TSTP Solution File: NLP250-1 by Refute---2015

View Problem - Process Solution

%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File     : Refute---2015
% Problem  : NLP250-1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm  : none
% Format   : tptp:raw
% Command  : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s

% Computer : n010.star.cs.uiowa.edu
% Model    : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU      : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 2.40GHz
% Memory   : 16091.75MB
% OS       : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% DateTime : Thu Apr 14 01:28:37 EDT 2016

% Result   : Timeout 300.10s
% Output   : None 
% Verified : 
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax   : Number of formulae    : 0

% Comments : 
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----No solution output by system
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.00/0.03  % Problem  : NLP250-1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.00/0.04  % Command  : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s
% 0.02/0.23  % Computer : n010.star.cs.uiowa.edu
% 0.02/0.23  % Model    : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.02/0.23  % CPU      : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 @ 2.40GHz
% 0.02/0.23  % Memory   : 16091.75MB
% 0.02/0.23  % OS       : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64
% 0.02/0.23  % CPULimit : 300
% 0.02/0.23  % DateTime : Tue Apr  5 14:36:24 CDT 2016
% 0.02/0.23  % CPUTime  : 
% 6.30/5.84  > val it = (): unit
% 6.60/6.14  Trying to find a model that refutes: True
% 8.31/7.89  Unfolded term: [| !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8 X9.
% 8.31/7.89        ((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_smoke U V |
% 8.31/7.89        ~ bnd_present U V) |
% 8.31/7.89       ~ bnd_agent U V (bnd_skf4 U)) |
% 8.31/7.89      ~ bnd_event U V) |
% 8.31/7.89     ~ bnd_accessible_world W U) |
% 8.31/7.89    ~ bnd_proposition W U) |
% 8.31/7.89   ~ bnd_theme W X U) |
% 8.31/7.89  ~ bnd_event W X) |
% 8.31/7.89                                       ~ bnd_present W X) |
% 8.31/7.89                                      ~ bnd_think_believe_consider W X) |
% 8.31/7.89                                     ~ bnd_forename W Y) |
% 8.31/7.89                                    ~ bnd_vincent_forename W Y) |
% 8.31/7.89                                   ~ bnd_of W Y Z) |
% 8.31/7.89                                  ~ bnd_man W Z) |
% 8.31/7.89                                 ~ bnd_agent W X Z) |
% 8.31/7.89                                ~ bnd_state W X1) |
% 8.31/7.89                               ~ bnd_be W X1 X2 X2) |
% 8.31/7.89                              ~ bnd_man W X2) |
% 8.31/7.89                             ~ bnd_of W X3 X2) |
% 8.31/7.89                            ~ bnd_jules_forename W X3) |
% 8.31/7.89                           ~ bnd_forename W X3) |
% 8.31/7.89                          ~ bnd_proposition W X4) |
% 8.31/7.89                         ~ bnd_accessible_world W X4) |
% 8.31/7.89                        ~ bnd_forename W X5) |
% 8.31/7.89                       ~ bnd_vincent_forename W X5) |
% 8.31/7.89                      ~ bnd_of W X5 X6) |
% 8.31/7.89                     ~ bnd_man W X6) |
% 8.31/7.89                    ~ bnd_agent W X7 X6) |
% 8.31/7.89                   ~ bnd_smoke X4 X8) |
% 8.31/7.89                  ~ bnd_present X4 X8) |
% 8.31/7.89                 ~ bnd_agent X4 X8 X6) |
% 8.31/7.89                ~ bnd_event X4 X8) |
% 8.31/7.89               ~ bnd_forename W X9) |
% 8.31/7.89              ~ bnd_jules_forename W X9) |
% 8.31/7.89             ~ bnd_of W X9 X6) |
% 8.31/7.89            ~ bnd_think_believe_consider W X7) |
% 8.31/7.89           ~ bnd_present W X7) |
% 8.31/7.89          ~ bnd_event W X7) |
% 8.31/7.89         ~ bnd_theme W X7 X4) |
% 8.31/7.89        ~ bnd_actual_world W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X Y Z X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X8.
% 8.31/7.89        (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((~ bnd_accessible_world U V |
% 8.31/7.89     ~ bnd_proposition U V) |
% 8.31/7.89    ~ bnd_theme U W V) |
% 8.31/7.89   ~ bnd_event U W) |
% 8.31/7.89  ~ bnd_present U W) |
% 8.31/7.89                                       ~ bnd_think_believe_consider U W) |
% 8.31/7.89                                      ~ bnd_forename U X) |
% 8.31/7.89                                     ~ bnd_vincent_forename U X) |
% 8.31/7.89                                    ~ bnd_of U X Y) |
% 8.31/7.89                                   ~ bnd_man U Y) |
% 8.31/7.89                                  ~ bnd_agent U W Y) |
% 8.31/7.89                                 ~ bnd_state U Z) |
% 8.31/7.89                                ~ bnd_be U Z X1 X1) |
% 8.31/7.89                               ~ bnd_man U X1) |
% 8.31/7.89                              ~ bnd_of U X2 X1) |
% 8.31/7.89                             ~ bnd_jules_forename U X2) |
% 8.31/7.89                            ~ bnd_forename U X2) |
% 8.31/7.89                           ~ bnd_proposition U X3) |
% 8.31/7.89                          ~ bnd_accessible_world U X3) |
% 8.31/7.89                         ~ bnd_forename U X4) |
% 8.31/7.89                        ~ bnd_vincent_forename U X4) |
