TSTP Solution File: NLP258+1 by PyRes---1.5
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : PyRes---1.5
% Problem : NLP258+1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% Computer : n004.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Thu May 9 17:34:55 EDT 2024
% Result : Theorem 5.04s 5.20s
% Output : Refutation 5.04s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.07/0.12 % Problem : NLP258+1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.07/0.13 % Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% 0.13/0.33 % Computer : n004.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.33 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.33 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.33 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.33 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.34 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Wed May 8 13:31:38 EDT 2024
% 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 5.04/5.20 % Version: 1.5
% 5.04/5.20 % SZS status Theorem
% 5.04/5.20 % SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 5.04/5.20 fof(co1,conjecture,(~((?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3))&present(Y,X4))&smoke(Y,X4))))))&of(U,Z,X1))&man(U,X1))&jules_forename(U,Z))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&state(U,X2))&be(U,X2,X1,X1)))))))))))&(~(?[X5]:(actual_world(X5)&(?[X6]:(?[X7]:(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:(?[X8]:(?[X9]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((of(X5,X6,X1)&jules_forename(X5,X6))&forename(X5,X6))&of(X5,X7,V))&vincent_forename(X5,X7))&forename(X5,X7))&of(X5,W,V))&man(X5,V))&vincent_forename(X5,W))&forename(X5,W))&proposition(X5,Y))&agent(X5,X,V))&theme(X5,X,Y))&event(X5,X))&present(X5,X))&think_believe_consider(X5,X))&accessible_world(X5,Y))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3))&present(Y,X4))&smoke(Y,X4))))))&of(X5,Z,X1))&man(X5,X1))&jules_forename(X5,Z))&forename(X5,Z))&man(X5,X1))&state(X5,X2))&be(X5,X2,X1,X1))&proposition(X5,X9))&agent(X5,X8,V))&theme(X5,X8,X9))&event(X5,X8))&present(X5,X8))&think_believe_consider(X5,X8))&accessible_world(X5,X9))&(?[X10]:(((event(X9,X10)&agent(X9,X10,X1))&present(X9,X10))&smoke(X9,X10)))))))))))))))))))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', co1)).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c36,negated_conjecture,(~(~((?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3))&present(Y,X4))&smoke(Y,X4))))))&of(U,Z,X1))&man(U,X1))&jules_forename(U,Z))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&state(U,X2))&be(U,X2,X1,X1)))))))))))&(~(?[X5]:(actual_world(X5)&(?[X6]:(?[X7]:(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:(?[X8]:(?[X9]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((of(X5,X6,X1)&jules_forename(X5,X6))&forename(X5,X6))&of(X5,X7,V))&vincent_forename(X5,X7))&forename(X5,X7))&of(X5,W,V))&man(X5,V))&vincent_forename(X5,W))&forename(X5,W))&proposition(X5,Y))&agent(X5,X,V))&theme(X5,X,Y))&event(X5,X))&present(X5,X))&think_believe_consider(X5,X))&accessible_world(X5,Y))&(![X3]:(man(Y,X3)=>(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3))&present(Y,X4))&smoke(Y,X4))))))&of(X5,Z,X1))&man(X5,X1))&jules_forename(X5,Z))&forename(X5,Z))&man(X5,X1))&state(X5,X2))&be(X5,X2,X1,X1))&proposition(X5,X9))&agent(X5,X8,V))&theme(X5,X8,X9))&event(X5,X8))&present(X5,X8))&think_believe_consider(X5,X8))&accessible_world(X5,X9))&(?[X10]:(((event(X9,X10)&agent(X9,X10,X1))&present(X9,X10))&smoke(X9,X10))))))))))))))))))))),inference(assume_negation,[status(cth)],[co1])).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c37,negated_conjecture,((?[U]:(actual_world(U)&(?[V]:(?[W]:(?[X]:(?[Y]:(?[Z]:(?[X1]:(?[X2]:((((((((((((((((((of(U,W,V)&man(U,V))&vincent_forename(U,W))&forename(U,W))&proposition(U,Y))&agent(U,X,V))&theme(U,X,Y))&event(U,X))&present(U,X))&think_believe_consider(U,X))&accessible_world(U,Y))&(![X3]:(~man(Y,X3)|(?[X4]:(((event(Y,X4)&agent(Y,X4,X3))&present(Y,X4))&smoke(Y,X4))))))&of(U,Z,X1))&man(U,X1))&jules_forename(U,Z))&forename(U,Z))&man(U,X1))&state(U,X2))&be(U,X2,X1,X1)))))))))))&(![X5]:(~actual_world(X5)|(![X6]:(![X7]:(![V]:(![W]:(![X]:(![Y]:(![Z]:(![X1]:(![X2]:(![X8]:(![X9]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X5,X6,X1)|~jules_forename(X5,X6))|~forename(X5,X6))|~of(X5,X7,V))|~vincent_forename(X5,X7))|~forename(X5,X7))|~of(X5,W,V))|~man(X5,V))|~vincent_forename(X5,W))|~forename(X5,W))|~proposition(X5,Y))|~agent(X5,X,V))|~theme(X5,X,Y))|~event(X5,X))|~present(X5,X))|~think_believe_consider(X5,X))|~accessible_world(X5,Y))|(?