TSTP Solution File: KRS098+1 by PyRes---1.5
View Problem
- Process Solution
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
% File : PyRes---1.5
% Problem : KRS098+1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v3.1.0.
% Transfm : none
% Format : tptp:raw
% Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% Computer : n008.cluster.edu
% Model : x86_64 x86_64
% CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 2.10GHz
% Memory : 8042.1875MB
% OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% CPULimit : 300s
% WCLimit : 300s
% DateTime : Thu May 9 17:28:41 EDT 2024
% Result : Unsatisfiable 1.37s 1.53s
% Output : Refutation 1.37s
% Verified :
% SZS Type : -
% Comments :
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----WARNING: Could not form TPTP format derivation
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------
%----ORIGINAL SYSTEM OUTPUT
% 0.03/0.12 % Problem : KRS098+1 : TPTP v8.1.2. Released v3.1.0.
% 0.03/0.13 % Command : pyres-fof.py -tifbsVp -nlargest -HPickGiven5 %s
% 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n008.cluster.edu
% 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz
% 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB
% 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64
% 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 300
% 0.13/0.34 % WCLimit : 300
% 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Thu May 9 00:18:53 EDT 2024
% 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime :
% 1.37/1.53 % Version: 1.5
% 1.37/1.53 % SZS status Unsatisfiable
% 1.37/1.53 % SZS output start CNFRefutation
% 1.37/1.53 fof(axiom_4,axiom,cUnsatisfiable(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_4)).
% 1.37/1.53 cnf(c44,plain,cUnsatisfiable(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[axiom_4])).
% 1.37/1.53 fof(axiom_2,axiom,(![X]:(cUnsatisfiable(X)<=>((((?[Y]:((rr3(X,Y)&(?[Z]:(rt3(Y,Z)&ce(Z))))&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))=>Z0=Z1)))))&(?[Y]:((rr2(X,Y)&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))=>Z0=Z1))))&(?[Z]:(rt2(Y,Z)&cd(Z))))))&(~(?[Y0]:(?[Y1]:((rr(X,Y0)&rr(X,Y1))&Y0!=Y1)))))&(?[Y]:((rr1(X,Y)&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))=>Z0=Z1))))&(?[Z]:(rt1(Y,Z)&cc(Z)))))))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_2)).
% 1.37/1.53 fof(c53,plain,(![X]:((~cUnsatisfiable(X)|((((?[Y]:((rr3(X,Y)&(?[Z]:(rt3(Y,Z)&ce(Z))))&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((~rtt(Y,Z0)|~rtt(Y,Z1))|Z0=Z1)))))&(?[Y]:((rr2(X,Y)&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((~rtt(Y,Z0)|~rtt(Y,Z1))|Z0=Z1))))&(?[Z]:(rt2(Y,Z)&cd(Z))))))&(![Y0]:(![Y1]:((~rr(X,Y0)|~rr(X,Y1))|Y0=Y1))))&(?[Y]:((rr1(X,Y)&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((~rtt(Y,Z0)|~rtt(Y,Z1))|Z0=Z1))))&(?[Z]:(rt1(Y,Z)&cc(Z)))))))&(((((![Y]:((~rr3(X,Y)|(![Z]:(~rt3(Y,Z)|~ce(Z))))|(?[Z0]:(?[Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))&Z0!=Z1)))))|(![Y]:((~rr2(X,Y)|(?[Z0]:(?[Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))&Z0!=Z1))))|(![Z]:(~rt2(Y,Z)|~cd(Z))))))|(?[Y0]:(?[Y1]:((rr(X,Y0)&rr(X,Y1))&Y0!=Y1))))|(![Y]:((~rr1(X,Y)|(?[Z0]:(?[Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))&Z0!=Z1))))|(![Z]:(~rt1(Y,Z)|~cc(Z))))))|cUnsatisfiable(X)))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[axiom_2])).
