1644] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1646] ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1646] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1647] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1648] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1648] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1647] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1645] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1649] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1649] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1650] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1651] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1651] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1652] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1653] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1653] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1652] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1650] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [48] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1750] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1751] ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1750] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1751] BETA_IMPLY : ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1752] ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1753] ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1752] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1755] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1756] ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1756] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1758] exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1758] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1755] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1761] BETA_IMPLY : (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) => (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1883] ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1884] (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1883] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1884] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1909] ~is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1910] exemplifies_property(none_greater, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1910] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1911] ~((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1911] BETA_NOT_AND : ~((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1913] ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1914] ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1914] CLOSURE : ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1913] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1917] ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1918] ~exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1917] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1918] CLOSURE : ~exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1909] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1912] ~((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1912] BETA_NOT_AND : ~((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1915] ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1916] ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1916] CLOSURE : ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1915] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1919] ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [1920] ~exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1919] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [1920] CLOSURE : ~exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [23] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [5] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X7_7, F8_8] : ((is_the(X7_7, F8_8) => (property(F8_8) & object(X7_7))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [10] (is_the(god, none_greater) => (property(none_greater) & object(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [10] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => (property(none_greater) & object(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [12] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [13] (property(none_greater) & object(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [12] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [19] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2328] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2329] (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2328] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2329] BETA_EQUIV : (exemplifies_property(none_greater, god) <=> (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2561] ~exemplifies_property(none_greater, god), ~(exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2562] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god), (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2562] ALPHA_AND : (exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2567] exemplifies_property(conceivable, god), ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2567] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2574] (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2574] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2578] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2579] ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2578] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2579] BETA_IMPLY : ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2582] ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2583] ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2582] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2584] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2585] ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2584] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2585] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2588] exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2588] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2603] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2612] ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2613] ~is_the(skolem_Y1212(god), none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2612] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2613] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2621] ~((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2621] BETA_NOT_AND : ~((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2622] ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2623] ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2623] CLOSURE : ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2622] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2628] ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2629] ~exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2629] CLOSURE : ~exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2628] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2561] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(exemplifies_property(conceivable, god) & ~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2563] ~exemplifies_property(conceivable, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2564] ~~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2563] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2568] (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2568] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2570] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2571] ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2570] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2571] BETA_IMPLY : ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2626] ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2627] ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2626] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2630] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2631] ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2630] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2631] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2637] exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2637] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2627] DELTA_EXISTS : ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2633] ((object(skolem_Y1212) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2633] ALPHA_AND : ((object(skolem_Y1212) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2638] (object(skolem_Y1212) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212, god)), exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2638] ALPHA_AND : (object(skolem_Y1212) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2643] object(skolem_Y1212), exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2643] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2644] ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2644] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2645] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2646] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2645] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2646] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2564] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2565] ? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2565] DELTA_EXISTS : ? [Y10_10] : (((object(Y10_10) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y10_10, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y10_10)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2566] ((object(skolem_Y1010) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1010))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2566] ALPHA_AND : ((object(skolem_Y1010) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1010))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2569] (object(skolem_Y1010) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010, god)), exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1010)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2569] ALPHA_AND : (object(skolem_Y1010) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2589] object(skolem_Y1010), exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1010, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2589] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [X11_11] : ((object(X11_11) => ((is_the(X11_11, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, X11_11)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, X11_11)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2592] (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2592] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2593] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2594] ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2593] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2594] BETA_IMPLY : ((is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god)) => ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2595] ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2596] ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2595] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(is_the(god, none_greater) & ~exemplifies_property(existence, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2597] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2598] ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2597] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2598] ALPHA_NOT_NOT : ~~exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2605] exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2605] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(existence, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2596] DELTA_EXISTS : ? [Y12_12] : (((object(Y12_12) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, Y12_12, god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, Y12_12)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2600] ((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2600] ALPHA_AND : ((object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)) & exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2604] (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)), exemplifies_property(conceivable, skolem_Y1212(god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2604] ALPHA_AND : (object(skolem_Y1212(god)) & exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2608] object(skolem_Y1212(god)), exemplifies_relation(greater_than, skolem_Y1212(god), god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2608] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2609] ~(object(skolem_Y1010) & is_the(skolem_Y1010, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2609] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(skolem_Y1010) & is_the(skolem_Y1010, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2610] ~object(skolem_Y1010)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2611] ~is_the(skolem_Y1010, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2610] CLOSURE : ~object(skolem_Y1010)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2611] : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2617] ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2617] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [F4_4] : ((property(F4_4) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, F4_4))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, F4_4) => exemplifies_property(F4_4, Z6_6)))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2618] (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2618] BETA_IMPLY : (property(none_greater) => (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2619] ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2620] (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2619] CLOSURE : ~property(none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2620] BETA_IMPLY : (? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater))) => ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6)))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2624] ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2625] ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2625] GAMMA_FORALL : ! [Z6_6] : ((object(Z6_6) => (is_the(Z6_6, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, Z6_6))))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2636] (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2636] BETA_IMPLY : (object(god) => (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2639] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2640] (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2639] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2640] BETA_IMPLY : (is_the(god, none_greater) => exemplifies_property(none_greater, god))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2647] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2648] exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2647] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2648] CLOSURE : exemplifies_property(none_greater, god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2624] GAMMA_NOT_EXISTS : ~? [Y5_5] : ((object(Y5_5) & is_the(Y5_5, none_greater)))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2632] ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2632] BETA_NOT_AND : ~(object(god) & is_the(god, none_greater))
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2634] ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14 -> [2635] ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2634] CLOSURE : ~object(god)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 [2635] CLOSURE : ~is_the(god, none_greater)
% 16.89/3.14
% 16.89/3.14 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark.p
% 16.89/3.14 [2.788272s][1][Res] 35072 goroutines created
% 16.89/3.14 ==== Result ====
% 16.89/3.14 [2.788290s][1][Res] VALID
% 16.89/3.14 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark.p
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------