[X3]:(man(Y,X3)&(![X4]:(((~event(Y,X4)|~agent(Y,X4,X3))|~present(Y,X4))|~smoke(Y,X4))))))|~of(X5,Z,X1))|~man(X5,X1))|~jules_forename(X5,Z))|~forename(X5,Z))|~man(X5,X1))|~state(X5,X2))|~be(X5,X2,X1,X1))|~proposition(X5,X9))|~agent(X5,X8,V))|~theme(X5,X8,X9))|~event(X5,X8))|~present(X5,X8))|~think_believe_consider(X5,X8))|~accessible_world(X5,X9))|(![X10]:(((~event(X9,X10)|~agent(X9,X10,X1))|~present(X9,X10))|~smoke(X9,X10)))))))))))))))))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[c36])).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c38,negated_conjecture,((?[X2]:(actual_world(X2)&(?[X3]:(?[X4]:(?[X5]:(?[X6]:(?[X7]:(?[X8]:(?[X9]:((((((((((((((((((of(X2,X4,X3)&man(X2,X3))&vincent_forename(X2,X4))&forename(X2,X4))&proposition(X2,X6))&agent(X2,X5,X3))&theme(X2,X5,X6))&event(X2,X5))&present(X2,X5))&think_believe_consider(X2,X5))&accessible_world(X2,X6))&(![X10]:(~man(X6,X10)|(?[X11]:(((event(X6,X11)&agent(X6,X11,X10))&present(X6,X11))&smoke(X6,X11))))))&of(X2,X7,X8))&man(X2,X8))&jules_forename(X2,X7))&forename(X2,X7))&man(X2,X8))&state(X2,X9))&be(X2,X9,X8,X8)))))))))))&(![X12]:(~actual_world(X12)|(![X13]:(![X14]:(![X15]:(![X16]:(![X17]:(![X18]:(![X19]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X12,X13,X20)|~jules_forename(X12,X13))|~forename(X12,X13))|~of(X12,X14,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X14))|~forename(X12,X14))|~of(X12,X16,X15))|~man(X12,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X16))|~forename(X12,X16))|~proposition(X12,X18))|~agent(X12,X17,X15))|~theme(X12,X17,X18))|~event(X12,X17))|~present(X12,X17))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X17))|~accessible_world(X12,X18))|(?[X24]:(man(X18,X24)&(![X25]:(((~event(X18,X25)|~agent(X18,X25,X24))|~present(X18,X25))|~smoke(X18,X25))))))|~of(X12,X19,X20))|~man(X12,X20))|~jules_forename(X12,X19))|~forename(X12,X19))|~man(X12,X20))|~state(X12,X21))|~be(X12,X21,X20,X20))|~proposition(X12,X23))|~agent(X12,X22,X15))|~theme(X12,X22,X23))|~event(X12,X22))|~present(X12,X22))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X22))|~accessible_world(X12,X23))|(![X26]:(((~event(X23,X26)|~agent(X23,X26,X20))|~present(X23,X26))|~smoke(X23,X26)))))))))))))))))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c37])).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c40,negated_conjecture,(![X10]:(![X12]:(![X13]:(![X14]:(![X15]:(![X16]:(![X17]:(![X18]:(![X19]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X25]:(![X26]:((actual_world(skolem0001)&((((((((((((((((((of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)&man(skolem0001,skolem0002))&vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003))&forename(skolem0001,skolem0003))&proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005))&agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002))&theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005))&event(skolem0001,skolem0004))&present(skolem0001,skolem0004))&think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004))&accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005))&(~man(skolem0005,X10)|(((event(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10))&agent(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10),X10))&present(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10)))&smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10)))))&of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007))&man(skolem0001,skolem0007))&jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006))&forename(skolem0001,skolem0006))&man(skolem0001,skolem0007))&state(skolem0001,skolem0008))&be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)))&(~actual_world(X12)|((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X12,X13,X20)|~jules_forename(X12,X13))|~forename(X12,X13))|~of(X12,X14,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X14))|~forename(X12,X14))|~of(X12,X16,X15))|~man(X12,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X16))|~forename(X12,X16))|~proposition(X12,X18))|~agent(X12,X17,X15))|~theme(X12,X17,X18))|~event(X12,X17))|~present(X12,X17))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X17))|~accessible_world(X12,X18))|(man(X18,skolem0010(X12,X13,X14,X15,X16,X17,X18,X19,X20,X21,X22,X23))&(((~event(X18,X25)|~agent(X18,X25,skolem0010(X12,X13,X14,X15,X16,X17,X18,X19,X20,X21,X22,X23)))|~present(X18,X25))|~smoke(X18,X25))))|~of(X12,X19,X20))|~man(X12,X20))|~jules_forename(X12,X19))|~forename(X12,X19))|~man(X12,X20))|~state(X12,X21))|~be(X12,X21,X20,X20))|~proposition(X12,X23))|~agent(X12,X22,X15))|~theme(X12,X22,X23))|~event(X12,X22))|~present(X12,X22))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X22))|~accessible_world(X12,X23))|(((~event