% 1.37/1.53 fof(c54,plain,((![X]:(~cUnsatisfiable(X)|((((?[Y]:((rr3(X,Y)&(?[Z]:(rt3(Y,Z)&ce(Z))))&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((~rtt(Y,Z0)|~rtt(Y,Z1))|Z0=Z1)))))&(?[Y]:((rr2(X,Y)&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((~rtt(Y,Z0)|~rtt(Y,Z1))|Z0=Z1))))&(?[Z]:(rt2(Y,Z)&cd(Z))))))&(![Y0]:(![Y1]:((~rr(X,Y0)|~rr(X,Y1))|Y0=Y1))))&(?[Y]:((rr1(X,Y)&(![Z0]:(![Z1]:((~rtt(Y,Z0)|~rtt(Y,Z1))|Z0=Z1))))&(?[Z]:(rt1(Y,Z)&cc(Z))))))))&(![X]:(((((![Y]:((~rr3(X,Y)|(![Z]:(~rt3(Y,Z)|~ce(Z))))|(?[Z0]:(?[Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))&Z0!=Z1)))))|(![Y]:((~rr2(X,Y)|(?[Z0]:(?[Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))&Z0!=Z1))))|(![Z]:(~rt2(Y,Z)|~cd(Z))))))|(?[Y0]:(?[Y1]:((rr(X,Y0)&rr(X,Y1))&Y0!=Y1))))|(![Y]:((~rr1(X,Y)|(?[Z0]:(?[Z1]:((rtt(Y,Z0)&rtt(Y,Z1))&Z0!=Z1))))|(![Z]:(~rt1(Y,Z)|~cc(Z))))))|cUnsatisfiable(X)))),inference(shift_quantors,[status(thm)],[c53])).
% 1.37/1.53 fof(c55,plain,((![X19]:(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|((((?[X20]:((rr3(X19,X20)&(?[X21]:(rt3(X20,X21)&ce(X21))))&(![X22]:(![X23]:((~rtt(X20,X22)|~rtt(X20,X23))|X22=X23)))))&(?[X24]:((rr2(X19,X24)&(![X25]:(![X26]:((~rtt(X24,X25)|~rtt(X24,X26))|X25=X26))))&(?[X27]:(rt2(X24,X27)&cd(X27))))))&(![X28]:(![X29]:((~rr(X19,X28)|~rr(X19,X29))|X28=X29))))&(?[X30]:((rr1(X19,X30)&(![X31]:(![X32]:((~rtt(X30,X31)|~rtt(X30,X32))|X31=X32))))&(?[X33]:(rt1(X30,X33)&cc(X33))))))))&(![X34]:(((((![X35]:((~rr3(X34,X35)|(![X36]:(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36))))|(?[X37]:(?[X38]:((rtt(X35,X37)&rtt(X35,X38))&X37!=X38)))))|(![X39]:((~rr2(X34,X39)|(?[X40]:(?[X41]:((rtt(X39,X40)&rtt(X39,X41))&X40!=X41))))|(![X42]:(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))))|(?[X43]:(?[X44]:((rr(X34,X43)&rr(X34,X44))&X43!=X44))))|(![X45]:((~rr1(X34,X45)|(?[X46]:(?[X47]:((rtt(X45,X46)&rtt(X45,X47))&X46!=X47))))|(![X48]:(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c54])).
% 1.37/1.53 fof(c57,plain,(![X19]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X25]:(![X26]:(![X28]:(![X29]:(![X31]:(![X32]:(![X34]:(![X35]:(![X36]:(![X39]:(![X42]:(![X45]:(![X48]:((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|(((((rr3(X19,skolem0001(X19))&(rt3(skolem0001(X19),skolem0002(X19))&ce(skolem0002(X19))))&((~rtt(skolem0001(X19),X22)|~rtt(skolem0001(X19),X23))|X22=X23))&((rr2(X19,skolem0003(X19))&((~rtt(skolem0003(X19),X25)|~rtt(skolem0003(X19),X26))|X25=X26))&(rt2(skolem0003(X19),skolem0004(X19))&cd(skolem0004(X19)))))&((~rr(X19,X28)|~rr(X19,X29))|X28=X29))&((rr1(X19,skolem0005(X19))&((~rtt(skolem0005(X19),X31)|~rtt(skolem0005(X19),X32))|X31=X32))&(rt1(skolem0005(X19),skolem0006(X19))&cc(skolem0006(X19))))))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|((rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35))&rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))&skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|((rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39))&rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))&skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|((rr(X34,skolem0011(X34))&rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))&skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|((rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45))&rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))&skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))))))))))))))))),inference(shift_quantors,[status(thm)],[fof(c56,plain,((![X19]:(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|(((((rr3(X19,skolem0001(X19))&(rt3(skolem0001(X19),skolem0002(X19))&ce(skolem0002(X19))))&(![X22]:(![X23]:((~rtt(skolem0001(X19),X22)|~rtt(skolem0001(X19),X23))|X22=X23))))&((rr2(X19,skolem0003(X19))&(![X25]:(![X26]:((~rtt(skolem0003(X19),X25)|~rtt(skolem0003(X19),X26))|X25=X26))))&(rt2(skolem0003(X19),skolem0004(X19))&cd(skolem0004(X19)))))&(![X28]:(![X29]:((~rr(X19,X28)|~rr(X19,X29))|X28=X29))))&((rr1(X19,skolem0005(X19))&(![X31]:(![X32]:((~rtt(skolem0005(X19),X31)|~rtt(skolem0005(X19),X32))|X31=X32))))&(rt1(skolem0005(X19),skolem0006(X19))&cc(skolem0006(X19)))))))&(![X34]:(((((![X35]:((~rr3(X34,X35)|(![X36]:(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36))))|((rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35))&rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))&skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))))|(![X39]:((~rr2(X34,X39)|((rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39))&rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))&skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(![X42]:(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))))|((rr(X34,skolem0011(X34))&rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))&skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34)))|(![X45]:((~rr1(X34,X45)|((rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45))&rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))&skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(![X48]:(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))),inference(skolemize,[status(esa)],[c55])).])).
