CADE-13 ATP System Competition Times

General Hardware, Mixed Problems

(CPU times, in seconds)

Monolithic Systems Open Systems
LINUS Otter-Wos RRTP CSatchmo FSatchmo SETHEO E-SETHEO Violet Gandalf Otter3.0.4 SPASS
COL002-3 9 timeout 289 timeout timeout 2 8 timeout 1 timeout timeout
NUM284-1.010 timeout 2 269 timeout timeout timeout timeout 50 timeout 1 timeout
GRP048-2 16 110 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 25 25 95 167
CAT012-3 11 1 6 3 timeout 4 4 3 timeout 7 6
SET232-6 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 55 72 timeout timeout timeout timeout
LCL210-1 76 8 timeout timeout timeout 14 13 234 3 6 timeout
PLA011-2 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 7 3 timeout 21 timeout 1
RNG040-1 9 2 3 3 1 2 4 80 2 1 timeout
SET196-6 18 timeout timeout timeout timeout 9 62 4 timeout timeout 19
PLA018-1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 4 5 timeout timeout timeout 2
NUM009-1 timeout 5 37 timeout timeout 47 189 timeout timeout 7 72
GRP099-1 timeout 8 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 84 60 2
RNG005-1 30 3 155 timeout timeout 27 23 11 4 3 timeout
GEO006-1 timeout 22 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 24 timeout timeout 8
SET243-6 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
PLA004-1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 7 9 timeout 16 timeout 1
COL003-4 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 269 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
SET082-6 260 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 103 8 timeout 150 2
PLA014-1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 2 2 timeout 37 timeout 1
GEO027-2 95 3 27 timeout timeout 85 timeout timeout 28 timeout timeout
GEO059-2 timeout 10 18 timeout timeout timeout 219 2 2 timeout 1
SET261-6 timeout 157 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 16
SET240-6 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 21 65 timeout timeout timeout 6
BOO016-1 30 9 timeout timeout timeout 4 5 5 timeout 6 timeout
SYN200-1 15 2 63 15 10 16 21 3 2 2 3
NUM159-1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
RNG038-1 22 1 timeout timeout timeout 14 14 6 timeout 1 timeout
SET080-6 26 1 143 timeout timeout 9 54 3 2 2 1
GEO002-1 timeout 4 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 3 timeout timeout 2
SET061-6 timeout 3 timeout timeout timeout timeout 57 7 timeout 11 2
NUM003-1 9 timeout 6 timeout timeout 2 2 5 24 timeout timeout
SYN271-1 19 3 219 14 18 15 22 6 8 3 9
SET101-6 115 1 38 timeout timeout 8 47 13 20 2 1
CAT003-4 17 1 9 4 timeout 2 3 42 1 28 201
BOO006-1 10 4 26 timeout timeout 2 3 2 50 3 timeout
PLA014-2 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 281 2 timeout 21 timeout 1
NUM232-1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
SET024-6 13 1 33 timeout timeout 8 50 3 timeout 1 1
COL002-2 10 timeout timeout timeout timeout 2 3 2 1 timeout timeout
SYN202-1 18 3 272 14 12 17 22 5 10 3 4
SET063-6 timeout 12 138 timeout timeout timeout 246 13 timeout 19 44
NUM046-1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
SET083-6 77 79 timeout timeout timeout timeout 44 8 3 115 2
SET015-2 timeout timeout 25 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 6
BOO012-1 14 20 timeout timeout timeout 3 3 3 timeout 27 timeout
SET558-6 timeout 1 timeout timeout timeout timeout 60 timeout timeout 2 13
SET008-1 10 3 3 timeout timeout 2 3 2 1 4 13
HEN003-1 16 2 259 timeout timeout timeout 7 2 2 1 10
SET075-6 timeout 132 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout 124 5
LCL196-1 timeout 24 timeout timeout timeout 7 6 120 2 30 222

General Hardware, Unit Equality Problems

(CPU times, in seconds)