(X23,X26)|~agent(X23,X26,X20))|~present(X23,X26))|~smoke(X23,X26)))))))))))))))))))),inference(shift_quantors,[status(thm)],[fof(c39,negated_conjecture,((actual_world(skolem0001)&((((((((((((((((((of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)&man(skolem0001,skolem0002))&vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003))&forename(skolem0001,skolem0003))&proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005))&agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002))&theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005))&event(skolem0001,skolem0004))&present(skolem0001,skolem0004))&think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004))&accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005))&(![X10]:(~man(skolem0005,X10)|(((event(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10))&agent(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10),X10))&present(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10)))&smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10))))))&of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007))&man(skolem0001,skolem0007))&jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006))&forename(skolem0001,skolem0006))&man(skolem0001,skolem0007))&state(skolem0001,skolem0008))&be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)))&(![X12]:(~actual_world(X12)|(![X13]:(![X14]:(![X15]:(![X16]:(![X17]:(![X18]:(![X19]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X12,X13,X20)|~jules_forename(X12,X13))|~forename(X12,X13))|~of(X12,X14,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X14))|~forename(X12,X14))|~of(X12,X16,X15))|~man(X12,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X16))|~forename(X12,X16))|~proposition(X12,X18))|~agent(X12,X17,X15))|~theme(X12,X17,X18))|~event(X12,X17))|~present(X12,X17))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X17))|~accessible_world(X12,X18))|(man(X18,skolem0010(X12,X13,X14,X15,X16,X17,X18,X19,X20,X21,X22,X23))&(![X25]:(((~event(X18,X25)|~agent(X18,X25,skolem0010(X12,X13,X14,X15,X16,X17,X18,X19,X20,X21,X22,X23)))|~present(X18,X25))|~smoke(X18,X25)))))|~of(X12,X19,X20))|~man(X12,X20))|~jules_forename(X12,X19))|~forename(X12,X19))|~man(X12,X20))|~state(X12,X21))|~be(X12,X21,X20,X20))|~proposition(X12,X23))|~agent(X12,X22,X15))|~theme(X12,X22,X23))|~event(X12,X22))|~present(X12,X22))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X22))|~accessible_world(X12,X23))|(![X26]:(((~event(X23,X26)|~agent(X23,X26,X20))|~present(X23,X26))|~smoke(X23,X26)))))))))))))))))),inference(skolemize,[status(esa)],[c38])).])).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c41,negated_conjecture,(![X10]:(![X12]:(![X13]:(![X14]:(![X15]:(![X16]:(![X17]:(![X18]:(![X19]:(![X20]:(![X21]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X25]:(![X26]:((actual_world(skolem0001)&((((((((((((((((((of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)&man(skolem0001,skolem0002))&vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003))&forename(skolem0001,skolem0003))&proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005))&agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002))&theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005))&event(skolem0001,skolem0004))&present(skolem0001,skolem0004))&think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004))&accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005))&((((~man(skolem0005,X10)|event(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10)))&(~man(skolem0005,X10)|agent(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10),X10)))&(~man(skolem0005,X10)|present(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10))))&(~man(skolem0005,X10)|smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(X10)))))&of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007))&man(skolem0001,skolem0007))&jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006))&forename(skolem0001,skolem0006))&man(skolem0001,skolem0007))&state(skolem0001,skolem0008))&be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)))&((~actual_world(X12)|((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X12,X13,X20)|~jules_forename(X12,X13))|~forename(X12,X13))|~of(X12,X14,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X14))|~forename(X12,X14))|~of(X12,X16,X15))|~man(X12,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X16))|~forename(X12,X16))|~proposition(X12,X18))|~agent(X12,X17,X15))|~theme(X12,X17,X18))|~event(X12,X17))|~present(X12,X17))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X17))|~accessible_world(X12,X18))|man(X18,skolem0010(X12,X13,X14,X15,X16,X17,X18,X19,X20,