TSTP Solution File: NLP081-1 by Gandalf---c-2.6
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Gandalf---c-2.6
% Problem : NLP081-1 : TPTP v3.4.2. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : add_equality:r
% Format : otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)
% Command : gandalf-wrapper -time %d %s
% Computer : art06.cs.miami.edu
% Model : i686 unknown
% CPU : Intel(R) Pentium(R) 4 CPU 2.80GHz @ 2793MHz
% Memory : 1000MB
% OS : Linux 2.4.22-21mdk-i686-up-4GB
% CPULimit : 600s
% Result : Unsatisfiable 40.0s
% Output : Assurance 40.0s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax : Number of formulae : 0
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----NO SOLUTION OUTPUT BY SYSTEM
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
%
% Gandalf c-2.6 r1 starting to prove: /home/graph/tptp/TSTP/PreparedTPTP/otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)---add_equality:r/NLP/NLP081-1+noeq.in
% Using automatic strategy selection.
% Time limit in seconds: 600
%
% prove-all-passes started
%
% detected problem class: nne
% detected subclass: medium
%
% strategies selected:
% (hyper 27 #f 2 37)
% (binary-unit 10 #f 2 37)
% (binary-double 16 #f 2 37)
% (binary 54 #t 2 37)
% (binary-order 27 #f 2 37)
% (binary-posweight-order 125 #f)
% (binary-order-sos 54 #t)
% (binary-unit-uniteq 27 #f)
% (binary-weightorder 54 #f)
% (binary-order 54 #f)
% (hyper-order 43 #f)
% (binary 109 #t)
%
%
% SOS clause
% -revenge(X,Y) | -of(X,Z,Y) | -event(X,Z) | -present(X,Z) | -nonreflexive(X,Z) | -scream(X,Z) | -shot(X,skf6(X,U)) | -group(X,V) | -six(X,V) | -cannon(X,W) | -agent(X,Z,X1) | -ss^sk^p0(W,X1,V,X) | -of(X,W,X1) | -man(X,X1) | -male(X,X1) | -patient(X,Z,X2) | -cry(X,X2) | -actual_world(X) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% was split for some strategies as:
% -revenge(X,Y) | -of(X,Z,Y) | -event(X,Z) | -present(X,Z) | -nonreflexive(X,Z) | -scream(X,Z) | -shot(X,skf6(X,U)) | -group(X,V) | -six(X,V) | -cannon(X,W) | -agent(X,Z,X1) | -ss^sk^p0(W,X1,V,X) | -of(X,W,X1) | -man(X,X1) | -male(X,X1) | -patient(X,Z,X2) | -cry(X,X2) | -actual_world(X).
% -ss^sk^c0(0).
%
% ********* EMPTY CLAUSE DERIVED *********
%
%
% timer checkpoints: c(49,40,1,102,0,1,194522,5,902,194523,1,902,194523,50,902,194523,40,902,194576,0,902,194675,50,902,194728,0,902,194827,50,903,194880,0,903,194979,50,903,195032,0,903,195131,50,904,195184,0,904,195283,50,904,195336,0,905,195435,50,905,195488,0,905,195587,50,906,195640,0,906,195739,50,906,195792,0,907,195891,50,907,195944,0,907,196043,50,908,196096,0,908,196195,50,909,196248,0,909,196347,50,909,196400,0,909,196499,50,910,196552,0,910,196651,50,911,196704,0,911,196803,50,912,196856,0,912,196955,50,913,197008,0,913,197107,50,914,197160,0,914,197259,50,915,197312,0,915,197411,50,916,197464,0,916,197563,50,917,197563,40,917,197616,0,917,199419,3,1168,200379,4,1301,201461,5,1418,201461,1,1418,201461,50,1418,201461,40,1418,201514,0,1418,206988,3,2374,209922,4,2769,210543,50,2903,210543,40,2903,210596,0,2903,213911,3,3417,215609,50,3573,215609,40,3573,215662,0,3573)
%
%
% START OF PROOF
% 215610 [] -ss^sk^c0(0) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 215611 [] ss^sk^c0(0) | -shot(X,skf12(X,Y)) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,V,X) | -patient(X,W,X1) | -agent(X,W,U) | -of(X,W,X2) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,X1) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,V) | -group(X,V) | -scream(X,W) | -nonreflexive(X,W) | -present(X,W) | -event(X,W) | -revenge(X,X2) | -actual_world(X).
