TSTP Solution File: NLP251-1 by Metis---2.4
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Metis---2.4
% Problem : NLP251-1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : metis --show proof --show saturation %s
% Computer : n024.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 600s
% DateTime : Mon Jul 18 03:16:45 EDT 2022
% Result : Unsatisfiable 1.14s 1.36s
% Output : CNFRefutation 1.20s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : Refutation
% Derivation depth : 54
% Number of leaves : 25
% Syntax : Number of clauses : 104 ( 33 unt; 0 nHn; 95 RR)
% Number of literals : 869 ( 0 equ; 797 neg)
% Maximal clause size : 41 ( 8 avg)
% Maximal term depth : 3 ( 1 avg)
% Number of predicates : 17 ( 16 usr; 1 prp; 0-4 aty)
% Number of functors : 10 ( 10 usr; 8 con; 0-1 aty)
% Number of variables : 231 ( 12 sgn)
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
cnf(clause52,axiom,
( ~ accessible_world(U,V)
| ~ man(U,W)
| man(V,W) ) ).
cnf(clause72,negated_conjecture,
actual_world(skc8) ).
cnf(clause73,negated_conjecture,
man(skc8,skc15) ).
cnf(clause74,negated_conjecture,
forename(skc8,skc14) ).
cnf(clause75,negated_conjecture,
vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) ).
cnf(clause76,negated_conjecture,
event(skc8,skc13) ).
cnf(clause77,negated_conjecture,
present(skc8,skc13) ).
cnf(clause78,negated_conjecture,
think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13) ).
cnf(clause79,negated_conjecture,
jules_forename(skc8,skc11) ).
cnf(clause80,negated_conjecture,
forename(skc8,skc11) ).
cnf(clause81,negated_conjecture,
man(skc8,skc10) ).
cnf(clause82,negated_conjecture,
state(skc8,skc9) ).
cnf(clause83,negated_conjecture,
accessible_world(skc8,skc12) ).
cnf(clause84,negated_conjecture,
proposition(skc8,skc12) ).
cnf(clause85,negated_conjecture,
of(skc8,skc14,skc15) ).
cnf(clause86,negated_conjecture,
agent(skc8,skc13,skc15) ).
cnf(clause87,negated_conjecture,
theme(skc8,skc13,skc12) ).
cnf(clause88,negated_conjecture,
of(skc8,skc11,skc10) ).
cnf(clause89,negated_conjecture,
be(skc8,skc9,skc10,skc10) ).
cnf(clause90,negated_conjecture,
( ~ man(skc12,U)
| smoke(skc12,skf2(V)) ) ).
cnf(clause91,negated_conjecture,
( ~ man(skc12,U)
| present(skc12,skf2(V)) ) ).
cnf(clause92,negated_conjecture,
( ~ man(skc12,U)
| event(skc12,skf2(V)) ) ).
cnf(clause93,negated_conjecture,
( ~ man(skc12,U)
| agent(skc12,skf2(U),U) ) ).
cnf(clause94,negated_conjecture,
( ~ proposition(U,V)
| ~ accessible_world(U,V)
| ~ think_believe_consider(U,W)
| ~ present(U,W)
| ~ event(U,W)
| ~ theme(U,W,V)
| ~ vincent_forename(U,X)
| ~ forename(U,X)
| ~ agent(U,W,Y)
| ~ man(U,Y)
| ~ of(U,X,Y)
| ~ state(U,Z)
| ~ man(U,X1)
| ~ be(U,Z,X1,X1)
| ~ forename(U,X2)
| ~ jules_forename(U,X2)
| ~ of(U,X2,X1)
| ~ accessible_world(U,X3)
| ~ proposition(U,X3)
| ~ jules_forename(U,X4)
| ~ forename(U,X4)
| ~ smoke(X3,X5)
| ~ present(X3,X5)
| ~ agent(X3,X5,X6)
| ~ event(X3,X5)
| ~ man(U,X6)
| ~ of(U,X4,X6)
| ~ vincent_forename(U,X7)
| ~ forename(U,X7)
| ~ agent(U,X8,X9)
| ~ man(U,X9)
| ~ of(U,X7,X9)
| ~ theme(U,X8,X3)
| ~ event(U,X8)
| ~ present(U,X8)
| ~ think_believe_consider(U,X8)
| ~ actual_world(U)
| man(V,skf4(V)) ) ).
