TSTP Solution File: NLP046+1 by Refute---2015
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : Refute---2015
% Problem : NLP046+1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s
% Computer : n023.star.cs.uiowa.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 2.40GHz
% Memory : 16091.75MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% DateTime : Thu Apr 14 01:27:51 EDT 2016
% Result : CounterSatisfiable 218.48s
% Output : Assurance 0s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : None (Parsing solution fails)
% Syntax : Number of formulae : 0
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----No solution output by system
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.00/0.03 % Problem : NLP046+1 : TPTP v6.4.0. Released v2.4.0.
% 0.00/0.04 % Command : isabelle tptp_refute %d %s
% 0.03/0.22 % Computer : n023.star.cs.uiowa.edu
% 0.03/0.22 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.03/0.22 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2609 0 @ 2.40GHz
% 0.03/0.22 % Memory : 16091.75MB
% 0.03/0.22 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-327.10.1.el7.x86_64
% 0.03/0.22 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.03/0.22 % DateTime : Tue Apr 5 12:04:54 CDT 2016
% 0.03/0.22 % CPUTime :
% 6.30/5.83 > val it = (): unit
% 6.50/6.06 Trying to find a model that refutes: ~ ~ (((EX U. bnd_actual_world U &
% 6.50/6.06 (EX V W X Y Z.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((((((((((((bnd_of U W V & bnd_woman U V) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_mia_forename U W) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_forename U W) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_shake_beverage U X) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_event U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_agent U Y V) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient U Y X) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_past U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_order U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonhuman U Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X1.
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_member U X1 Z -->
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X2.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((bnd_event U X2 & bnd_agent U X2 Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient U X2 X1) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_present U X2) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive U X2) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_cost U X2))) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_five U Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_group U Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X3. bnd_member U X3 Z --> bnd_dollar U X3))) -->
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X4.
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_actual_world X4 &
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X5 X6 X7 X8 X9.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((((((((((((bnd_nonhuman X4 X8 & bnd_of X4 X6 X5) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_woman X4 X5) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_mia_forename X4 X6) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_forename X4 X6) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_shake_beverage X4 X7) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_event X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_agent X4 X8 X5) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient X4 X8 X7) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_past X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_order X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X10.
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_member X4 X10 X9 -->
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X11.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((bnd_event X4 X11 & bnd_agent X4 X11 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient X4 X11 X10) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_present X4 X11) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X11) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_cost X4 X11))) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_five X4 X9) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_group X4 X9) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X12. bnd_member X4 X12 X9 --> bnd_dollar X4 X12)))) &
% 6.50/6.06 ((EX X4.
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_actual_world X4 &
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X5 X6 X7 X8 X9.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((((((((((((bnd_nonhuman X4 X8 & bnd_of X4 X6 X5) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_woman X4 X5) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_mia_forename X4 X6) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_forename X4 X6) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_shake_beverage X4 X7) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_event X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_agent X4 X8 X5) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient X4 X8 X7) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_past X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_order X4 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X10.
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_member X4 X10 X9 -->
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X11.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((bnd_event X4 X11 & bnd_agent X4 X11 X8) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient X4 X11 X10) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_present X4 X11) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X11) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_cost X4 X11))) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_five X4 X9) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_group X4 X9) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X12. bnd_member X4 X12 X9 --> bnd_dollar X4 X12))) -->
% 6.50/6.06 (EX U. bnd_actual_world U &
% 6.50/6.06 (EX V W X Y Z.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((((((((((((bnd_of U W V & bnd_woman U V) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_mia_forename U W) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_forename U W) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_shake_beverage U X) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_event U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_agent U Y V) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient U Y X) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_past U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_order U Y) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonhuman U Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X1.
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_member U X1 Z -->
% 6.50/6.06 (EX X2.
% 6.50/6.06 ((((bnd_event U X2 & bnd_agent U X2 Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_patient U X2 X1) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_present U X2) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_nonreflexive U X2) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_cost U X2))) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_five U Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 bnd_group U Z) &
% 6.50/6.06 (ALL X3. bnd_member U X3 Z --> bnd_dollar U X3)))))
% 7.01/6.60 Unfolded term: ~ ~ (((EX U. bnd_actual_world U &
% 7.01/6.60 (EX V W X Y Z.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((((((((((((bnd_of U W V & bnd_woman U V) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_mia_forename U W) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_forename U W) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_shake_beverage U X) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_event U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_agent U Y V) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient U Y X) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_past U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_order U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonhuman U Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X1.