% 215612 [] ss^sk^c0(0) | member(X,skf12(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 215622 [] -ss^sk^c0(0) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 215623 [] ss^sk^c0(0) | -member(skc39,X,skc42) | shot(skc39,X).
% 215624 [] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215625 [] ss^sk^p0(skc43,skc44,skc42,skc39) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215626 [] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215627 [] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215628 [] agent(skc14,skc15,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215629 [] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215630 [] patient(skc39,skc40,skc41) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215631 [] of(skc39,skc43,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215632 [] agent(skc39,skc40,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215633 [] of(skc39,skc40,skc45) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215634 [] revenge(skc14,skc16) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215635 [] male(skc14,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215636 [] man(skc14,skc19) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215637 [] cannon(skc14,skc18) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215638 [] six(skc14,skc17) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215639 [] group(skc14,skc17) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215640 [] scream(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215641 [] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215642 [] present(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215643 [] event(skc14,skc15) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215644 [] cry(skc14,skc20) | -ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215645 [] cry(skc39,skc41) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215646 [] male(skc39,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215647 [] man(skc39,skc44) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215648 [] cannon(skc39,skc43) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215649 [] six(skc39,skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215650 [] group(skc39,skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215651 [] scream(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215652 [] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215653 [] present(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215654 [] event(skc39,skc40) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215655 [] revenge(skc39,skc45) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 215656 [] actual_world(skc14).
% 215657 [] actual_world(skc39).
% 215659 [] -ss^sk^c0(0) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Y) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -male(U,Y) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 215660 [] -shot(X,skf6(X,Y)) | $spltprd1($spltcnst17,X).
% 215661 [] $spltprd1($spltcnst18,X) | -actual_world(X).
% 215662 [] -$spltprd1($spltcnst17,X) | -$spltprd1($spltcnst16,X) | -$spltprd1($spltcnst18,X).
% 215664 [binary:215656,215661.2] $spltprd1($spltcnst18,skc14).
% 215791 [binary:215634.2,215652.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 215792 [binary:215635.2,215652.2] male(skc14,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215793 [binary:215636.2,215652.2] man(skc14,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215794 [binary:215637.2,215652.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215795 [binary:215659,215652.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Y) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -male(U,Y) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 215796 [binary:215638.2,215652.2] six(skc14,skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215797 [binary:215639.2,215652.2] group(skc14,skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215798 [binary:215640.2,215652.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215799 [binary:215641.2,215652.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | nonreflexive(skc14,skc15).
% 215800 [binary:215642.2,215652.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | present(skc14,skc15).
% 215801 [binary:215643.2,215652.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | event(skc14,skc15).
% 215802 [binary:215644.2,215652.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215803 [binary:215610,215652.2] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 215806 [binary:215634.2,215653.2] present(skc39,skc40) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 215807 [binary:215635.2,215653.2] male(skc14,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215808 [binary:215636.2,215653.2] man(skc14,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215809 [binary:215637.2,215653.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215810 [binary:215659,215653.2] present(skc39,skc40) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Y) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -male(U,Y) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 215811 [binary:215638.2,215653.2] six(skc14,skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215812 [binary:215639.2,215653.2] group(skc14,skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215813 [binary:215640.2,215653.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215814 [binary:215641.2,215653.2] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215815 [binary:215642.2,215653.2] present(skc39,skc40) | present(skc14,skc15).
% 215816 [binary:215643.2,215653.2] present(skc39,skc40) | event(skc14,skc15).