cnf(clause95,negated_conjecture,
( ~ proposition(U,V)
| ~ accessible_world(U,V)
| ~ smoke(V,W)
| ~ present(V,W)
| ~ agent(V,W,skf4(V))
| ~ event(V,W)
| ~ think_believe_consider(U,X)
| ~ present(U,X)
| ~ event(U,X)
| ~ theme(U,X,V)
| ~ vincent_forename(U,Y)
| ~ forename(U,Y)
| ~ agent(U,X,Z)
| ~ man(U,Z)
| ~ of(U,Y,Z)
| ~ state(U,X1)
| ~ man(U,X2)
| ~ be(U,X1,X2,X2)
| ~ forename(U,X3)
| ~ jules_forename(U,X3)
| ~ of(U,X3,X2)
| ~ accessible_world(U,X4)
| ~ proposition(U,X4)
| ~ jules_forename(U,X5)
| ~ forename(U,X5)
| ~ smoke(X4,X6)
| ~ present(X4,X6)
| ~ agent(X4,X6,X7)
| ~ event(X4,X6)
| ~ man(U,X7)
| ~ of(U,X5,X7)
| ~ vincent_forename(U,X8)
| ~ forename(U,X8)
| ~ agent(U,X9,X10)
| ~ man(U,X10)
| ~ of(U,X8,X10)
| ~ theme(U,X9,X4)
| ~ event(U,X9)
| ~ present(U,X9)
| ~ think_believe_consider(U,X9)
| ~ actual_world(U) ) ).
cnf(refute_0_0,plain,
( ~ man(skc12,skc10)
| agent(skc12,skf2(skc10),skc10) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause93:[bind(U,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_1,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_213)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| man(X_213,skc10) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause52:[bind(U,$fot(skc8)),bind(V,$fot(X_213)),bind(W,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_2,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_213)
| man(X_213,skc10) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc8,skc10) )],[clause81,refute_0_1]) ).
cnf(refute_0_3,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,skc12)
| man(skc12,skc10) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_2:[bind(X_213,$fot(skc12))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_4,plain,
man(skc12,skc10),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( accessible_world(skc8,skc12) )],[clause83,refute_0_3]) ).
cnf(refute_0_5,plain,
agent(skc12,skf2(skc10),skc10),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc12,skc10) )],[refute_0_4,refute_0_0]) ).
cnf(refute_0_6,plain,
( ~ man(skc12,skf4(skc12))
| agent(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)),skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause93:[bind(U,$fot(skf4(skc12)))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_7,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_798)
| ~ actual_world(skc8)
| ~ agent(X_798,X_800,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_803,X_804)
| ~ be(skc8,skc9,skc10,skc10)
| ~ event(X_798,X_800)
| ~ event(skc8,X_803)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_802)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ man(skc8,X_804)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_799,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_802,X_804)
| ~ present(X_798,X_800)
| ~ present(skc8,X_803)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_798)
| ~ smoke(X_798,X_800)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_803,X_798)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_803)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_802)
| man(X_798,skf4(X_798)) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause94:[bind(U,$fot(skc8)),bind(V,$fot(X_798)),bind(W,$fot(X_803)),bind(X,$fot(X_802)),bind(X1,$fot(skc10)),bind(X2,$fot(X_799)),bind(X3,$fot(X_798)),bind(X4,$fot(X_799)),bind(X5,$fot(X_800)),bind(X6,$fot(skc10)),bind(X7,$fot(X_802)),bind(X8,$fot(X_803)),bind(X9,$fot(X_804)),bind(Y,$fot(X_804)),bind(Z,$fot(skc9))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_8,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_798)
| ~ actual_world(skc8)
| ~ agent(X_798,X_800,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_803,X_804)
| ~ event(X_798,X_800)
| ~ event(skc8,X_803)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_802)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ man(skc8,X_804)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_799,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_802,X_804)
| ~ present(X_798,X_800)
| ~ present(skc8,X_803)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_798)
| ~ smoke(X_798,X_800)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_803,X_798)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_803)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_802)
| man(X_798,skf4(X_798)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( be(skc8,skc9,skc10,skc10) )],[clause89,refute_0_7]) ).