X21,X22,X23)))|~of(X12,X19,X20))|~man(X12,X20))|~jules_forename(X12,X19))|~forename(X12,X19))|~man(X12,X20))|~state(X12,X21))|~be(X12,X21,X20,X20))|~proposition(X12,X23))|~agent(X12,X22,X15))|~theme(X12,X22,X23))|~event(X12,X22))|~present(X12,X22))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X22))|~accessible_world(X12,X23))|(((~event(X23,X26)|~agent(X23,X26,X20))|~present(X23,X26))|~smoke(X23,X26))))&(~actual_world(X12)|((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~of(X12,X13,X20)|~jules_forename(X12,X13))|~forename(X12,X13))|~of(X12,X14,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X14))|~forename(X12,X14))|~of(X12,X16,X15))|~man(X12,X15))|~vincent_forename(X12,X16))|~forename(X12,X16))|~proposition(X12,X18))|~agent(X12,X17,X15))|~theme(X12,X17,X18))|~event(X12,X17))|~present(X12,X17))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X17))|~accessible_world(X12,X18))|(((~event(X18,X25)|~agent(X18,X25,skolem0010(X12,X13,X14,X15,X16,X17,X18,X19,X20,X21,X22,X23)))|~present(X18,X25))|~smoke(X18,X25)))|~of(X12,X19,X20))|~man(X12,X20))|~jules_forename(X12,X19))|~forename(X12,X19))|~man(X12,X20))|~state(X12,X21))|~be(X12,X21,X20,X20))|~proposition(X12,X23))|~agent(X12,X22,X15))|~theme(X12,X22,X23))|~event(X12,X22))|~present(X12,X22))|~think_believe_consider(X12,X22))|~accessible_world(X12,X23))|(((~event(X23,X26)|~agent(X23,X26,X20))|~present(X23,X26))|~smoke(X23,X26))))))))))))))))))))),inference(distribute,[status(thm)],[c40])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c42,negated_conjecture,actual_world(skolem0001),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c60,negated_conjecture,jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c61,negated_conjecture,forename(skolem0001,skolem0006),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c45,negated_conjecture,vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c46,negated_conjecture,forename(skolem0001,skolem0003),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c44,negated_conjecture,man(skolem0001,skolem0002),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c47,negated_conjecture,proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c50,negated_conjecture,event(skolem0001,skolem0004),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c51,negated_conjecture,present(skolem0001,skolem0004),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c52,negated_conjecture,think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c53,negated_conjecture,accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c59,negated_conjecture,man(skolem0001,skolem0007),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c63,negated_conjecture,state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c58,negated_conjecture,of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c43,negated_conjecture,of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c48,negated_conjecture,agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c49,negated_conjecture,theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c54,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0005,X397)|event(skolem0005,skolem0009(X397)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(ax49,axiom,(![U]:(![V]:(![W]:((accessible_world(V,W)&man(V,U))=>man(W,U))))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', ax49)).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c134,plain,(![U]:(![V]:(![W]:((~accessible_world(V,W)|~man(V,U))|man(W,U))))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[ax49])).
% 5.04/5.20 fof(c135,plain,(![X102]:(![X103]:(![X104]:((~accessible_world(X103,X104)|~man(X103,X102))|man(X104,X102))))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c134])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c136,plain,~accessible_world(X621,X619)|~man(X621,X620)|man(X619,X620),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c135])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c654,plain,~accessible_world(skolem0001,X666)|man(X666,skolem0007),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c136, c59])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c684,plain,man(skolem0005,skolem0007),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c654, c53])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c686,plain,event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c684, c54])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c56,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0005,X398)|present(skolem0005,skolem0009(X398)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c685,plain,present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c684, c56])