% 1.37/1.53 fof(c58,plain,(![X19]:(![X22]:(![X23]:(![X25]:(![X26]:(![X28]:(![X29]:(![X31]:(![X32]:(![X34]:(![X35]:(![X36]:(![X39]:(![X42]:(![X45]:(![X48]:(((((((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|rr3(X19,skolem0001(X19)))&((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|rt3(skolem0001(X19),skolem0002(X19)))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|ce(skolem0002(X19)))))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|((~rtt(skolem0001(X19),X22)|~rtt(skolem0001(X19),X23))|X22=X23)))&(((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|rr2(X19,skolem0003(X19)))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|((~rtt(skolem0003(X19),X25)|~rtt(skolem0003(X19),X26))|X25=X26)))&((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|rt2(skolem0003(X19),skolem0004(X19)))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|cd(skolem0004(X19))))))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|((~rr(X19,X28)|~rr(X19,X29))|X28=X29)))&(((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|rr1(X19,skolem0005(X19)))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|((~rtt(skolem0005(X19),X31)|~rtt(skolem0005(X19),X32))|X31=X32)))&((~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|rt1(skolem0005(X19),skolem0006(X19)))&(~cUnsatisfiable(X19)|cc(skolem0006(X19))))))&((((((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))))&((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0007(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))))&((((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))))&((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|rtt(X35,skolem0008(X34,X35)))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))))&((((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0009(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|rtt(X39,skolem0010(X34,X39)))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))))&((((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0011(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|rr(X34,skolem0012(X34)))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))&((((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0013(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|rtt(X45,skolem0014(X34,X45)))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34)))&((((((~rr3(X34,X35)|(~rt3(X35,X36)|~ce(X36)))|skolem0007(X34,X35)!=skolem0008(X34,X35))|((~rr2(X34,X39)|skolem0009(X34,X39)!=skolem0010(X34,X39))|(~rt2(X39,X42)|~cd(X42))))|skolem0011(X34)!=skolem0012(X34))|((~rr1(X34,X45)|skolem0013(X34,X45)!=skolem0014(X34,X45))|(~rt1(X45,X48)|~cc(X48))))|cUnsatisfiable(X34))))))))))))))))))))))),inference(distribute,[status(thm)],[c57])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c61,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X154)|ce(skolem0002(X154)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c247,plain,ce(skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c61, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(axiom_6,axiom,(![X]:(~(ce(X)&cc(X)))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_6)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c38,plain,(![X]:(~ce(X)|~cc(X))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[axiom_6])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c39,plain,(![X15]:(~ce(X15)|~cc(X15))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c38])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c40,plain,~ce(X126)|~cc(X126),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c39])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c71,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X159)|cc(skolem0006(X159)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c253,plain,cc(skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c71, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c2,axiom,X157!=X156|~cc(X157)|cc(X156),theory(equality)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(axiom_10,axiom,(![X]:(![Y]:(rt1(X,Y)=>rtt(X,Y)))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_10)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c26,plain,(![X]:(![Y]:(~rt1(X,Y)|rtt(X,Y)))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[axiom_10])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c27,plain,(![X8]:(![X9]:(~rt1(X8,X9)|rtt(X8,X9)))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c26])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c28,plain,~rt1(X146,X145)|rtt(X146,X145),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c27])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c70,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X219)|rt1(skolem0005(X219),skolem0006(X219)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c278,plain,rt1(skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c70, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c279,plain,rtt(skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c278, c28])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(rtt_substitution_1,axiom,(![A]:(![B]:(![C]:((A=B&rtt(A,C))=>rtt(B,C))))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', rtt_substitution_1)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c175,plain,(![A]:(![B]:(![C]:((A!=B|~rtt(A,C))|rtt(B,C))))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[rtt_substitution_1])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c176,plain,(![X60]:(![X61]:(![X62]:((X60!=X61|~rtt(X60,X62))|rtt(X61,X62))))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c175])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c177,plain,X228!=X229|~rtt(X228,X227)|rtt(X229,X227),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c176])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c285,plain,skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)!