cnf(refute_0_9,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_798)
| ~ agent(X_798,X_800,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_803,X_804)
| ~ event(X_798,X_800)
| ~ event(skc8,X_803)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_802)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ man(skc8,X_804)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_799,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_802,X_804)
| ~ present(X_798,X_800)
| ~ present(skc8,X_803)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_798)
| ~ smoke(X_798,X_800)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_803,X_798)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_803)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_802)
| man(X_798,skf4(X_798)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( actual_world(skc8) )],[clause72,refute_0_8]) ).
cnf(refute_0_10,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_798)
| ~ agent(X_798,X_800,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_803,X_804)
| ~ event(X_798,X_800)
| ~ event(skc8,X_803)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_802)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ man(skc8,X_804)
| ~ of(skc8,X_799,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_802,X_804)
| ~ present(X_798,X_800)
| ~ present(skc8,X_803)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_798)
| ~ smoke(X_798,X_800)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_803,X_798)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_803)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_802)
| man(X_798,skf4(X_798)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc8,skc10) )],[clause81,refute_0_9]) ).
cnf(refute_0_11,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_798)
| ~ agent(X_798,X_800,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_803,X_804)
| ~ event(X_798,X_800)
| ~ event(skc8,X_803)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_802)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_799)
| ~ man(skc8,X_804)
| ~ of(skc8,X_799,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_802,X_804)
| ~ present(X_798,X_800)
| ~ present(skc8,X_803)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_798)
| ~ smoke(X_798,X_800)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_803,X_798)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_803)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_802)
| man(X_798,skf4(X_798)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( state(skc8,skc9) )],[clause82,refute_0_10]) ).
cnf(refute_0_12,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,skc12)
| ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ event(skc8,skc13)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ theme(skc8,skc13,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_11:[bind(X_798,$fot(skc12)),bind(X_799,$fot(X_807)),bind(X_800,$fot(X_808)),bind(X_802,$fot(X_809)),bind(X_803,$fot(skc13)),bind(X_804,$fot(X_811))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_13,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,skc12)
| ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ event(skc8,skc13)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( theme(skc8,skc13,skc12) )],[clause87,refute_0_12]) ).
cnf(refute_0_14,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ event(skc8,skc13)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( accessible_world(skc8,skc12) )],[clause83,refute_0_13]) ).
cnf(refute_0_15,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( event(skc8,skc13) )],[clause76,refute_0_14]) ).
cnf(refute_0_16,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( present(skc8,skc13) )],[clause77,refute_0_15]) ).
cnf(refute_0_17,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( proposition(skc8,skc12) )],[clause84,refute_0_16]) ).
cnf(refute_0_18,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_808,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_811)
| ~ event(skc12,X_808)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_809)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_807)
| ~ man(skc8,X_811)
| ~ of(skc8,X_807,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_809,X_811)
| ~ present(skc12,X_808)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_808)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_809)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13) )],[clause78,refute_0_17]) ).
cnf(refute_0_19,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_813,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,skc15)
| ~ event(skc12,X_813)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ forename(skc8,skc14)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_812,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,skc14,skc15)
| ~ present(skc12,X_813)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_813)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_18:[bind(X_807,$fot(X_812)),bind(X_808,$fot(X_813)),bind(X_809,$fot(skc14)),bind(X_811,$fot(skc15))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_20,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_813,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,skc15)
| ~ event(skc12,X_813)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ forename(skc8,skc14)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_812,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_813)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_813)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( of(skc8,skc14,skc15) )],[clause85,refute_0_19]) ).