% 215817 [binary:215644.2,215653.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215818 [binary:215610,215653.2] present(skc39,skc40) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 215822 [binary:215634.2,215654.2] event(skc39,skc40) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 215823 [binary:215635.2,215654.2] male(skc14,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215824 [binary:215636.2,215654.2] man(skc14,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215825 [binary:215637.2,215654.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215826 [binary:215659,215654.2] event(skc39,skc40) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Y) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -male(U,Y) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 215827 [binary:215638.2,215654.2] six(skc14,skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215828 [binary:215639.2,215654.2] group(skc14,skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215829 [binary:215640.2,215654.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215830 [binary:215641.2,215654.2] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215831 [binary:215642.2,215654.2] present(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215832 [binary:215643.2,215654.2] event(skc39,skc40) | event(skc14,skc15).
% 215833 [binary:215644.2,215654.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215834 [binary:215610,215654.2] event(skc39,skc40) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 215837 [binary:215634.2,215655.2] revenge(skc39,skc45) | revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 215838 [binary:215635.2,215655.2] male(skc14,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215839 [binary:215636.2,215655.2] man(skc14,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215840 [binary:215637.2,215655.2] cannon(skc14,skc18) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215841 [binary:215659,215655.2] revenge(skc39,skc45) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Y) | -of(U,X,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -male(U,Y) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 215842 [binary:215638.2,215655.2] six(skc14,skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215843 [binary:215639.2,215655.2] group(skc14,skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215844 [binary:215640.2,215655.2] scream(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215845 [binary:215641.2,215655.2] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215846 [binary:215642.2,215655.2] present(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215847 [binary:215643.2,215655.2] event(skc14,skc15) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215848 [binary:215644.2,215655.2] cry(skc14,skc20) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215849 [binary:215610,215655.2] revenge(skc39,skc45) | member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -of(X,Z,U) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 215859 [binary:215652.2,215626.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215860 [binary:215653.2,215626.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215861 [binary:215654.2,215626.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215862 [binary:215655.2,215626.2] of(skc14,skc15,skc16) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215871 [binary:215652.2,215627.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215872 [binary:215653.2,215627.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215873 [binary:215654.2,215627.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215874 [binary:215655.2,215627.2] of(skc14,skc18,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215883 [binary:215652.2,215628.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc19) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215884 [binary:215653.2,215628.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc19) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215885 [binary:215654.2,215628.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc19) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215886 [binary:215655.2,215628.2] agent(skc14,skc15,skc19) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 215896 [binary:215652.2,215629.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 215897 [binary:215653.2,215629.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 215898 [binary:215654.2,215629.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 215899 [binary:215655.2,215629.2] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 216036 [binary:215652.2,215622] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 216037 [binary:215653.2,215622] present(skc39,skc40) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 216038 [binary:215654.2,215622] event(skc39,skc40) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 216039 [binary:215655.2,215622] revenge(skc39,skc45) | -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 216065 [binary:215652.2,215624.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 216066 [binary:215653.2,215624.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 216067 [binary:215654.2,215624.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 216068 [binary:215655.2,215624.2] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 216095 [binary:215612.3,215625,cut:215657,binarycut:215631,binarycut:215646,binarycut:215647,binarycut:215648,binarycut:215649,binarycut:215650] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0) | -agent(skc39,X,skc44) | -patient(skc39,X,Y) | -of(skc39,X,Z) | -cry(skc39,Y) | -scream(skc39,X) | -nonreflexive(skc39,X) | -present(skc39,X) | -event(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Z).