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c57,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0005,X403)|smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(X403)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c690,plain,smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c684, c57])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c55,negated_conjecture,~man(skolem0005,X486)|agent(skolem0005,skolem0009(X486),X486),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c688,plain,agent(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007),skolem0007),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c684, c55])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c64,negated_conjecture,be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c65,negated_conjecture,~actual_world(X500)|~of(X500,X498,X495)|~jules_forename(X500,X498)|~forename(X500,X498)|~of(X500,X501,X506)|~vincent_forename(X500,X501)|~forename(X500,X501)|~of(X500,X505,X506)|~man(X500,X506)|~vincent_forename(X500,X505)|~forename(X500,X505)|~proposition(X500,X496)|~agent(X500,X497,X506)|~theme(X500,X497,X496)|~event(X500,X497)|~present(X500,X497)|~think_believe_consider(X500,X497)|~accessible_world(X500,X496)|man(X496,skolem0010(X500,X498,X501,X506,X505,X497,X496,X502,X495,X499,X504,X494))|~of(X500,X502,X495)|~man(X500,X495)|~jules_forename(X500,X502)|~forename(X500,X502)|~man(X500,X495)|~state(X500,X499)|~be(X500,X499,X495,X495)|~proposition(X500,X494)|~agent(X500,X504,X506)|~theme(X500,X504,X494)|~event(X500,X504)|~present(X500,X504)|~think_believe_consider(X500,X504)|~accessible_world(X500,X494)|~event(X494,X503)|~agent(X494,X503,X495)|~present(X494,X503)|~smoke(X494,X503),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c530,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1078,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1078)|~forename(skolem0001,X1078)|~of(skolem0001,X1077,X1076)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1077)|~forename(skolem0001,X1077)|~of(skolem0001,X1085,X1076)|~man(skolem0001,X1076)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1085)|~forename(skolem0001,X1085)|~proposition(skolem0001,X1082)|~agent(skolem0001,X1083,X1076)|~theme(skolem0001,X1083,X1082)|~event(skolem0001,X1083)|~present(skolem0001,X1083)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1083)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,X1082)|man(X1082,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1078,X1077,X1076,X1085,X1083,X1082,X1079,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1081,X1084))|~of(skolem0001,X1079,skolem0007)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1079)|~forename(skolem0001,X1079)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~proposition(skolem0001,X1084)|~agent(skolem0001,X1081,X1076)|~theme(skolem0001,X1081,X1084)|~event(skolem0001,X1081)|~present(skolem0001,X1081)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1081)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,X1084)|~event(X1084,X1080)|~agent(X1084,X1080,skolem0007)|~present(X1084,X1080)|~smoke(X1084,X1080),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c65, c64])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1093,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1413,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1413)|~forename(skolem0001,X1413)|~of(skolem0001,X1410,X1409)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1410)|~forename(skolem0001,X1410)|~of(skolem0001,X1411,X1409)|~man(skolem0001,X1409)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1411)|~forename(skolem0001,X1411)|~proposition(skolem0001,X1412)|~agent(skolem0001,X1415,X1409)|~theme(skolem0001,X1415,X1412)|~event(skolem0001,X1415)|~present(skolem0001,X1415)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1415)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,X1412)|man(X1412,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1413,X1410,X1409,X1411,X1415,X1412,X1414,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1416,skolem0005))|~of(skolem0001,X1414,skolem0007)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1414)|~forename(skolem0001,X1414)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,X1416,X1409)|~theme(skolem0001,X1416,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,X1416)|~present(skolem0001,X1416)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1416)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007))|~present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007))|~smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c530, c688])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