cnf(refute_0_21,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_813,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_813)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ forename(skc8,skc14)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_812,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_813)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_813)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( agent(skc8,skc13,skc15) )],[clause86,refute_0_20]) ).
cnf(refute_0_22,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_813,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_813)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_812,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_813)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_813)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( forename(skc8,skc14) )],[clause74,refute_0_21]) ).
cnf(refute_0_23,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_813,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_813)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ of(skc8,X_812,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_813)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_813)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc8,skc15) )],[clause73,refute_0_22]) ).
cnf(refute_0_24,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_813,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_813)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_812)
| ~ of(skc8,X_812,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_813)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_813)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) )],[clause75,refute_0_23]) ).
cnf(refute_0_25,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,skf2(skc10),skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ of(skc8,X_816,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_24:[bind(X_812,$fot(X_816)),bind(X_813,$fot(skf2(skc10)))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_26,plain,
( ~ event(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ of(skc8,X_816,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( agent(skc12,skf2(skc10),skc10) )],[refute_0_5,refute_0_25]) ).
cnf(refute_0_27,plain,
( ~ man(skc12,skc10)
| event(skc12,skf2(V)) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause92:[bind(U,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_28,plain,
event(skc12,skf2(V)),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc12,skc10) )],[refute_0_4,refute_0_27]) ).
cnf(refute_0_29,plain,
event(skc12,skf2(skc10)),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_28:[bind(V,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_30,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ of(skc8,X_816,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( event(skc12,skf2(skc10)) )],[refute_0_29,refute_0_26]) ).
cnf(refute_0_31,plain,
( ~ man(skc12,skc10)
| present(skc12,skf2(V)) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause91:[bind(U,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_32,plain,
present(skc12,skf2(V)),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc12,skc10) )],[refute_0_4,refute_0_31]) ).
cnf(refute_0_33,plain,
present(skc12,skf2(skc10)),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_32:[bind(V,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_34,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ of(skc8,X_816,skc10)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( present(skc12,skf2(skc10)) )],[refute_0_33,refute_0_30]) ).
cnf(refute_0_35,plain,
( ~ man(skc12,skc10)
| smoke(skc12,skf2(V)) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause90:[bind(U,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_36,plain,
smoke(skc12,skf2(V)),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc12,skc10) )],[refute_0_4,refute_0_35]) ).
cnf(refute_0_37,plain,
smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_36:[bind(V,$fot(skc10))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_38,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_816)
| ~ of(skc8,X_816,skc10)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)) )],[refute_0_37,refute_0_34]) ).
cnf(refute_0_39,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,skc11)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,skc11)
| ~ of(skc8,skc11,skc10)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_38:[bind(X_816,$fot(skc11))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_40,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,skc11)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,skc11)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( of(skc8,skc11,skc10) )],[clause88,refute_0_39]) ).
cnf(refute_0_41,plain,
( ~ jules_forename(skc8,skc11)
| man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( forename(skc8,skc11) )],[clause80,refute_0_40]) ).
cnf(refute_0_42,plain,
man(skc12,skf4(skc12)),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( jules_forename(skc8,skc11) )],[clause79,refute_0_41]) ).
cnf(refute_0_43,plain,
agent(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)),skf4(skc12)),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc12,skf4(skc12)) )],[refute_0_42,refute_0_6]) ).
cnf(refute_0_44,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ actual_world(skc8)
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1407,skf4(X_1409))
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1411,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1413,X_1415)
| ~ be(skc8,skc9,skc10,skc10)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1414)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1415)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1410,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1414,X_1415)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1413,X_1409)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1414) ),
inference(subst,[],[clause95:[bind(U,$fot(skc8)),bind(V,$fot(X_1409)),bind(W,$fot(X_1407)),bind(X,$fot(X_1413)),bind(X1,$fot(skc9)),bind(X10,$fot(X_1415)),bind(X2,$fot(skc10)),bind(X3,$fot(X_1410)),bind(X4,$fot(X_1409)),bind(X5,$fot(X_1410)),bind(X6,$fot(X_1411)),bind(X7,$fot(skc10)),bind(X8,$fot(X_1414)),bind(X9,$fot(X_1413)),bind(Y,$fot(X_1414)),bind(Z,$fot(X_1415))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_45,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ actual_world(skc8)
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1407,skf4(X_1409))
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1411,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1413,X_1415)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1414)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1415)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1410,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1414,X_1415)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1413,X_1409)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1414) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( be(skc8,skc9,skc10,skc10) )],[clause89,refute_0_44]) ).