% 216471 [binary:215795.2,216065,binarycut:215871,binarycut:215792,binarycut:215793,binarycut:215794,binarycut:215796,binarycut:215797] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216473 [binary:215803.3,216065,cut:215656,binarycut:215871,binarycut:215792,binarycut:215793,binarycut:215794,binarycut:215796,binarycut:215797] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216483 [binary:215810.2,216066,binarycut:215872,binarycut:215807,binarycut:215808,binarycut:215809,binarycut:215811,binarycut:215812] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216485 [binary:215818.3,216066,cut:215656,binarycut:215872,binarycut:215807,binarycut:215808,binarycut:215809,binarycut:215811,binarycut:215812] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216503 [binary:215826.2,216067,binarycut:215873,binarycut:215823,binarycut:215824,binarycut:215825,binarycut:215827,binarycut:215828] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216505 [binary:215834.3,216067,cut:215656,binarycut:215873,binarycut:215823,binarycut:215824,binarycut:215825,binarycut:215827,binarycut:215828] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216516 [binary:215841.2,216068,binarycut:215874,binarycut:215838,binarycut:215839,binarycut:215840,binarycut:215842,binarycut:215843] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216518 [binary:215849.3,216068,cut:215656,binarycut:215874,binarycut:215838,binarycut:215839,binarycut:215840,binarycut:215842,binarycut:215843] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 216956 [binary:215632,216095.3,binarycut:215651,binarycut:215652,binarycut:215653,binarycut:215654] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0) | -patient(skc39,skc40,X) | -of(skc39,skc40,Y) | -cry(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Y).
% 217588 [binary:215883,216471.3,binarycut:215798] -nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217615 [binary:215883,216473.3,binarycut:215798] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -nonreflexive(skc14,skc15) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217623 [binary:215799.2,217588] -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217673 [binary:215800.2,217623] -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217705 [binary:215884,216483.3,binarycut:215813,binarycut:215814] -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217721 [binary:215801.2,217673] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217738 [binary:215884,216485.3,binarycut:215813,binarycut:215814] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217767 [binary:215896,217721.3,binarycut:215802] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 217775 [binary:215859,217767.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 217783 [binary:215791.2,217775] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 217809 [binary:215885,216503.3,binarycut:215829,binarycut:215830,binarycut:215831] -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217832 [binary:215885,216505.3,binarycut:215829,binarycut:215830,binarycut:215831] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -event(skc14,skc15) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217857 [binary:215886,216516.3,binarycut:215844,binarycut:215845,binarycut:215846,binarycut:215847] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217880 [binary:215886,216518.3,binarycut:215844,binarycut:215845,binarycut:215846,binarycut:215847] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 217968 [binary:215899,217857.3,binarycut:215848] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 217980 [binary:215862,217968.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 217990 [binary:215837.2,217980] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 218505 [binary:215832.2,217809] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 218522 [binary:215898,218505.3,binarycut:215833] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 218531 [binary:215861,218522.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 218540 [binary:215822.2,218531] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 218809 [binary:215630,216956.3,binarycut:215645] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0) | -of(skc39,skc40,X) | -revenge(skc39,X).
% 218812 [binary:215633,218809.3,binarycut:215655] member(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42),skc42) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 218833 [binary:215623.2,218812] shot(skc39,skf12(skc39,skc42)) | ss^sk^c0(0).
% 218866 [binary:215611.2,218833,cut:215657] ss^sk^c0(0) | -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,skc39) | -patient(skc39,U,V) | -agent(skc39,U,Y) | -of(skc39,U,W) | -of(skc39,X,Y) | -cry(skc39,V) | -male(skc39,Y) | -man(skc39,Y) | -cannon(skc39,X) | -six(skc39,Z) | -group(skc39,Z) | -scream(skc39,U) | -nonreflexive(skc39,U) | -present(skc39,U) | -event(skc39,U) | -revenge(skc39,W).
% 219296 [binary:215815.2,217705] -event(skc14,skc15) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 219360 [binary:215816.2,219296] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 219409 [binary:215897,219360.3,binarycut:215817] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 219417 [binary:215860,219409.3] -revenge(skc14,skc16) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 219425 [binary:215806.2,219417] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 220452 [binary:215899,217880.3,binarycut:215848] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 220464 [binary:215862,220452.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 220483 [binary:215837.2,220464.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 220510 [binary:216039.2,220483,binarydemod:215660] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 220615 [binary:215662,220510,cut:215664,binarycut:217990] revenge(skc39,skc45).