1293,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1485,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1485)|~forename(skolem0001,X1485)|~of(skolem0001,X1486,X1490)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1486)|~forename(skolem0001,X1486)|~of(skolem0001,X1488,X1490)|~man(skolem0001,X1490)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1488)|~forename(skolem0001,X1488)|~proposition(skolem0001,X1489)|~agent(skolem0001,X1487,X1490)|~theme(skolem0001,X1487,X1489)|~event(skolem0001,X1487)|~present(skolem0001,X1487)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1487)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,X1489)|man(X1489,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1485,X1486,X1490,X1488,X1487,X1489,X1484,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1491,skolem0005))|~of(skolem0001,X1484,skolem0007)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1484)|~forename(skolem0001,X1484)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,X1491,X1490)|~theme(skolem0001,X1491,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,X1491)|~present(skolem0001,X1491)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1491)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007))|~present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1093, c690])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1315,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1571,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1571)|~forename(skolem0001,X1571)|~of(skolem0001,X1568,X1570)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1568)|~forename(skolem0001,X1568)|~of(skolem0001,X1565,X1570)|~man(skolem0001,X1570)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1565)|~forename(skolem0001,X1565)|~proposition(skolem0001,X1569)|~agent(skolem0001,X1567,X1570)|~theme(skolem0001,X1567,X1569)|~event(skolem0001,X1567)|~present(skolem0001,X1567)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1567)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,X1569)|man(X1569,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1571,X1568,X1570,X1565,X1567,X1569,X1566,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1572,skolem0005))|~of(skolem0001,X1566,skolem0007)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1566)|~forename(skolem0001,X1566)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,X1572,X1570)|~theme(skolem0001,X1572,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,X1572)|~present(skolem0001,X1572)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1572)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1293, c685])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1330,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1590,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1590)|~forename(skolem0001,X1590)|~of(skolem0001,X1589,X1585)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1589)|~forename(skolem0001,X1589)|~of(skolem0001,X1583,X1585)|~man(skolem0001,X1585)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1583)|~forename(skolem0001,X1583)|~proposition(skolem0001,X1586)|~agent(skolem0001,X1588,X1585)|~theme(skolem0001,X1588,X1586)|~event(skolem0001,X1588)|~present(skolem0001,X1588)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1588)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,X1586)|man(X1586,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1590,X1589,X1585,X1583,X1588,X1586,X1584,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1587,skolem0005))|~of(skolem0001,X1584,skolem0007)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1584)|~forename(skolem0001,X1584)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,X1587,X1585)|~theme(skolem0001,X1587,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,X1587)|~present(skolem0001,X1587)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1587)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1315, c686])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1332,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1596,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1596)|~forename(skolem0001,X1596)|~of(skolem0001,X1593,X1592)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1593)|~forename(skolem0001,X1593)|~of(skolem0001,X1594,X1592)|~man(skolem0001,X1592)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1594)|~forename(skolem0001,X1594)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,X1591,X1592)|~theme(skolem0001,X1591,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,X1591)|~present(skolem0001,X1591)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1591)