cnf(refute_0_46,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1407,skf4(X_1409))
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1411,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1413,X_1415)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1414)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1415)
| ~ man(skc8,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1410,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1414,X_1415)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1413,X_1409)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1414) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( actual_world(skc8) )],[clause72,refute_0_45]) ).
cnf(refute_0_47,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1407,skf4(X_1409))
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1411,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1413,X_1415)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1414)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1415)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1410,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1414,X_1415)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ state(skc8,skc9)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1413,X_1409)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1414) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc8,skc10) )],[clause81,refute_0_46]) ).
cnf(refute_0_48,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1407,skf4(X_1409))
| ~ agent(X_1409,X_1411,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1413,X_1415)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ event(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1414)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1410)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1415)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1410,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1414,X_1415)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ present(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ proposition(skc8,X_1409)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1407)
| ~ smoke(X_1409,X_1411)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1413,X_1409)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1413)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1414) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( state(skc8,skc9) )],[clause82,refute_0_47]) ).
cnf(refute_0_49,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,skc12)
| ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)),skf4(skc12))
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_48:[bind(X_1407,$fot(skf2(skf4(skc12)))),bind(X_1409,$fot(skc12)),bind(X_1410,$fot(X_1428)),bind(X_1411,$fot(X_1429)),bind(X_1413,$fot(X_1430)),bind(X_1414,$fot(X_1431)),bind(X_1415,$fot(X_1432))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_50,plain,
( ~ accessible_world(skc8,skc12)
| ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( agent(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)),skf4(skc12)) )],[refute_0_43,refute_0_49]) ).
cnf(refute_0_51,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( accessible_world(skc8,skc12) )],[clause83,refute_0_50]) ).
cnf(refute_0_52,plain,
event(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12))),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_28:[bind(V,$fot(skf4(skc12)))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_53,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( event(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12))) )],[refute_0_52,refute_0_51]) ).
cnf(refute_0_54,plain,
present(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12))),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_32:[bind(V,$fot(skf4(skc12)))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_55,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ proposition(skc8,skc12)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( present(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12))) )],[refute_0_54,refute_0_53]) ).
cnf(refute_0_56,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12)))
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( proposition(skc8,skc12) )],[clause84,refute_0_55]) ).
cnf(refute_0_57,plain,
smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12))),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_36:[bind(V,$fot(skf4(skc12)))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_58,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1429,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,X_1430,X_1432)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ event(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1431)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1428)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1432)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1428,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1431,X_1432)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ present(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1429)
| ~ theme(skc8,X_1430,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,X_1430)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1431) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( smoke(skc12,skf2(skf4(skc12))) )],[refute_0_57,refute_0_56]) ).
cnf(refute_0_59,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1434,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_1437)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ event(skc8,skc13)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1436)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1437)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1433,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1436,X_1437)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ theme(skc8,skc13,skc12)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1436) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_58:[bind(X_1428,$fot(X_1433)),bind(X_1429,$fot(X_1434)),bind(X_1430,$fot(skc13)),bind(X_1431,$fot(X_1436)),bind(X_1432,$fot(X_1437))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_60,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1434,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_1437)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ event(skc8,skc13)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1436)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1437)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1433,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1436,X_1437)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1436) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( theme(skc8,skc13,skc12) )],[clause87,refute_0_59]) ).
cnf(refute_0_61,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1434,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_1437)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1436)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1437)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1433,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1436,X_1437)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ present(skc8,skc13)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1436) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( event(skc8,skc13) )],[clause76,refute_0_60]) ).