% 221414 [binary:215799.2,217615.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -present(skc14,skc15) | -event(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 221517 [binary:215832.2,217832.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 221538 [binary:215898,221517.3,binarycut:215833] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 221549 [binary:215861,221538.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 221560 [binary:215822.2,221549.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 221585 [binary:216038.2,221560,binarydemod:215660] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | event(skc39,skc40).
% 221681 [binary:215662,221585,cut:215664,binarycut:218540] event(skc39,skc40).
% 221691 [binary:215815.2,217738.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -event(skc14,skc15) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 221808 [binary:215816.2,221691.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 221827 [binary:215897,221808.3,binarycut:215817] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 221839 [binary:215860,221827.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 221849 [binary:215806.2,221839.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 221872 [binary:216037.2,221849,binarydemod:215660] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | present(skc39,skc40).
% 221959 [binary:215662,221872,cut:215664,binarycut:219425] present(skc39,skc40).
% 223234 [binary:215800.2,221414.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -event(skc14,skc15) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 223243 [binary:215801.2,223234.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 223260 [binary:215896,223243.3,binarycut:215802] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 223271 [binary:215859,223260.3] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -revenge(skc14,skc16) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 223280 [binary:215791.2,223271.2] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 223301 [binary:216036.2,223280,binarydemod:215660] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14) | nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 223411 [binary:215662,223301,cut:215664,binarycut:217783] nonreflexive(skc39,skc40).
% 225318 [binary:215625,218866.2,binarycut:215631,binarycut:215646,binarycut:215647,binarycut:215648,binarycut:215649,binarycut:215650] ss^sk^c0(0) | -agent(skc39,X,skc44) | -patient(skc39,X,Y) | -of(skc39,X,Z) | -cry(skc39,Y) | -scream(skc39,X) | -nonreflexive(skc39,X) | -present(skc39,X) | -event(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Z).
% 225329 [binary:215632,225318.2,cut:223411,cut:221959,cut:221681,binarycut:215651] ss^sk^c0(0) | -patient(skc39,skc40,X) | -of(skc39,skc40,Y) | -cry(skc39,X) | -revenge(skc39,Y).
% 225341 [binary:215630,225329.2,binarycut:215645] ss^sk^c0(0) | -of(skc39,skc40,X) | -revenge(skc39,X).
% 225343 [binary:215633,225341.2,cut:220615] ss^sk^c0(0).
% 225345 [binary:215634.2,225343] revenge(skc14,skc16).
% 225346 [binary:215635.2,225343] male(skc14,skc19).
% 225347 [binary:215636.2,225343] man(skc14,skc19).
% 225348 [binary:215637.2,225343] cannon(skc14,skc18).
% 225349 [binary:215659,225343] -ss^sk^p0(X,Y,Z,U) | -patient(U,V,W) | -agent(U,V,Y) | -of(U,V,X1) | -of(U,X,Y) | $spltprd1($spltcnst16,U) | -cry(U,W) | -male(U,Y) | -man(U,Y) | -cannon(U,X) | -six(U,Z) | -group(U,Z) | -scream(U,V) | -nonreflexive(U,V) | -present(U,V) | -event(U,V) | -revenge(U,X1).
% 225350 [binary:215638.2,225343] six(skc14,skc17).
% 225351 [binary:215639.2,225343] group(skc14,skc17).
% 225352 [binary:215640.2,225343] scream(skc14,skc15).
% 225353 [binary:215641.2,225343] nonreflexive(skc14,skc15).
% 225354 [binary:215642.2,225343] present(skc14,skc15).
% 225355 [binary:215643.2,225343] event(skc14,skc15).
% 225356 [binary:215644.2,225343] cry(skc14,skc20).