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1596,X1593,X1592,X1594,X1591,skolem0005,X1595,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1591,skolem0005))|~of(skolem0001,X1595,skolem0007)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1595)|~forename(skolem0001,X1595)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(factor,[status(thm)],[c1330])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1334,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1604,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1604)|~forename(skolem0001,X1604)|~of(skolem0001,X1607,X1605)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1607)|~forename(skolem0001,X1607)|~of(skolem0001,X1603,X1605)|~man(skolem0001,X1605)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1603)|~forename(skolem0001,X1603)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,X1606,X1605)|~theme(skolem0001,X1606,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,X1606)|~present(skolem0001,X1606)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,X1606)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1604,X1607,X1605,X1603,X1606,skolem0005,X1604,skolem0007,skolem0008,X1606,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(factor,[status(thm)],[c1332])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1339,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1611,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1611)|~forename(skolem0001,X1611)|~of(skolem0001,X1609,X1610)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1609)|~forename(skolem0001,X1609)|~of(skolem0001,X1608,X1610)|~man(skolem0001,X1610)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1608)|~forename(skolem0001,X1608)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,X1610)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1611,X1609,X1610,X1608,skolem0004,skolem0005,X1611,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1334, c49])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1340,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1612,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1612)|~forename(skolem0001,X1612)|~of(skolem0001,X1614,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1614)|~forename(skolem0001,X1614)|~of(skolem0001,X1613,skolem0002)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1613)|~forename(skolem0001,X1613)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1612,X1614,skolem0002,X1613,skolem0004,skolem0005,X1612,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1339, c48])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1341,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1615,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1615)|~forename(skolem0001,X1615)|~of(skolem0001,X1616,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,X1616)|~forename(skolem0001,X1616)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1615,X1616,skolem0002,X1616,skolem0004,skolem0005,X1615,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(factor,[status(thm)],[c1340])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1343,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,X1617,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,X1617)|~forename(skolem0001,X1617)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,X1617,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,X1617,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1341, c43])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1344,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1343, c58])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1348,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1344, c63])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1349,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1348, c59])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1350,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1349, c53])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1351,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1350, c52])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1352,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1351, c51])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1355,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1352, c50])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1356,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1355, c47])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1357,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1356, c44])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1358,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1357, c46])).