cnf(refute_0_62,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1434,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_1437)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1436)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1437)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1433,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1436,X_1437)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1436) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( present(skc8,skc13) )],[clause77,refute_0_61]) ).
cnf(refute_0_63,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1434,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,X_1437)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1436)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1433)
| ~ man(skc8,X_1437)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1433,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1436,X_1437)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1434)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,X_1436) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( think_believe_consider(skc8,skc13) )],[clause78,refute_0_62]) ).
cnf(refute_0_64,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1439,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,skc15)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ forename(skc8,skc14)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1438,skc10)
| ~ of(skc8,skc14,skc15)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_63:[bind(X_1433,$fot(X_1438)),bind(X_1434,$fot(X_1439)),bind(X_1436,$fot(skc14)),bind(X_1437,$fot(skc15))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_65,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1439,skc10)
| ~ agent(skc8,skc13,skc15)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ forename(skc8,skc14)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1438,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( of(skc8,skc14,skc15) )],[clause85,refute_0_64]) ).
cnf(refute_0_66,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1439,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ forename(skc8,skc14)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1438,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( agent(skc8,skc13,skc15) )],[clause86,refute_0_65]) ).
cnf(refute_0_67,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1439,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ man(skc8,skc15)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1438,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( forename(skc8,skc14) )],[clause74,refute_0_66]) ).
cnf(refute_0_68,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1439,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1438,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( man(skc8,skc15) )],[clause73,refute_0_67]) ).
cnf(refute_0_69,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,X_1439,skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1438)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1438,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,X_1439)
| ~ smoke(skc12,X_1439) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( vincent_forename(skc8,skc14) )],[clause75,refute_0_68]) ).
cnf(refute_0_70,plain,
( ~ agent(skc12,skf2(skc10),skc10)
| ~ event(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1442,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_69:[bind(X_1438,$fot(X_1442)),bind(X_1439,$fot(skf2(skc10)))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_71,plain,
( ~ event(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1442,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( agent(skc12,skf2(skc10),skc10) )],[refute_0_5,refute_0_70]) ).
cnf(refute_0_72,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1442,skc10)
| ~ present(skc12,skf2(skc10))
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( event(skc12,skf2(skc10)) )],[refute_0_29,refute_0_71]) ).
cnf(refute_0_73,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1442,skc10)
| ~ smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( present(skc12,skf2(skc10)) )],[refute_0_33,refute_0_72]) ).
cnf(refute_0_74,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,X_1442)
| ~ of(skc8,X_1442,skc10) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( smoke(skc12,skf2(skc10)) )],[refute_0_37,refute_0_73]) ).
cnf(refute_0_75,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,skc11)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,skc11)
| ~ of(skc8,skc11,skc10) ),
inference(subst,[],[refute_0_74:[bind(X_1442,$fot(skc11))]]) ).
cnf(refute_0_76,plain,
( ~ forename(skc8,skc11)
| ~ jules_forename(skc8,skc11) ),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( of(skc8,skc11,skc10) )],[clause88,refute_0_75]) ).
cnf(refute_0_77,plain,
~ jules_forename(skc8,skc11),
inference(resolve,[$cnf( forename(skc8,skc11) )],[clause80,refute_0_76]) ).
cnf(refute_0_78,plain,
$false,
inference(resolve,[$cnf( jules_forename(skc8,skc11) )],[clause79,refute_0_77]) ).
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.03/0.11 % Problem : NLP251-1 : TPTP v8.1.0. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.03/0.11 % Command : metis --show proof --show saturation %s
% 0.11/0.32 % Computer : n024.cluster.edu
% 0.11/0.32 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.11/0.32 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.11/0.32 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.11/0.32 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.11/0.32 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.11/0.32 % WCLimit : 600
% 0.11/0.32 % DateTime : Fri Jul 1 07:52:30 EDT 2022
% 0.11/0.32 % CPUTime :
% 0.11/0.32 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
% 1.14/1.36 % SZS status Unsatisfiable for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% 1.14/1.36
% 1.14/1.36 % SZS output start CNFRefutation for /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p
% See solution above
% 1.20/1.37
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------