% 225357 [binary:215610,225343] member(X,skf6(X,Y),Y) | -ss^sk^p0(Z,U,Y,X) | -patient(X,V,W) | -agent(X,V,U) | -of(X,Z,U) | -of(X,V,X1) | -cry(X,W) | -male(X,U) | -man(X,U) | -cannon(X,Z) | -six(X,Y) | -group(X,Y) | -scream(X,V) | -nonreflexive(X,V) | -present(X,V) | -event(X,V) | -revenge(X,X1) | -actual_world(X).
% 225358 [binary:215626.2,225343] of(skc14,skc15,skc16).
% 225359 [binary:215627.2,225343] of(skc14,skc18,skc19).
% 225360 [binary:215628.2,225343] agent(skc14,skc15,skc19).
% 225361 [binary:215629.2,225343] patient(skc14,skc15,skc20).
% 225362 [binary:215622,225343] -member(skc14,X,skc17) | shot(skc14,X).
% 225363 [binary:215624.2,225343] ss^sk^p0(skc18,skc19,skc17,skc14).
% 225509 [binary:225363,225349,cut:225359,cut:225346,cut:225347,cut:225348,cut:225350,cut:225351] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 225519 [binary:225360,225509.2,cut:225352,cut:225353,cut:225354,cut:225355] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 225523 [binary:225361,225519.2,cut:225356] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 225525 [binary:225358,225523.2,cut:225345] $spltprd1($spltcnst16,skc14).
% 228063 [binary:225363,225357.2,cut:225359,cut:225346,cut:225347,cut:225348,cut:225350,cut:225351,cut:215656] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -agent(skc14,X,skc19) | -patient(skc14,X,Y) | -of(skc14,X,Z) | -cry(skc14,Y) | -scream(skc14,X) | -nonreflexive(skc14,X) | -present(skc14,X) | -event(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Z).
% 228086 [binary:225360,228063.2,cut:225352,cut:225353,cut:225354,cut:225355] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -patient(skc14,skc15,X) | -of(skc14,skc15,Y) | -cry(skc14,X) | -revenge(skc14,Y).
% 228093 [binary:225361,228086.2,cut:225356] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17) | -of(skc14,skc15,X) | -revenge(skc14,X).
% 228095 [binary:225358,228093.2,cut:225345] member(skc14,skf6(skc14,skc17),skc17).
% 228104 [binary:225362,228095,binarydemod:215660] $spltprd1($spltcnst17,skc14).
% 228135 [binary:215662,228104,cut:225525,cut:215664] contradiction
% END OF PROOF
%
% Proof found by the following strategy:
%
% using binary resolution
% using first neg lit preferred strategy
% not using sos strategy
% using dynamic demodulation
% using ordered paramodulation
% using kb ordering for equality
% preferring bigger arities for lex ordering
% using clause demodulation
% seconds given: 41
%
%
% ***GANDALF_FOUND_A_REFUTATION***
%
% Global statistics over all passes:
%
% given clauses: 10761
% derived clauses: 356393
% kept clauses: 17302
% kept size sum: 907957
% kept mid-nuclei: 180927
% kept new demods: 0
% forw unit-subs: 79
% forw double-subs: 61807
% forw overdouble-subs: 72902
% backward subs: 8232
% fast unit cutoff: 49409
% full unit cutoff: 0
% dbl unit cutoff: 15201
% real runtime : 48.30
% process. runtime: 48.23
% specific non-discr-tree subsumption statistics:
% tried: 5025685
% length fails: 75561
% strength fails: 633920
% predlist fails: 2461815
% aux str. fails: 6148
% by-lit fails: 1000112
% full subs tried: 774108
% full subs fail: 689957
%
% ; program args: ("/home/graph/tptp/Systems/Gandalf---c-2.6/gandalf" "-time" "600" "/home/graph/tptp/TSTP/PreparedTPTP/otter:hypothesis:set(auto),clear(print_given)---add_equality:r/NLP/NLP081-1+noeq.in")
%
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------