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_member U X1 Z -->
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X2.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((bnd_event U X2 & bnd_agent U X2 Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient U X2 X1) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_present U X2) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive U X2) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_cost U X2))) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_five U Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_group U Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X3. bnd_member U X3 Z --> bnd_dollar U X3))) -->
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X4.
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_actual_world X4 &
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X5 X6 X7 X8 X9.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((((((((((((bnd_nonhuman X4 X8 & bnd_of X4 X6 X5) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_woman X4 X5) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_mia_forename X4 X6) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_forename X4 X6) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_shake_beverage X4 X7) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_event X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_agent X4 X8 X5) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient X4 X8 X7) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_past X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_order X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X10.
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_member X4 X10 X9 -->
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X11.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((bnd_event X4 X11 & bnd_agent X4 X11 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient X4 X11 X10) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_present X4 X11) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X11) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_cost X4 X11))) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_five X4 X9) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_group X4 X9) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X12. bnd_member X4 X12 X9 --> bnd_dollar X4 X12)))) &
% 7.01/6.60 ((EX X4.
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_actual_world X4 &
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X5 X6 X7 X8 X9.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((((((((((((bnd_nonhuman X4 X8 & bnd_of X4 X6 X5) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_woman X4 X5) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_mia_forename X4 X6) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_forename X4 X6) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_shake_beverage X4 X7) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_event X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_agent X4 X8 X5) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient X4 X8 X7) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_past X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_order X4 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X10.
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_member X4 X10 X9 -->
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X11.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((bnd_event X4 X11 & bnd_agent X4 X11 X8) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient X4 X11 X10) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_present X4 X11) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive X4 X11) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_cost X4 X11))) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_five X4 X9) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_group X4 X9) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X12. bnd_member X4 X12 X9 --> bnd_dollar X4 X12))) -->
% 7.01/6.60 (EX U. bnd_actual_world U &
% 7.01/6.60 (EX V W X Y Z.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((((((((((((bnd_of U W V & bnd_woman U V) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_mia_forename U W) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_forename U W) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_shake_beverage U X) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_event U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_agent U Y V) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient U Y X) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_past U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_order U Y) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonhuman U Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X1.
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_member U X1 Z -->
% 7.01/6.60 (EX X2.
% 7.01/6.60 ((((bnd_event U X2 & bnd_agent U X2 Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_patient U X2 X1) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_present U X2) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_nonreflexive U X2) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_cost U X2))) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_five U Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 bnd_group U Z) &
% 7.01/6.60 (ALL X3. bnd_member U X3 Z --> bnd_dollar U X3)))))
% 7.01/6.60 Adding axioms...
% 7.11/6.61 Typedef.type_definition_def
% 10.01/9.53 ...done.
% 10.01/9.53 Ground types: ?'b, TPTP_Interpret.ind
% 10.01/9.53 Translating term (sizes: 1, 1) ...
% 12.21/11.72 Invoking SAT solver...
% 12.21/11.72 No model exists.
% 12.21/11.72 Translating term (sizes: 2, 1) ...
% 15.01/14.59 Invoking SAT solver...
% 15.01/14.59 No model exists.
% 15.01/14.59 Translating term (sizes: 1, 2) ...
% 215.86/214.57 Invoking SAT solver...
% 218.48/217.16 Model found:
% 218.48/217.16 Size of types: ?'b: 1, TPTP_Interpret.ind: 2
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_dollar: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_group: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, False), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_five: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_cost: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_present: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_member: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_nonhuman: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, False)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_order: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_nonreflexive: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_past: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_patient: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_agent: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_event: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_shake_beverage: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_forename: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_mia_forename: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_woman: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_of: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, False), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, False)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, False), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, False)})}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}),
% 218.48/217.16 (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1,
% 218.48/217.16 {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)})})}
% 218.48/217.16 bnd_actual_world: {(??.TPTP_Interpret.ind0, True), (??.TPTP_Interpret.ind1, True)}
% 218.48/217.16
% 218.48/217.16 % SZS status CounterSatisfiable
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------