% 8.31/7.89                       ~ bnd_of U X4 X5) |
% 8.31/7.89                      ~ bnd_man U X5) |
% 8.31/7.89                     ~ bnd_agent U X6 X5) |
% 8.31/7.89                    ~ bnd_smoke X3 X7) |
% 8.31/7.89                   ~ bnd_present X3 X7) |
% 8.31/7.89                  ~ bnd_agent X3 X7 X5) |
% 8.31/7.89                 ~ bnd_event X3 X7) |
% 8.31/7.89                ~ bnd_forename U X8) |
% 8.31/7.89               ~ bnd_jules_forename U X8) |
% 8.31/7.89              ~ bnd_of U X8 X5) |
% 8.31/7.89             ~ bnd_think_believe_consider U X6) |
% 8.31/7.89            ~ bnd_present U X6) |
% 8.31/7.89           ~ bnd_event U X6) |
% 8.31/7.89          ~ bnd_theme U X6 X3) |
% 8.31/7.89         ~ bnd_actual_world U) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_man V (bnd_skf4 V);
% 8.31/7.89     !!U. ~ bnd_man bnd_skc12 U | bnd_agent bnd_skc12 (bnd_skf2 U) U;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_man bnd_skc12 U | bnd_event bnd_skc12 (bnd_skf2 V);
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_man bnd_skc12 U | bnd_present bnd_skc12 (bnd_skf2 V);
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_man bnd_skc12 U | bnd_smoke bnd_skc12 (bnd_skf2 V);
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_be bnd_skc8 bnd_skc9 bnd_skc10 bnd_skc10;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_of bnd_skc8 bnd_skc11 bnd_skc10;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_theme bnd_skc8 bnd_skc13 bnd_skc12;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_agent bnd_skc8 bnd_skc13 bnd_skc15;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_of bnd_skc8 bnd_skc14 bnd_skc15; bnd_proposition bnd_skc8 bnd_skc12;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_accessible_world bnd_skc8 bnd_skc12; bnd_state bnd_skc8 bnd_skc9;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_man bnd_skc8 bnd_skc10; bnd_forename bnd_skc8 bnd_skc11;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_jules_forename bnd_skc8 bnd_skc11;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_think_believe_consider bnd_skc8 bnd_skc13;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_present bnd_skc8 bnd_skc13; bnd_event bnd_skc8 bnd_skc13;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_vincent_forename bnd_skc8 bnd_skc14; bnd_forename bnd_skc8 bnd_skc14;
% 8.31/7.89     bnd_man bnd_skc8 bnd_skc15; bnd_actual_world bnd_skc8;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X Y Z.
% 8.31/7.89        (((((((~ bnd_proposition U V | ~ bnd_proposition U W) |
% 8.31/7.89              ~ bnd_theme U X V) |
% 8.31/7.89             ~ bnd_think_believe_consider U X) |
% 8.31/7.89            ~ bnd_think_believe_consider U Y) |
% 8.31/7.89           ~ bnd_theme U Y W) |
% 8.31/7.89          ~ bnd_agent U Y Z) |
% 8.31/7.89         ~ bnd_agent U X Z) |
% 8.31/7.89        V = W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X.
% 8.31/7.89        ((((~ bnd_forename U V | ~ bnd_of U W X) | ~ bnd_forename U W) |
% 8.31/7.89          ~ bnd_of U V X) |
% 8.31/7.89         ~ bnd_entity U X) |
% 8.31/7.89        W = V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X Y.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_be U W X Y) | bnd_be V W X Y;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_of U W X) | bnd_of V W X;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_theme U W X) | bnd_theme V W X;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_agent U W X) | bnd_agent V W X;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_jules_forename U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_jules_forename V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_vincent_forename U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_vincent_forename V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_relname U W) | bnd_relname V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_forename U W) | bnd_forename V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_male U W) | bnd_male V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_animate U W) | bnd_animate V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_human U W) | bnd_human V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_living U W) | bnd_living V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_impartial U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_impartial V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_existent U W) | bnd_existent V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_entity U W) | bnd_entity V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_organism U W) | bnd_organism V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_human_person U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_human_person V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_man U W) | bnd_man V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_state U W) | bnd_state V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_general U W) | bnd_general V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_nonhuman U W) | bnd_nonhuman V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_abstraction U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_abstraction V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_relation U W) | bnd_relation V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_proposition