% 5.04/5.20 cnf(c1359,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1358, c45])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1361,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1359, c61])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1362,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1361, c60])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1363,plain,man(skolem0005,skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1362, c42])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1365,plain,event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1363, c54])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1364,plain,present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1363, c56])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1369,plain,smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005))),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1363, c57])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c66,negated_conjecture,~actual_world(X515)|~of(X515,X513,X510)|~jules_forename(X515,X513)|~forename(X515,X513)|~of(X515,X516,X522)|~vincent_forename(X515,X516)|~forename(X515,X516)|~of(X515,X521,X522)|~man(X515,X522)|~vincent_forename(X515,X521)|~forename(X515,X521)|~proposition(X515,X511)|~agent(X515,X512,X522)|~theme(X515,X512,X511)|~event(X515,X512)|~present(X515,X512)|~think_believe_consider(X515,X512)|~accessible_world(X515,X511)|~event(X511,X519)|~agent(X511,X519,skolem0010(X515,X513,X516,X522,X521,X512,X511,X517,X510,X514,X520,X509))|~present(X511,X519)|~smoke(X511,X519)|~of(X515,X517,X510)|~man(X515,X510)|~jules_forename(X515,X517)|~forename(X515,X517)|~man(X515,X510)|~state(X515,X514)|~be(X515,X514,X510,X510)|~proposition(X515,X509)|~agent(X515,X520,X522)|~theme(X515,X520,X509)|~event(X515,X520)|~present(X515,X520)|~think_believe_consider(X515,X520)|~accessible_world(X515,X509)|~event(X509,X518)|~agent(X509,X518,X510)|~present(X509,X518)|~smoke(X509,X518),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c41])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1367,plain,agent(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1363, c55])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1452,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)))|~present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)))|~smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)|~event(skolem0005,X1949)|~agent(skolem0005,X1949,skolem0007)|~present(skolem0005,X1949)|~smoke(skolem0005,X1949),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1367, c66])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1539,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)))|~present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)|~event(skolem0005,X2010)|~agent(skolem0005,X2010,skolem0007)|~present(skolem0005,X2010)|~smoke(skolem0005,X2010),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1452, c1369])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1553,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0010(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0003,skolem0002,skolem0003,skolem0004,skolem0005,skolem0006,skolem0007,skolem0008,skolem0004,skolem0005)))|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)|~event(skolem0005,X2011)|~agent(skolem0005,X2011,skolem0007)|~present(skolem0005,X2011)|~smoke(skolem0005,X2011),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1539, c1364])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1555,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~be(skolem0001,skolem0008,skolem0007,skolem0007)|~event(skolem0005,X2012)|~agent(skolem0005,X2012,skolem0007)|~present(skolem0005,X2012)|~smoke(skolem0005,X2012),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1553, c1365])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1556,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~event(skolem0005,X2013)|~agent(skolem0005,X2013,skolem0007)|~present(skolem0005,X2013)|~smoke(skolem0005,X2013),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1555, c64])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1557,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007))|~present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007))|~smoke(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1556, c688])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1558,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007))|~present(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1557, c690])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1559,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008)|~event(skolem0005,skolem0009(skolem0007)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1558, c685])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1560,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~theme(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1559, c686])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1561,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~agent(skolem0001,skolem0004,skolem0002)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1560, c49])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1562,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0003,skolem0002)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1561, c48])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1563,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~of(skolem0001,skolem0006,skolem0007)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1562, c43])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1564,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007)|~state(skolem0001,skolem0008),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1563, c58])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1565,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0007),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1564, c63])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1566,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~accessible_world(skolem0001,skolem0005),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1565, c59])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1567,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~think_believe_consider(skolem0001,skolem0004),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1566, c53])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1568,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004)|~present(skolem0001,skolem0004),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1567, c52])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1569,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005)|~event(skolem0001,skolem0004),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1568, c51])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1570,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002)|~proposition(skolem0001,skolem0005),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1569, c50])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1571,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~man(skolem0001,skolem0002),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1570, c47])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1572,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0003),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1571, c44])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1573,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~vincent_forename(skolem0001,skolem0003),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1572, c46])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1574,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006)|~forename(skolem0001,skolem0006),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1573, c45])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1575,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001)|~jules_forename(skolem0001,skolem0006),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1574, c61])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1576,plain,~actual_world(skolem0001),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1575, c60])).
% 5.04/5.21 cnf(c1577,plain,$false,inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c1576, c42])).
% 5.04/5.21 % SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 5.04/5.21
% 5.04/5.21 % Initial clauses : 135
% 5.04/5.21 % Processed clauses : 1099
% 5.04/5.21 % Factors computed : 70
% 5.04/5.21 % Resolvents computed: 1223
% 5.04/5.21 % Tautologies deleted: 3
% 5.04/5.21 % Forward subsumed : 325
% 5.04/5.21 % Backward subsumed : 92
% 5.04/5.21 % -------- CPU Time ---------
% 5.04/5.21 % User time : 4.852 s
% 5.04/5.21 % System time : 0.016 s
% 5.04/5.21 % Total time : 4.868 s
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------