Barcelona DISCOUNT Gandalf Otter304 SPASS Waldmeister
RNG021-6 26 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
RNG007-4 1 4 1 1 1 1
COL035-1 timeout 12 8 12 timeout 1
COL063-6 1 5 timeout 1 1 timeout
GRP190-2 9 9 10 5 timeout 1
ROB002-1 7 4 3 1 1 1
COL004-3 1 4 6 1 1 1
LCL157-1 2 4 4 1 3 1
LCL160-1 21 timeout timeout timeout timeout 3
LDA002-1 63 6 53 2 80 3
COL066-3 1 4 timeout 1 1 timeout
LCL163-1 26 timeout 17 timeout 205 35
GRP148-1 3 7 257 36 183 2
BOO014-4 timeout timeout 17 9 timeout 90
COL064-6 3 4 timeout 1 1 timeout
COL063-4 1 4 timeout 1 1 223
RNG019-6 1 timeout timeout timeout timeout timeout
GRP185-3 timeout timeout timeout 5 timeout timeout
BOO009-2 timeout timeout 1 3 7 1
RNG018-6 66 5 2 1 180 6
GRP167-1 timeout 18 timeout timeout timeout 6
ROB004-1 20 6 1 1 90 2
COL064-9 2 timeout timeout 1 1 timeout
BOO007-2 timeout timeout timeout 20 timeout 241
BOO007-4 timeout timeout timeout 46 timeout 137
GRP169-2 timeout 7 9 2 190 3
BOO013-2 1 4 2 1 1 1
LCL153-1 timeout 7 2 2 timeout 1
GRP166-4 72 8 1 1 timeout 1
COL036-1 timeout timeout timeout 2 timeout timeout
GRP138-1 6 7 258 31 timeout 1
COL037-1 timeout timeout 257 25 timeout timeout
GRP174-1 14 8 1 1 51 1
BOO009-4 timeout 4 1 1 6 1
COL039-1 timeout 7 2 11 timeout 1
LCL158-1 timeout 5 5 5 timeout 1
GRP122-1 timeout 7 timeout timeout timeout 14
GRP170-1 129 16 timeout 64 timeout 33
GRP193-1 timeout 19 39 2 timeout 7
RNG025-4 timeout timeout timeout 143 timeout timeout
RNG012-6 timeout 5 4 1 timeout 1
COL009-1 timeout 4 1 3 timeout 1
LCL164-1 1 4 7 2 1 1
GRP167-3 timeout 190 timeout timeout timeout timeout
COL064-7 1 4 timeout 1 1 timeout
GRP169-1 timeout 41 timeout 3 273 1
BOO014-2 timeout timeout 50 9 timeout 2
GRP175-2 217 15 40 9 timeout 3
COL062-3 1 4 timeout 1 1 timeout
LCL135-1 1 4 1 1 1 1

Special Hardware, Mixed Problems

(Wall clock times, in seconds)

CLIN-E CLIN-S SPTHEO
COL002-3 timeout timeout 7
NUM284-1.010 timeout 273 timeout
GRP048-2 235 timeout timeout
CAT012-3 timeout 83 199
SET232-6 timeout timeout 253
LCL210-1 timeout timeout timeout
PLA011-2 timeout 75 11
RNG040-1 timeout 10 timeout
SET196-6 timeout timeout 226
PLA018-1 timeout timeout 65
NUM009-1 timeout timeout 209
GRP099-1 timeout timeout timeout
RNG005-1 139 timeout timeout
GEO006-1 timeout timeout timeout
SET243-6 timeout timeout timeout
PLA004-1 timeout 257 32
COL003-4 timeout timeout timeout
SET082-6 timeout timeout timeout
PLA014-1 timeout timeout 44
GEO027-2 timeout timeout 271
GEO059-2 timeout timeout timeout
SET261-6 timeout timeout timeout
SET240-6 timeout timeout timeout
BOO016-1 timeout timeout timeout
SYN200-1 33 timeout 156
NUM159-1 timeout timeout timeout
RNG038-1 timeout timeout timeout
SET080-6 timeout timeout 295
GEO002-1 timeout timeout timeout
SET061-6 timeout timeout timeout
NUM003-1 timeout timeout timeout
SYN271-1 timeout timeout 296
SET101-6 timeout timeout 216
CAT003-4 timeout timeout 117
BOO006-1 timeout timeout timeout
PLA014-2 timeout 153 258
NUM232-1 timeout timeout timeout
SET024-6 timeout timeout timeout
COL002-2 timeout timeout 71
SYN202-1 timeout timeout 60
SET063-6 timeout timeout timeout
NUM046-1 timeout timeout timeout
SET083-6 timeout timeout timeout
SET015-2 timeout 68 timeout
BOO012-1 timeout timeout 221
SET558-6 timeout timeout timeout
SET008-1 timeout 15 197
HEN003-1 100 timeout timeout
SET075-6 timeout timeout timeout
LCL196-1 timeout 242 timeout

Special Hardware, Unit Equality Problems

(Wall clock times, in seconds)

DISCOUNT 3.0
RNG021-6 43
RNG007-4 16
COL035-1 21
COL063-6 156
GRP190-2 27
ROB002-1 17
COL004-3 17
LCL157-1 timeout
LCL160-1 273
LDA002-1 157
COL066-3 timeout
LCL163-1 timeout
GRP148-1 23
BOO014-4 timeout
COL064-6 30
COL063-4 17
RNG019-6 timeout
GRP185-3 timeout
BOO009-2 30
RNG018-6 45
GRP167-1 timeout
ROB004-1 62
COL064-9 timeout
BOO007-2 217
BOO007-4 timeout
GRP169-2 20
BOO013-2 timeout
LCL153-1 timeout
GRP166-4 24
COL036-1 timeout
GRP138-1 26
COL037-1 timeout
GRP174-1 30
BOO009-4 20
COL039-1 36
LCL158-1 41
GRP122-1 141
GRP170-1 58
GRP193-1 68
RNG025-4 timeout
RNG012-6 40
COL009-1 33
LCL164-1 20
GRP167-3 timeout
COL064-7 21
GRP169-1 181
BOO014-2 184
GRP175-2 21
COL062-3 17
LCL135-1 19

Christian Suttner, Geoff Sutcliffe 11.8.96