U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_proposition V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_think_believe_consider U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_think_believe_consider V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_present U W) | bnd_present V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_unisex U W) | bnd_unisex V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_nonexistent U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_nonexistent V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_specific U W) | bnd_specific V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_singleton U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_singleton V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_thing U W) | bnd_thing V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W.
% 8.31/7.89        (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_eventuality U W) |
% 8.31/7.89        bnd_eventuality V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_event U W) | bnd_event V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W. (~ bnd_accessible_world U V | ~ bnd_smoke U W) | bnd_smoke V W;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V W X. ~ bnd_be U V W X | W = X;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_nonexistent U V | ~ bnd_existent U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_human U V | ~ bnd_nonhuman U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_general U V | ~ bnd_specific U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_male U V | ~ bnd_unisex U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_jules_forename U V | bnd_forename U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_vincent_forename U V | bnd_forename U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_relname U V | bnd_relation U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_forename U V | bnd_relname U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_man U V | bnd_male U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_human_person U V | bnd_animate U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_human_person U V | bnd_human U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_organism U V | bnd_living U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_organism U V | bnd_impartial U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_entity U V | bnd_existent U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_entity U V | bnd_specific U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_entity U V | bnd_thing U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_organism U V | bnd_entity U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_human_person U V | bnd_organism U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_man U V | bnd_human_person U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_state U V | bnd_event U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_state U V | bnd_eventuality U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_abstraction U V | bnd_unisex U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_abstraction U V | bnd_general U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_abstraction U V | bnd_nonhuman U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_abstraction U V | bnd_thing U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_relation U V | bnd_abstraction U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_proposition U V | bnd_relation U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_unisex U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_nonexistent U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_specific U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_thing U V | bnd_singleton U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_eventuality U V | bnd_thing U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_event U V | bnd_eventuality U V;
% 8.31/7.89     !!U V. ~ bnd_smoke U V | bnd_event U V |]
% 8.31/7.89  ==> True
% 8.31/7.89  Adding axioms...
% 8.41/7.90  Typedef.type_definition_def
% 17.32/16.81   ...done.
% 17.62/17.20  Ground types: ?'b, TPTP_Interpret.ind
% 17.62/17.20  Translating term (sizes: 1, 1) ...
% 26.13/25.64  Invoking SAT solver...
% 26.13/25.64  No model exists.
% 26.13/25.64  Translating term (sizes: 2, 1) ...
% 35.56/35.09  Invoking SAT solver...
% 35.56/35.09  No model exists.
% 35.56/35.09  Translating term (sizes: 1, 2) ...
% 300.10/298.22  /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/lib/scripts/run-polyml-5.5.2: line 82: 46231 CPU time limit exceeded (core dumped) "$ISABELLE_HOME/lib/scripts/feeder" -p -h "$MLTEXT" -t "$MLEXIT" $FEEDER_OPTS
% 300.10/298.22       46232                       (core dumped) | { read FPID; "$POLY" -q -i $ML_OPTIONS; RC="$?"; kill -TERM "$FPID"; exit "$RC"; }
% 300.10/298.23  /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/src/HOL/TPTP/lib/Tools/tptp_refute: line 26: 46177 Exit 152                "$ISABELLE_PROCESS" -q -e "use_thy \"/tmp/$SCRATCH\"; exit 1;" HOL-TPTP
% 300.10/298.23       46178 CPU time limit exceeded (core dumped) | grep --line-buffered -v "^###\|^PROOF FAILED for depth\|^Failure node\|inferences so far.  Searching to depth\|^val \|^Loading theory\|^Warning-The type of\|^   monotype.$"
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------