=X341|rtt(X341,skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c177, c279])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(axiom_8,axiom,(![X]:(![Y]:(rr1(X,Y)=>rr(X,Y)))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_8)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c32,plain,(![X]:(![Y]:(~rr1(X,Y)|rr(X,Y)))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[axiom_8])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c33,plain,(![X12]:(![X13]:(~rr1(X12,X13)|rr(X12,X13)))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c32])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c34,plain,~rr1(X150,X149)|rr(X150,X149),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c33])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c68,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X174)|rr1(X174,skolem0005(X174)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c264,plain,rr1(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524,skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c68, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c265,plain,rr(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524,skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c264, c34])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(axiom_12,axiom,(![X]:(![Y]:(rr3(X,Y)=>rr(X,Y)))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_12)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c20,plain,(![X]:(![Y]:(~rr3(X,Y)|rr(X,Y)))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[axiom_12])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c21,plain,(![X4]:(![X5]:(~rr3(X4,X5)|rr(X4,X5)))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c20])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c22,plain,~rr3(X138,X139)|rr(X138,X139),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c21])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c59,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X170)|rr3(X170,skolem0001(X170)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c260,plain,rr3(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524,skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c59, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c261,plain,rr(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524,skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c260, c22])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c67,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X299)|~rr(X299,X297)|~rr(X299,X298)|X297=X298,inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c322,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)|~rr(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524,X409)|X409=skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c67, c261])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c355,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)|skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)=skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c322, c265])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c357,plain,skolem0005(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)=skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c355, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c370,plain,rtt(skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c357, c285])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(axiom_13,axiom,(![X]:(![Y]:(rt3(X,Y)=>rtt(X,Y)))),file('/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', axiom_13)).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c17,plain,(![X]:(![Y]:(~rt3(X,Y)|rtt(X,Y)))),inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[axiom_13])).
% 1.37/1.54 fof(c18,plain,(![X2]:(![X3]:(~rt3(X2,X3)|rtt(X2,X3)))),inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[c17])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c19,plain,~rt3(X137,X136)|rtt(X137,X136),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c18])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c60,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X213)|rt3(skolem0001(X213),skolem0002(X213)),inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c273,plain,rt3(skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c60, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c274,plain,rtt(skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c273, c19])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c62,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(X287)|~rtt(skolem0001(X287),X288)|~rtt(skolem0001(X287),X286)|X288=X286,inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c58])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c313,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)|~rtt(skolem0001(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),X962)|X962=skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c62, c274])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c728,plain,~cUnsatisfiable(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)|skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)=skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c313, c370])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c730,plain,skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)=skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c728, c44])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c737,plain,~cc(skolem0006(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524))|cc(skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c730, c2])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c840,plain,cc(skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c737, c253])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c842,plain,~ce(skolem0002(i2003_11_14_17_20_25524)),inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c840, c40])).
% 1.37/1.54 cnf(c843,plain,$false,inference(resolution,[status(thm)],[c842, c247])).
% 1.37/1.54 % SZS output end CNFRefutation
% 1.37/1.54
% 1.37/1.54 % Initial clauses : 156
% 1.37/1.54 % Processed clauses : 342
% 1.37/1.54 % Factors computed : 5
% 1.37/1.54 % Resolvents computed: 598
% 1.37/1.54 % Tautologies deleted: 10
% 1.37/1.54 % Forward subsumed : 252
% 1.37/1.54 % Backward subsumed : 5
% 1.37/1.54 % -------- CPU Time ---------
% 1.37/1.54 % User time : 1.178 s
% 1.37/1.54 % System time : 0.010 s
% 1.37/1.54 % Total time : 1.188 s
%------------------------------------------------------------------------------